Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This revision challenges an order passed by the Additional Munsif, Kendrapara, who refused to appoint a civil court commissioner for local inspection under Order 26, Rule 9 of the Civil Procedure Code (CPC). The dispute between the parties concerned the precise location of a wall—whether it stood on the west of plot No. 306 or on the east of plot No. 307. The Additional Munsif rejected the plaintiff-petitioner’s application for local inspection as premature, stating that if necessary, a commissioner would be appointed after the closure of evidence.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the court should exercise its discretion under Order 26, Rule 9 CPC to appoint a commissioner for local investigation when the dispute involves identification, location, or measurement of land or objects.
  2. Whether the appointment of a commissioner for local inspection can be deferred until after the closure of evidence or should be allowed at an earlier stage.
  3. Whether the court can refuse to appoint a commissioner on the ground that a party can engage a private surveyor and produce evidence through such a person.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Amulya Kumar Samaddar v. Ananda Charan Das, AIR 1933 Cal 475 Local investigation is essential in disputes involving identification or determination of land area, as the evidence can only be properly gathered on the spot. The Court relied on this precedent to emphasize the necessity of appointing a commissioner for local investigation in land disputes to enable proper evidence collection.
P. Moosa Kutty, AIR 1953 Mad 717 Local investigation and measurement are essential in cases involving land identification or measurement disputes. The Court cited this case to support the proposition that local investigation should ordinarily not be refused when it is requisite for elucidating matters in dispute.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court began by interpreting Order 26, Rule 9 CPC, which grants the Court discretion to appoint a commissioner for local investigation when it deems such investigation requisite or proper to clarify matters in dispute. The Court emphasized that this discretion must be exercised judiciously and not whimsically or capriciously. It noted that refusal to appoint a commissioner is justifiable only if the application is belated, mala fide, or under circumstances warranting refusal.

The Court rejected the argument that the right of a party to adduce evidence through a private surveyor justifies denying appointment of a court commissioner. It highlighted practical difficulties private surveyors face, such as possible resistance when entering the other party’s premises, which a court-appointed commissioner would not encounter due to the authority of the court’s writ.

Since the dispute concerned the precise location of a wall between two plots, the Court found local investigation essential. It further held that such investigation should ordinarily be conducted at an early stage, before the parties adduce evidence, so that the report of the commissioner can inform the trial preparation. The Court thus concluded that the Additional Munsif erred in refusing to appoint a commissioner on the ground of prematurity.

Holding and Implications

The Court’s final decision was to allow the revision and vacate the impugned order refusing the appointment of a civil court commissioner. The Additional Munsif was directed to appoint a survey-knowing commissioner to carry out the local investigation.

The direct effect of this decision is that local investigations for land disputes, particularly those involving location and measurement, should not be deferred until after evidence closure but conducted early to aid trial preparation. No new precedent was explicitly set beyond reaffirming the proper exercise of discretion under Order 26, Rule 9 CPC.

    Mahendranath Parida v. Purnananda Parida And Others

    1. This revision is directed against an order passed by the additional Munsif, Kendrapara refusing to appoint a civil court commissioner for local inspection under the provision of O. 26, R. 9 of the Civil P.C

    2. The controversy between the parties was as to the location of a wall, namely, whether it stood on west of plot No. 306 or on the east of plot No. 307. The learned Additional Munsif rejected the petition filed by the plaintiff-petitioner for local inspection. The application was rejected as premature with the observation that if it was considered necessary, commissioner would be appointed after evidence was closed.

    3. Though the question of law is a simple one, it requires elaboration having regard to some stray observations in some judgments that the Court can refuse to appoint a commissioner under the provision of O. 26, R. 9 and require the party to adduce evidence through a private Amin after getting the land measured by him.

    4. O. 26, R. 9 of the Civil P.C reads as under:—

    “R. 9. Commissions to make local investigation.

    In any suit in which the Court deems a local investigation to be requisite or proper for the purpose of elucidating any matter in dispute, or of ascertaining the marked value of any property, or the amount of any mesne profits or damages or annual net profits, the Court may issue a commission to such person as it thinks fit directing him to make such investigation and to report thereon to the Court:

    Provided that, where the State Government has made ules as to the persons to whom such commission shall be issued, the Court shall be bound by such rules.”

    No doubt, the provision confers a discretion on the Court. But the discretion, as it is well known, has to be exercised in a judicious and sound manner but not whimsically and capriciously. What is necessary to note in the provision is the expression ‘deems a local investigation to be requisite or proper for the purpose of elucidating any matter in dispute………’ Therefore, where the Court considers a local investigation to be requisite and proper, ordinarily it should not decline to exercise jurisdiction. It may decline jurisdiction if the motion is made at a belated stage, or if the motion is mala fide or in circumstances justifying refusal. A party has choice and a right to examine a survey knowing person after getting the identification or measurement privately done by him. For examining such witness it does not seek any privilege or indulgence.

    Where the controversy between the parties is the area of the land or identification or location of an object or the land, local investigation is necessary, essential, requisite or proper. It will not be a sound exercise of discretion without anything more to decline to appoint a commissioner. Very often decision of a case turns on the identification or determination of the area and evidence in relation thereto from its peculiar nature can only be had on the spot. (See Amulya Kumar Samaddar v. Ananda Charan Das, AIR 1933 Cal 475 and in P. Moosa Kutty, AIR 1953 Mad 717). In such cases local investigation and measurement are essential. Evidence in respect thereof can be laid by engaging a person qualified to conduct the investigation and measurement privately. But there are some difficulties. While doing the survey, the person has to take measurements from various points. In course of such investigation it may be necessary for him to enter upon land and premises of the other party and he may be resisted by the latter, whereas neither of the parties can resist the commissioner appointed by the Court from carrying out the writ. I am, therefore, of the view that where local investigation is considered necessary/Court should not ordinarily refuse to appoint a commissioner for the purpose of elucidating any matter in dispute between the parties.

    5. When the controversy is as to identification, location or measurement of the land or premise or object, local investigation should be done at an early stage so that the parties are aware of the report of the Commissioner and go to trial prepared. The party against whom the report may have gone may choose to adduce evidence in rebuttal. Hence, ordinarily in such type of cases local investigation should not be deferred to a stage after the closure of evidence. I do not mean thereby that in no circumstances can local investigation be sought after the evidence is closed. But ordinarily it should be done before the parties adduced evidence. Hence, I do not accept the contention of Mr. B. Patnaik that inasmuch as the party has a right to and can adduce evidence of a survey knowing person engaged by him privately with reference to identification of location, it is open to the Court to decline to appoint a commissioner for local investigation under O. 26, R. 9. In this case the controversy can be resolved by locating the wall upon measurement, that is to say, whether it stood on plot No. 306 or plot No. 307. So, the local investigation is essential. The learned Munsif having failed to exercise jurisdiction vested in him, I interfere and vacate the impugned order. He is directed to appoint a survey knowing-commissioner.

    6. In the result, the revision is allowed but in the circumstances without any order as to costs.

    Revision allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Mahendranath Parida v. Purnananda Parida And Others
    (Sep 3, 1987)