1. This rule has been obtained by two persons who have been convicted of having committed theft by the learned Magistrate, Sri S.C Mukherjee, exercising first class powers at Diamond Harbour. On appeal the Additional Sessions Judge, 24 Parganas, upheld the order of the learned Magistrate with respect to the two petitioners. Six persons were tried by the Magistrate and convicted. Four of these six were act quitted by the lower appellate Court. The sentence passed on the petitioners consists of fine of ss. 100 each, in default rigorous imprisonment for a period of four months.
2. Having regard to the order which I am about to pass it will not be necessary to state the facts in full. The case was argued with commendable fairness on both sides. Mr. Mukherjee appearing to oppose the Rule was of great assistance to this Court in determining the questions of law involved. The facts briefly an these: There is a plot of land which is being claimed on the one hand by Atul Krishna Ghose and others and on the other by Osman Mistry and others. Proceedings under Section 144 of the Cr PC were started and an order was passed prohibiting both parties from entering upon the land, Thereafter, it is said, three persons namely the two petitioners (Osman Mistry and Jane Alam Mistry) and one Akkas Ali Molla went on the land and cut the paddy thereon in spite of the prohibitory order. Six days after this these three persons together with three others again went on the land and cut and took away the paddy therefrom. On these facts two cases were started in respect of the two occurrences and the charge against the accused in each of these cases was a charge of theft. Thereafter the learned Magistrate, to use his own words, amalgamated both, the cases and tried both the cases together as a single case and passed a judgment finding all the six persons guilty of the offence of theft. On appeal, as I have said before, four persons were acquitted and the conviction of the two petitioners was upheld.
3. Learned advocate appearing for the petitioners urges that the entire proceedings are bad. First, he points out that the offence committed: was one which was really punishable under S. 188, Penal Code, inasmuch as the offence consisted in disobeying an order passed under Section 144 of the Cr PC. Next, he says that not Court can take cognizance of such an offence except upon a complaint made by the public servant concerned and he refers me to the provisions of Section 195(1)(a) of the Cr PC. In the present case there was no complaint made by the learned Magistrate who passed the order-under Section 144 of the Cr PC. That being so, the entire proceedings are without foundation. There really no answer to this contention. The prosions of the law are perfectly clear. If the act a person amounts to an offence punishable under S. 188, Penal Code, then no Court shall ??? cognizance of that offence except upon the implant of the public servant concerned whose under has been disobeyed. It is not permissible the prosecution to ignore the provisions of his section of the Code of Criminal Procedure 7 describing the offence as being one punishable under some other section of the Penal Code, such a change of garb, if I may use the express on, would be of no avail. If this is permitted, ten the provisions of Section 195(1)(a) of the Cr PC ??? will be rendered absolutely nugatory. I ??? not wish to enlarge upon this matter. It is ??? by a decision of this Court. I refer to the judgment of Rankin, C.J and C.C Ghose, J. ??? the case of Ibrahim v. Emperor, reported ??? 111 I.C 433 : (29 Cr. L.J 849 Cal.). It was aid that where the offence committed is punishable under s. 471, Penal Code, it is illegal to reads the charge to one under S. 474 of the said ode and prosecute the accused without a complaint being made under Section 476 of the Cr PC he entire proceedings are therefore vitiated by as on of there being no complaint by the Magistrate who passed the order under Section 144 of the Cr PC.
4. The next point urged is that the trial is legal inasmuch as there was a joinder of two fences which could not under the law be joined, his ground is perfectly sound. There is no provision in the Code of Criminal Procedure for amalgamating cases. The sections relating to ??? joinder of charges and the joinder of persona ??? where permit of the procedure adopted by the learned Magistrate. The first offence was committed by three persons. The second offence was ??? six days thereafter by those three arson and three others. These two offences cannot be joined under any of the provisions of ??? Code of Criminal Procedure. The trial is therefore illegal on this ground.
5. Lastly, it was pointed out that a charge, theft cannot lie inasmuch as the paddy was ??? not in possession of the opposite parties by ??? of the fact that there was an order under 144 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, prohibiting both parties ??? going on the land and exercising acts of possession thereon. At the time of the alleged ??? of the paddy therefore it cannot be said lat it was in the possession of the opposite parties. An offence of theft cannot be committed an less the property is moved out of possession a person. On this ground also the charge of left would not be maintainable.
6. I therefore set aside the order of conviction and sentence passed. The Magistrate who passed the order under Section 144 of the Cr PC may, if he thinks proper, make a complaint in accordance with the provisions of Section 195(1) of the Cr PC, in respect of each of the incident.
7. If he decides to take action, he shall have to make two complaints and the complaints will have to be tried separately.
8. Nothing which I have said is intended to prevent the Magistrate from considering the-application made by the petitioners against the opposite parties charging them with an offence punishable under S. 188, Penal Code.
K.S
9. Conviction & sentence set aside.