Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 2(g) of the Workmen's Compensation Act of 1923 (hereinafter referred to as "the Act").
  • Section 30(a) of Workmen's Compensation Act of 1923.
  • SECTION 79 FACTORIES ACT
  • Workmen's Compensation Act.
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 2(g) of the Workmen's Compensation Act of 1923 (hereinafter referred to as "the Act").
  • Section 30(a) of Workmen's Compensation Act of 1923.
  • SECTION 79 FACTORIES ACT
  • Workmen's Compensation Act.
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

Deshraj Singh, employed by J. C. Mills Ltd., was injured on 4-1-1956 when a shuttle struck his left eye while working. He filed a compensation claim under the Workmen's Compensation Act on 26-4-1956. The Mills contested the claim, arguing that Singh was already blind in the left eye due to old corneal opacity and that the injury did not cause the loss of sight. The Commissioner for Workmen's Compensation held that Singh was not blind prior to the accident and awarded Rs. 1470 as compensation with costs. The Mills appealed this decision under Section 30(a) of the Workmen's Compensation Act of 1923.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the injury caused permanent partial disablement as defined in Section 2(g) of the Workmen's Compensation Act of 1923.
  2. Whether the Commissioner was correct in including wages for the period of annual leave in calculating the worker's wages under Section 5A of the Act.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • There was no permanent partial disablement because the worker had a pre-existing defect (corneal opacity) that caused blindness before the injury.
  • The Commissioner erred in adding wages for the period of annual leave to the worker’s yearly wages when calculating compensation.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The injury resulted in the complete removal of the eye, indicating permanent partial disablement caused by the accident.
  • The Commissioner’s addition of annual leave wages to the yearly wages was justified based on the interpretation of "wages" including privileges or benefits under the Act.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court analyzed the first issue by noting the lack of trustworthy evidence regarding the extent of the pre-existing defect before the injury. Since no doctor examined the eye prior to the injury and the eye had to be completely removed due to the accident, the court agreed with the Commissioner that the injury caused permanent partial disablement.

Regarding the second issue, the court examined the Commissioner’s reasoning for adding wages for the annual leave period to the yearly wages. It clarified that Section 79 of the Factories Act entitles a worker to annual leave with wages, meaning wages are not deducted during leave, but this does not imply an addition to total yearly wages. The court found that annual leave with wages is a privilege preventing wage deduction during leave rather than a benefit that increases the total yearly wages. Therefore, the Commissioner’s addition of annual leave wages was unjustified.

Consequently, the court reduced the compensation amount from Rs. 1470 to Rs. 1260 by excluding the annual leave wages from the calculation.

Holding and Implications

The court partly allowed the appeal and modified the Commissioner’s order by reducing the compensation amount to Rs. 1260. Both parties were directed to bear their own costs.

The decision directly affects the compensation amount payable to the worker but does not establish any new precedent beyond clarifying the interpretation of wages in the context of annual leave under the Workmen's Compensation Act.

    J.C. Mills Ltd. v. Desliraj Singh Bachcbusingh

    JUDGMENT A.H. Khan, J.

    1. The short facts leading to this appeal are that Deshraj Singh was employed by the J. C. Mills Ltd., that on 4-1-56, while he was working in the Mills, a shuttle flew from the loom and struck him in the left eye. He applied on 26-4-56 for compensation under the Workmen's Compensation Act. The claim was resisted by the Mills on the ground that the workman already suffered from old corneal opacity in the left eye, which made him blind and that the injury by the shuttle did not cause the loss of sight, which was already impaired.

    2. The Commissioner for Workmen's Compensation Mr. Srikishandas Shah held that the workman, was not blind before the accident and awarded Rs. 1470/- as compensation together with costs. Aggrieved by the order, the Mills has filed this appeal under Section 30(a) of Workmen's Compensation Act of 1923.

    3. The points urged by the appellant are two;

    First, that in the instant case there is no permanent partial disablement as described in Section 2(g) of the Workmen's Compensation Act of 1923 (hereinafter referred to as

    "the Act"
    ).

    Two, that in calculating the wages according to section 5a of "the act", the Commissioner has added the wages for the period of leave to which he was entitled after working for one year.

    4. With regard to the first point, it is contended that there was defect in the worker's eye which is technically known as corneal opacity and that the loss in the eye does not entitle the worker to compensation indicated in Schedule I of "the Act". There is no trustworthy evidence on record to show the extent of defect from which the worker suffered before the present injury. None of the two Doctors, that have been produced in this case, saw the eye of the worker before it had been injured.

    In the circumstances their statements about the nature of defect which existed before the injury are mere guesses. It is admitted that as a result of the injury one of the eyes had to be completely removed from the socket, but none of the Doctors examined the removed eye to ascertain the nature of the injury which is alleged to have existed prior to the accident. Since the fact is admitted that the eye had to be removed totally, I think the Commissioner was justified in holding that the injury to the eye has resulted in permanent partial disablement.

    5. With regard to the second question, the judgment of the lower Court does not disclose the ground on which the wages during the period of leave have been added to the wages the worker has earned during the year.

    6. It is admitted on both hands that the wages during one year amounted to Rs. 1130/1/-. It is said that after the worker has put in one year of work, he becomes entitled to annual leave with the wages according to Section 79 of the Factories Act. I have not followed the reasoning of the learned Commissioner as to why the wages of the annual leave should be added to the wages a worker earns during a year.

    Section 79 of the Factories Act provides for annual leave with wages, which means that if a worker has completed a year's service, he can during the subsequent year go on leave without any deduction from the total amount of the wages to which he would be entitled in the course of the second year. This would make his wages for the second year amount to the same figure as that of the first year.

    In other words when he goes out on leave for certain days, his wages during the period of leave shall not be deducted. Mr. Athawale has submitted that after becoming entitled to leave with wages, it is open to the worker either to take leave during the next year or to get the wages for the period of leave added to his total yearly income. But he has not been able to show according to what section of "the Act" this is possible.

    7. Reliance has been placed upon the definition of the wages given in clause (m) of section 2 of "the act", which runs as follows:

    "Wages" include any privilege or benefit which is capable of being estimated in money, other than a travelling allowance or the value of any travelling concession or a contribution paid by the employer of a workman towards any pension or provident fund or a sum paid to a workman to cover any special expenses entailed on him by the nature of his employment.''

    8. It is contended that since "wages" include privilege and other benefits therefore the wages during the annual leave should be added to the wages earned in the course of a year. Privilege and the benefits referred to above are like the dearness allowance or the facility of having free quarters. But I do not quite see how the annual leave with wages can be regarded as a privilege or benefit which it going to swell the wages. Annual leave with wages no doubt is a privilege but this privilege only means that no money shall be deducted from the wages when the worker is on annual leave. This privilege does not mean that there should be an accretion or addition to the wages of the next year.

    9. In this view of the matter I am afraid the learned Commissioner was not justified in adding the wages of the period of the annual leave to the total wages one would earn in a year. If this amount of wages for annual leave is deducted from the amount calculated by the Commissioner, then both the parties agree that the compensation to which the worker is entitled would be Rs. 1260/-. I, therefore, hold that the worker is entitled to Rs. 1260/- and not Rs. 1470 as compensation for the injury be sustained.

    10. For reasons stated above, I allow the appeal partly and modify the order of the Commissioner as stated above. Parties to bear their own costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    J.C. Mills Ltd. v. Desliraj Singh Bachcbusingh
    (Jan 15, 1958)