AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Smart Summary

Summary of Judgment — Sanju Panda, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

The two writ petitions were heard together because they raise common questions. The Petitioner challenged orders passed by the Sub-Collector, Keonjhar and the Additional District Magistrate (Revenue), Keonjhar (Opposite Parties No. 1 & 2) which cancelled the alienation of approximately 0.30 decimals of land (Plot No. 717, Khata No. 21, Mouza-Gambharia, Keonjhar) and issued a warrant of restoration to execute that order.

The Petitioner originally belongs to village Dhamuria in the district of Singhbhum, State of Bihar, and belongs to the caste "Tanti", which the record indicates is declared a Scheduled Caste in the State of Bihar as per the amended Presidential Notification of 1956. After migrating to Orissa, the Petitioner and his wife purchased the subject property by sale deeds dated 27.3.1989 and obtained mutations from the Tahasildar, Keonjhar; separate khata numbers were issued on 9.8.1996. The vendors were Scheduled Caste persons as per the Presidential Notification for the State of Orissa.

A dispute arose when Opposite Party No. 3 alleged encroachment in relation to an area of 0.12 decimals in Plot No. 717/1501 (Khata No. 159/11) and filed OLR Case No. 5 of 2000 before the Sub-Collector. An inquiry (R.I.) was conducted in the Petitioner's absence. Opposite Party No. 1 allowed the OLR case on 10.12.1999, rejecting the Petitioner's plea that Section 23 of the Orissa Land Reforms Act did not apply because both vendor and purchaser were Scheduled Caste. The Petitioner's appeal (OLR Appeal Case No. 1 of 2000) to Opposite Party No. 2 was dismissed on 7.6.2000, confirming the Sub-Collector's order. The impugned administrative orders declared the alienation invalid on the basis that persons who are Scheduled Castes/Scheduled Tribes of other States are to be treated as belonging to their State of origin for benefits and land alienation purposes unless permissions were validly obtained.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a person who originally belongs to the State of Bihar and is declared a Scheduled Caste for the State of Bihar by Presidential notification (here, the Petitioner identified as "Tanti") is entitled to the same rights and benefits as a Scheduled Caste in the State of Orissa, having migrated and resided there for a prolonged period.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The Petitioner's counsel argued that the caste "Tanti" (called "Pana" & "Swasi" in Bihar) is a Scheduled Caste in Bihar and that the same caste is declared a Scheduled Caste in Orissa; therefore, the Petitioner residing in Orissa should be entitled to the benefits accorded to Scheduled Castes in Orissa.
  • The Petitioner emphasised long residence in Orissa (about 20 years), inclusion in the voter list, possession of a photo identity card, and that his daughter was issued a Scheduled Caste certificate by the Tahasildar, Keonjhar — arguing these facts demonstrate entitlement to SC benefits in Orissa.

Opposite Party No. 3's Arguments

  • Opposite Party No. 3's counsel contended that Scheduled Caste/Tribe persons who have migrated from one State to another are to be treated as Scheduled Caste/Tribe of the State of their origin, not of the State to which they migrated; accordingly, such migrants cannot claim SC/ST status and its attendant benefits in the receiving State.
  • To support that principle, counsel relied on the Apex Court decision in Action Committee on Issue of Caste Certificate to Scheduled Castes & Scheduled Tribes in the State of Maharashtra v. Union of India, (1994) 5 SCC 244, and on governmental orders (G.O. No. B.C-16014.I/82-S.C. & B.C.D-I dated 22.2.1985 and G.O. No. 36259.R dated 17.9.1996 / 17.8.1996 as cited in the record) which, according to counsel, expressly treat migrants as belonging to their State of origin and declare any alienation in favour of such persons without valid permission as null and void.
  • Based on those authorities and orders, Opposite Party No. 3 supported the impugned administrative decisions cancelling the alienation and asked that the writ petitions be dismissed.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Action Committee on Issue of Caste Certificate to Scheduled Castes & Scheduled Tribes in the State of Maharashtra v. Union of India, (1994) 5 SCC 244 Held that the Presidential declaration by public notification (in consultation with the State Governor) about Scheduled Castes/Scheduled Tribes in relation to a State is conclusive and the Court cannot substitute its own declaration; supports the principle that migrants are to be treated as Scheduled Caste/Tribe of their State of origin for the purposes indicated in administrative orders. The Court relied on the principle that Presidential notifications determining SC/ST status for a State are conclusive and on the administrative practice that migrants remain SC/ST of their State of origin; this underpinned the view that the Petitioner could not claim SC status and benefits in Orissa merely by residence.
Marri Chandra Shekar Rao v. Dean Seth G.S. Medical College, (1990) 3 SCC 130 Explains the need to balance protections: Scheduled Castes & Scheduled Tribes of different States require protection within their own State contexts and such protection must be balanced against other communities in that State. The Court invoked this Constitution Bench authority to emphasise that SC/ST protections are area-specific and that those entitled to protection in one State are not automatically entitled to equivalent protection in another; this supported the conclusion that the Petitioner, being SC in Bihar, could not claim equivalent SC status in Orissa.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's analysis proceeded in discrete steps strictly grounded in the materials and authorities cited in the record:

  1. Factual assessment: The court accepted the essential factual matrix as undisputed — the Petitioner's Bihar origin, his caste identification as "Tanti", migration to Orissa, long residence (approximately 20 years), mutation entries and khata numbers, and the administrative proceedings (OLR case and appeal) culminating in cancellation of alienation.
  2. Constitutional/legal source: The court noted that Presidential notifications made under Articles 341(1) and 342(1) of the Constitution (issued in 1950 and later amended by Parliament) identify Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes for particular States, and that such declarations are conclusive unless amended by Parliament.
  3. Precedential support: The court relied on the Apex Court's pronouncement in the Action Committee case that the President's declaration for a State (made in consultation with the Governor) is conclusive and the judiciary cannot make an alternative declaration; this principle limits judicial re-characterisation of who is a Scheduled Caste/Tribe for a given State.
  4. Balancing principle: The court invoked the reasoning in Marri Chandra Shekar Rao emphasizing that protections for SC/ST are to be administered with regard to the specific State context — each State's SC/ST communities require protection within that State, and migrants do not automatically displace the locally disadvantaged communities.
  5. Administrative framework and policy rationale: The court described the policy reasons for State and Union instructions and the allocation of responsibilities to revenue officers to verify and issue social status certificates — namely, to prevent unscrupulous persons from obtaining reservation benefits and from grabbing land belonging to SC/ST persons. These policy considerations support strict adherence to the area-specific character of Presidential notifications and administrative rules.
  6. Application to the present dispute: Based on the foregoing constitutional text, precedent, and policy considerations, the court concluded that the Petitioner — though a Scheduled Caste in Bihar and a long-term resident in Orissa — could not claim the status and attendant benefits of a Scheduled Caste in Orissa merely by residence. Consequently, there was no error apparent on the face of the impugned orders cancelling the alienation and directing restoration.
  7. Scope of judicial interference: The court determined that, given the conclusive nature of Presidential notifications and the administrative scheme, there was no basis for interference under Article 227 of the Constitution; the impugned administrative orders stood validly made and confirmed by the appellate revenue authority.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The writ petitions were dismissed. The court held that the Petitioner, who is a Scheduled Caste as regards the State of Bihar by Presidential notification, is not entitled to claim Scheduled Caste status and the attendant benefits in the State of Orissa merely by virtue of migration and residence.

Implications:

  • The direct effect is that the impugned orders passed by the Sub-Collector and the Additional District Magistrate (Revenue) cancelling the alienation and issuing warrant of restoration are upheld and the Petitioner’s challenge is rejected.
  • The court underscored and applied the established principle that Presidential notifications under Articles 341/342 determine the territorial application of SC/ST status; this case does not create new law but applies existing constitutional and precedential rules to the facts before it.
  • No broader or novel precedent was announced by the court; the decision enforces the settled position that SC/ST status is area-specific and that administrative and judicial actors must respect Presidential notifications and the related administrative orders designed to protect local SC/ST communities and prevent misuse.

Disposition: Both writ petitions are dismissed.

    Banamali Mallick v. Sub-Collector, Keonjhar & Ors. Opp. Parties.

    Sanju Panda, J.:— Both the Writ Petitions having involved common questions were heard together & are being disposed of by this common order.

    2. The Petitioner, in both the Writ Petitions, has challenged the impugned orders passed by the Sub-Collector, Keonjhar & Addl. District Magistrate (Revenue), Keonjhar, Opp. Parties 1 & 2 respectively cancelling alienation of the land measuring Ac. 0.30 decimals of land appertaining to Plot No. 717 under Khata No. 21 of Mouza-Gambharia in the district of Keonjhar & issuing warrant of restoration for execution of order. The facts leading to the present case are as follows:

    The Petitioner belongs to village Dhamuria in the district of Singhbhum of the State of Bihar. The caste of the Petitioner is “Tanti” which is declared to be Scheduled Caste, as amended by the Scheduled Castes/Scheduled Tribes List Modification Order, 1956 so far as the State of Bihar is concerned. He migrated from Bihar to Orissa. The Petitioner & his wife purchased the aforesaid property from Kathin Patra, Gai Patra & Narottama Patra by virtue of different sale deeds dated 27.3.1989 After purchasing the said property, the Petitioner & his wife separately filed two mutation cases before the Tahasildar, Keonjhar for mutation of their names. Both the cases were allowed, ROR was corrected & separate Khata Nos. 159/44 & 159/48 respectively were issued in their favour on 9.8.1996 The vendors of the Petitioner are Scheduled Caste persons as per the Presidential Notification, 1950 relating to the State of Orissa. Since both the vendors & the purchasers belonged to Scheduled Caste, at the time of purchase, no prior permission was obtained from the competent authorities. Opp. Party No. 3 along with the Petitioner purchased an area of Ac. 0.12 decimals of land in Plot No. 717/1501 under Khata No. 159/11. Opp. Party No. 3 claiming about encroachment by the Petitioner filed OLR Case No. 5 of 2000 before the Sub-Collector, Keonjkhar who directed to depute an R.1 to conduct an inquiry. Accordingly, the concerned R.1 conducted an inquiry in the absence of the Petitioner. Said OLR Case No. 5 of 2000 was allowed by Opp. Party No. 1 on 10.12.1999 In that case, the Petitioner had taken a plea that since both are Scheduled Caste persons, Section 23 of the Orissa Land Reforms Act (in short, “the Act”) was not applicable to the said case. However, the said plea of the Petitioner was rejected. The Petitioner also contended that he is residing in the State of Orissa for the last 20 years. His name has been included in the voter-list & photo identity card has been issued in his favour & he is enjoying all the benefits of Scheduled Caste in the State of Orissa. However, Opp. Parties 1 & 2 did not accept the plea of the Petitioner following G.O No. B.C-16014.I/82-S.C. & B.C.D-I dated 22nd February, 1985 issued by the Government of India in the Ministry of Home Affairs & G.O No. 36259.R dated 17.9.1996 passed in the Revenue & Excise Department of Government of Orissa to the effect that Scheduled Tribe/Scheduled Caste persons of other States/Union Territories will be deemed to be the Scheduled Tribe/Caste persons of the State/Union Territories of the origin. Any alienation made in their favour without valid’.p-lrmission??? will be null & void. Being aggrieved by the order passed by Opp. Party No. 1, the Petitioner preferred OLR Appeal Case No. 1 of 2000 before Opp. Party No. 2 under Section 58 of the Act. However, the appeal was also dismissed confirming the order of the Sub-Collector on 7.6.2000 The Petitioner further contended that the Tahasildar, Keonjhar, who is the competent authority, issued Scheduled Caste Certificate to his daughter Manju Mallick as per the Rules prevailing in the State of Orissa & is getting all the benefits as Scheduled Caste in the State of Orissa. Though he filed all the documents before the authorities, they did not consider those materials.

    3. Learned Counsel appearing for the Petitioner submitted that in the State of Bihar, “Pana” & “Swasi” Castes are called as “Tanti” & those castes are enlisted in the categories of Scheduled Caste as per the amended Notification of 1956 relating to the State of Bihar. Since the Petitioner belongs to the caste “Tanti” which is a Scheduled Caste in the State of Bihar & the same caste is also declared as Scheduled Caste in the State of Orissa & he is residing in Orissa, he is entitled to get all the benefits as provided to the category of Scheduled Caste in the State of Orissa & the impugned orders passed by Opp. Parties 1 & 2 are liable to be set aside.

    4. Learned Counsel appearing for Opp. Party No. 3 contended that the Scheduled Caste & Scheduled Tribe persons who have migrated from one State to another will be deemed to be Scheduled Caste or Scheduled Tribe persons of the State of their origin. However, they will not be treated as Scheduled Caste or Scheduled Tribe in the State to which they have migrated. In support of his contention, he placed reliance on a decision of the Apex Court in the case of Action Committee on Issue of Caste Certificate to Scheduled Castes & Scheduled Tribes in the State of Maharashtra v. Union of India, (1994) 5 SCC 244. He also relied on G.O No. B.C-16014/1182-S.C. & B.C.D-I dated 22nd February, 1985 issued by the Government of India, Ministry of Home Affairs wherein it is clarified that a Scheduled Castel Tribe person, who has migrated from the State of origin to some other State for the purpose of seeking education, employment, etc., will be deemed to be a Scheduled Caste/Tribe of the State of his origin & will be entitled to derive benefits from the State of origin & not from the State to which he has migrated. He also placed reliance on G.O No. 36259 dated 17.8.1996 of the Government of Orissa in the Revenue & Excise Department wherein it is clarified that since the Scheduled Tribe/Scheduled Caste persons of other State/Union Territories will be deemed to be Scheduled Tribe/Caste persons of the State/Union Territories of the Origin, any alienation made in their favour without valid permission will be null & void. Accordingly, he supported the impugned orders passed by Opp. Parties 1 & 2 & submitted that the Writ Petition is liable to be dismissed being devoid of merit.

    5. From the facts narrated above & the submissions made by the Learned Counsel for the parties, it is to be decided as to whether the Petitioner, who originally belongs to the State of Bihar & whose caste is declared as a Scheduled Caste as per the Presidential Notification in respect of the State of Bihar, is entitled to get similar benefits as a Scheduled Caste in the State of Orissa?

    6. The factual aspects of the case are not in dispute in this Writ Petition though the Petitioner is residing in the State of Orissa or the last 20 years & also Scheduled Caste certificate has been issued in favour of his daughter. The Petitioner originally belongs to the State of Bihar. Migrating from Bihar to Orissa, he is now residing in Orissa. He belongs to Scheduled Caste, so far as the State of Bihar is concerned. However, he cannot claim the same benefits in the State of Orissa as are available to a Schedule Caste person in the State of Bihar.

    7. The President in the year 1950 in exercise of the powers under Article 341(1) & 342(1) of the Constitution of India notified the Scheduled Castes & Scheduled Tribe respectively in respect of the States after consultation with the Governors of the respective States by public notification. The said Presidential declaration, subject to amendment by the Parliament being conclusive, no addition to it or declaration of castes/tribes or sub-castes/parts of groups of tribes or tribal communities is permissible.

    8. The Apex Court in the State of Maharashtra's case (supra) has held that the declaration by the President by a public notification in relation to a State in consultation with the Governor of that State is conclusive & the Court cannot give such a declaration.

    9. The Union of India & the State Governments have prescribed the procedure & have entrusted duty & responsibility to Revenue Officers of gazetted cadre to issue social status certificate, after due verification. It is common knowledge that endeavour of States to fulfill constitutional mandate of upliftment of Scheduled Castes & Scheduled Tribes by providing for reservation of seats in educational institutions & for reservation of posts & appointments, are sought to be denied to them by unscrupulous persons who come forward to obtain the benefits of such reservations & also grab the landed property of Scheduled Castes/Scheduled Tribes. Therefore, the Union of India & the State Governments are issuing G.O giving certain instructions to their officers so that the Scheduled Caste/Scheduled Tribe persons of the State will get the benefits & they will not cease to get the better & more social free & liberal atmosphere & their status will be uplifted in the State & they will get the full scope to blossom & flourish.

    10. The Scheduled Castes & Scheduled Tribes belonging to a particular area of the country must be given protection so long as & to the extent they are entitled to in order to equal with others but those who go to other areas should ensure that they make way for the disadvantaged & disabled of that part of the community who suffer from disabilities in those areas.

    11. A Constitution Bench of the Apex Court in the case of Marri Chandra Shekar Rao v. Dean Seth G.S Medical College, (1990) 3 SCC 130, has held as follows:

    “In other words, Scheduled Castes & Scheduled Tribes say of Andhra Pradesh do require necessary protection as balanced between other communities. But equally the Scheduled Castes & Scheduled Tribes say of Maharashtra in the instant case, do require protection in the State of Maharashtra, which will have to be in balance to other communities. This must be the basic approach to the problem. If one bears this basic in mind, then the determination of the controversy in the instant case does not become difficult.”

    12. In view of the above decision of the Apex Court, the Petitioner who belongs to Scheduled Caste of State of Bihar as per the Presidential Notification is not entitled to become a Scheduled Caste so far as the State of Orissa is concerned.

    13. Law is well settled that the President, as required under Articles 341 & 342 of the Constitution of India with respect to other State & Union Territory, & where it is a State, after consultation with the Governor of the concerned State, has issued orders notifying various castes & tribes as Scheduled Castes & Scheduled Tribes in relation to that State or Union Territory from time to time. The inter-state area restrictions have been deliberately imposed so that the people belonging to the specific community residing in a specific area, which has been assessed to qualify for the Scheduled Caste or Scheduled Tribe status, only benefit from the facilities provided for them.

    14. In view of the above analysis & as there is no error apparent on the face of the impugned orders passed by Opp. Parties 1 & 2, this Court is not inclined to interfere with the same in exercise of its jurisdiction under Article 227 of the Constitution of India. Accordingly, both the Writ Petitions are dismissed.

    15. Writ Petition dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Banamali Mallick v. Sub-Collector, Keonjhar & Ors. Opp. Parties.
    (Mar 7, 2012)