Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Sub-rule (8) of Rule 43 of the Karnataka Land Revenue Rules, 1966 (hereinafter referred
  • provisions of sub-rule (4) of Rule 43-G
  • sub-rule (4) of Rule 43-G of the Rules.
  • Section 233 of the Land Revenue Code,
  • Sub-rule (2) of Rule 43 of the Rules
  • Rule 43(L) of Land Revenue
  • Rule 43(G)(4) of the Rules,
  • sub-rule (4) of Rule 43-G
  • Rule 43(2) of the Rules.
  • Rule 43-G of the Rules
  • Rule 43-L of the Rules.
  • Sub-rule (2) of Rule 43,
  • Rule 42 of the Rules
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Sub-rule (8) of Rule 43 of the Karnataka Land Revenue Rules, 1966 (hereinafter referred
  • provisions of sub-rule (4) of Rule 43-G
  • sub-rule (4) of Rule 43-G of the Rules.
  • Section 233 of the Land Revenue Code,
  • Sub-rule (2) of Rule 43 of the Rules
  • Rule 43(L) of Land Revenue
  • Rule 43(G)(4) of the Rules,
  • sub-rule (4) of Rule 43-G
  • Rule 43(2) of the Rules.
  • Rule 43-G of the Rules
  • Rule 43-L of the Rules.
  • Sub-rule (2) of Rule 43,
  • Rule 42 of the Rules
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This petition challenges two administrative orders: Annexure-C (order dated 22.7.1989 by the third respondent) and Annexure-D (order dated 16.9.1991 by the second respondent, confirming Annexure-C). The impugned orders declared null and void the sale in favor of the petitioner of land measuring 3 acres 14 guntas in Survey No. 11 of Gummareddypura village (Srinivasapura Taluk, Kolar District) and directed that possession be handed back to the original grantee, one Gopalappa (deceased, identified as the 4th respondent).

Background facts relevant to disposal: - In 1954 a grant order dated 21.9.1954 granted 2 acres in Survey No. 11 to Gopalappa with a condition that the land not be alienated for 20 years; a Saguvli Chit issued on 11.9.1954 recorded the non-alienation condition. - By order dated 24.6.1966 (Annexure-B), on recommendation of the Divisional Commissioner and purportedly in exercise of Rule 43 powers, an additional 1 acre 14 guntas in the same survey number was granted to Gopalappa at an upset price of Rs. 50 per acre, subject to recovery of back assessment. That grant was stated to be in relaxation of Rule 42 and under the powers of Rule 43-L. - The petitioner purchased the entire 3 acres 14 guntas by a registered Sale Deed dated 26.3.1967 (covering both the original 2 acres and the additional 1 acre 14 guntas). - On an application by Gopalappa under Section 5(1) of the Act, the third respondent passed Annexure-C setting aside the sale; that decision was affirmed by the second respondent in Annexure-D. The present petition challenges those orders.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the 1 acre 14 guntas granted by Annexure-B was granted for an "upset price" (i.e., for full market value as required by sub-rule (2) of Rule 43); and
  2. If it was granted at an upset price, whether the subsequent sale by the grantee (Gopalappa) contravened sub-rule (4) of Rule 43-G of the Karnataka Land Revenue Rules (which prohibits alienation for 15 years when the grant is free or at a price less than market value).

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments (as advanced by Sri B.T. Parthasarthy)

  • The petitioner conceded he would not contest the orders insofar as they related to the original 2 acres (1954 grant) and accepts confirmation of those orders in relation to that extent.
  • As to the 1 acre 14 guntas granted by Annexure-B, the petitioner argued that Annexure-B expressly shows the grant was made at an upset price of Rs. 50 per acre; under sub-rule (2) of Rule 43 the upset price must represent market value, so it cannot be inferred that the upset price was a reduced price.
  • Because Annexure-B does not impose any condition prohibiting alienation (and there is no Saguvali Chit for the 1 acre 14 guntas), sub-rule (4) of Rule 43-G (non-alienation for 15 years where grant is free or at reduced price) is inapplicable.
  • The petitioner argued the impugned orders are non-speaking and lack reasons for the finding that the sale violated the terms of the grant or the law governing the grant — i.e., there was no proper application of mind by the authorities.

Respondents 1–3 (State / Government Pleader, Sri M. Siddagangaiah)

  • While conceding that the impugned orders may not be speaking orders, the Government Pleader argued the upset price of Rs. 50 per acre was effectively a reduced market price (not true market value) and that such an inference can be drawn from the low figure.
  • Relied on prior decisions of this Court (Basappa v. Special Deputy Commissioner, ILR 1991 KAR 1321; Virupakashappa v. Hanumanthappa, ILR 1994 KAR 1270) to support the contention that a grant at a reduced upset price attracts the non-alienation condition under Rule 43-G(4).

Supplemental Respondents 4(a)–(f) (Legal heirs of deceased Gopalappa)

  • Adopted the submissions of the Government Pleader and supported the validity of the impugned orders.
  • Added that Gopalappa was in unauthorised occupation of the relevant land even before Annexure-B, supporting the grant to him.
  • Contended that the upset price in Annexure-B (Rs. 50) was not the market value that Rule 43(2) requires, and further that the subsequent grant must be construed as subject to the same conditions as the original 2-acre grant.
  • Relied on the same precedents (Basappa and Virupakashappa) cited by the Government Pleader.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Basappa v. Special Deputy Commissioner, ILR 1991 KAR 1321 Used where grant order and Saguvali Chit specifically provided non-alienation for 15 years; treated as indicating upset price fixed was not market price (i.e., grant effectively at reduced price). The Court held that Basappa's principle could not be applied here because Annexure-B expressly stated the land was granted on payment of an upset price of Rs. 50 per acre; therefore the factual basis in Basappa (a waiver/reduced upset price reflected in documents) was absent in this case.
Virupakashappa v. Hanumanthappa, ILR 1994 KAR 1270 Illustrates that when part of the market price is waived (example: out of Rs.500 market price, Rs.200 was waived), the grant is for a reduced upset price and the non-alienation rules apply. The Court observed Virupakashappa is distinguishable because that case involved an explicit partial waiver of the market price, showing a reduced upset price. In the present case no waiver is recorded in Annexure-B, so Virupakashappa's principle does not apply.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court framed the determinative issue narrowly: whether the 1 acre 14 guntas granted by Annexure-B was in fact a grant at an upset price (i.e., full market value) and, if so, whether the sale by the grantee contravened sub-rule (4) of Rule 43-G which prohibits alienation for 15 years when the grant is free or at a price less than full market value.

The Court's step-by-step analysis (restricted to the content of the opinion) is as follows:

  1. Annexure-B expressly states the grant of 1 acre 14 guntas was made "at an upset price of Rs. 50/- per acre" and was based on the Divisional Commissioner's recommendation.
  2. The Court relied on sub-rule (2) of Rule 43, which mandates that the "Upset Price" shall not be arbitrarily fixed but shall represent the actual market value as nearly as can be ascertained by local enquiries and sale records. Given this statutory mandate, the Court found it not permissible to infer, merely from the face value of Rs. 50/-, that the upset price was not the market value.
  3. The State has the statutory power under Rule 43-G to waive the upset price (in whole or in part) when granting land to persons belonging to Scheduled Castes or Scheduled Tribes and others unable to pay, up to Rs. 200. Such a waiver would ordinarily be reflected in the grant order.
  4. Annexure-B contains no reference to any waiver (total or partial) of the upset price. In the absence of any explicit waiver recorded in the order, the Court concluded the grant was made at the upset price stated (Rs. 50 per acre) and not at a reduced or waived price.
  5. Because sub-rule (4) of Rule 43-G applies only where the grant is free or made at less than full market value, the Court concluded that sub-rule (4) was not attracted here: there was no waiver and therefore no basis to treat the grant as less than market value.
  6. The Court distinguished the precedents relied upon by the respondents (Basappa and Virupakashappa) on the factual ground that those cases involved either an express non-alienation condition tied to a reduced upset price or an express waiver/partial waiver of the market price; such factual features are absent in Annexure-B.
  7. Consequently, the Court held the 1 acre 14 guntas was not sold in contravention of the terms of the grant or sub-rule (4) of Rule 43-G, and the impugned administrative orders could not be sustained insofar as they related to that portion.

The Court also accepted the petitioner's concession to abandon challenge to the 2 acres originally granted in 1954 and expressly confirmed the impugned orders in respect of that 2-acre portion.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The petition is disposed of in part: the orders Annexure-C (22.7.1989) and Annexure-D (16.9.1991) are confirmed insofar as they relate to the original 2 acres granted by the 21.9.1954 order, and are quashed insofar as they relate to the 1 acre 14 guntas granted by Annexure-B (24.6.1966).

Direct consequences and directions contained in the decision (as stated in the opinion):

  • If the legal heirs of the deceased grantee have not yet been put in possession of the 2 acres (the 1954 grant), the third respondent is directed to put supplemental respondents 4(a) to (f) in possession of that 2-acre portion within three months from receipt of the order, after issuing notice to the petitioner and those supplemental respondents.
  • If the legal heirs already have possession of the entire 3 acres 14 guntas, the third respondent is directed to put the petitioner in possession of the 1 acre 14 guntas (the portion granted under Annexure-B) within three months from receipt of the order.
  • While identifying the 2 acres for which the earlier orders are confirmed, respondents 2 and 3 are directed to have due regard to the identification made by the supplemental respondents 4(a) to (f).
  • The petition is otherwise disposed of in terms stated above; the opinion contains no indication that a new legal principle or precedent is being laid down beyond the application of the existing rules to the facts of the case.
  • Procedurally, the learned High Court Government Pleader (Sri M. Siddagangaiah) was permitted to file his memo of appearance within four weeks.

The opinion does not assert that it establishes a new or broader precedent; its holding is fact-specific—turning on the contents of Annexure-B and the absence of any recorded waiver of the upset price.

    G.N Vemareddy v. State Of Karnataka & Ors.

    P. Vishwanatha Shetty, J.:—

    This petition is directed against the order dated 16.9.1991, the copy of which has been produced as Annexure-D, passed by the second respondent confirming the order dated 22.7.1989, the copy of which has been produced as Annexure-C, passed by the third respondent declaring the sale of land measuring 3 acres 14 guntas in Survey No. 11 of Gummareddypura village, Srinivasapura Taluk, Kolar District, made by one Gopalappa in favour of the petitioner as null and void and further directing the petitioner to hand over possession of the said land to the said Gopalappa (deceased 4th respondent).

    2. The brief facts, which are relevant for the purpose of disposal of this petition, are these:

    Land measuring 2 acres in Survey No. 11 of Gummareddypura village, Srinivasapura Talik, Kolar District, was granted to the deceased 4th respondent - one Gopalappa, by means of order dated 21.9.1954 with a condition that the said land should not be alienated by the grantee for a period of 20 years from the date of the grant. Sub-rule (8) of Rule 43 of the Karnataka Land Revenue Rules, 1966 (hereinafter referred to as “the Rules”), which was framed by the State in exercise of its power under Section 233 of the Land Revenue Code, also prohibited the alienation of the land granted to the depressed class of persons for an upset price or reduced upset price for a period of 20 years from the date of the grant. Pursuant to the grant made in favour of the said Gopalappa, Saguvali Chit dated 11th September 1954 also was issued to the said Gopalappa putting him in possession of the said 2 acres of land. Saguvli Chit specifically provided that the land granted should not be alienated for a period of 20 years. Thereafter, on the recommendation made by the Divisional Commissioner, Bangalore Division, another extent of land measuring 1 acre 14 guntas comprised in Survey No. 11 of Gummareddypura village, was granted to the said Gopalappa at an upset price of Rs. 50/- per acre subject to recovery of back assessment from the year of the original grant made in favour of the said Gopalappa by the Government in exercise of the power vested in Rule 43, by means of the order dated 24.6.1966, the copy of which has been produced as Annexure-B. Since the major dispute in this petition revolves round the said 1 acre 14 guntas of land, which has been granted as per Annexure-B, it is useful to extract the said order, which reads thus:

    “Sanction is accorded to the confirmation of excess area of 1 acre 14 guntas of land over the valid grant of 2 acres of land granted out of S. No. 11 of Gummareddypura a village, Srinivasapura Taluk in favour of Sri A.K Gopalappa at an upset price of Rs. 50/- (Rupees Fifty only) per acre subject to recovery of back assessment from the year of original grant.

    The grant is made in relaxation of Rule 42 and in exercise of powers vested under Rule 43(L) of Land Revenue Rules.”

    Subsequently, by means of a registered Sale Deed dated 26.3.1967, the petitioner purchased the entire extent of 3 acres 14 guntas of land in the said Survey No. 11, which comprised of 2 acres of land originally granted to the deceased 4th respondent-Gopalappa by means of the grant order dated 21.9.1954 and the subsequent grant order dated 24.6.1966 On the application filed by the deceased 4th respondent, under Section 5(1) of the Act, the third respondent passed the order at Annexure-C, which came to be affirmed by the second respondent in the appeal filed by the petitioner.

    3. Sri B.T Parthasarthy, Learned Counsel appearing for the petitioner, fairly submitted that though the petitioner has challenged the orders to the entire extent of 3 acres 14 guntas, which was purchased by the petitioner by means of a registered Sale Deed dated 26.3.1967, having regard to the facts and circumstances of the case and with a view to give a quietus to the litigation, the petitioner would give up his challenge to the extent of 2 acres, which was granted to the said Gopalappa by means of the order dated 21.9.1954 and he has no objection for this Court confirming the orders impugned in so far as they relate to 2 acres of land in Survey No. 11. However, in so far as 1 acre 14 guntas of land which was granted to the said Gopalppa subsequently is concerned, he submitted that the orders impugned are without jurisdiction and liable to be set aside on that ground. According to him, the said extent of land was not sold by the original grantee in violation of either the terms of the grant or the law governing the grant and therefore the provisions of the Act cannot be made applicable in so far as the said 1 acre 14 guntas of land is concerned. It is his further submission that as can be seen from the order at Annexure-B, the land in question came to be granted to the grantee for an upset price of Rs. 50/- per acre by the State after relaxing Rule 42 of the Rules in exercise of the power vested under Rule 43-L of the Rules. According to the Learned Counsel, in respect of the land granted for an upset price, there was no provision made in the Rules which prohibited the alienation of the land within any particular period. In this connection, he drew my attention to sub-rule (4) of Rule 43-G of the Rules, which reads thus:

    “(4) Where the grant is made free of cost, or is made at a price which is less than the full market value, the grant shall be subject to the condition that the land shall not be alienated for a period of fifteen years form the date of the grantee taking possession of the land, after the grant.

    Provided…….”

    According to the Learned Counsel, it is only in the case where the grant was made free of cost or was made at a price which was less than the full market value, the grant made could be subject to a condition that the land should not be alienated for a period of 15 years from the date of the grantee taking possession of the land. He further submitted that since the land in question was granted for an upset price, the grant order at Annexure-B did not impose a condition on the grantee that the land should not be alienated for a period of 15 years. He further submitted that there is no Saguvali Chit issued to the petitioner as has been done in respect of the said 2 acres of land providing that the grantee should not alienate the land for a period of 15 years and that since the grant order (Annexure-B) specifically states that the grant was for an upset price of Rs. 50/-, it is not permissible to draw an inference that the grant was made for a reduced upset price. He referred to the definition of “upset price” provided under Sub-rule (2) of Rule 43, which reads thus:”

    “(2) The “Upset Price” shall not be arbitrarily fixed but shall represent the actual market value of the land, as nearly as it can be ascertained by local enquiries and by the examination of records of sales of similar lands in the neighbourhood, and if necessary, of the registration statistics relating to them.”

    He submitted that it is not permissible to draw an inference that the upset price fixed was not the market price as provided under Rule 43(2) of the Rules. Since the order (Annexure-B) clearly states that the land was granted on payment of upset price of Rs. 50/-, respondents 2 and 3 ought to have held that there is no violation of either the terms of the grant or the law governing the grant of the land in question. He further submitted that at any event of the matter, the orders impugned in so far as 1 acre 14 guntas of land is concerned, are liable to be quashed as both the Authorities have not assigned any reason in support of their finding that the land in question came to be sold in violation of either the terms of the grant or the law governing the grant. In other words, his submission is that the impugned orders are not speaking orders and that there is no application of mind by both the Authorities with regard to the claim of the petitioner in respect of 1 acre 14 guntas of land is concerned.

    4. Sri M. Siddagangaiah, learned High Court Government Pleader appearing for respondents 1 to 3, while was unable to controvert the submissions made by the Learned Counsel for the petitioner that the impugned orders are not speaking orders, tried to support the orders impugned on the ground that the upset price fixed is not the market price and it is only a reduced market price and this has to be inferred from the fact that the upset price fixed is only Rs. 50/- per acre. In support of his submission, he relied upon a Decision of this Court in Basappa v. Special Deputy Commissioner* . ILR 1991 KAR 1321. and also the Division Bench decision of this Court in Virupakashappa v. Hanumanthappa . ILR 1994 KAR 1270..

    5. Sri Jawahar Babu, Learned Counsel for supplemental respondents 4(a) to (f) - legal heirs of deceased respondent-4, adopted the submissions of the learned Government Pleader and submitted that there is no infirmity in the orders impugned. He further submitted that the land in question came to be granted to the said Gopalappa in view of the fact that he was in unauthorised occupation of the land in question even before the grant of the said land by means of the order Annexure-B. He also submitted that the upset price mentioned in the order Annexure-B was not the market value which was required to be fixed by the Authority as required under Rule 43(2) of the Rules. He further submitted that the grant of the land by means of the order Annexure-B must be construed as a grant made subject to the same terms and conditions, on which 2 acres of land was earlier granted. In support of his submissions, he also relied upon the decisions of this Court in Basappa's case (supra) and Virupakshappa's case (supra).

    6. Having regard to the contentions advanced by the parties, the only question, which arises for my consideration in this petition, is whether the land measuring 1 acre 14 guntas, which was granted to late Gopalappa, was granted for an upset price and if it is so, whether the said land came to be sold by the said Gopalappa in contravention of sub-rule (4) of Rule 43-G of the Rules.

    7. The order Annexure-B, extracted above, states that the land in question was granted at an upset price of Rs. 50/- per acre subject to the recovery of back assessment from the year of the original grant. Sub-rule (2) of Rule 43 of the Rules provides that the upset price shall not be arbitaraily fixed, but shall represent the actual market value of the land as nearly as it can be ascertained by local enquiries and by examination of records of sales or similar lands in the neighborhood and if necessary, of the registration statistics relating to them. In view of the mandate of Sub-rule (2) of Rule 43, it is not possible to infer and take the view that upset price fixed at Rs. 50/- is not the market value. As can be seen from the order (Annexure-B), the grant has been made on the basis of the recommendation made by the Divisional Commissioner. The Authorities, who are required to discharge their statutory duties, are expected to have discharged their duties in terms of the mandate of the law. Further, even if the upset price is fixed with reference to the market value, it is open to the State Government, which granted the land, to waive the upset price either totally or partly thereof inexercise of the power conferred on it under Rule 43-G of the Rules when the grant is made in favour of persons belonging to Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes and other applicants who are unable to pay occupancy price on account of poverty, upto Rs. 200/-. Though such power could have been exercised by the Government, the said power has not been exercised and upset price fixed has not been waived either in toto or any portion thereof while granting the land in question as per the order Annexure-B. If either the entire market price or a portion thereof has been waived, there would have been a reference to the same in the order Annexure-B. Therefore, I am of the view that the land in question came to be granted to land Gopalappa at an upset price of Rs. 50.

    8. No doubt, as rightly pointed out by Sri Siddagangaiah, who relied upon the decision in Virupakshappa's Case (supra), that though there is no condition provided in the grant order prohibiting the alienation of the land granted for a particular number of years, the provisions of the Rules can be read into the grant. Rule 43(G)(4) of the Rules, which government the grant, prohibits the alienation of the land in question by the grantee for a period of 15 years from the date of taking possession of the granted land, provided the grant was made free of cost or is made at a price which is less than the full market value. As stated earlier, unless the upset price fixed is waived off in full or in part, the provisions of sub-rule (4) of Rule 43-G cannot be attracted. I am of the view that the land in question was not sold in contravention of either the terms of the grant of the land in question or sub-rule (4) of Rule 43-G of the Rules. Therefore, the orders impugned passed by respondents 2 and 3 are liable to be quashed. In the decision in Basappa's Case (supra), this Court, while considering the stipulations in the grant order and the Saguvali Chit, wherein it was specifically provided that the grantee should not alienate the land for a period of 15 years from the date of the grant, took the view that upset price fixed was not the market price. The principle laid down in the said decision cannot be applied to the facts of this case in view of the specific observation made in the order (Annexure-B) stating that the land in question was granted on payment of upset price of Rs. 50 per acre. Even in Virupakshappa's case (supra) relied upon by the learned Counsel for the respondents, it is specifically observed that out of Rs. 500/- fixed as market price, a sum of Rs. 200/- was waived. Therefore, it is clear that in the said case, the land was granted for a reduced upset price. That is not the position in the present case.

    9. For the foregoing reasons, I make the following:

    10. The order dated 16.9.1991 (Annexure-D) passed by the second respondent and the order dated 22.7.1989 (Annexure-C) passed by the third respondent in so far as they relate to 2 acres of land in Survey No. 11 of Gummareddypura Village, Srinivasapura Taluk, Kolar District, which was granted to late Gopalappa by means of the order dated 21.9.1954, are confirmed. The said orders at Annexures-C and D in so far as they relate to 1 acre 14 guntas in the same Survey Number, which was granted to Gopalappa by means of the order (Annexure-B), are quashed.

    11. If either the deceased 4th respondent or the legal representatives of the deceased 4th respondent have not yet been put in possession of the said 2 acres of land in Survey No. 11, the third respondent is directed to put supplemental respondents 4(a) to (f) in possession of the said 2 acres of land as expeditiously as possible and at any event of the matter, not later than three months from the date of receipt of this order, after issuing notice both to the petitioner and respondents 4(a) to (f).

    12. Further, in the event of either deceased respondent-4 or supplemental respondents 4(a) to (f) have been put in possession of the entire extent of 3 acres 14 guntas of land in Survey No. 11, the third respondent is directed to put the petitioner in possession of 1 acre 14 guntas of land, which was granted to late Gopalappa by means of the order (Annexure-B), as expeditiously as possible and at any event of the matter, not later than three months from the date of receipt of this order. While identifying the 2 acres of land, in respect of which the orders at Annexures-C and D are confirmed, respondents 2 and 3 are directed to have due regard to the identification made by supplemental respondents 4(a) to (f).

    13. In terms stated above, this petition is disposed of.

    14. Sri M. Siddagangaiah, learned High Court Government Pleader, is permitted to file his memo of appearance within four weeks from to-day.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    G.N Vemareddy v. State Of Karnataka & Ors.
    (Aug 21, 1996)