Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Judgment Summary — Lachhman Das (petitioner)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner, Lachhman Das, challenged under Article 226 the legality of an order transferring him to the Ferozepore Division as an Enquiry and Reservation Clerk, the validity of an order withholding his increments for two years, and the treatment of his suspension period as non-duty. Employment history given in the opinion: appointed Supervisor in the Department of Catering Establishment on 1 July 1956; appointed Assistant Manager Catering on 11 January 1958; promoted to Manager Catering on 24 September 1962.

The petitioner was suspended with effect from 20 June 1964 and an enquiry was conducted on allegations that on 11 June 1964 he was found lying in a drunken state (smelling of country liquor) with three other persons and that he connived at sale of unauthorised private material by vendors. The petitioner denied the allegations and maintained that the Enquiry Officer did not find him guilty of any charge. The disciplinary authority nevertheless concluded that the petitioner had taken liquor (quantity uncertain) and imposed the penalty of withholding increments for two years.

Orders thereafter: on 3 September 1965 the petitioner was posted as Assistant Manager in Catering and the suspension period (20 June 1964 to 24 February 1965) was declared non-duty. A subsequent administrative correction restored the petitioner to the grade held at suspension. Because the authorities considered it administratively undesirable to keep the petitioner in the Catering Department, he was transferred by order dated 16 September 1965 to Ferozepore Division as Assistant Licensed Porter Inspector; that order was later modified so he would take over as Enquiry and Reservation Clerk.

The petition alleges mala fides in the initiation of the enquiry and transfer, asserting that respondent No. 2 (Shri Kapur Singh) engineered complaints after the petitioner refused to arrange a free lunch and a false receipt; respondent No. 2 and the railway authorities resisted the petition and filed affidavits. The court heard counsel for both sides and dismissed the petition.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the transfer of the petitioner from the Catering Department to the Ferozepore Division (post carrying equivalent grade) was lawful and/or mala fide.
  2. Whether the order withholding the petitioner’s increments for two years was valid.
  3. Whether the period of suspension (20 June 1964 to 24 February 1965) was validly treated as a non-duty period.
  4. Whether the authority that effected the transfer was legally competent to do so, and whether the delegation clause in Rule 148 (permitting re-delegation) is constitutionally objectionable under the maxim delegatus non potest delegare.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The enquiry and subsequent transfer were mala fide and were engineered by respondent No. 2 (Shri Kapur Singh) after the petitioner refused to make arrangements for a free lunch and issue a false receipt.
  • Under the conditions of his service the petitioner was not liable to serve in any department other than the Catering Department and should have been posted back to his previous post after the enquiry.
  • The stoppage of increments for two years and the treatment of the suspension period as non-duty were invalid.
  • Not all respondents filed affidavits in reply (argument as to insufficiency of replies).
  • The authority which made the transfer order was not legally competent to make it (challenge to competence of authority and to the permitted re-delegation in Rule 148 under the maxim delegatus non potest delegare).

Respondents' Arguments / Position

  • Shri Kapur Singh (respondent No. 2) filed an affidavit denying the allegations that he engineered the enquiry and denying the specific factual accusations (including that he was Assistant to respondent No. 1).
  • The Senior Personnel Officer (Shri A.K. Bhaduri) filed an affidavit explaining that other departmental enquiries and a criminal case (misappropriation) by the Special Police Establishment were pending against the petitioner, and that in view of embezzlement and misappropriation it was administratively undesirable to continue him in the sensitive Catering Department; hence transfer to an equivalent grade in Ferozepore Division was ordered.
  • Respondents contended that the material on record indicates the transfer was made by a competent authority and in the exigencies of service.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Barium Chemicals Ltd. v. The Company Law Board, Civil Appeal No. 381 of 1966, dated 4-5-1966 : (AIR 1960 SC 295) Consideration of maxim delegatus non potest delegare; principle that the maxim is not absolute and is a rule of construction, not an inexorable rule of law. The court relied on this authority to reject the petitioner’s contention that the part of Rule 148 permitting re-delegation was invalid; held that the rule’s clear language permits delegation and cannot be struck down on the basis of the maxim.
G.K. Tandon v. Judicial Commr., State of Ajmer, AIR 1957 Raj 230 Authority for the view that Fundamental Rule 12-A read with Fundamental Rule 15 (corresponding to Rule 2011) authorises transfer of a Government servant from one service or department to another notwithstanding the wishes of the servant. The court cited this decision to support the proposition that permanent transfer between departments may be authorised by rules and is not necessarily a justiciable right of the servant.
Krishena Kumar v. Comptroller and Auditor General of India, C.W. No. 509-D of 1965, Dated 28-1-1966 (Punj.) Application of regulations on transfer and the non-justiciability of certain transfer decisions (regulations did not confer a justiciable right on the petitioner). Used by the court to reinforce the view that transfer decisions under the rules are not ordinarily justiciable and that the court will not interfere unless there is a legal violation or mala fides.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded through a sequence of focused legal inquiries applying the facts recited in the record to governing rules and precedents:

  1. Mala fides allegation: The petitioner alleged respondent No. 2 engineered the enquiry after a personal dispute. The court noted that respondent No. 2 filed an affidavit denying those allegations (including denial of being assistant to respondent No. 1). Given the denial and the absence of persuasive evidence showing that respondent No. 2 influenced superior officers to give an adverse finding or to effect the transfer, the court concluded the petitioner failed to prove mala fides.
  2. Affidavits and parties: The court considered the point that not all respondents had filed individual affidavits. It held that because personal allegations were made only against respondent No. 2 (who filed an affidavit) and because the Senior Personnel Officer’s affidavit sufficiently addressed the matter for the remaining respondents, the petitioner's complaint about missing affidavits did not cause shown prejudice.
  3. Legal power to transfer: The court examined Rule 148 of the Indian Railway Establishment Code (issued under Article 309) and observed that a non-gazetted railway servant may be transferred by an Agent or a lower authority to whom the Agent may re-delegate his power. Rule 2011 (and the delegation provisions in Appendix XXXII and Appendix XXXVIII) permits transfer of a railway servant from one post to another and delegates power to heads of departments, which include Chief Commercial Superintendents. The record (Annexure Q and the note referring to an order of the Chief Commercial Superintendent dated 24 September 1965) indicated the transfer was made by a competent authority.
  4. Equivalence of grade and exigencies of service: It was accepted (and not disputed) that the post to which petitioner was transferred carried the same scale of pay as his earlier post. The court further accepted the Senior Personnel Officer’s affidavit that there were other departmental enquiries and a criminal case for misappropriation pending against the petitioner, and that given findings of embezzlement/misappropriation it was not desirable to keep him in the sensitive Catering Department (involving public contact and monetary transactions). The court concluded the order of transfer was made in the exigencies of service and in view of the petitioner’s antecedents, and found nothing legally objectionable.
  5. Competence and delegatus non potest delegare: The petitioner raised a challenge to the re-delegation clause in Rule 148 as contrary to the maxim delegatus non potest delegare. The court relied on Barium Chemicals Ltd. v. Company Law Board to observe that the maxim is not an absolute rule of law but a rule of construction; the clear language of Rule 148 permitting re-delegation indicates that such delegation is permissible and the rule could not be struck down merely because of the maxim.
  6. Scope of judicial review: The court emphasized that transfer decisions are primarily administrative and that a variety of relevant considerations (suitability, aptitude, past conduct, reputation, period on post, and other grounds collectively termed "exigencies of service") may inform them. It reiterated that under Article 226 the court will not adjudicate the advisability of a transfer and will interfere only if the transfer violates a legal provision or is otherwise mala fide. The court cited G.K. Tandon and Krishena Kumar as authorities supporting non-justiciability in such contexts.
  7. Stoppage of increments and treatment of suspension: The authority had found the charge against the petitioner to be partly proved. Given that finding, the court considered the authority was within its rights to withhold increments for two years and to treat the suspension period as non-duty, and the petitioner did not show any infirmity in that order.

On the cumulative basis of the foregoing analysis, including competence to transfer, absence of established mala fides, the equivalence of the post in pay scale, the pending allegations of misappropriation, and established administrative discretion in transfers, the court found no merit in the petition.

Holding and Implications

Holding: Petition dismissed.

Implications:

  • The petitioner's challenge to the transfer, the stoppage of increments for two years, and the treatment of the suspension period as non-duty was rejected; the impugned orders were held valid on the facts and law before the court.
  • The court directed that each party bear their own costs.
  • The decision rests on the immediate facts and existing rules and authorities; the opinion does not purport to set any new legal precedent beyond the application of established principles (noting prior case law and the relevant provisions of the Indian Railway Establishment Code).

Source: Opinion text as provided. This summary is limited to and strictly derived from the content of the provided judgment; no external facts or inferences beyond that text have been introduced.

    Lachman Dass v. Shiveshwarkar And Others

    1. Lachhman Das petitioner by means of this petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India has challenged the legality of the order by which he was transferred to Ferozepore Division as Enquiry and Reservation Clerk. The validity of the order by which the increment of the petitioner was stopped for two years, and the period of his suspension was directed to be treated as non-duty period, has also been assailed. The brief facts of the case are that the petitioner was appointed as Supervisor in the Department of Catering Establishment on 1st July 1956. On 11th January 1958 the petitioner was appointed Assistant Manager Catering. On 24th September 1962 the petitioner was promoted as Manager Catering. The petitioner was suspended with effect from 20th June 1964 and an enquiry was held against him on the allegation that on 11th June 1964, while on duty, he was found lying in a drunken state, smelling of country liquor along with three other persons. There was also allegation about his connivance at the sale of unauthorised private material by the vendors. The petitioner denied the allegations against him. According to the petitioner, the Enquiry Officer did not find the petitioner guilty of any charge. The disciplinary authority then considered the matter and, after discussing the material on record, observed as under:

    “Summing up my discussion of evidence, I arrive at the conclusion that Shri Lachman Das had undoubtedly taken liquor but the quantity consumed could not be ascertained without a medical test so as to declare in unequivocal words that he was not fit to perform his normal duties. Giving him the full benefit of his doubt, 1 impose the penalty of withholding his increments permanently for two years.”

    2. On 3rd September 1965 an order posting petitioner as Assistant Manager in the Catering Establishment was passed. It was also directed that the period of his suspension from 20th June 1964 to 24th February 1965 shall be treated as non-duty period. Subsequently, it was realised that the order about the demotion of the petitioner as Assistant Manager was contrary to Railway Board's Confidential instructions. Order was then made as a result of which the petitioner was restored to the same grade which he was holding at the time of his suspension. As the railway authorities did not think it administratively desirable to continue the petitioner in the catering department, order for his transfer to Ferozepore Division as Assistant Licensed Porter Inspector was made on 16th September 1965. The above order was later modified and it was directed that the petitioner shall take over in Ferozepore Division as Enquiry and Reservation Clerk.

    3. According to the allegations of the petitioner, the above enquiry was started against him and the order about his transfer was made mala fide because he had incurred the wrath of Shri Kapur Singh, Vigilance Officer, who has been impleaded as respondent No. 2. The order of transfer has also been challenged on the ground that according to the conditions of his service the petitioner is not liable to serve in any department other than catering department. The order regarding the stoppage of increments for two years and about treating the period of his suspension as not on duty, it is claimed, has also not been validly made.

    4. The petition has been resisted by the respondents, and the affidavits of Shri Kapur Singh respondent No. 2 and Shri A.K Bhaduri, Senior Personnel Officer of Northern Railway, has been filed I have heard Mr. Lall on behalf of the petitioner and Mr. Radhey Lal Aggarwal on behalf of the respondents, and am of the view that there is no merit in the petition.

    5. So far as the allegation about the mala lide nature of the enquiry and order of transfer is concerned, I find that, according to the petitioner, in February 1964 respondent No. 2, who is Assistant to Shri Shiveshwarkar, Additional Member Vigilance in the Ministry of Railways, New Delhi, respondent No. 1, called upon the petitioner to make arrangements for a free sumptuous lunch for respondent No. 2 and his friends, and to issue a false receipt about the payment of the charges. When the petitioner declined to do so, respondent No. 2 held out a threat to the petitioner and subsequently engineered complaints against him. In reply to the above, Shri Kapur Singh respondent No. 2 has denied all the allegations made against him and has described them as totally false. It has also been denied that respondent No. 2 is Assistant to respondent No. 1. In the face of the above denial in the affidavit of Shri Kapur Singh respondent No. 2 it is not possible to hold that the enquiry against the petitioner was engineered by respondent No. 2. Apart from that, I fail to understand as to how respondent No. 2 could influence the superior officers of the petitioner in giving a finding against him and making an order regarding his transfer. I would, therefore, hold that the petitioner has failed to show that the impugned orders have been made mala fide.

    6. Argument has also been advanced that all the respondents have not filed their affidavits in reply to the petition. In this respect it may be observed that apart from Shri Shiveshwarkar and Shri Kapur Singh, the other three respondents are Chief Commercial Superintendent, Divisional Personnel Officer Northern Divisional Office, and Shri Moti Lal who has now been appointed as Unit Manager Catering in place of the petitioner Allegations of personal nature have been made only against Shri Kapur Singh respondent No. 2 and he has filed an affidavit controverting the allegations against him. So far as the other respondents are concerned, the affidavit filed by the Senior Personal Officer of Northern Railway, in my opinion, is quite enough and it is not necessary in view of the absence of any personal allegations against them that they should have filed their individual affidavits. In any case no prejudice is shown to have been caused to the petitioner by the failure of those respondents to file their personal affidavits.

    7. The main question in the present case, which has been argued, is about the validity of the order transferring the petitioner from Delhi to Ferozepore Division. The contention advanced on behalf of the petitioner is that as he was Manager Catering before the enquiry was held against him he should have, after the conclusion of the enquiry, been posted back to the same post and that he should not have been transferred to Ferozepore Division either as Assistant Licensed Porter Inspector or a Enquiry and Reservation Clerk. Reference in this connection is made to the Railway Board's Schedules entitled “Authorised Scales of Pay” according to which Manager Catering and Assistant Manager Catering belong to Group No. 61, while Enquiry and Reservation Clerks belong to Group No. 04, and Licensed Porter Inspectors belong to Group No. 68-A.

    8. In this connection I find that Rule 148 of Indian Railway Establishment Code, which has been issued by the President in exercise of the powers conferred on him, by the proviso to Article 309 of the Constitution, reads as under:

    “Ordinarily, a railway servant shall be employed throughout his service on the railway or railway establishment to which he is posted on first appointment and shall have no claim as of right for transfer to another railway or railway establishment. In the exigencies of service, however, it shall be open to the President to transfer the railway servant to any other department or railway or railway establishment including a project in or out of India. In regard to non-gazetted railway servants, the power of the President under this rule, in respect of transfer within India, may be exercised by an Agent or by a lower authority to whom the Agent may re-delegate his power.”

    9. The petitioner is admittedly a non-gazetted railway servant and as such in terms of the later part of the rule the power of transfer in respect of the petitioner could be exercised by an agent or lower authority to whom the agent may re-delegate his power. According to rule 2011 a competent authority may transfer a railway servant from one post to another. There follows a proviso but we are not concerned with that. It is not disputed that the post to which the petitioner has been transferred carries the same scale of pay as the post of Manager Catering which was held by the petitioner before the enquiry. As such I find that there was no legal bar to the impugned order of transfer being made in respect of the petitioner in the exigencies of service.

    10. From the affidavit of Shri A.K Bhaduri it would appear that some other departmental enquiry and case of misappropriation have been started against the petitioner by the Special Police Establishment and the case is now pending in the Court of Additional Sessions Judge, Delhi. As the petitioner was found indulging in embezzlement and misappropriation it was not considered desirable to keep him in the Catering Department which is a sensitive post as it involves contact with the public and monetary transactions. It was, therefore, ordered that he be transferred to a post in Ferozepore Division carrying equivalent grade. It would thus seem that the order about the transfer of the petitioner has been made keeping in view the exigencies of service and the antecedents of the petitioner and I find nothing legally objectionable to that.

    11. Argument has been advanced that the authority, which made the order for the transfer of the petitioner, was not legally competent to do so. No such objection was taken in the petition and I agree with Mr. Aggarwal that the petitioner should not be allowed to agitate this matter at the hearing of the petition. Had such an objection been raised, the respondents might have adduced material to rebut such contention. Even, as things are, I find that the material on record indicates that the order in respect of the petitioner has been made by a competent authority. Annexure ‘Q’ to the petition, which was Issued by the Divisional Personnel Officer for the transfer of the petitioner to Ferozepore Division, contains a note within it that the authority for the issue of that notice was the order of CCS i.e, the Chief Commercial Superintendent, daled 24th September 1965. According to entry No. 5 of Appendix XXXII of Indian Railway Establishment Code, the power to transfer a railway servant from one post to another has been delegated by the President to all heads of departments. Appendix XXXVIII gives the list of officers who have been declared to be heads of departments and according to this Appendix heads of departments include the Chief Commercial Superintendents. It would follow from the above that the Chief Commercial Superintendent was competent to pass an order in respect of the petitioner. As the indications on the record are that the impugned order was made by the Chief Commercial Superintendent, it cannot be said that it was not made by the competent authority.

    12. Mr. Lall has then referred to the later part of rule 146, reproduced above, according to which, in regard to non-gazetted railway servants, the power of transfer under the rule may be exercised by an Agent or by a lower authority to whom the Agent may re-delegate his power. It is urged that part of the rule, according to which an Agent may re-delegate his powers to a lower authority, is liable to be struck down because it contravenes the maxim “delegatus non potest delegare” according to which a delegated authority cannot be re-delegated. The above maxim tvas considered by their Lordships of the Supreme Court to the case of Barium Chemicals Ltd. v. The Company Law Board, Civil Appeal No. 381 of 1966, dated 4-5-1966 : (AIR 1960 SC 295), and it was observed that the above maxim must not be too far (sic) and that it did not embody a rule of law it indicates a rule of construction of a statute or other instrument conferring an authority. It was further observed that a discretion conferred by a statute on authority is intended to be exercised by that authority and by no other but the intention may be negatived by any contrary indications in the language, scope or object of the statute in the present case the rule expressly makes a provision that the power of transfer can be delegated to a authority lower than the Agent in the face of the clear language used in the rule, there is no escape from the conclusion that the rule contemplates that such a delegation of power is permissible. The rule can also, in my opinion, be not struck down for being not in consonance with a maxim.

    13. Apart from the above I am of the view that the question about the transfer of an official is primarily for the authorities concerned A variety of factors may weigh with the authorities while considering the question of transfer, viz., the suitability of the official for the post, his aptitude, past conduct, reputation, the period for which he has been on that post and a number of other grounds which may be clubbed together under the head “exigencies of service” It is not for this Court in a petition under Article 226 to go into the matter and adjudicate about the advisability or propriety of the transfer. The Court can only interfere if the transfer is violative of any legal provision or is otherwise mala fide Except in such a limited contingency, the order of transfer is neither open to judicial review nor justiciable.

    14. In G.K Tandon v. Judicial Commr. State of Ajmer, AIR 1957 Raj 230, a Division Bench of that Court held that Fundamental Rule 12-A, read with Fundamental Rule 15 which corresponds to Rule 2011 reproduced above, authorises the transfer of a Government servant from a permanent post in any service or department to a permanent transfer from one service or department. Such permanent transfer from one service or department to another service or department can be made. In respective of the wishes of the Government servant concerned. Somewhat similar question arose before Kapur, J. in Krishena Kumar v. Comptroller and Auditor General of India C.W No. 509-D of 1965, D/- 28-1-1966 (Punj). The petitioner in that case challenged the order of his transfer. It was held that the regulations did not confer a justiciable right on the petitioner. His petition challenging his transfer was, consequently, dismissed. So far as the order is concerned in respect of the stoppage of the increment of the petitioner for two years and about treating the period of his suspension as non-duty period, I find that the authority concerned found that charge against the petitioner had been partly proved. In the circumstances, the authority concerned was well within its rights to pass that order it has not been shown to me that the aforesaid order suffers from any infirmity.

    15. The petition, consequently, falls and is dismissed, but, in the circumstances. I leave file parties to bear their own costs.

    KJ/AGJ/D.V.C

    16. Petition dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Lachman Dass v. Shiveshwarkar And Others
    (Jul 22, 1966)