AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion (Pasayat, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

Two interlinked writ applications were considered together. One (OJC No. 10871 of 1996) was registered on the basis of a letter addressed to the Chief Justice and was presented as being in public interest by villagers of Jajarsingh. The other (OJC No. 13341 of 1996) was filed by Basantinath Dulta.

The dispute concerned the shifting of foreign liquor retail shops in Khurda (Khurda No. 1 and Khurda No. 2). Basantinath Dulta was the licensee for Khurda No. 2; Raghunath Patnaik was the licensee for Khurda No. 1. Licences for both had been renewed for the period 1-11-1996 to 31-3-1997 on payment of consideration money.

Raghunath applied to the Collector, Khurda for permission to shift his shop from its existing site to another premises. The Superintendent of Excise, Khurda issued an order permitting the shift on the basis of the Collector's orders and forwarded the matter to the Excise Commissioner for approval. Basantinath objected, contending the Collector lacked power to permit shifting and that approval ought to be given by the Commissioner of Excise; he also asserted that his business would be adversely affected. The villagers asserted the shift would disturb law and order and the peaceful nature of the locality, describing the proposed site as close to residential and official quarters and educational institutions.

Procedurally, the Collector had allowed shifting and the Superintendent of Excise had issued an order; the Superintendent's order and contemporaneous events indicated that physical shifting had been effected on 26-11-1996. The Excise Minister forwarded objections on 27-11-1996 and desired no final decision without discussion with him. The State represented that concurrence/approval of the Excise Commissioner was sought and was under consideration when Basantinath filed his writ.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the writ application filed by the villagers (styled as a public interest litigation) was bona fide public interest litigation or a mala fide/private dispute masked as public interest.
  2. Whether the Collector and Superintendent of Excise had power to permit and effect a change of site of an excise shop without prior approval of the Commissioner of Excise, in light of the Orissa Excise Manual and related government instructions.
  3. What interim directions (if any) should be given where physical shifting has been effected but the Commissioner of Excise has not given final approval.

Arguments of the Parties

Villagers (petitioners in OJC No. 10871 of 1996)

  • Asserted that the proposed shifting of the liquor shop would adversely affect law and order and disturb peaceful traffic and serenity of the locality, which contains official residences, courts, hospital and various schools and temples.
  • Presented their petition as being in the public interest.

Basantinath Dulta (petitioner in OJC No. 13341 of 1996)

  • Objected to the shifting on the ground that the Collector had no power to permit shifting and any permission ought to be by orders of the Commissioner of Excise.
  • Contended that allowing shifting would adversely affect his business causing financial loss.

Raghunath Patnaik (licensee seeking to shift his shop)

  • Contended that the new site was only about 100 yards from the earlier site and would not adversely affect Basantinath’s business.
  • Alleged that the villagers’ objections were set up by Basantinath and were mala fide because they had not earlier objected when Basantinath’s shop was located close to the existing site.
  • Relied on the Superintendent of Excise's order and the Collector's decision to justify that shifting had been permitted.

State / Excise Authorities

  • Submitted that the Collector had exercised discretion in permitting the shift and that there was nothing illicit in his decision.
  • Represented that the matter had been sent to the Commissioner of Excise for concurrence and that the Commissioner’s approval was being/was to be sought and considered when the writ was filed.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Janata Dal v. H.S. Chowdhury, AIR 1993 SC 892 (1993 AIR SCW 248) Principles on Public Interest Litigation: petitioners must act bona fide and have clean hands, clean mind and clean objective; caution against misuse of public interest litigation for private motives. The court relied on the principles laid down in this decision to assess the bona fides of the villagers' petition, to hold that the villagers' writ was mala fide and to emphasise strict criteria for allowing public interest litigation.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded in two parts: first addressing the villagers' writ application (OJC No. 10871 of 1996) and then Basantinath's writ (OJC No. 13341 of 1996).

Analysis of the villagers' writ (public interest petition)

  • The court observed that the villagers' objections were directed against a shift that was undisputedly only a very short distance from the earlier location, and noted the inconsistency that existence of two shops in nearby vicinity had not previously produced objections.
  • The court invoked Article 47 (Directive Principles) which postulates that the State shall endeavour to bring about prohibition, observing that invocation of public interest cannot be selective or used to advance private disputes.
  • Relying on the principle in Janata Dal v. H.S. Chowdhury, the court held that public interest litigation must be genuine, and that petitioners must have clean hands, clean mind and clean objective; the court cautioned against busy bodies and persons using public interest litigation as a cloak for private malice, vested interest or publicity-seeking.
  • Factually, the court found that the shop was not intended to be shifted to the house of Shri Surendra Mohan Patnaik (contrary to the villagers' allegation) and concluded that the villagers' petition was mala fide and amounted to a private dispute presented as public interest litigation.

Analysis of Basantinath's writ (jurisdiction and procedural validity)

  • The court identified relevant administrative instructions: Para 92 of the Orissa Excise Manual (Vol. III) and Government of Orissa instruction No. IEX-20/90 (Pt. II) 671.Ex. dt. 23-4-1990, which require that sites of excise shops be specified in the sale notification and provide that sites are subject to approval of the Collector and that "after the Commissioner of Excise has sanctioned settlement proposals, his approval must be obtained before any change of site is sanctioned or required." Clause 2(vi) of the government instruction provides for removal to any other approved site subject to Excise Commissioner's approval.
  • Given the requirement that change of site becomes effective only with the approval of the Commissioner of Excise, the court reasoned that permitting a change and effecting physical shifting before the Commissioner had passed a final order was procedurally improper.
  • On the facts, the Superintendent of Excise's office order not only directed shifting but also required supervision and submission of compliance report. The Superintendent forwarded the matter to the Commissioner of Excise for approval, but the Commissioner had not passed a final order at the time the writ was considered.
  • The court acknowledged the practical reality that shifting had been effected physically, making the situation "piquant", but emphasised that substantive approval remained outstanding and that procedural requirement of prior approval should have been respected.
  • Balancing these considerations, the court directed the Commissioner of Excise to take a decision on whether the shifting should be allowed and to pass necessary orders within ten days. Pending the Commissioner's decision, the court ordered maintenance of status quo respecting the shop's status, while expressly stating it did not express any opinion on the merits.

Holding and Implications

Holding:

  • Villagers' writ application (OJC No. 10871 of 1996) — DISMISSED as frivolous and mala fide.
  • Basantinath's writ application (OJC No. 13341 of 1996) — disposed of with direction that the Commissioner of Excise shall decide on the permissibility of the shifting within ten days and that status quo shall be maintained until disposal by the Commissioner.
  • The court awarded No costs in respect of Basantinath's writ.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: the villagers' challenge is rejected; Basantinath's challenge is disposed of subject to administrative action by the Commissioner of Excise within the timeline prescribed by the court, and an interim status quo has been ordered.
  • The court emphasised procedural compliance with the Orissa Excise Manual and the need for prior approval by the Commissioner of Excise before a change of site becomes effective. The decision requires the Commissioner to regularise the matter by a final order within ten days.
  • The opinion does not purport to lay down any new legal principle beyond enforcing existing administrative requirements and applying established public interest litigation principles; no broader precedent was announced beyond the application of those existing principles to the facts before the court.

Order recorded: S.N. Phukan, C.J., agreed. "Order accordingly."

    Villagers Of Jajarsingh Basantinath Dutta v. State Of Orissa And Others Opposite Parties.

    Pasayat, J.:— These two writ applications are interlinked and are disposed of by this judgment which shall govern each one of them. Writ application (OJC No. 10871 of 1996) was registered on the basis of a letter addressed to the Hon'ble the Chief Justice and it was staled to be in public interest. The oilier one is by one Basanlinalh Dulta. The controversy revolves round shilling of a liquor shop from its earlier site to another place.

    2. Factual position is almost undisputed, and in a nutshell is as follows:

    State Government intended to grant exclusive privilege of possession and retail sale of foreign liquor at various localities in the districts of Puri and accordingly objections were invited from persons residing within the local area specified. Present controversy relates to two foreign liquor shops, namely, Khurda No. 1, and Khurda No. 2. Basantinath Dulta petitioner in OJC No. 13341 of 1996 has been granted licensee for retail sale of potable foreign liquor in respect of Khurda No. 2 shop. Raghunath Patnaik is the licensee in respect of Khurda No. 1 shop. The local areas specified for Khurda No. 1 and Khurda No. 2 are as follows:

    Khurda No. 1 Existing site at eastern portion of Khurda bus stand.

    Khurda No. 2 Existing site at western portion of Khurda bus stand.

    Licenees of both Basantinath and Raghunath have been renewed for the period from 1-11-1996 to 31-3-1997, both days inclusive, on payment of consideration money. Raghunath applied for permission to shift the shop from the existing premises to the house of one Shri Bibhuti Patnaik. The Superintendent of Excise. Khurda permitted shilling on the basis of orders passed by the Collector, Khurda, Basantinath Dutta objected to it saying that the Collector has no power to permit shifting, and if any permission is to be granted, same has to be by orders of the Commissioner of Excise. In any event, his business would be adversely affected. The villagers of Jajarsingh, who have filed OJC No. 10871 of 1996, have raised dispute that the shifting would affect law and order situation, and peaceful traffic condition of the locality would be disturbed. It was stated that the proposed site to which Raghunath wanted to shift is the house of one Shri Surendra Mohan Patnaik and situates in a peaceful area having official and residential quarters of the Additional District Judge. Civil Judges of Khurda Court. Khurda hospital. B.T.B High School, Sanskrit Mahavidyalay, D.T.H.T Practising U.G.M.E School, Saraswati Shishu Mandir, Monalisa English Medium School, Saraswali Temple. Hingulal Temple and Satsang Vihar etc. Shilling would not be according to them, against public interest. While Basantinath has raised the point of jurisdiction to assail the permission granting shifting of the shop. Villagers of Jajarsingh have indicated public interest.

    3. Stand of Raghunath on the other hand is that the place to which the shop was shifted would hardly be at a distance of 100 yards from the earlier site, and in no way would affect the business of Basantinath. The villagers have been set up by Basantinath and if they did not object to location of Basantinath's shop which was hardly at a distance of 25 yards from the earlier site, objection to location of new shop at the new site is clearly mala fide. Learned counsel for State submitted that the Collector has exercised his discretion and there is nothing illicit in his decision to allow shifting. In any event, the matter was sent for concurrence of the Commissioner of Excise, and in hot haste writ application has been filed by Basantinath.

    4. We shall first deal with the application registered as writ application filed by the villagers. We find it strange that they have objected to the shilling of the shop which is undisputedly at a very short distance from its earlier location. If serenity of the locality was to be affected by shifting, it is unfathomable as to how existance of two shops in the nearby vicinity have not dime it.

    5. Article 47 of the Constitution of India forms part of Chapter relating to directive Principles. It postulates that the State shall endevaour to bring about prohibition. There can be no semblance of public interest when several persons object to the shilling of location of a shop by a person, while espousing the cause of another. The writ application is certainly mala fide, and a private dispute is intended to be given a colour of public interest dispute. Factually also the correct position has not been indicated. The shop was not intended to be shifted to the house of one Shri Surendra Mohan Patnaik as alleged.

    6. Before we grapple with the actual problems, we feel it necessary to keep the records straight so far as public interest aspects are concerned. Public interest litigation which has now come to occupy an important field in the administration of law should not be public interest litigation or private interest litigation. There must be real and genuine public interest involved in the litigation, and it cannot be invoked by a person or a body of persons to further his or their personal causes or satisfy him or his personal grudge and enmity. The Courts of justice should not be allowed to be polluted by unscrupulous litigants by resorting to the extraordinary jurisdiction. A person acting bona fide and having sufficient interest in the proceeding of public interest litigation will alone have a locus standi and can approach the Court to wipe out violation of fundamental rights and genuine infraction of statutory provisions, but not for personal gain or private profit or political motive or any oblique consideration. These aspects were highlighted by the Apex Court in The Janata Dal v. H.S Chowdhury, AIR 1993 SC 892 : (1993 AIR SCW 248). A writ petitioner who comes to the Court for relief in public interest must come not only with clean hands like any other writ petitioner, but also with a clean hand, clean mind and a clean objective.

    Public interest litigation is a weapon which has to be used with great care and circumspection and the judiciary has to be extremely careful to see that behind the beautiful vail of public interest any ugly private malice, vested interest and/or publicity seeking is not lurking. It is to be used as an effective weapon in the armoury of law for delivering social justice to the citizens. The attractive brand name of public interest litigation should not be used for suspicious products of mischief. It should be aimed at redressal of genuine public wrong or public injury and not publicity oriented or founded on personal vendetta. Court must be careful to see that a member of public, who approaches the Court is acting bona fide and not for personal gain or private motive or political motivation or other oblique consideration. The Court must not allow its process to be abused for oblique considerations. They indulge in the pasttime of meddling with the judicial process either by force of habit or from improper motives. Often they are actuated by a desire to win notoriety or cheap popularity. The petitions of such busy bodies deserve to be thrown out by rejection at the threshold.

    7. The council for Public Interest Law set up by the Ford Foundation in U.S.A defined the Public Interest Litigation in its report of Public Interest Law. U.S.A 1976 as follows:

    “Public Interest Law is the name that has recently been given to efforts provide legal representation to previously unrepresented groups and interests. Such efforts have been undertaken in the recognition that ordinary market place for legal services fails to provide such services to significant segments of the population and to significant interests. Such groups and interests include the proper, environmentalities consumers, recial and othenic minorities, and others.”

    The Court has to be satisfied about (a) the credentials of the applicant: (b) the prima facie correctness of nature of information given by him: (c) the intention being not vague and indefinite. The information should show gravity and seriousness involved. Court has to strike a balance between two conflicting interests: (a) Nobody should be allowed to indulge in wild and reckless allegations be smirching the character of others: and (b) avoidance of public mischief and to avoid publicly mischievous executive actions. In such cases, however, the Court cannot afford to be liberal. It has to be extremely careful to see that under the guise of redressing a public grievance, it does not encroach upon the sphere reserved by the Constitution to the Executive and the Legislature. The Court has to act ruthlessly while dealing with impostors and busy bodies, of meddlesome interlopers impersonating as public spirited holymen. They masquerads as crusaders of justice. They pretend to act in the name of Pro Bono Publico, though they have no interest of the public or even of their own to protect.

    In ‘public Interest Law’ edited by Jeromy Cooper and Rajeev Chavan (Paga 56) about the jurisdiction of the Court what was said was:

    “Moreover, the judiciary have fairly limited powers at common law to extend the areas of public interest generally and in legal proceedings in particular. The responsibility for such extension and expansion has become a matter of political argument and debate and has fallen on the legislative branch of government, so that what social, economic, financial or other activities should be regarded as coming within the parameters of the public interest, and if so to what extent and the method of their regulation, are largely matters that have to be enacted by Parliament and statutory instruments.”

    8. Test litigation, representative actions. Pro Bono Publico, and like broadened forms of legal proceedings are in keeping with the current ascent on justice to common man and a necessary disincentive to those who wish to by-pass the real issues on merits by suspect reliance on peripheral, procedural shortcomings.

    The writ application by the villagers (OJC No. 10871 of 1996) is frivolous and is dismissed.

    9. Coming to the writ application filed by Basantinath, few facts which are relevant need to be indicated. On 17-9-1996 Raghunath filed an application for permission before the Collector. Khurda to shift his shop room as the existing shop room was badly damaged due to heavy rain. Basantinath filed an objection petition on 17-10-1996 stating that if such shifting is allowed, there will be a clash in business causing great financial loss to him. The Collector allowed the shifting under intimation to the Excise Commissioner. Accordingly, the Superintendent of Excise issued an order which is impugned in the writ application, forwarding a copy to the Excise Commissioner seeking his approval. Objection of some persons was forwarded by the Minister of Excise on 27-11-1996. It was indicated in the endorsement of the Excise minister that he had discussed the matter with residents of Khurda N.A.C who wanted shifting not to be allowed. He desired that no final decision should be taken without discussion with him. But by that time, the Collector had already allowed the shifting. Superintendent of Excise on the basis of report of S.I in charge noted that on 26-11-1996 shifting had been done.

    10. Orissa Excise Manual, Volume III contains the instructions issued by Board of Revenue (Revenue Commissioner), and deals with settlement of licences. Para 92 deals with the sites of the shops, and reads as follows:

    “92. When an excise shop is settled, what is settled is the right of vend of a certain intoxicant in a certain locality. As a general rule it is not desirable that the sites of shops should be absolutely fixed in the sale proceedings, as the person who takes settlement may find difficulty in coming to terms with the owner of specified premises. On the other hand, vagueness, which may mislead as to locality, is to be avoided. Ordinarily it will be sufficient to specify as the locality of vend, a village or certain tolas of a village, or in towns a street or certain streets. Where this is insufficient, the Collector should specify a particular distance from some fixed spot as the limit within which the shop may be opened or some particular tract, the boundaries of which should be so described as to leave no possible room for misapprehension. The locality must be fixed and notified in the sale notification published before the settlement is made. The sites of all shops are subject to the approval of the Collector. After the Commissioner of Excise has sanctioned settlement proposals, his approval must be obtained before any change of site is sanctioned or required.”

    These instructions have been issued by the Member. Board of Revenue by exercise of powers conferred under S. 90 of the Bihar and Orissa Excise Act, 1915 (in short, ‘the Act’). The Government of Orissa in Revenue and Excise Department has issued instructions vide No. IEX-20/90 (Pt. 11) 671.Ex. dt. 23-4-1990 wherein the details of sale notice have been indicated. Clause 2(vi) makes a provision for removal to any other approved site subject to approval of the Excise Commissioner.

    Stand of the State Government is that approval of the Excise Commissioner was sought for and the matter was under consideration when the writ application came to be filed and the process of consideration came to be stalled.

    11. In view of requirement of approval of the Commissioner of Excise the change of site is to be effective only with the approval of the Excise Commissioner. In the instant case, change has been permitted and a copy of office order allowing shifting was sent to the Commissioner of Excise for favour of information. However, his approval was sought for. The Commissioner has not passed final order in the matter. Before approval the shifting should not have been permitted to be effected. From the impugned office order vide Annexure 6 it appears that the Superintendent of Excise has not only directed shifting, but also has indicated that shifting was to be done under the supervision of local charge officer and compliance report was to be submitted for records so far as the actual date of shifting is concerned. The learned counsel for Raghunath submitted that in view of the order passed by the Superintendent of Excise physical shifting has been done. The situation is certainly piquant. In the peculiar circumstances, we direct the Commissioner of Excise to take a decision whether shifting is to be allowed. He shall pass necessary orders within ten days from today. In view of undisputed position that the shop has been shifted, status quo shall be maintained till disposal of the matter by the Commissioner. We make it clear that by directing maintenance of status quo we have not expressed any opinion on the merits.

    The writ application (OJC No. 13341 of 1996) filed by Basantinath is disposed of accordingly. No cost.

    S.N Phukan, C.J:— 12. I agree.

    Order accordingly.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Villagers Of Jajarsingh Basantinath Dutta v. State Of Orissa And Others Opposite Parties.
    (Jan 24, 1997)