Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • r. 28 of the Companies (Court) Rules, 1959,
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • r. 28 of the Companies (Court) Rules, 1959,
Smart Summary

Summary of Opinion: Winding-up Petition — Admission Order

Factual and Procedural Background

This summary is drawn exclusively from the provided opinion. A winding-up petition was presented on 24 January 1980. On the returnable date, notice was directed to be served on the company calling upon it to show cause why the petition should not be admitted, and directions were given for filing affidavits. The company filed an affidavit (affirmed by its director Pradyut Kumar Banerjee on 19 February 1980) and the petitioning-creditor filed an affidavit-in-reply.

The petitioning-creditor's claim sought the price of goods sold and delivered pursuant to orders placed by the company between February 1978 and May 1978. The petitioning-creditor produced bills, receipted challans and various demand letters which had not been replied to. A statutory notice was served through the petitioning-creditor's advocate on 7 December 1979; the company allegedly replied to that statutory notice on 17 January 1980 (after presentation of the petition). The company relied on an alleged contract/letter dated 13 February 1978 and a receipt dated 14 February 1978 for Rs. 15,000; the petitioning-creditor produced original receipted challans and bill covers. The company raised allegations (in paragraph 19 of its affidavit) of forgery, dishonest dealings and similar misconduct by the petitioning-creditor, based on information from an ex-sales manager, Mr. Bhati.

At hearing, the court inspected documents, heard counsel for both sides (Mr. S.K. Kapoor and Mr. M.L. Jain for the petitioning-creditor; Mr. P.C. Sen for the company) and considered whether the winding-up petition should be admitted.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the winding-up petition should be admitted on the evidence produced by the petitioning-creditor and the company's affidavit-in-opposition.
  2. Whether the company has raised a bona fide dispute to the petitioning-creditor's claim sufficient to prevent admission of the winding-up petition.
  3. Whether documents (notably the alleged letter dated 13 February 1978 and its endorsement) produced by the company are genuine or were manufactured after presentation of the petition.
  4. Whether the winding-up petition constitutes an abuse of the process of the court.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioning-creditor's Arguments (Mr. S.K. Kapoor with Mr. M.L. Jain)

  • The petitioning-creditor produced necessary documents, including original receipted challans and bill covers showing receipt by the company, thereby proving the claim for goods supplied between February–May 1978.
  • The company did not reply to the statutory notice until after presentation of the winding-up petition; the company's late reply first raised disputes and relied on an alleged contract (letter dated 13 February 1978) not previously referenced.
  • The copy of the alleged letter produced by the company in court appears to bear a recent endorsement by Mr. Bhati with the petitioning-creditor's firm name written wrongly — suggesting the document was manufactured to create confusion.
  • The petitioning-creditor maintained that the company is disputing the claim not in good faith and that the defence raised is a highly improbable story and not a bona fide dispute; thus the petition is not an abuse of process.

Company's Arguments (Mr. P.C. Sen)

  • The company asserted that the petitioning-creditor suppressed an alleged contract dated 13 February 1978 and produced a xeroxed copy and the original receipt for Rs. 15,000 dated 14 February 1978, receipted on the back by the petitioning-creditor.
  • Those Rs. 15,000 represented an advance towards a Bittzer Compressor (complete) with accessories; the petitioning-creditor allegedly supplied a different make (Freezking Compressor), and therefore the petitioning-creditor is guilty of suppression of facts and extortion.
  • The company relied on allegations in paragraph 19 of its affidavit (based on information from ex-sales manager Mr. Bhati) asserting similar dishonest acts by the petitioning-creditor with other customers, to contend that the petitioning-creditor's claim is bona fide disputed and fabricated.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court conducted an evidential assessment of the documents and the parties' contentions. The analysis proceeded in identifiable steps drawn from the opinion:

  1. Documentary proof by petitioning-creditor: The court noted that the petitioning-creditor had disclosed bills and receipted challans for the supplies and produced original receipted challans and bill covers showing the receipt of bills by the company. The court found these documents were issued by the defendant company in the usual course of business and that the petitioning-creditor had duly supplied the goods which were received by the company.
  2. Timing and nature of the company's defence: The court observed that the company's substantive reply to the statutory notice was sent only after presentation of the winding-up petition and that the defence for the first time raised certain disputes and relied on an alleged contract/letter dated 13 February 1978.
  3. Authenticity of the alleged letter dated 13 February 1978: The court examined the copies and endorsements. It found that the copy annexed to the company's affidavit did not bear Mr. Bhati's endorsement, whereas a copy produced in court bore a recent endorsement with the petitioning-creditor's firm's name wrongly written. On the face of it, the court characterized the document as highly improbable and possibly manufactured after the petition was filed.
  4. Inconsistency with the Rs. 15,000 receipt of 14 February 1978: The court reasoned that if the alleged contract dated 13 February 1978 had existed as now claimed, it should have been referred to in the admitted receipt dated 14 February 1978. The absence of such a reference was taken as evidence against the genuineness of the company's asserted contract.
  5. Evaluation of the company's allegations of substituted goods and commercial misconduct: The court found the company's defence — that a Freezking Compressor (of lesser value) was supplied instead of the contracted Bittzer Compressor — to be absurd and highly improbable. The court noted it was unlikely that for a contract said to be for Rs. 25,000 goods worth about Rs. 53,000 would be supplied, undermining the company's account.
  6. Credibility and conduct: The court accepted as credible the information that suggested the company's director had procured the ex-sales manager to create a forged document and that the company's affidavit contained highly defamatory and reckless allegations. The court described the company as "highly dishonest" and "lacking in commercial morality" and held that the company was attempting to create documents and make reckless allegations to weave a web of suspicion.
  7. Conclusion on bona fide dispute and abuse: On the basis of the documentary evidence, timing, inconsistencies, and apparent manufacturing of documents, the court concluded that the company had not raised any bona fide dispute in law or fact and that the winding-up petition was not an abuse of process.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The court ordered that the WINDING-UP PETITION IS ADMITTED.

Direct consequences and order terms:

  • There will be an advertisement once in Statesman, once in Basumati and once in the Calcutta Gazette, but not to be published before 15 April 1981.
  • If the company pays or settles the claim of the petitioning-creditor together with an assessed cost of "30 G.Ms", the winding-up petition would remain permanently stayed and compliance with r. 28 of the Companies (Court) Rules, 1959 will be dispensed with.
  • In default of payment/settlement, the winding-up petition will be advertised as directed and will appear in the list on 8 June 1981.

Implications: The immediate effect is the admission of the petition and the procedural directions set out above. The opinion does not state or claim that a new legal precedent is established; it addresses the specific admission decision and its consequences for the parties in this case.

This summary is confined strictly to matters stated in the provided opinion. No information beyond the text of the opinion has been added or inferred.

    Smt. Madan Debi Kundalia v. Alpine Dairy Ltd.

    1. This is a winding-up petition presented on the 24th of January, 1980, and on the returnable date notice was directed to be served on the company to show cause why the winding-up petition should not be admitted. Thereafter, directions for filing affidavits were given. The company filed an affidavit and the petitioning-creditor also filed an affidavit-in-reply thereto.

    2. The petititioning-creditors' claim is very simple and straight-forward for the price of goods sold and delivered pursuant to the orders placed by the company between February, 1978, to May, 1978.

    3. The petitioning-creditor has disclosed the bills and the receipted challans for such supplies and also various demand letters which were not replied to and ultimately, when the statutory notice was served through the advocate of the petitioning-creditor, being 7th of December, 1979, and after the presentation of the petition on the 24th of January, 1980, the alleged reply to the statutory notice dated 17th of January, 1980, was sent to the petitioning-creditors' advocate where for the first time certain disputes were sought to be raised without any reference to an alleged contract dated 13th of February, 1978, in any way whatsoever. The said reply to the statutory notice is annexed to the affidavit of Pradyut Kumar Banerjee, a director of the company, who has affirmed the affidavit on behalf of the company on the 19th of February, 1980. Along with the said affidavit, an alleged copy of the letter dated 13th of February, 1978, is annexed which is purported to record the agreement between the parties for the supply of a compressor and in the copy which is annexed there is nothing showing the receipt of the said letter by the petitioning-creditor and at the time of hearing, a copy was produced with an endorsement of one Mr. Bhati, who was the sales manager of the petitioning-creditor previously, but has left her a long time back and appears to have endorsed in the said copy the receipt of the same wrongly describing the name of the petitioning-creditor's firm and, on the face of it, it appears to be highly improbable, and a manufactured document on which the endorsement of the said Mr. Bhati was procured subsequent to the present application being moved. The petitioning-creditor being called upon to produce the original bill cover and challans, to which there is no serious denial but only allegations in the nature to raise only some suspicion and doubt. But, after looking into the documents that the same were issued by the defendant company in the usual course of its business, I am satisfied that the petitioning-creditor has duly supplied the goods to the defendant company which has been received by the company and the petitioning-creditor has also submitted the original bills with the receipted challans to the company and the bill covers show various bills which have been received by the company. The company's affidavit, particularly the allegations in para. 19, making highly defamatory allegations against the petitioner of forgery, dishonesty and commercial immorality, appears to have been verified, as information received from Mr. Bhati, the Ex-Sales Manager of the petitioning-creditor firm, itself shows that the company's director, the said Mr. Pradyut Banerjee, is not only reckless but has no respect for the court and has procured the Ex-Sales Manager of the petitioning-creditor firm to create a forged document, being dated 13th of February, 1978, and to make highly defamatory statements in the affidavit as stated in para. 19 of the petition. I have no hesitation in holding that the company is a highly dishonest company which is lacking in commercial morality and after the present winding-up petition has been filed is trying to create documents and make reckless and defamatory allegations against the petitioning-creditor which are not only highly improbable but also unacceptable to any court of law. It has been made only to weave a cobweb and create a cloud as to the main issue, if possible, by raising suspicion and surmise in the mind of the court.

    4. Mr. S.K Kapoor, appearing with Mr. M.L Jain, for the petitioning-creditor placed all the necessary documents and produced the original receipted challans and the bill cover showing the receipt of the bills and, in my view, has clearly proved beyond doubt the legitimate claim of the petitioning-creditor and established the absurdity of the nature of defence sought to be raised from the Bar by creating documents after the presentation of the winding-up petition by the petitioning-creditor.

    5. Mr. P.C Sen, appearing for the company, submitted that the petitioning-creditor has suppressed the alleged contract dated 13th of February, 1978, and he also referred to the xerox copy of the receipt for Rs. 15,000 dated 14th of February, 1978, copy of which is annexed to the affidavit-in-opposition of the said Mr. Pradyut Kumar Banerjee affirmed on the 19th of February, 1980, and produced the original receipt which has been duly, receipted at the back by the petitioning-creditor and submitted that the said Rs. 15,000 represented the advance towards Bittzer Compressor (complete) with a condenser, oil separator, pipe and fittings, etc., and, therefore, the petitioning-creditor is guilty of suppression of facts and trying to extort money by supplying a different make of compressor and also is guilty of similar acts with other customers as alleged in para. 19 of the said affidavit of Mr. Pradyut Kumar Banerjee, which is based on the information received from the Ex-Sales Manager, Mr. Bhati, as hereinbefore stated. Mr. Sen submitted that the bill for Rs. 6,000 odd, which has been disclosed by the petitioning-creditor, is for Freezking Compressor and, therefore, the petitioning-creditor's claim is bona fide disputed and the same being false and fabricated, in the circumstances, the winding-up petition should not be admitted.

    6. Mr. Kapoor, in reply, rightly pointed out that the alleged letter dated February 13, 1978, a copy of which is annexed to the said affidavit-in-opposition filed on behalf of the company does not contain the endorsement of Mr. Bhati but the copy which was produced in court appears to contain a recent endorsement of Mr. Bhati with the wrong name of the petitioning-creditor's firm. He further submitted that the receipt for Rs. 15,000 is admitted, but there is no reference to the alleged agreement dated February 13, 1978. Therefore, the said alleged document dated February 13, 1978, has been brought into existence for the purpose of creating confusion and doubt in the mind of the court and weave a cobweb, if possible, in respect of the clear and specific claim of the petitioning-creditor. Further, there was no reply to the statutory notice by the company till the present winding-up petition was filed as hereinbefore stated. The company is trying to dispute the claim of the petitioning-creditor not in good faith and raising a highly improbable story. Therefore, Mr. Kapoor submitted that in this case it cannot be said that the present winding-up petition is an abuse of the process of the court.

    7. After a careful consideration of all the documents and the contentions of both the parties, I am of the view that the company is now in the hands of dishonest persons who lack in commercial morality and tried to confuse the court by raising highly improbable and false pleas by setting up a document which, on the face of it, appears to be a manufactured document being the alleged letter dated February 13, 1978. Firstly, the said letter is not referred to in the said admitted receipt dated February 14, 1978, as, had it been a contract in existence as now alleged by the company, it must have been referred in the said receipt. Secondly, the copy of the letter annexed to the affidavit-in-opposition does not bear the endorsement by Mr. Bhati, the Ex-Sales Manager of the petitioning-creditor, whereas the copy produced in court at the time of hearing appears to bear a recent endorsement with the name of the petitioning creditor's firm wrongly written. Therefore, the said letter is highly improbable and must be held to be not a genuine document.

    8. The case sought to be made out by the company in defence that the petitioning-creditor did not supply the said Bittzer Compressor but supplied a defective Freezking Compressor appears to be absurd and highly improbable from the documents disclosed by the petitioning-creditor. The challans and the receipts of the bills are not seriously disputed, save and except some doubt as to that they might have been signed by the employees of the company, but that those goods are not received, or in relation to Freezking Compressor, is also not acceptable, as, for a contract of Rs. 25,000, no one is expected to supply goods worth about Rs. 53,000 odd. Therefore, it is quite clear that the company is trying to weave a cobweb as it is now in the hands of a new management which is making an attempt to dispute a bona fide claim of the petitioning-creditor, if possible. It cannot be ignored that there are several winding-up petitions against the company which after some time the company had to settle by taking time and by making payment by instalments. But, in this case, it seems to me that the company has become too daring and tried to weave a cobweb and amuse itself by eminent lawyers by taking advantage of the credit given by the petitioning-creditor and also making use of an ex-employee of the petitioning-creditor for manufacturing documents. In these circumstances, I am bound to hold that the winding-up petition is not an abuse of the process of the court and the company is unable to pay its debt and has not raised any bona fide dispute to the claim of the petitioning-creditor and there is no substance in the defence sought to be raised either in law or in fact.

    9. In the result, I am making the following order:

    The winding-up petition is admitted. There will be an advertisement once in Statesman, once in Basumati and once in Calcutta Gazette but not to be published before April 15, 1981. If the company pays off or settles the claim of the petitioning-creditor together with an assessed cost of 30 G.Ms the winding-up petition would remain permanently stayed and compliance with r. 28 of the Companies (Court) Rules, 1959, will be dispensed with. In default, the winding-up petition will be advertised as directed and the same would appear in list on June 8, 1981.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Smt. Madan Debi Kundalia v. Alpine Dairy Ltd.
    (Mar 18, 1981)