Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • (i) Section 83 (1) and (2), (ii) Section 85 and (iii), Section 87 of the Wakf Act,
  • provisions of this Act. (2) The provisions of sub-section (1)
  • Section 83 read with Section 85 of the Wakf Act.
  • Section 83(2) of the Wakf Act, 1995.
  • Section 87 of the Wakf Act, 1995,
  • SECTION 36 WAKF ACT
  • Section 83(1) and (2),
  • Wakf Act, 1995
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • (i) Section 83 (1) and (2), (ii) Section 85 and (iii), Section 87 of the Wakf Act,
  • provisions of this Act. (2) The provisions of sub-section (1)
  • Section 83 read with Section 85 of the Wakf Act.
  • Section 83(2) of the Wakf Act, 1995.
  • Section 87 of the Wakf Act, 1995,
  • SECTION 36 WAKF ACT
  • Section 83(1) and (2),
  • Wakf Act, 1995
Smart Summary

Judgment Summary — Kurian Joseph, J. (with T.R. Ramachandran Nair, JJ.)

Factual and Procedural Background

The central dispute concerns whether legal proceedings can be maintained on behalf of an unregistered wakf before the Wakf Tribunal. The petitioner (plaintiff in W.O.S.18/07) is the Chairman of a trust managing Madeena Mazjid, Pullepady, and styled as the mutawalli of the mosque. The mosque had an Imam and Khateeb appointed by the mutawalli (one Abdul Sathar Moulavi), but the respondents (an organization as first respondent and an individual as second respondent) claimed the second respondent to be the Imam and Khateeb as usually nominated by the organization. On an attempt by the respondents to interfere with control and management of the mosque, the petitioner filed a suit for a permanent prohibitory injunction and an application for temporary injunction (I.A.74/07). The respondents contested the suit and the application.

The Wakf Tribunal disposed of the application by an order dated 14.5.2007, holding that the suit itself was not maintainable due to the bar in Section 87 of the Wakf Act, 1995, because the wakf was not registered under Section 36. The application for interim relief was therefore held not maintainable, though partial interim relief was granted in favour of the second respondent to continue as Imam until disposal of the suit. The petitioner filed a revision challenging the Tribunal's order.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a suit or other legal proceeding for enforcement of any right on behalf of a wakf that has not been registered under Section 36 of the Wakf Act, 1995, can be maintained before the Wakf Tribunal.
  2. Whether the bar under Section 87 of the Wakf Act applies to proceedings before the Wakf Tribunal or only to civil courts.
  3. Whether a person styled as a mutawalli is entitled to institute proceedings before the Wakf Tribunal under Section 83(2) even if the wakf is unregistered.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's (Revision Petitioner) Arguments

  • The suit was instituted by the mutawalli of Madeena Mazjid and therefore is maintainable before the Wakf Tribunal under Section 83(2) of the Wakf Act, 1995.
  • The bar under Section 87 of the Act does not apply to proceedings before the Wakf Tribunal and is applicable only to civil courts.

Respondents' / Tribunal's Position

  • The Tribunal held that the suit was not maintainable because the wakf was not registered with the Wakf Board under Section 36 and, under Section 87, no suit for enforcement of rights on behalf of an unregistered wakf can be instituted or continued in a court.
  • The respondents contested both the suit and the application for temporary injunction; the Tribunal, while holding the suit not maintainable, granted limited interim relief allowing the second respondent to continue as Imam until disposal of the suit.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Pookoya Haji v. Cheriyakoya, 2003 (3) KLT 32 Interpreted the words "any dispute, question or other matter relating to wakf or wakf property" in Section 85 broadly to include matters conferred on the Tribunal and other disputes relating to wakf; emphasised legislative intent that disputes should be resolved by the Wakf Tribunal, not civil courts. The Court relied on this bench decision to affirm that Section 85 and the scheme of the Act indicate exclusive jurisdiction of the Tribunal over disputes relating to wakf and wakf property, supporting the conclusion that such matters fall within the Tribunal's remit.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined Sections 83(1) and (2), 85 and 87 of the Wakf Act, 1995. Section 83(2) expressly entitles any mutawalli, any person interested in a wakf, or any person aggrieved by an order under the Act to apply to the Tribunal for determination of any dispute, question or other matter relating to the wakf. The Court noted that Section 83(2) contains no precondition that the wakf be registered; the jurisdictional requirement is only that the applicant belong to one of the enumerated categories and that the application relates to a wakf matter.

The Court observed that the Act defines "person interested in a wakf" broadly (including the mutawalli), reinforcing that a mutawalli can approach the Tribunal under Section 83(2). It then turned to Section 87, which prohibits courts from instituting, continuing or deciding suits or other proceedings for the enforcement of any right on behalf of a wakf that has not been registered under Section 36 after the commencement of the Act. Section 87 also prevents continuation of pre-existing proceedings in a court unless the wakf is registered.

The Court undertook a purposive reading of the Act and noted that the statute uses the terms "court" and "Tribunal" in multiple places (for example, Section 90(1) requires notice to the Board by "the court or Tribunal"). From a joint reading of Sections 83, 85 and 87 and in light of the decision in Pookoya Haji v. Cheriyakoya, the Court reasoned:

  • Section 85's reference to "any dispute, question or other matter relating to any wakf or wakf property" is wide enough to bring within the Tribunal's jurisdiction not only matters specifically conferred on it by other provisions but all disputes relating to wakf and wakf property; the legislative intent is to have a single forum (the Tribunal) for such disputes.
  • Section 87's bar is directed at courts (civil courts) and prevents civil courts from proceeding in enforcement actions on behalf of unregistered wakfs; it does not operate to bar proceedings before the Wakf Tribunal constituted under Section 83.
  • Registered wakfs have the additional privilege of instituting suits in civil courts for enforcement of rights not related to the wakf, but exclusive jurisdiction over disputes relating to wakf or wakf property lies with the Tribunal.

Applying these principles to the present case, the Court found that the Tribunal had failed to note that the plaintiff was styled as the mutawalli and therefore entitled to approach the Tribunal under Section 83(2). Because the suit relates to wakf matters and was instituted by a person claiming to be the mutawalli, the suit is maintainable before the Wakf Tribunal notwithstanding that the wakf had not been registered under Section 36; Section 87's bar does not apply to proceedings before the Tribunal.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The order in I.A.74/07 in W.O.S.18/07 of the Wakf Tribunal, Ernakulam is set aside.

Core legal determination: A suit instituted by a person claiming to be the mutawalli and relating to wakf matters is maintainable before the Wakf Tribunal under Section 83 read with Section 85 of the Wakf Act, 1995, even if the wakf is not registered under Section 36; the bar in Section 87 operates against civil courts and does not bar proceedings before the Wakf Tribunal.

Direct consequences and directions given by the Court:

  • The Wakf Tribunal's order holding the suit not maintainable was set aside and the interim order granted by this Court during pendency of the revision (that Juma prayer will be led by Shri Abdul Sathar Moulavi and that the sermon will be delivered by the second respondent) was to continue until disposal of the suit.
  • The Wakf Tribunal was directed to dispose of the suit expeditiously.
  • The Court observed that Wakf Boards were often not made parties; relying on Section 90, it directed Wakf Tribunals in the State to issue notice to the Wakf Board at the cost of the party instituting a suit or proceeding where the matter relates to title or possession of wakf property or the right of the mutawalli or beneficiary, if the Board is not already on the party array. A copy of the judgment was to be sent to all Wakf Tribunals in the State.

The opinion does not state that it establishes any new legal precedent beyond applying existing statutory provisions and the Court's interpretation; it applies the legislative scheme and the authority of the cited bench decision to resolve the dispute before it.

    Muthawalli v. Kerala Jama Ath Islami Hind

    Kurian Joseph, J.

    Whether a suit or other legal proceedings can be maintained on behalf of an unregistered Wakf for enforcement of any of its rights before the Wakf Tribunal, is the crucial question arising for consideration in this case. Petitioner is the plaintiff in W.O.S.18/07 on the file of the Wakf Tribunal, Ernakulam. The defendants are the respondents herein. The suit is one for permanent prohibitory injunction. Petitioner is the Chairman of a Trust managing Madeena Mazjid, Pullepady. One Abdul Sathar Moulavi was appointed by the Muthavalli as Imam and Khathib of the Mosque as per the Wakf deed. However, the first respondent organization and the second respondent claimed that the second respondent is the Imam and Khathib of the Mosque, as usually nominated by the first respondent organization. On their attempt to interfere with the control and management of the affairs of the Mosque the suit was filed. Along with the suit, I.A.74/07 was filed for temporary injunction. The suit and the application were contested by the respondents. The application was disposed of by the order under revision dated 14.5.2007 of the Wakf Tribunal holding that the suit itself is not maintainable, in view of the bar under Section 87 of the Wakf Act, 1995, since the Wakf is not registered with the Wakf Board under Section 36 of the Wakf Act. Consequently, the application was also held to be not maintainable. However, partial relief was granted in favour of the second respondent to continue as the Imam of the Mosque till the disposal of the suit. It is the main contention of the revision petitioner that the suit is one filed by the mutawalli of Madeena Mazjid and the same is maintainable under Section 83(2) of the Wakf Act, 1995. It is also contended that the bar provided under Section 87 of the Act will not apply for maintaining a suit before the Wakf Tribunal since the same is applicable only to the civil court.

    2. In order to appreciate the contentions taken by the parties, it is necessary to refer to three relevant portions, (i) Section 83 (1) and (2), (ii) Section 85 and (iii), Section 87 of the Wakf Act, which read as follows :-

    "
    3. Constitution of Tribunals, etc.-
    (1) The State Government shall, by notification in the Official Gazette, constitute as many Tribunals as it may think fit, for the determination of any dispute, question or other matter relating to a wakf or wakf or wakf property under this Act and define the local limits and jurisdiction under this Act of each of such Tribunals.
    (2) Any mutawalli, person interested in a wakf or any other person aggrieved by an order made under this Act, or rules made thereunder, may make an application within the time specified in this Act or where no such time has been specified, within such time as may be prescribed, to the Tribunal for the determination of any dispute, question or other matter relating to the wakf."
    "85.Bar of jurisdiction of civil courts:- No suit or other legal proceeding shall lie in any civil court in respect of any dispute, question or other matter relating to any wakf, wakf property or other matter which is required by or under this Act to be determined by a Tribunal."
    87. Bar to the enforcement of right on behalf of unreggistered wakfs:-
    (1) Notwithstanding anything contained in any other law for the time being in force, no suit, appeal or other legal proceeding for the enforcement of any right on behalf of any wakf which has not been registered in accordance with the provisions of this Act, shall be instituted or commenced or heard, tried or decided by any court after the commencement of this Act, or where any such suit, appeal or other legal proceeding had been instituted or commenced before such commencement, no such suit, appeal or other legal proceeding shall be continued, heard, tried or decided by any court after such commencement unless such wakf has been registered, in accordance with the provisions of this Act.
    (2) The provisions of sub-section (1) shall apply as far as may be, to the claim for set off or any other claim made on behalf of any wakf which has not been registered in accordance with the provisions of this Act."

    As far as the jurisdiction of the Tribunal is concerned, the law is well settled by a bench decision of this Court in Pookoya Haji v. Cheriyakoya (2003(3) KLT 32) that "The words any dispute, question or other matters relating to Wakf or Wakf property under S.85 are wide enough to take in within its sweep not only matters which are specifically conferred on the Tribunal by the various provisions of the Act but also any dispute, question or any other matter relating to any Wakf or Wakf property since those powers have also been conferred on the Tribunal by the Wakf Act itself. On examining the scheme of the Act and various provisions we are of the view that the intention of the Legislature is to resolve all disputes by one machinery and forum provided in the Act itself, that is, the Wakf Tribunal and not by the Civil Courts in the State".

    3. Under Section 83(2), (1)any mutawally or (2) person interested in a Wakf or (3) any person aggrieved by an order made under this Act is entitled to make an application to the Tribunal for the determination of any dispute, question or other matter relating to the Wakf. For thus approaching the Wakf Tribunal there is no precondition regarding the registration of the Wakf in question; the only jurisdictional factor is that the application by any of the three enumerated categories should be for the determination of any dispute, question or other matters relating to Wakf. In this context, it is also profitable to note that the "person interested in a wakf" is given a wide interpretation in the Act itself, which reads as follows :-

    3(k) "person interested in a wakf", means any person who is entitled to receive any pecuniary or other benefits from the wakf and includes-
    (i) any person who has a right to worship or to perform any religious rite in a mosque, idgah, imambara, dargah, khangah, maqbara, graveyard or any other religious institutions connected with the wakf or to participate in any religious or charitable institution under the wakf;
    (ii) the wakf and any descendant of the wakf and the mutawalli"

    4. A close look at Section 87 would indicate that notwithstanding anything contained in any other law for the time being in force (and notwithstanding anything contained in the Wakf Act) no suit or appeal or other legal proceeding for the enforcement of any right on behalf of any Wakf shall be instituted or commenced or heard, tried or decided by any court, if the Wakf is not registered with the Wakf Board under Section 36 of the Act, after the commencement of the Wakf Act. The second limb of the provision clearly stipulates that no such suit, appeal or legal proceeding instituted prior to the commencement of the Act shall be continued by any court unless the Wakf has been registered in accordance with the provisions of this Act. It is significant to note that the Wakf Act, 1995 has used both expressions, "Court" and "Tribunal" in many places. For example, under Section 90(1) it is provided that "In every suit or proceeding relating to a title or possession of a Wakf property or the right of mutawalli or beneficiary, the court or Tribunal shall issue notice to the Board at the cost of the party instituting such suit or proceeding". If the provisions are given a purposive interpretation, it is clear that in respect of the rights of a Wakf which are not enumerated under Section 83(1) and (2), a suit is still maintainable before the civil court, in case the Wakf is registered. Whether registered or not, for determination of any dispute, question or any other matter relating to any Wakf or Wakf property, the exclusive jurisdiction is on the Wakf Tribunal constituted under Section 83 of the Act and not on the civil court. The bar under Section 87 applies only to the civil court and not to the Tribunal. A joint reading of Sections 83, 85 and 87 would clearly show that the civil court has no jurisdiction to adjudicate on any dispute, question or other matter relating to any Wakf and Wakf property, or other matters which are to be determined by the Tribunal constituted under Section 83 of the Act. However, under Section 87, an additional privilege is granted to registered Wakfs to institute a suit or appeal or other legal proceedings before the civil court for the enforcement of any right on behalf of such Wakf which is not related to the Wakf.

    5. In the instant case, the Wakf Tribunal also has not taken note of the fact that the plaintiff is styled as the mutawalli of Madeena Mazjid. Under Section 83(2) any mutawalli is entitled to make an application before the Tribunal for the determination of any dispute, question or other matters relating to the Wakf. Since the suit is one instituted by a person claiming to be the mutawalli of a Wakf and since the questions apparently are relating to the Wakf, for the only reason that the Wakf is not registered with the Wakf Board under Section 36 of the Wakf Act, it cannot be said that the suit is not maintainable before the Wakf Tribunal. The bar under Section 87 will not apply to the instant case. The suit is plainly maintainable before the Wakf Tribunal under Section 83 read with Section 85 of the Wakf Act.

    6. In the result, the order in I.A.74/07 in W.O.S.18/07 of the Wakf Tribunal, Ernakulam is set aside. During the pendency of the revision petition, regarding Juma prayer in Madeena Mazjid on Fridays, this Court has ordered that the Juma prayer will be led by Shri.Abdul Sathar Moulavi. Kutuba (sermon) during the Juma prayers will be delivered by the second respondent herein. The said interim arrangement will continue till the disposal of the suit. There will be a direction to the Wakf Tribunal to dispose of the suit expeditiously.

    7. In respect of several matters, it has come to the notice of this Court that the Wakf Board is not made a party either before this Court or the Tribunal. In view of the clear mandate under Section 90 of the Act, in every suit or proceeding relating to title or possession of a Wakf property or the right of mutawalli or beneficiary, the court or Tribunal shall make the Wakf Board a party, at the cost of the party instituting such suit or proceedings. There will be a direction to the Wakf Tribunals in the State to issue notice to the Wakf Board at the cost of the party instituting the suit or proceedings, in case the same relates to title or possession of a Wakf property or the right of the mutawalli or beneficiary, if the Board is not already on the party array. A copy of this judgment will be sent to all the Wakf Tribunals in the State.

    KURIAN JOSEPH, JUDGE.

    T.R.RAMACHANDRAN NAIR, JUDGE.

    tgs KURIAN JOSEPH & T.R.RAMACHANDRAN NAIR, JJ

    ----------------------------------------------

    L.A.A. NO. OF 2004

    ----------------------------------------------

    J U D G M E N T Dated July, 2007.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Muthawalli v. Kerala Jama Ath Islami Hind
    (Jul 5, 2007)