Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 110-A of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1939 (for short, the 1939 Act).
  • provisions of the 1939 Act. Section 103 of the 1939 Act
  • Motor Vehicles Act 1988 (for short, the Act), the Act
  • provisions of Section 103-A of the 1939 Act,
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 110-A of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1939 (for short, the 1939 Act).
  • provisions of the 1939 Act. Section 103 of the 1939 Act
  • Motor Vehicles Act 1988 (for short, the Act), the Act
  • provisions of Section 103-A of the 1939 Act,
Smart Summary

Judgment Summary — FAO No. 352 of 1987; Cross Objection No. 76-C-II of 1989 in FAO No. 352 of 1987; FAO 611 of 1987

Factual and Procedural Background

The claimants, Smt. Sukhrania and Ram Dhan, lost their son Chinku as a result of a road accident that occurred on March 1, 1984. Chinku, a rickshaw puller, was struck by a motorcycle (registration No. P.U.T 3504) driven in a rash and negligent manner while he was near the Alankar Cinema. Witnesses took Chinku to Civil Hospital, Bhatinda; he was later referred to C.M.C. Ludhiana where he was admitted on March 2, 1984 and died on May 5, 1984. The hospital retained the body because the claimants could not pay medical expenses. The claimants filed a petition under Section 110-A of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1939. Parties arrayed included Pawan Kumar and Ashok Kumar, Rikhi Ram (Appellant No. 1), M/s Azad Engineering Works, and the New India Assurance Company Limited (the insurer).

At the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal (the Tribunal), issues were framed including (1) whether Chinku died due to rash and negligent driving of the motorcycle, (2) the quantum of compensation and from whom it was payable, and (3) relief. The Tribunal held the accident was caused by Ashok Kumar, applied the doctrine of res ipsa loquitur, awarded Rs. 64,000/- to the claimants, found that M/s Azad Engineering Works had purchased the motorcycle and that Ashok Kumar was its employee, and held the registered owner (who had insured the vehicle) had not intimated transfer to the insurer, so the insurer was not liable.

Rikhi Ram and M/s Azad Engineering Works appealed against the award; the claimants filed a cross-objection seeking enhancement of compensation. The principal appellate dispute before this Court concerned whether the insurer (New India Assurance) could be held liable given the statutory provisions on transfer/intimation of insurance certificates under the Motor Vehicles Act, 1939.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether Chinku died due to the rash and negligent driving of the motorcycle bearing No. PUT-3504 (as framed by the Tribunal)?
  2. To what amount of compensation the applicants are entitled and from whom that compensation should be recovered (as framed by the Tribunal)?
  3. Whether, in the circumstances of transfer/purchase of the vehicle and lack of intimation to the insurer, the insurer (New India Assurance Co. Ltd.) is liable to pay compensation under the Motor Vehicles Act, 1939 (in particular the consequences of non-compliance with Section 103-A)?

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments (Rikhi Ram; M/s Azad Engineering Works)

  • The written statements filed by Pawan Kumar and Rikhi Ram denied the accident and further asserted that the motorcycle did not belong to them; they stated that Azad Engineering Works, Bhatinda was the owner.
  • Appellants and M/s Azad Engineering Works asserted that Rikhi Ram was not the registered owner of the vehicle and challenged ownership and insurance transfer issues.
  • At the appellate hearing, counsel for the appellants did not dispute the occurrence of the accident or the quantum of compensation awarded by the Tribunal; instead the contention centered on whether the insurer was liable.

Respondents / Claimants' Arguments

  • The claimants sought compensation for death of Chinku and filed a cross-objection seeking enhancement of the compensation awarded by the Tribunal; at the appellate hearing, the court records that the claimants' counsel could not raise a meaningful argument for enhancement.

Insurance Company's Position (New India Assurance Co. Ltd.)

  • The insurer admitted that the motorcycle was insured with it but pleaded that the policy was taken out by M/s Bhagwan Rai Amrit Lal Commission Agents, Bhucho Mandi, and that any subsequent purchase by Rikhi Ram and M/s Azad Engineering Works was not intimated to the Insurance Company and therefore the policy had not been transferred to the purchasers.
  • The insurer's position, as recorded, was that because no intimation was given in the prescribed form, the insurer could not be held liable for the accident occurring after the alleged transfer.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Jolly Engineers & Contractors (P) Ltd., 1985 87 PLR 187 Change of ownership of a vehicle ends the policy of insurance even if the original policy-holder continues to be shown as registered owner; insurance is a personal contract of indemnity and insurer cannot be compelled to accept responsibility for a third party unknown to it. The Court relied on and quoted this authority to support the conclusion that the insurer is not liable where transfer/intimation was not made in terms of the statute.
Labh Singh v. Smt. Sunehri Reiterated the principle that intimation regarding purchase must be given by the original owner under the statutory provision (referred to in the judgment as Section 102-A) and if sent and no refusal is intimated within 15 days the certificate/policy would be deemed transferred; insurer may be liable if statutory procedure complied with. The Court treated this decision as a reiteration of the principle applied in the present case and as supporting the requirement of statutory intimation for transfer of insurance liability.
Baldev Raj v. Smt. Dharmo Rani (single-judge references) Same underlying proposition concerning intimation/transfer of insurance certificate and insurer's liability during the interregnum between vehicle transfer and transfer of certificate. Counted among authorities that endorse the position that the insurer's liability depends on compliance with statutory intimation/transfer rules; used to support the Court's conclusion.
Peters v. General Accident & Life Assurance Corpn. Ltd. (King's Bench Division) Adopted the view that change of ownership affects insurance liability unless statutory/contractual requirements are satisfied. Noted as an overseas authority that reached an identical conclusion; relied upon as supportive precedent.
Oriental Fire & General Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Smt. Vimal Rai High Court decision aligning with the principle that insurer's liability depends on compliance with statutory transfer/intimation requirements. Listed among High Court authorities adopting the identical view and relied upon as supportive precedent.
Roshan Lal Bhalla v. Sudesh Kumar High Court decision adopting the same principle regarding transfer/intimation and insurer's liability. Listed and treated as supporting authority.
Oriental Fire & General Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Meena Sharma High Court decision endorsing the principle that change of ownership affects the insurer's obligations unless statutory transfer is effected. Relied upon as one of several High Court decisions supporting the Court's stance.
Balwant Singh v. Jhannubai High Court authority in support of the majority view that insurer is not liable without proper intimation/transfer. Counted among supporting authorities.
United India Fire and General Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Chemnamma High Court authority endorsing the majority view on non-liability of insurer without statutory transfer/intimation. Relied on as supportive precedent.
M/s. National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Thirumalai Ammal High Court decision cited as part of the consistent line of authorities that the insurer's liability depends on statutory transfer/intimation. Used to show the overwhelming weight of High Court precedent for the proposition endorsed by this Court.
National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Thekkeil Rajan Another High Court authority aligned with the majority position on insurer liability and intimation/transfer rules. Included among multiple supporting cases relied upon by the Court.
P.K. Pamla v. Smt. Prema Lata Choudhury High Court decision supporting the same principle about transfer/intimation and insurer liability. Counted among the authorities the Court noted as adopting an identical view.
Motor Owners Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Ket Pal Singh High Court decision in the same line that transfer without intimation affects insurer liability. Listed and relied upon as supporting precedent.
Shantilal Mohan Lal v. Aher Bawanji Malde High Court authority endorsing the majority view on transfer/intimation requirements. Referred to as part of the consistent line of decisions followed by this Court.
Oriental Fire & General. Ins. Co. Ltd., Kolhapur v. Ratnabai Balu Kadam High Court decision aligning with the majority approach regarding insurer non-liability without statutory transfer/intimation. Included among supportive High Court authorities.
Anand Sarup Sharma v. P.P. Khurana High Court authority adopting the same principle on transfer/intimation and insurer liability. Relied upon as corroborative precedent.
Madineni Kodaiah v. Yaseen Fatima, AIR 1986 Andhra Pradesh 62 (FB) A contrary view (i.e., this decision took a view at variance with the majority of High Courts on the consequence of change of ownership and insurer liability). The Court explicitly rejected the contrary view expressed in this decision, stating it cannot be taken to be correct in view of the overwhelming contrary view of the majority of High Courts.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court's analysis proceeded from facts found by the Tribunal and the statutory framework in place at the time of the accident. The steps in the Court's reasoning, as recorded in the opinion, are:

  1. The accident occurred on March 1, 1984 when the Motor Vehicles Act, 1939 (the "1939 Act") governed liability. The later Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 came into force on July 1, 1989 and is not applicable to the present facts.
  2. The Tribunal had found (a) that the accident was caused by Ashok Kumar and applied the doctrine of res ipsa loquitur; (b) the claimants were entitled to Rs. 64,000/-; and (c) the motorcycle had been purchased by M/s Azad Engineering Works, with Ashok Kumar an employee, so the owner was vicariously liable for the acts of its servant.
  3. The pivotal legal question on appeal was whether the insurer could be held liable despite the asserted transfer of the vehicle. The Court examined the relevant statutory provisions of the 1939 Act, in particular Section 103 (certificate of insurance) and Section 103-A (procedure for transfer of certificate and policy upon transfer of vehicle).
  4. Section 103-A (as explained in the judgment) requires that where the holder of a certificate of insurance proposes to transfer ownership of the vehicle together with the policy, he must apply in the prescribed form to the insurer for transfer of the certificate and policy; if the insurer does not refuse within 15 days the certificate and policy are deemed transferred with effect from the date of transfer of the vehicle.
  5. On the facts, the Tribunal made a positive finding that there was no evidence the insured had intimated the insurer of any transfer to the purchasers (the appellants). Because the statutory intimation/transfer procedure of Section 103-A was not complied with, the insurer could not be held liable under the 1939 Act.
  6. The Court reviewed an "overwhelming weight" of judicial precedent supporting the proposition that a change of ownership terminates the policy of insurance as between insurer and third parties unless the statutory transfer/notification provisions are complied with; the Court relied on these authorities to uphold the Tribunal's conclusion on non-liability of the insurer.
  7. The Court noted that the Tribunal correctly held the transferee of the vehicle and the driver were jointly and severally liable to pay the compensation awarded.

Holding and Implications

HOLDING: The appeals and the cross-objection are dismissed. The Tribunal's award is affirmed on the points considered.

Implications:

  • The direct effect of the decision is that the insurer (New India Assurance Co. Ltd.) is not liable to pay the compensation because the statutory procedure for transfer of the certificate/policy (Section 103-A of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1939, as discussed in the judgment) was not complied with and there was no intimation to the insurer of the transfer.
  • The transferee (M/s Azad Engineering Works / Rikhi Ram as applicable) and the driver (Ashok Kumar) are jointly and severally liable to pay the compensation awarded by the Tribunal (Rs. 64,000/- as found by the Tribunal and not contested on quantum in the appeal).
  • No broader or novel legal principle was laid down by this judgment; the Court applied and followed an existing and consistent line of precedent to resolve the issue of insurer liability under the 1939 Act. The Court rejected a contrary High Court Full Bench decision (Madineni Kodaiah v. Yaseen Fatima) in favor of the majority view of other decisions.
  • Costs: The parties were directed to bear their own costs in view of the appellants' fair stance.

Disposition recorded in the text: "Appeal dismissed." (Order signed by H.K. Sandhu, J.)

    Rikhi And Another v. Smt. Sukhrania And Others

    G.R Majithia, J.:— This judgment disposes of FAO No. 352 of 1987, Cross objection No. 76-C-II of 1989 in F.A.O No. 352 of 1987 and FAO 611 of 1987.

    The facts:—

    2. A reference to relevant facts for adjudicating the question of law raised in these appeals has been made from the pleadings in File No. 15 of 27-8-1984 (F.A.O No. 352 of 1987). Smt. Sukhrania and Ram Dhan (hereinafter, referred to as the claimants) lost their son Chinku in an accident. Chinku was rickshaw puller by profession and while he was going to the Khokhas opposite to the Cinema Alankar Cinema on March 1, 1984 at about 12 noon to have a change of Rs. 5/- Pawan Kumar and Ashok Kumar were coming from Goniana side on a Motor Cycle bearing registration No. P.U.T 3504, on the wrong side of the road and were driving the same in a rash and negligent manner and without giving any horn struck against Chinku. The accident was witnessed by Nand Lal son of Durga Parshad, rickshaw puller, Shiv Lal son of Dhannu Ram, rickshaw puller, Ram Sarjiwan, brother of Chinku, Ram Sarup and one Prem Kumar, resident of Bhatinda. Chinku was taken to Civil Hospital Bhatinda by these persons for medical treatment. He was given treatment at Civil Hospital, Bhatinda. His condition worsened and he was referred to C.M.C Ludhiana, where he was admitted on March 2, 1984 in Unit No. 437522. Appellant No. 1 accompanied Chinku to C.M.C Ludhiana and had given an undertaking that he would bear all the expenses for the treatment but later on resiled from the same. Chinku died in C.M.C Ludhiana on May 5, 1984. The hospital authorities did not handover his dead-body to the claimants since they could not pay the medical expenses. The claimants moved a petition under Section 110-A of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1939 (for short, the 1939 Act). The appellants and respondent Nos. 3 to 6 were arrayed as party respondent to the petition.

    3. Pawan Kumar and Rikhi Ram (Appellant No. 1) filed a joint written statement denying the accident and pleaded that the Motor Cycle bearing registration No. PUT-3504 did not belong to them. Rather Azad Engineering Works, Bhatinda was the owner of the vehicle. Azad Engineering Works, Bhatinda was added as a party respondent to the petition, the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal by order, dated November 18, 1986 impleaded respondent No. 4 as party respondent to the claim petition. Appellant No. 1 and M/s. Azad Engineering Works filed another written statement taking the plea that Rikhi Ram was not the owner of the vehicle in question. Ashok Kumar, respondent No. 6 filed a separate written statement taking identical objections as were taken by the appellants. The New India Assurance Company Limited admitted the factum of the insurance of the motor cycle with it. However, it pleaded that it was got insured by M/s. Bhagwan Rai Amrit Lal Commission Agents, Bhucho Mandi and they were the registered owner of the vehicle with it. It further pleaded the purchase of the vehicle in question made by Rikhi Ram and M/s Azad Engineering Works (Appellants) was not intimated to the Insurance Company and as such, the policy had not been transferred in the name of the purchasers.

    4. On the pleading of the parties, the following issues were framed:—

    1. Whether Chinku died due to the rash and negligent driving of a motor cycle bearing No. PUT-3504 driven by Pawan Kumar & Ashok Kumar, respondent No. 1 and 1-A? OPA.

    2. To what amount of compensation, if any, the applicants are entitled and from whom? OPA.

    3. Relief.

    5. Under Issue No. 1. the Tribunal held that the accident was caused by Ashok Kumar (Respondent No. 6). It further held that the accident took place in front of the Cinema and it was incumbent upon the driver of the vehicle to have driven the vehicle in a careful and cautious manner so that even if any pedestrian comes in front of the vehicle, he could have stopped the same. He applied the doctrine of res ipsa loquitor to the facts of the instant case. Under issue No. 2, it held that the claimants were entitled to Rs. 64,000/- as compensation. It further came to the conclusion that the motorcycle, which was involved in the accident, was purchased by M/s. Azad Engineering Works, Bhatinda. Ashok Kumar was an employee of M/s. Azad Engineering Works and the owner of the vehicle was vicariously liable for the acts of its servant. Rikhi Ram was the partner of M/s. Azad Engineering Works. It further held the intimation of the transfer of the vehicle was not given by the registered owner of the vehicle, who had got the vehicle insured, with the Insurance Company and as such, the Insurance Company was not liable.

    6. Feeling aggrieved against the award, Rikhi Ram, respondent No. 2, and M/s. Azad Engineering Works, respondent No. 2-A have preferred this appeal.

    7. Being dis-statisfied with the award on the quantum of compensation, the claimants have also filed cross-objection for enhancement of compensation.

    8. The learned counsel for the appellants very fairly did not dispute the accident and the manner in which it had taken place. He also did not dispute the correctness of the findings regarding the quantum of compensation. The learned counsel for the claimants could not raise any meaningful argument for enhancement of the compensation. The only dispute is whether the Insurance Company can be held liable for the payment of the compensation amount. The accident took place on March 1, 1984 when the 1939 Act was in force. The 1939 Act was repealed by the Motor Vehicles Act 1988 (for short, the Act), the Act came into force with effect from July 1, 1989. The dispute in the accident has to be decided under the provisions of the 1939 Act. Section 103 of the 1939 Act envisages that an insurer issues a certificate of Insurance in respect of a contract of insurance between it and the insured person. Section 103-A of the 1939 Act further says that where a person in whose favour the certificate of insurance has been issued in accordance with the provisions contained in Chapter VII proposes to transfer to another person the ownership of the Motor Vehicle in respect of which such insurance was taken together with the policy of insurance relating thereto, he may apply in the prescribed form to the insurer for the transfer of the certificate of insurance and the policy described in the certificate in favour of the person to whom the motor vehicle is proposed to be transferred, and if within fifteen days of the receipt of such application by the insurer, the insurer has not intimated the insured and such other person his refusal to transfer the certificate and policy to the other person, the certificate of insurance and the policy described in the certificate shall be deemed to have been transferred in favour of the person to whom the motor vehicle is transferred with effect from the date of its transfer. The liability of the insurer would be fastened if an intimation was given to it by the insured that the vehicle insured with the former had been transferred to the third person. In the instant case, the Tribunal had given a positive finding that there is no evidence on record that the insured had intimated the insurer regarding the factum of transfer by him to appellant No. 2. Since the intimation was not given in terms of the provisions of Section 103-A of the 1939 Act, the insurer cannot be held liable. The privity of contract which flows form the contract of insurance is between the insured and the insurer. The insurer can transfer the certificate of insurance alongwith transfer of the vehicle if he complied with the provisions of Section 103-A of the 1939 Act. On the proved facts, there is no escape from the conclusion that the Insurance Company is not liable. This was the view, which has been consistently taken by this Court in The New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Jolly Engineers & Contractors (P) Ltd. 1985 87 PLR 187 wherein it was held thus:—

    “The over whelming weight of judicial precedent, however, points to the contrary view, namely, that the change of ownership of a vehicle puts an end to the polity of insurance even if the original policy-holder continues to be shown as the registered owner of the vehicle concerned. The rationale behind this being that a policy of insurance is a contract of personal indemnity and the insurer cannot, therefore, be compelled to accept responsibility in respect of a third party, who may be quite unknown to him.”

    9. This view was reiterated in Labh Singh v. Smt. Sunehri Devi,2. I sitting singly in Baldev Raj v. Smt. Dharmo Rani etc.,3 held thus:—

    “The intimation regarding purchase had to be given by the original owner as provided under Section 102-A of the Act. If the intimation had been sent and no response had been received thereto from the Insurance Company within 15 days, the transfer of the insurance certificate in favour of the transferee would have been effected from the date of the transfer of the vehicle in his favour. The principle underlying the aforesaid provision is that the insurance cannot be allowed to ward off his liability by simply delaying the transfer of the certificate of insurance in favour of the purchaser of the vehicle. If an accident takes place liability is incurred by the purchaser during the period between the date of the transfer of the vehicle and the date of the actual transfer of the certificate of insurance by the insurer, the insurer has to discharge it.”

    10. The identical view has been taken by the King's Bench Division in Peters v. General Accident & Life Assurance Corpn. Ltd.,4 and other High Courts in The Oriental Fire & General Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Smt. Vimal Rai,5; Roshan Lal Bhalla v. Sudesh Kumar,6; Oriental Fire & General Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Meena Sharma,7; Balwant Singh v. Jhannubai,8; United India Fire and General Insurance Co. Ltd. and etc. v. Chemnamma,9; Calcutta Insurance, Madras, now known as M/s. National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Thirumalai Ammal,10; National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Thekkeil Rajan,11 P.K Pamla v. Smt. Prema Lata Choudhury,12; Motor Owners Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Ket Pal Singh,13; Shantilal Mohan Lal v. Aher Bawanji Malde,14 Oriental Fire & General. Ins. Co. Ltd. Kolhapur v. Ratnabai Balu Kadam,15 and Anand Sarup Sharma v. P.P Khurana,16. The contrary view taken in Madineni Kodaiah, etc. v. Yaseen Fatima etc. AIR 1986 Andhra Pradesh 62 FB with respect to the Hon'ble Judges, cannot be taken to be correct in view of the overwhelming contrary view taken almost by majority of the High Courts.

    11. The Tribunal rightly came to the conclusion that the transferee of the vehicle and the driver of the vehicle are jointly and severally liable to pay the compensation amount.

    12. For the reasons stated above, the appeals and the cross-objection are dismissed. However, in view of the very fair stand of Mr. Anupam Gupta, learned counsel for the appellants, the parties are left to bear their own costs.

    Sd/- H.K Sandhu, J.

    R.M.S
    Appeal dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Rikhi And Another v. Smt. Sukhrania And Others
    (Sep 7, 1993)