AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts

    Union Of India And Another v. Regional Labour Commissioner (Central), Dhanbad, And Another

    1. This application under Arts. 226 and 227 of the Constitution of India has been filed by the Union of India through the General Manager, North Eastern Railway and by the Executive Engineer (Construction) (TPS), North Eastern Railway.

    2. The order under challenge is Annexure 1, dated 28 September 1984, whereby the Regional Labour Commissioner (Central), Dhanbad, who is the authority under the Minimum Wages Act, 1948, decided the applications under Sub-sec(2) of S. 20 of the Minimum Wages Act and passed the following operative order against the petitioners:

    “After hearing the applicant, the opponent is directed to pay the difference of wages as mentioned in the claim application amounting to Rs. 3,892 due to non-payment minimum wages the employees have suffered hardships and mental agony. The payment of less than the minimum wages amounts to treating the workers as bonded labour, crime against the society as well as violation of Art. 23 of the Constitution of India as observed by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Civil Appeal No. 8143 of 1981 between People's Union for Democratic Rights v. Union of India [1982 (2) L.L.N 410], I am, therefore, of the view that the end of justice will be met by allowing compensation to the employees to the extent of two times of the difference. Accordingly, I hereby direct the opponent to pay the differences of wages amounting to Rs. 3,892.00 as well as compensation amounting to Rs. 7,784.00. The entire amount to Rs. 11,676.00 should be paid to the workers within thirty days from the date of this order in the presence of the applicant.”

    Sri A.B Ojha, learned counsel for the petitioners, contended that the impugned order is illegal and without jurisdiction since the Labour Commissioner passed the order without notice to petitioner 1, who, under the law is liable to carry out the award and not petitioner 2.

    3. Petitioner 1 is the owner of the Indian Railways and petitioner 2 is an officer of petitioner 1.

    4. In the year 1972 a decision was taken to convert Barabanki-Samastipur metre gauge section via Muzaffarpur into broad gauge. Accordingly, sanction of the President of India was communicated to the General Manager/N.E Rly/Gorakhpur, vide Annexure @. In order to complete the aforesaid project, a separate organisation, namely, N.E Railway Broad Gauge Conversion Organistaion was constituted under the Chief Engineer (Construction). The conversion of M.G Section between Muzaffarpur and Raxaul was not under the estimate. Since a major project of the State Government for construction of High Thermal Power Station was going on at Kanti near Muzaffarpur, Union Government was requested to lay broad gauge line between Muzaffarpur and Kanit as the metre gauge was incapable to cater the needs of Thermal Power Station causing delay and hardship. Accordingly, the said request of the State Government was accepted and work to lay down B.G Railway line between Muzaffarpur and Kanti was entrusted to the construction organistion under the supervision of Executive Engineer (petitioner 2), who engaged casual labourers of different grades to lay down the lines.

    5. Petitioner 2 received a notice, dated 5 November 1982 stating that the Labour Enforcement Officer (Central) — Respondent 2 has filed a claim application for realistion of Rs. 3,892.50 towards arrears of minimum wages payable to the casual laboruers engaged by petitioner 2 later, second notice, dated 3 September 1984, was received by petitioner 2 informing that the case would be heard on 20 September 1984 in the Guest House of Barauni Oil Refinery, Barauni. The head clerk of petitioner 2 was deputed to collect the details of the claim. It is alleged that when the said clerk wanted to know the details of claim, the clerk of respondent 1 asked him to copy out the details of casual labourers and amounts allegedly not paid.

    6. The petitioners have annexed with the writ application a chart containing details of the orders and the amount claimed by the Enforcement Officer. Petitioner 2 received the copy of the award and other, dated 28 September 1984, on 15 October 1984 calling upon him to pay the wages and compensation amounting to Rs. 11, 676.00 within thirty days from the award. It is admitted that the notice of the claim was issued only to petitioner 2 and the General Manager was not impleaded. The petitioners have annexed chart containing details of payment made to different workers and on the basis of this it is contended that the casual labourers were paid Rs. 13.18 per day which is much higher than Rs. 7.03 as claimed minimum rate by respondent 2. Learned counsel for the petitioners contended that the claim application was barred by limitation and the delay was condoned without there being any explanation from the second respondent in not preferring the claim application within time. In order to appreciate the contention of the learned counsel for the petitioners that notice to Union of India was necessary although labourers had been employed by petitioner 2, it will be necessary to turn to definition of employer as defined in S. 2(e) of the Minimum Wages Act, 1948. According to this definition, any person who employs, whether directly or through another person, or whether on behalf of himself or any other person, one or more employees in any scheduled employment in respect of which minimum rates of wages have been fixpd under this Act come within the definition of employer.

    7. There are few decisions of the High Court interpreting S. 2(e) of the Minimum Wages Act. There is one decision of Gauhati High Court in Bisnupada Paul v. Sreedam Mandal [1977 (2) L.L.N 204], where the question for consideration was whether the Managing Director of a company making negotiations with the employees on behalf of the Company will come within the definition of Employer, K. Lahiri, J., held considering the facts of that case that the Managing Director was an employer covered by the definition. I may quote in Para. 37, at pages 214 and 215 of the judgment where this question has been discussed:

    “The next point urged by the learned counsel for the petitioner was not very strenuously argued. The argument sought to be made out was that the petitioner was the Managing Director and the company was not impleaded and, as such the entire proceeding is bad. This aspect of the case has been thoroughly dealt with by the authority in question. The petitioner claims that he is the Managing Director of the company registered under the Companies Act, 1956. Along with the petitioner one Swapan Kumar Paul was also added as an employer. The petitioner was made the main opposite party as he happened to be the Managing Director of Assam Bidi Factory (Private), Ltd., and that Swapan Kumar Paul was made the respondent as in charge of Jai Hind Bidi Factory No. 2. The authority has held that Jai Hind Bidi Factory is in fact owned by the Assam Bidi Factory. Nothing has been shown before me as to why the Managing Director of a Bidi Factory cannot be said to be an employer. The company is represented by the Managing Director and he never disowned the said relationship. The Managing Director falls squarely within the definition of S. 2(e) of the Act. The company is to act through somebody. The company employed the bidi makers and the evidence and findings of the authority is that the petitioner was the Managing Director of the company and the employees were employed by the said company. The company cannot itself employ its employees, but must act through somebody. The evidence on the point clearly indicates that this very Managing Director made negotiations, agreements with these employees as an employer or representing the company. Under these circumstances, the Managing Director cannot come around and say that he was not an employer. I hold that the petitioner is an employer covered by the definition and nothing has been shown before the authority nor before me that he is not so. These are questions of fact and cannot be agitated in an application of this nature.”

    8. Now, in the instant case, petitioner 2, it appears, did not raise any objection that he was not an employer nor the employer of the casual labourers. Respondent 1 the Regional Labour Commissioner (Central) had, therefore, no occasion to deal with the question and he proceeded to decide the claim against petitioner 2 alone but this will not debar Union of India from challenging the proceeding on the ground that it was necessary party and hence the notice should have been issued to Union of India through General Manager; North Eastern Railway.

    9. In my opinion, petitioner 2 is not expected to pay the minimum wages from his own pocket and whether he had authority to discharge the liability of Union of India, although in my opinion, petitioner 2 will squarely come within the definition of employer but this question has not been considered by the Regional Labour Commissioner (Central), Dhanbad, whose order is impugned. It would be proper to remand the matter to the said authority for fresh decision in accordance with law.

    10. Accordingly, the impugned order as contained in Annexure 1 is quashed and respondent 1 the Regional Labour Commissioner (Central) Dhanbad, is directed to decide MW (Claim 30/82) in accordance with law within two months of appearance of the petitioners and respondent 2, who was not appeared to contest this application. The petitioners are directed to appear before respondent 1 within two weeks of receipt of certified copy of this order. Respondent 1 the Regional Labour Commissioner (Central), Dhanbad, should decide the dispute after notice to respondent 2. It is, however, made clear that if respondent 1 holds the petitioners liable to pay minimum wage, the petitioner shall be liable to pay 12 per cent interest on the entire dues. No cost.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Union Of India And Another v. Regional Labour Commissioner (Central), Dhanbad, And Another
    (Feb 15, 1996)