Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The plaintiff, who is the appellant, discounted a cheque dated 20-8-1977 for Rs. 10,000 drawn by K.J. Mathai on Canara Bank, Kothamangalam through the 8th defendant. The cheque was presented on 12-10-1977 but was dishonoured. Defendants 1 to 7 are the legal representatives of Mathai, and defendants 9 to 12 are the legal representatives of the 8th defendant. The trial Court found in favour of the plaintiff on all issues except that the suit was not maintainable due to the absence of a notice of dishonour under Section 93 of the Negotiable Instruments Act.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a notice of dishonour is mandatory to the drawer of a cheque when the cheque is dishonoured on presentation.
  2. Whether the suit is maintainable against the legal representatives of the drawer without a notice of dishonour.
  3. Whether the liability of the endorser (8th defendant) arises without a notice of dishonour.

Arguments of the Parties

Defendants 1 to 7's Arguments

  • The plaintiff did not advance Rs. 10,000 to Mathai through the 8th defendant.
  • The suit is not maintainable as no notice of dishonour under Section 93 of the Negotiable Instruments Act was given to the defendants.

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the plaintiff's arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
John Chandy v. State Bank of Travancore (1973 K.L.J 450) Liability of endorser arises only if notice of dishonour is issued to him. The court held that since the 8th defendant (endorser) was not given notice of dishonour, he cannot be held liable for the claim.
Janki Das v. Kushalya Devi (AIR 1943 Lahore 207) Documents produced along with the plaint under Order 7 Rule 14 should be treated as part of the pleadings. The court held that the cheque and its endorsement produced with the plaint sufficed to show dishonour without separate pleading regarding notice of dishonour.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined the nature of the cheque's dishonour, which was endorsed "refer to drawer," indicating insufficient funds in the drawer's account. It applied Section 98(c) of the Negotiable Instruments Act, which dispenses with the requirement of notice of dishonour when the party charged could not have suffered damage due to the absence of notice. Since the cheque could not be encashed due to lack of funds, the legal representatives of the drawer (defendants 1 to 7) did not suffer damage for want of notice, making the notice unnecessary as per the statute.

However, the court distinguished the position of the 8th defendant, an endorser, whose liability arises only upon receipt of a notice of dishonour. Since no such notice was given to the 8th defendant, he cannot be held liable.

The court also noted that the cheque and its dishonour endorsement were produced along with the plaint, which under Order 7 Rule 14 is treated as part of the pleadings, negating the defence's contention that there was a lack of pleading about the notice of dishonour.

Consequently, the trial court's dismissal of the suit against defendants 1 to 7 for want of notice was unjustified, while the suit could not be decreed against the 8th defendant.

Holding and Implications

The appeal is allowed. The judgment and decree of the trial Court are set aside, and the suit is decreed for Rs. 10,000 from the estate of the deceased K.J. Mathai in the hands of defendants 1 to 7, with 6% interest per annum from the date of the suit until realization.

There is no order as to costs. The 8th defendant, being an endorser, is not held liable due to the absence of a notice of dishonour. The decision directly affects the parties by confirming liability of the drawer's legal representatives without the necessity of notice of dishonour under the specific circumstances but does not establish any new legal precedent beyond the application of existing statutory provisions.

    Commercial Finances v. Thressia And Others

    1. Plaintiff is the appellant. Plaintiff discounted cheque dated 20-8-1977 for Rs. 10,000- drawn by K.J Mathai on Ganara Bank, Kothamangalam through the 8th defendant. The cheque was presented by the Canara Bank on 12-10-1977. It was dishonored. Defendants 1 to 7 are the legal representatives of Mathai. Additional defendants 9 to 12 are the legal representatives of the 8th defendant.

    2. Defendants 1 to 7 contended interalia that the plaintiff did not advance Rs. 10,000/- to Mathai through the 8th defendant. All the findings by the trial Court were in favour of the plaintiff except the one that the suit is not main tamable as no notice of dishonor under Section 93 of the Negotiable Instruments Act was given to the defendants.

    3. The question that arises for consideration is as to whether a notice of dishonour is mandatory to the drawer of a cheque in a case where the cheque was dishonoured on presentation. The Court below obviously overlooked Section 98(c) of the Nogotiable Instruments Act.

    4. It is in evidence that the cheque when presented by the plaintiff was returned with the endorsement “refer to drawer”. What is meant by ‘refer to drawer’ is stated in Parthasarathy's “Cheques in Law and Practice” thus:

    “This is used generally while returning cheques for want of funds in the drawer's account, or because of service of a garnishee order”.

    5. In Tannan's Banking Law and Practice page 313 (18th Edition) meaning of “refer to drawer” is stated as below:

    “It is generally meant to convey to the holder that he should refer to the drawer for payment, that is, the banker has not sufficient funds at his disposal to honour the cheque.”

    6. Ext. A3 cheque was returned with the endorsement “refer to drawer”. Hence it is obvious that there was no fund in the bank in the drawer's account for payment of the cheque. Section 98 of Negotiable Instruments Act states the circumstances under which a notice of dishonour is dispensed with.

    7. Section 98(c) of the Act provides that when the party charged could not suffer damage for want of notice, notice of dishonour is unnecessary. As Ext. A3 cheque could not be encashed for want of finds, it cannot be said that defendants 1 to 7 who are the legal representatives of the drawer of the cheque had suffered any damage for want sf notice. So far as the 8th defendant is concerned the position is different. Under the provisions of the Act the liability of an endorser is not that of a principal debtor and the liability of endorser can arise only if a notice of dishonour is issued to him and lot otherwise. [See John Chandy v. State Bank of Travancore (1973 K.L.J 450)]. As the 8th defendant, was not given the notice of dishonour, he cannot be held liable for the plaint claim.

    8. Along with the plaint Ext. A3 cheque and the endorsement by the bank were produced. A document produced along with the plaint under Order 7 Rule 14 should be treated as part of the pleadings. In Janki Das v. Kushalya Devi (AIR 1943 Lahore 207) the court held that the list of documents mentioned in Order 7 Rule 14(2) should be treated as part of plaint. Therefore there is no force in the defence contention that there is lack of pleading regarding dispensing with notice of dishonour. As Ext. A3 cheque with the endorsement showing that it was dishonoured was produced along with plaint, there is no need for a further pleading that notice of dishonour is not necessary. As there is evidence in the a case that Ext. A3 cheque was returned without payment as there was no necessary fund to meet the cheque it is a case where Section 98(c) applies and so no notice of dishonour is legally necessary.

    9. So far as defendants 1 to 7 are concerned it cannot be held that the suit against them is bad for want of notice of dishonour. So far as the 8th defendant is concerned he being an endorsee notice of dishonour was necessary. That being the position, there cannot be a decree against the 8th defendant. The trial Court was not justified in dismissing the suit as against defendants 1 to 7.

    10. The judgment and decree of the trial Court are set aside and the suit is deceased for Rs. 10,000/- from the estate of deceased K.J Matbai in the hands of defendants 1 to 7 with 6% interest per annum from date of suit till realisation.

    11. The appeal is allowed as stated above with no order as to costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Commercial Finances v. Thressia And Others
    (Apr 4, 1990)