Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • SECTION 158 KARNATAKA LAND REVENUE ACT 1964
  • Section 11 of the Central Excise Act, 1944 read with section 142 of the Customs Act, 1962,
  • Section 12. Application of the Provisions of Act 8 of 1878 of Central Excise Duties
  • provisions of the SARFAESI Act or the Karnataka Co-operative Societies Act, 1959
  • Section 69 or Section 69A of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 (4 of 1882),
  • Security Interest Act, 2002 (hereinafter referred to as the SARFAESI Act)
  • Section 31; Chapter 1 of the SARFAESI Act 13. Enforcement of Security
  • provisions of the Central Excise Act, 1944 and the Customs Act, 1962
  • Section 103 of the Karnataka Co-operative Societies Act, 1959.
  • Section 71 of the Karnataka Co-operative Societies Act, 1959
  • SECTION 3 CUSTOMS ACT 1962
  • provisions of the Central Excise Act and the Rules.
  • Customs Act, 1962 and the Central Excise Act, 1944
  • SECTION 35 BANKING REGULATION ACT 1949
  • CENTRAL BOARDS OF REVENUE ACT 1963
  • provisions of the (Customs Act, 1962 (52 of 1962))
  • Central Excise Act, 1944 "Section 11. Recovery
  • Central Excise Act and the Customs Act
  • Central Excise Act or the Customs Act,
  • SECTION 142 A CUSTOMS ACT 1962
  • Co-operative Societies Act, 1951
  • provisions of sub-section (4),
  • clause (d) of sub-section (4)
  • sub-section (4). (3)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • SECTION 158 KARNATAKA LAND REVENUE ACT 1964
  • Section 11 of the Central Excise Act, 1944 read with section 142 of the Customs Act, 1962,
  • Section 12. Application of the Provisions of Act 8 of 1878 of Central Excise Duties
  • provisions of the SARFAESI Act or the Karnataka Co-operative Societies Act, 1959
  • Section 69 or Section 69A of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 (4 of 1882),
  • Security Interest Act, 2002 (hereinafter referred to as the SARFAESI Act)
  • Section 31; Chapter 1 of the SARFAESI Act 13. Enforcement of Security
  • provisions of the Central Excise Act, 1944 and the Customs Act, 1962
  • Section 103 of the Karnataka Co-operative Societies Act, 1959.
  • Section 71 of the Karnataka Co-operative Societies Act, 1959
  • SECTION 3 CUSTOMS ACT 1962
  • provisions of the Central Excise Act and the Rules.
  • Customs Act, 1962 and the Central Excise Act, 1944
  • SECTION 35 BANKING REGULATION ACT 1949
  • CENTRAL BOARDS OF REVENUE ACT 1963
  • provisions of the (Customs Act, 1962 (52 of 1962))
  • Central Excise Act, 1944 "Section 11. Recovery
  • Central Excise Act and the Customs Act
  • Central Excise Act or the Customs Act,
  • SECTION 142 A CUSTOMS ACT 1962
  • Co-operative Societies Act, 1951
  • provisions of sub-section (4),
  • clause (d) of sub-section (4)
  • sub-section (4). (3)
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Provided Legal Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner is the Central Excise and Customs Department, Hubli, represented by its Assistant Commissioner, seeking to challenge actions by the second respondent (a cooperative bank) in bringing properties of the first respondent (an assessee-company) to sale for recovery of amounts due. The petitioner claims priority in recovering arrears of central excise duty, penalty and interest assessed against the first respondent by an Adjudication Order dated 1-3-2006 for Rs. 7,83,23,235/-.

The petitioner issued a Detention Order on 9-11-2006 and a Notice of Demand followed by a proclaimed Order of Attachment on 9-1-2007 in respect of various immovable properties of the first respondent, including factory buildings and lands; attachment orders were also made in respect of properties belonging to a director and an executive director.

Meanwhile, the second respondent (Hirekerur Urban Co-op Bank) and the third respondent (State Bank of Mysore, SBM) pursued recovery of their loans. The Co-op Bank obtained possession and attachment under an arbitration award pursuant to Section 103 of the Karnataka Co-operative Societies Act, 1959, and issued public auction notices (auction dates included 25-1-2007 and 31-1-2007). SBM proceeded under the SARFAESI Act, publishing notices and claiming constructive and later physical possession in 2004–2005.

The petitioner filed a writ petition seeking to quash the Co-op Bank's recovery steps (relying on Supreme Court authority in Dena Bank v. Parekh and other decisions) and for relief against proposed auctions under the SARFAESI Act. The High Court granted interim stay of a public auction notice on 24-1-2007. The Co-op Bank nonetheless published a handbill tendering auction dates, prompting the petitioner to file a second writ petition (W.P. No. 11371/2007). The two petitions were heard together on the pure question of law relating to priority of debts between the Central Excise Department and the respondent banks.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Central Excise and Customs Department (the petitioner) can claim priority or a preferential right to recover excise duty arrears (including penalty and interest) from the assessee's immovable properties as against competing claims of secured creditors (the respondent banks).
  2. Whether the respondent banks, having initiated proceedings under the SARFAESI Act and the Karnataka Co-operative Societies Act and having taken possession/attachment earlier, can proceed with enforcement (including public auctions) notwithstanding the petitioner's recovery actions.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The petitioner asserted that amounts due as central excise duty, penalty and interest would entitle the Central Excise Department to priority over other institutions, including banks, in recovering dues from the assessee.
  • Relying on the Supreme Court judgments in Dena Bank v. Parekh and Macson Marbles Pvt. Ltd. v. Union of India (and other authorities), the petitioner contended that it had a preferable right to attach and sell immovable properties under Section 11 of the Central Excise Act, 1944 read with Section 142 of the Customs Act, 1962.
  • The petitioner argued that its legislative provisions for recovery (Central Excise Act / Customs Act) entitled it to assert a preferential right over subsequent claims by banks, and that the banks' auction/attachment actions were contrary to the authority and confirmed demand of the petitioner.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The State Bank of Mysore (SBM) argued that it was a secured creditor: the assessee had created an equitable mortgage (deposit of title deeds) in its favour; SBM classified the account as non-performing, took constructive possession (5-12-2004), issued sale notice (11-1-2005), and took physical possession (8-2-2005), and therefore proceeded legitimately under the SARFAESI Act.
  • The Co-operative Bank explained it had a prior claim by way of a loan (Rs. 6.50 crore) and had obtained an Award and Attachment under the Karnataka Co-operative Societies Act leading to a public auction notice; it relied on attachment by arbitration under Section 103 of that Act.
  • Both banks contended that the petitioner's actions were subsequent to their actions (SBM in particular acted earlier), and that a secured creditor exercising statutory rights under SARFAESI Act (SBM) or attachment under the Co-operative Societies Act (Co-op Bank) could not be displaced by the petitioner's general recovery powers.
  • It was further contended that the Crown's (or State's) preferential right to recover debts is generally confined to ordinary and unsecured creditors and does not extend to priority over secured creditors. The petitioner did not point to any statutory provision in the Central Excise Act or the Customs Act creating a first charge or statutory priority over secured creditors.
  • SBM emphasised that SARFAESI is a special code allowing enforcement without court intervention and that its statutory rights (including vesting and first-charge effects) cannot be curtailed by the petitioner's general recovery powers.
  • The banks also argued that any contest as to priority between themselves involved questions of fact and were not matters properly resolved in the present writ petitions between the petitioner and the banks.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Dena Bank v. Bhikhabhai Prabhudas Parekh and Company, AIR 2000 SC 3654 The principle that the priority of Government debts is founded on the rule of necessity and public policy; such preferential right is confined to ordinary (unsecured) creditors and does not override pre-existing complete and perfect rights of subjects (e.g., secured creditors). The court relied on this authority to explain the doctrine of State priority and to hold that such priority is limited to unsecured creditors; the court applied this principle to conclude against the petitioner's claim to priority over secured creditors.
Macson Marbles Pvt. Ltd. v. Union of India, 2003 (158) ELT 424 : AIR 2004 SC 4927 Authority cited by petitioner in support of its claim to priority/recovery rights (as relied upon by petitioner). Listed as a precedent relied upon by the petitioner. The opinion records the reliance but does not set out detailed analysis of this decision's content in the court's reasoning.
M/s. Builders Supply Corporation v. The Union of India and others, AIR 1965 SC 1061 Earlier authority concerning the State's preferential right; cited as part of the line of authorities followed by the Supreme Court on priority. The court noted that the Supreme Court in Dena Bank followed earlier decisions including this case; used as background authority supporting the doctrine described in Dena Bank.
The Bank of Bihar v. State of Bihar and Others, AIR 1971 SC 1210 Authority forming part of the precedent line on State priority over creditors. The court recorded this case as part of the jurisprudential basis followed by the Supreme Court in delineating the limited scope of State priority; referenced as background.
Karnataka State Industrial Investment and Development Corporation Ltd v. The Secretary, Government of India and others, ILR 2005 Kar 3572 Case cited by respondents in support of their position on competing priorities (as listed in the opinion). Listed among authorities relied upon by the respondents; the court did not elaborate further on its specific application in the body of its reasoning.
UTI Bank Limited v. The Deputy Commissioner of Central Excise, Chennai (Full Bench), AIR 2007 Mad 118 Authority referenced by the respondents (Full Bench decision of Madras High Court cited in support). Included in the list of authorities cited by the respondents; the court recorded the citation but did not analyse its detailed relevance in the judgment text.
Collector of Aurangabad v. Central Bank of India Limited, AIR 1967 SC 1831 Authority cited by respondents in support of their submissions on priority and recovery mechanisms. Recorded in the list of authorities relied upon by respondents; no detailed exposition of its rule was set out by the court in the opinion beyond its inclusion.
Sitani Textiles and Fabrics Pvt. Ltd. v. Collector of Customs and Central Excise, 1998 ALT 5-249 Authority cited by respondents in the context of recovery / priority disputes (as listed). Listed among the authorities cited; the court did not elaborate on a specific application of this precedent in its reasoning as set out in the text.
Union of India v. Metherukunju Moosakutty and others, AIR 1980 Ker 182 Authority cited by respondents in their list of supporting cases. Included in the respondents' list of authorities; the opinion does not extract a specific doctrinal point from this decision in the court's written analysis in the provided text.
ICICI Bank Limited v. SIDCO Leather Limited, AIR 2006 SC 2088 Supreme Court authority cited by respondents concerning banking/creditor rights (as listed). Recorded among the authorities relied upon by respondents; the provided opinion does not expand on a separate analysis of the decision beyond its citation.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court first identified the statutory machinery relied upon by the petitioner for recovery: Section 11 of the Central Excise Act, 1944 (recovery by deduction, attachment and sale of excisable goods, or by certificate to the District Collector as if arrears of land revenue), Section 12 (application of Customs Act provisions), and Section 142 of the Customs Act, 1962 (recovery of sums due to Government by deduction, detention and sale of goods, distress or certificate to the Collector).

The court next extracted and considered salient provisions of the SARFAESI Act invoked by SBM, including definitions of "secured creditor" and "security interest" and Section 13 (enforcement of security interest without court intervention, rights to take possession, take over management, transfer/vest rights on transfer, and prioritisation of costs and dues in receipt application).

Applying the doctrinal law on State priority as articulated in Dena Bank, the court emphasised that the principle of priority of Government debts is founded on necessity and public policy, but that such preferential right is confined to ordinary and unsecured creditors. The court noted that where the subject (i.e., private creditor) has a complete and perfect right before the State's right commences, the State's preference does not displace that existing right.

The court then observed that neither the Central Excise Act nor the Customs Act contains a specific provision creating a statutory first charge or priority over secured creditors' pre-existing rights. By contrast, the SARFAESI Act provides a legislative scheme enabling secured creditors (such as SBM) to enforce security interests without court intervention and to exercise rights that create practical precedence in enforcement of secured debts.

On the timeline of events, the court noted admissions in the record that the actions taken by SBM (classification as NPA, notices, constructive and physical possession) predated the petitioner's attachment steps; similarly, the Co-op Bank's attachment/auction steps arose under the Co-operative Societies Act. The court treated inter-bank priority (i.e., precedence between the two banks) as a matter involving facts and issues for the banks to resolve between themselves and not as part of the present writ petitions.

Because the petitioner's statutory recovery provisions do not confer a first-charge or clear statutory priority over secured creditors, and because SARFAESI supplies a special, comprehensive code for secured creditors' enforcement (which SBM had invoked), the court concluded that the petitioner could not assert the claimed preferential right in the circumstances of this case.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The petitions are dismissed; the interim order granted earlier is vacated.

Implications:

  • The court held against the petitioner on the core question: the Central Excise Department could not, on the basis of the Central Excise Act or Customs Act as presented in this case, claim a priority over secured creditors who had invoked statutory enforcement regimes (notably SARFAESI) and who had acted earlier.
  • The direct effect is that the petitioner’s claim to displace the banks’ enforcement steps fails and the earlier interim restraint is vacated, leaving the banks’ enforcement measures (including SARFAESI-based measures taken by SBM and attachments under the Co-operative Societies Act) unaffected by the writ petitions.
  • The court noted that questions concerning priority between the respondent banks themselves (i.e., which secured creditor has precedence) involve factual determinations and are not resolved in this petition; those matters must be addressed between the banks or in appropriate proceedings directed to those factual issues.
  • No new broad legislative principle was laid down by the court beyond application of established doctrine (as articulated in Dena Bank) and statutory interpretation showing that SARFAESI operates as a special code for secured creditors' enforcement, while the Central Excise / Customs recovery provisions do not confer a statutory first charge over secured creditors in the circumstances described.

Disposition: Petition dismissed.

    The Assistant Commissioner Of Central Excise And Customs v. Nandi Rerolling Mills Private Limited And Others

    Judgement

    The petitioner is the Central Excise and Customs Department, Hubli represented by its Assistant Commissioner of Central Excise, seeking to question the action of the second respondent in bringing to sale, the properties belonging to the first respondent in recovery of amounts due from the first respondent. The petitioner claims priority in such recovery.

    2. The brief facts as are necessary for consideration of the present writ petition are, that the first respondent is an assessee within the jurisdiction of the petitioner. It transpires that the first respondent is due to the petitioner in a sum of Rs. 7,83,23,235/- by way of central excise duty and penalty along with interest in terms of an Adjudication Order No. 2/2006, dated 1-3-2006. Pursuant to proceedings initiated for clandestine removal of the manufactured goods, it transpires that there was a Detention Order issued by the Authorised Officer as on 9-11-2006 for recovery of the said arrears and a Notice of Demand followed by a proclaimed Order of Attachment was issued on 9-1-2007 in respect of the properties of the first respondent, namely, its factory building and other buildings situate at plot No. 2D, 2E and 2F of Block No. 89. The further order of attachment has been proclaimed on the very date in respect of land situate in plot No. 1/14, Block No. 96A belonging to respondent No. 1(a), who is the Executive Director of the first respondent-Company, as well as in respect of land in Block No. 675, measuring about 3 acres and 27 guntas belonging to one of the directors of the Company.

    3. It further transpires that when these adjudication proceedings were in progress, the second respondent (hereinafter referred to as the Co-op. Bank) who had extended certain loans to the assessee-Company, on the mortgage of assets, had initiated proceedings against the assessee-Company and had taken possession of the same, by virtue of an attachment order pursuant to an Award by the Joint Registrar of Co-operative Societies as an Arbitrator in terms of Section 103 of the Karnataka Co-operative Societies Act, 1959. While other properties have been taken possession of by the third respondent namely, the State Bank of Mysore (hereinafter referred to as SBM for brevity) Hubli, under the provisions of the Securitisation and Reconstruction of Financial Assets and Enforcement of Security Interest Act, 2002 (hereinafter referred to as the SARFAESI Act) in lieu of default in payment of the loan availed as per its Public Notice dated 5-10-2004, published in the Newspaper on 17-10-2004. The Co-op. Bank had issued a Public Auction Sale Notice dated 26-11-2006, which has been published in a local Newspaper on 8-1-2007, proposing to hold auction sale of the properties belonging to the first respondent on 25-1-2007 and 31-1-2007. The petitioner apprehending that apart from the Co-op. Bank proceeding in terms of the above Public Notices, that the SBM was also likely to adopt similar measures, had preferred the above writ petition seeking to quash the said recovery proceedings before the Co-op. Bank, on the footing that such action was contrary to the judgment of the Supreme Court in the case of Dena Bank v. Bhikhabhai Prabhudas Parekh and Company, AIR 2000 SC 3654 and further reliefs against the proposed public auction pursuant to the notice under the SARFAESI Act issued by SBM.

    4. The petition coming on for Preliminary Hearing, this Court was pleased to issue notice to the respondents and ordered interim stay of Annexure-K by its order dated 24-1-2007, which was a Public Notice proposing to hold public auction of the properties. However, the Co-op. Bank published a tender notification by way of a hand-bill dated 28-6-2007, fixing the date of auction of the properties belonging to the above said assessee on various dates, in the face of an interim order granted by this Court as aforesaid. The petitioner was hence, constrained to file the second writ petition in W.P. No. 11371/2007 also challenging the said handbill on the very grounds that have been urged in the first petition. Hence, the two petitions are considered together on a pure question of law as to the priority of debts as between the petitioner and the respondents-Banks.

    5. It is the contention of the Counsel for the petitioner that the amounts sought to be recovered by the petitioner being arrears of central excise duty and penalty, with interest thereon, the petitioner-department would have priority over other institutions and organisations, including the respondent-Banks in the matter of realising its dues from an assessee. 6. In this regard, the Counsel places reliance on the judgment of the Supreme Court in the case of Dena Bank (AIR 2000 SC 3654) (supra) and Macson Marbles Private Limited v. Union of India, 2003 (158) ELT 424 : (AIR 2004 SC 4927). It is contended that the Coop. Bank seeking to claim under Section 71 of the Karnataka Co-operative Societies Act, 1959 and attachment before judgment under Section 103 of the said Act, while SBM seeking to proceed under the provisions of the SARFAESI Act, are overriding the priority claim of the Central Excise Department. The said respondent-Banks are negating the demand of the petitioner which has been confirmed in all respects, in accordance with the provisions of the Central Excise Act and the Rules.

    7. It is contended that by virtue of Section 11 of the Central Excise Act, 1944 read with section 142 of the Customs Act, 1962, the petitioner-department is empowered to recover excise duty by way of attachment and sale of immoveable properties. It is contended that the respondent-Banks seeking to proceed under the provisions of the SARFAESI Act or the Karnataka Co-operative Societies Act, 1959 which are legislations enacted subsequent to the provisions of the Central Excise Act, 1944 and the Customs Act, 1962 and even on that count, the petitioner would be able to assert a preferential right or priority to recover the dues over the right of the Banks.

    8. The Counsel for the respondent-SBM would contend as follows :-

    - That State Bank of Mysore is a nationalised Bank from whom the first respondent-Company had sought for financial assistance in a sum of Rs. 50 Lakh towards working capital and letter of credit of Rs. 50 Lakh. This was released in the year 2003. The said Company had created a equitable mortgage by deposit of title deeds in respect of the subject properties. On default of payment, the Bank has initiated action under the provisions of the SARFAESI Act. In terms of the said Act, the constructive possession had been taken of the secured assets as on 5-12-2004 and the Bank has issued a notice of sale dated 11-1-2005 and has taken physical possession of the secured assets as on 8-2-2005 and steps have been taken to auction the secured assets.

    9. The Counsel also would acknowledge that the Co-op. Bank, namely, Hirekerur Urban Co-operative Bank has a similar claim for recovery in respect of a loan of Rs. 6.50 Crore to the first respondent and of proceedings under the Karnataka Co-operative Societies Act, 1951 resulting in an Award and Attachment preceding a public auction sale proposed. In the light of these rival claims, the recovery proceedings have come to a stand-still. In any event, the Counsel would submit that the petitioners contention as to the petitioner having a priority over the assets belonging to the borrower-Company is incorrect.

    10. This Counsel would point out that insofar as the claim of the petitioner is concerned, admittedly, there was an Adjudication Order on 1-3-2000, a Detention Order on 9-11-2006 and Proclamation Order of Attachment on 9-1-2008 and a Notice of Warrant of Attachment has been issued on 9-1-2007. These admitted facts would indicate that all actions initiated by the petitioner against the respondent-Company and its assets, are subsequent to the action initiated by SBM.

    11. Similarly, insofar as the Co-operative Bank is concerned, in proceedings initiated under the Karnataka Co-operative Societies Act, 1951, there was an Attachment Order by the Arbitration Court on 3-9-2005, a public notice was published in the Newspapers on 17-10-2004, a Public Auction Sale Notice was published on 8-1-2007 and a public auction was proposed to be held on 25-1 -2007 and 31-1-2007. These admitted events would also indicate that even the Co-operative Bank has initiated proceedings subsequent to the charge and proceedings that are initiated by SBM. The respondent-Bank being a secured creditor, who had no prior notice of any claim, either by the petitioner or by the Co-operative Bank, they are estopped in law from seeking to claim a right of priority over the assets of the first respondent-Company.

    12. The Counsel would contend that a mortgage having been created in favour of the third responpent-Bank, the third respondent is a secured creditor on creation of such a right, the Bank would claim that under section 35 of the sarfaesi act, the power of SBM cannot be curtailed by the alleged preferential right of priority of the petitioner which is not supported by any statutory provision. The petitioner does not disclose or urge any such statutory provision which confers such a preferential priority over the secured assets. On the other hand, the third respondent-Bank having exercised its statutory right, under the provisions of the SARFAESI Act and the Bank having taken possession of the secured assets in accordance with law, the claim of the petitioner that it could still exercise any right of priority, cannot be sustained. Especially, in the light of the circumstance that such a claim is made subsequent to the action initiated by the respondent-Bank, it is contended that the general power of recovery under the Customs Act, 1962 and the Central Excise Act, 1944 is subject to the proceedings under the SARFAESI Act and the SARFAESI Act being a special enactment, would be applicable irrespective of other enactments being enforced. The SARFAESI Act is a complete code providing for all contingencies for recovery of debts from a defaulter. When once the Act is invoked, others, such as the the petitioner, would not have jurisdiction to proceed under section 142 of the Customs Act, 1962. A statutory first charge is created in favour of the third respondent under the provisions of the SARFAESI Act and the same will prevail over all other subsequent charges.

    13. The Crowns Preferential Right of Recovery of Debts over other creditors is confined to ordinary and unsecured creditors only. The Crown will not have a preferential right to recover its debts over a secured creditor. The Counsel would emphasize that there is no provision for claiming a first charge under the Central Excise Act and the Customs Act and hence, there is no legal basis for the petitioner to claim any such priority whereas the Bank as a secured creditor, is in a position to do so.

    14. The Counsel would place reliance on the following authorities in support of her case :

    i) M/s. Builders Supply Corporation v. The Union of India and others, AIR 1965 SC 1061,

    ii) Dena Bank v. Bhikhabhai Prabhudas Parekh and Company and others, AIR 2000 SC 3654,

    iii) Karnataka State Industrial Investment and Development Corporation Limited v. The Secretary, Government of India and others, ILR 2005 Kar 3572 : (2005 AIR - Kant HCR 1734),

    iv) UTI Bank Limited v. The Deputy Commissioner of Central Excise, Chennai, a Full Bench decision of the High Court of Madras in Writ Petition No. 39536/2005 (reported in AIR 2007 Mad 118),

    v) Collector of Aurangabad v. Central Bank of India Limited, AIR 1967 SC 1831,

    vi) The Bank of Bihar v. State of Bihar and Others, AIR 1971 SC 1210,

    vii) Sitani Textiles and Fabrics Private Limited v. Collector of Customs and Central Excise, 1998 ALT 5-249,

    viii) Union of India v. Metherukunju Moosakutty and others, AIR 1980 Ker 182,

    ix) ICICI Bank Limited v. SIDCO Leather Limited, AIR 2006 SC 2088.

    15. The Counsel for the second respondent would also urge similar contentions while emphasizing the fact that on account of the said respondent not being in a position to recover moneys, it has affected its business and its very functioning has come to a standstill inviting action by the Reserve Bank of India under Section 35 of the Banking Regulation Act, 1949.

    16. The question that arises for consideration in the present case on hand, is whether the petitioner can claim a priority in seeking to recover dues as against the respondent-Company over the claims of the respondent-Banks. Insofar as the legal provisions, under which the petitioner claims to have a right to recover the amounts are concerned, are extracted hereunder for a ready reference :-

    "The Central Excise Act, 1944

    "Section 11. Recovery of sums due to Government :

    In respect of duty and any other sums of any kind payable to the Central Government under any of the provisions of this Act or of the rules made thereunder, (including the amount required to be paid to the credit of the Central Government under Section 11D) the officer empowered by the (Central Board of Excise and Customs constituted under the Central Boards of Revenue Act, 1963 (54 of 1963)) to levy such duty or require the payment of such sums may deduct the amount so payable from any money owing to the person from whom such sums may be recoverable or due which may in his hands or under his disposal or control, or may recover the amount by attachment and sale of excisable goods belonging to such person; and if the amount payable is not so recovered he may prepare a certificate signed by him specifying the amount due from the person liable to pay the same and send it to the Collector of the District in which such person resides or conducts his business and the said Collector, on receipt of such certificate, shall proceed to recover from the said person the amount specified therein as if it were an arrear of land revenue.

    (Provided that where the person (hereinafter referred to as predecessor) from whom the duty or any other sums of any kind, as specified in this section, is recoverable or due, transfers or otherwise disposes of his business or trade in whole or in part, or effects any change in the ownership thereof, in consequence of which he is succeeded in such business or trade by any other person, all excisable goods, materials, preparations, plants, machinaries, vessels, utensils, implements and articles in the custody or possession of the person so succeeding may also be attached and sold by such officer empowered by the Central Board of Excise and Customs, after obtaining written approval from the Commissioner of Central Excise, for the purposes of recovering such duty or other sums recoverable or due from such predecessor at the time of such transfer or otherwise disposal or change.)

    Section 12. Application of the Provisions of Act 8 of 1878 of Central Excise Duties :-

    The Central Government may, by notification in the Official Gazette, declare that any of the provisions of the (Customs Act, 1962 (52 of 1962)) relating to the levy of and exemption from customs duties, drawback of duty, warehousing, offences and penalties, confiscation, and procedure relating to offences and appeals shall, with such modifications and alterations as it may consider necessary or desirable to adapt them to the circumstances, be applicable in regard to like matters in respect of the duties imposed by Section 3.

    The Customs Act, 1962

    "Section 142. Recovery of sums due to Government :-

    (1) (Where any sum payable by any person) under this Act (including the amount required to be paid to the credit of the Central Government under Section 28B) is not paid -

    (a) the proper officer may deduct or may require any other officer of customs to deduct the amount so payable from any money owing to such person which may be under the control of the proper officer or such other officer of customs; or

    (b) the (Assistant Commissioner of Customs or Deputy Commissioner of Customs) may recover or may require any other officer of customs to recover the amount so payable by detaining and selling any goods belonging to such person which are under the control of the (Assistant Commissioner of Customs or Deputy Commissioner of Customs) or such other officer of customs; or

    ((c) if the amount cannot be recovered from such person in the manner provided in clause (a) or clause (b) -

    (i) the (Assistant Commissioner of Customs or Deputy Commissioner of Customs) may prepare a certificate signed by him specifying the amount due from such person and send it to the Collector of the District in which such person owns any property or resides or carries on his business and the said Collector on receipt of such certificates shall proceed to recover from such person the amount specified thereunder as if it were an arrears of land revenue; or

    (ii) the proper officer may, on an authorisation by a Commissioner of Customs and in accordance with the rules made in this behalf, distrain any movable or immovable property belonging to or under the control of such person, and detain the same until the amount payable is paid; and in case, any part of the said amount payable or of the cost of the distress or keeping of the property, remains unpaid for a period of thirty days next after any such distress, may cause the said property to be sold and with the proceeds of such sale, may satisfy the amount payable and the costs including cost of sale remaining unpaid and shall render the surplus, if any, to such person :

    (Provided that where the person (hereinafter referred to as predecessor), by whom any sum payable under this Act, including the amount required to be paid to the credit of the Central Government under Section 28B is not paid, transfers or otherwise disposes of his business or trade in whole or in part, or effects any change in the ownership thereof, in consequence of which he is succeeded in such business or trade by any other person, all goods, materials, preparations, plants, machineries, vessels, utensils, implements and articles in the custody or possession of the person so succeeding may also be attached and sold by the proper officer, after obtaining written approval from the Commissioner of Customs, for the purposes of reconverting the amount so payable by such predecessor at the time of such transfer or otherwise disposal or change.)

    (2) Where the terms of any bond or other instrument executed under this Act or any rules or regulations made thereunder provide that any amount due under such instrument may be recovered in the manner laid down in sub-section (1), the amount may, without prejudice to any other mode of recovery, be recovered in accordance with the provisions of that sub-section."

    17. The provisions of the SARFAESI Act as are relevant in the respondent-State Bank of Mysore claiming that it has initiated proceedings and has taken possession prior to the action initiated by the petitioner is concerned, are also extracted below :

    "Chapter 1 of the SARFAESI Act

    Definitions :

    (zd) "secured creditor" means any bank or financial institution or any consortium or group of banks or financial institutions and includes -

    (i) debenture trustee appointed by any bank or financial institution; or

    (ii) (securitisation company or reconstruction company, whether acting as such or managing a trust set up by such securitisation company or reconstruction company for the securitisation or reconstruction, as the case may be; or)

    (iii) any other trustee holding securities on behalf of a bank or financial institution, in whose favour security interest is created for due repayment by any borrower of any financial assistance;

    (zf) "security interest" means right, title and interest of any kind whatsoever upon property, created in favour of any secured creditor and includes any mortgage, charge, hypothecation, assignment other than those specified in Section 31;

    Chapter 1 of the SARFAESI Act

    13. Enforcement of Security Interest :

    (1) Notwithstanding anything contained in Section 69 or Section 69A of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 (4 of 1882), any security interest created in favour of any secured creditor may be enforced, without the intervention of the Court or Tribunal, by such creditor in accordance with the provisions of this Act.

    (2) Where any borrower, who is under a liability to a secured creditor under a security agreement, makes any default in repayment of secured debt or any instalment thereof, and his account in respect of such debt is classified by the secured creditor as non-performing asset, then, the secured creditor may require the borrower by notice in writing to discharge in full his liabilities to the secured creditor within sixty days from the date of notice failing which the secured creditor shall be entitled to exercise all or any of the rights under sub-section (4).

    (3) The notice referred to in sub-section (2) shall give details of the amount payable by the borrower and the secured assets intended to be enforced by the secured creditor in the event of non-payment of secured debts by the borrower.

    (4) In case the borrower fails to discharge his liability in full within the period specified in sub-section (2), the secured creditor may take recourse to one or more of the following measures to recover his secured debt, namely :-

    a) take possession of the secured assets of the borrower including the right to transfer by way of lease, assignment or sale for realising the secured asset;

    b) take over the management of the business of the borrower including the right to transfer by way of lease, assignment or sale for realising the secured asset;

    c) appoint any person (hereinafter referred to as the manager), to manage the secured assets the possession of which has been taken over by the secured creditor;

    (5) Any payment made by any person referred to in clause (d) of sub-section (4) to the secured creditor shall give such person a valid discharge as if he has made payment to the borrower.

    (6) Any transfer of secured asset after taking possession thereof or take over of management under sub-section (4), by the secured creditor or by the manager on behalf of the secured creditors shall vest in the transferee all rights in, or in relation to, the secured asset transferred as if the transfer had been made by the owner of such secured asset.

    (7) Where any action has been taken against a borrower under the provisions of sub-section (4), all costs, charges and expenses which, in the opinion of the secured creditor, have been properly incurred by him or any expenses incidental thereto, shall be recoverable from the borrower and the money which is received by the secured creditor shall, in the absence of any contract to the contrary, be held by him in trust, to be applied, firstly, in payment of such costs, charges and expenses and secondly, in discharge of the dues of the secured creditor and the residue of the money so received shall be paid to the person entitled thereto in accordance with his rights and interest."

    18. Insofar as the doctrine of priority or precedence of State debts are concerned, the law has been succinctly laid down by the Supreme Court in Dena Banks case (AIR 2000 SC 3654) (supra), in holding that the principle of priority of Government debts is founded on the rule of necessity and of public policy. The basic justification for the claim for priority of State debts, rests on the well recognised principle that the State is entitled to raise money by taxation because, unless adequate revenue is received by the State, it would not be able to function as a sovereign Government at all. It is essential that as a sovereign, the State should be able to discharge its primary governmental functions and in order to be able to discharge such functions, it must be in possession of necessary funds and this consideration emphasizes the necessity and the wisdom of conceding to the State, the right to claim priority in respect of its tax dues. However, the States preferential right to recovery of debts over other creditors is confined to ordinary or unsecured creditors. It is only where the States right and that of the subject meet at the one and the same time, that the State is in general preferred. Where the right of the subject is complete and perfect, before that of the State commences, the rule does not apply, for there is no point of time at which the rights are at conflict nor can there be a question which of the two ought to prevail in a case where one, that of the subject has prevailed already. The Supreme Court in laying down thus, has followed its earlier decisions in Builders Supply Corporation v. The Union of India and others, AIR 1965 SC 1061 and in Bank of Bihar v. State of Bihar, AIR 1971 SC 1210.

    19. It has further held with specific reference to the Karnataka Sales Tax Act, 1957 and the Karnataka Land Revenue Act, 1964 whereunder Section 158 of the Karnataka Land Revenue Act, 1964 not only gives a statutory recognition to the doctrine of States priority for recovery of debts, but also extends its applicability over private debts forming the subject matter of mortgage, judgment, decree, execution, or attachment and the like and that the effect of Section 190 is to name the procedures for recovery of arrears of land revenue applicable for recovery of sales tax arrears and that Section 150 accords primacy to all moneys recoverable including the sales tax arrears.

    20. Thus, from a reading of the provisions under which, the petitioner claims primacy over the debts due to it as against the respondent-Banks, it is clear that there is no specific provision either under the Central Excise Act or the Customs Act, to enable the Central Excise Department to claim a precedence over the claim of a secured creditor such as the respondent-Banks. On the other hand, under the provisions of the SARFAESI Act, the State Bank of Mysore having initiated proceedings thereunder, would clearly claim precedence insofar as enforcing its right is concerned. The precedence, vis-a-vis the State Bank of Mysore and the Hirekerur Urban Co-operative Bank is not the subject matter of this writ petition and is a matter to be resolved as between the said respondents as the same would involve questions of fact which are purely matters concerning the said respondents. The question insofar as the petitioner is concerned, would clearly have to be answered against the petitioner.

    The petitions stand dismissed. The interim order granted earlier stands vacated.

    Petition dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    The Assistant Commis... v. Nandi Rerolling Mill...
    (Feb 6, 2008)