Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The plaintiffs instituted a suit under Section 6 of the Specific Relief Act, 1963, seeking possession of premises bearing No. 1739 (New No. 93), Sayyaji Rao Road, Mysore, and damages for use and occupation. They claimed ownership and alleged wrongful dispossession by the defendant, who was carrying on a hosiery business on the foot-path in front of the suit shop. The defendant had allegedly obtained a temporary injunction and forcibly entered the shop, dispossessing the plaintiffs without their consent and otherwise than in due course of law. The defendant denied the plaintiffs' claims and asserted tenancy rights over the property. The trial court framed issues related to possession, damages, relief, and tenancy, and ultimately answered the issues in favor of the plaintiffs except the tenancy issue, which was negatived. The defendant filed a Revision Petition challenging the judgment and decree dated 9.12.1993 passed by the learned Second Additional Civil Judge, Mysore, in O.S No. 292/87.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a Revision Petition under Section 115 of the Code of Civil Procedure is maintainable against a judgment and decree passed in a suit under Section 6 of the Specific Relief Act, 1963?
  2. Whether the trial court erred in placing the burden of proof on the defendant contrary to the provisions of Section 6 of the Specific Relief Act?
  3. Whether the trial court had jurisdiction to grant damages in a suit filed solely for possession under Section 6 of the Specific Relief Act?
  4. Whether the trial court correctly framed and adjudicated issues relevant to possession and dispossession under Section 6 of the Act?

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner-Defendant's Arguments

  • The learned Civil Judge erred in placing the burden of proving the plaintiffs' case on the defendant, contrary to Section 6 of the Specific Relief Act.
  • The judgment and decree are without jurisdiction as they were based on findings unrelated to the possession and dispossession issues required under Section 6 of the Act.

Respondents-Plaintiffs' Arguments

  • Sub-section (4) of Section 6 of the Act bars revision petitions against judgments and decrees passed under Section 6, as no appeal or review is allowed under sub-section (3).
  • Any dissatisfied party has an alternate remedy by instituting a suit to establish title and recover possession, which is a more efficacious remedy, thereby precluding revision.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Gobind Ram Jamna Das v. Mst. Mewa, AIR 1953 Pepsu 188 Revision is maintainable where trial court fails to exercise jurisdiction under the analogous Section 9 of the old Specific Relief Act despite prohibition of appeal and review. The Court relied on this precedent to hold that prohibition of appeal and review under Section 6(3) of the Act does not ipso facto bar revision under Section 115 CPC.
Neyveli Lignite Corporation Ltd. v. K.S Narayana Iyer, AIR 1965 Madras 122 Revision can be entertained in exceptional circumstances despite availability of alternate remedies by suit under Section 9 of the old Act. The Court applied this principle to assert that revision is not absolutely barred under Section 6 of the Act and may be allowed in exceptional cases.
Sri Ramakrishna Suvarna v. Smt. Shashi Hengsu, 1988 3 KLJ 139 Revision petition entertained under Section 115 CPC against judgment and decree in suit under Section 6 of the Act. Used as supporting authority to confirm that revision petitions under Section 115 CPC are maintainable in suits under Section 6 of the Act.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court first addressed the maintainability of the Revision Petition under Section 115 CPC against a suit decided under Section 6 of the Specific Relief Act. It noted that while Section 6(3) bars appeal and review, it does not expressly prohibit revision, and the legislature’s silence on revision suggests it remains available in exceptional circumstances. The Court relied on analogous provisions under the old Act and relevant precedents to support this interpretation.

On the merits, the Court found that the trial court erred by disposing of the suit based on the additional issue concerning tenancy without independently considering the evidence on the plaintiffs' possession and dispossession, which are the core questions under Section 6 of the Act. The trial court also erred in awarding damages, a relief not contemplated under Section 6, which deals solely with possession and dispossession.

The Court emphasized that the issues framed by the trial court were inadequate. Proper issues should have focused on whether the plaintiffs were in possession, were dispossessed without consent otherwise than in due course of law, and whether the suit was instituted within six months of dispossession. The question of tenancy was immaterial in this context.

Accordingly, the Court set aside the judgment and decree and remitted the suit for fresh disposal after framing the correct issues and considering the evidence already adduced.

Holding and Implications

The Revision Petition is allowed.

The judgment and decree dated 9.12.1993 passed by the learned Second Additional Civil Judge, Mysore, in O.S No. 292/87 are set aside. The suit is remitted to the Court of first instance for fresh disposal on properly framed issues in accordance with Section 6 of the Specific Relief Act, 1963. The Court of first instance is directed to dispose of the suit on or before 31st October 1994.

This decision clarifies that revision under Section 115 CPC is maintainable against orders in suits under Section 6 of the Act despite the bar on appeal and review, particularly where jurisdictional errors occur. The ruling does not establish new precedent beyond the case facts but ensures correct procedural and substantive adjudication in possession suits under the Act.

    Mahboob Pasha v. Viswanatha Chetty

    Sadashiva, J.:—

    This Petition is listed for admission. With the consent of the learned Counsel appearing on both the sides, the Petition is heard on merits and disposed of by this order.

    2. The defendant in O.S No. 297/87 on the file of the learned Second Additional Civil Judge, Mysore, is the petitioner herein. He has called in question the judgment and decree dated 9.12.1993 passed by the learned Second Additional Civil Judge, Mysore, in O.S No. 292/87 instituted under Section 6 of the Specific Relief Act, 1963 (for short ‘the Act’).

    3. The plaintiffs-respondents instituted the suit against the petitioner for possession of the premises bearing No. 1739 (New No. 93), Sayyaji Rao Road, Mysore, and for damages for use and occupation of the same. It was contended by the plaintiffs that they are the owners of the suit property and they were in possession of the said property till they were dispossessed by the defendant without their consent, otherwise than in due course of law. It is the case of the plaintiffs that the defendant was carrying on the business in the sale of hosiery on the foot-path situated in front of the suit shop, and when the plaintiffs' father closed the business temporarily in the suit shop, the defendant sought permission of the plaintiffs' father to take electricity through a detachable electric connection from inside the suit premises to carry on the business during nights also and the father of the plaintiffs on humanitarian consideration allowed the defendant, the said facility. The plaintiffs further state that, after some time the defendant instituted a suit against them alleging that he is a tenant of the suit shop and obtained an order of temporary injunction; and that on the strength of the said injunction, he broke open the lock of the suit shop and entered the shop premises. Thus the defendant dispossessed the plaintiffs of the suit shop, without their consent, otherwise than in due course of law. The plaintiffs have, therefore, instituted the suit for possession of the suit shop under Section 6 of the Act.

    4. The defendant having entered appearance filed his written statement denying the case of the plaintiffs and contending that he has been a tenant in respect of the suit shop.

    5. On the basis of the aforesaid pleadings, the learned Civil Judge framed four issues including the additional issue and they read as follows:

    (1) Whether plaintiffs are entitled for possession of the suit schedule property?

    (2) Whether the plaintiffs are entitled for damages for loss of profits, for use and occupation at the rate of Rs. 10,000/- per month as claimed by them?

    (3) To what relief plaintiffs are entitled?

    The additional issue reads as under:

    Whether the defendant proves that he is the tenant in respect of the suit property as pleaded by him in his written statement?

    6. The learned Civil Judge, after recording the evidence has answered Issue Nos. 1 and 2 in the affirmative. However he postponed to grant decree for damages for being taken in final decree proceedings and answered the additional issue in the negative.

    7. Sri P. Shivanna, the learned Counsel appearing for the petitioner-defendant, would argue that the approach of the learned Civil Judge to the case is erroneous, as the learned Civil Judge has put the burden of proving the case of the plaintiffs on the defendant, contrary to the provisions of the Section 6 of the Act. In this context he read to me the relevant portion from the Judgment of the learned Civil Judge.

    8. Sri Yoganarasimha, the learned Counsel appearing for the respondents-plaintiffs, submits that in view of sub-section (4) of Section 6 of the Act, the revision is not maintainable. He, therefore, prays for rejection of the Revision Petition on the ground of maintainability.

    9. In view of the aforesaid contentions, it becomes necessary for me to decide first whether the Revision Petition is maintainable against the judgment and decree passed in a suit under Section 6 of the Act before considering the case on merits. Section 6 of the Act reads as follows:

    “6. (1) If any person is dispossessed without his consent of immoveable property otherwise than in due course of law, he or any person claiming through him may, by suit recover possession thereof, notwithstanding any other title that may be set up in such suit.

    (2) No suit under this section shall be brought.

    (i) after the expiry of six months from the date of dispossession; or

    (ii) Against the Government.

    (3) No appeal shall lie from any order or decree passed in any suit instituted under this section, nor shall any review of any such order or decree be allowed.

    (4) Nothing in this section shall bar any person from suing to establish his title to such property and to recover possession thereof.”

    Placing reliance on sub-sections (3) and (4) of the aforesaid provision, Sri Yoganarasimha, the learned Counsel for the respondents, submits that neither an appeal nor a review is allowed against the order or decree made in a suit filed under Section 6 of the Act. And, a right is given to any person to sue to establish his title to such property and recover possession thereof which has been ordered to be delivered to the suitor. The provision of sub-section (4) of Section 6 of the Act, according to Sri Yoganarasimha, the learned Counsel for respondents, provides for an alternate remedy to an unsuccessful party, by way of instituting a suit for declaration of title and for possession and such suit being more efficacious and effective, the Revision is avoided by necessary implication.

    10. I am unable to persuade myself to agree with the contention of Sri Yoganarasimha, the learned Counsel for the respondents. It is true that sub-section (3) of Section 6 of the Act prohibits the appeal as well as the review against the order or decree made in the suit filed under Section 6 of the Act. It is further true that a right is given particularly to the unsuccessful party in the suit for instituting a suit for declaration of his title and for possession, as the suit instituted under Section 6 of the Act would not necessarily deal with the title but deals only with possession of the plaintiff of the immoveable property and his dispossession therefrom without his consent. This does not mean that a Revision under Section 115 C.P.C is prohibited where the order or decree is made in violation of Section 6 of the Act.

    11. Section 9 of the Specific Relief Act, 1977 (for short the ‘old Act’) is a provision analogous to Section 6 of the Act. Dealing with Section 9 of the old Act, the High Court of Pepsu in the case of Gobind Ram Jamna Das v. Mst. Mewa . AIR 1953 Pepsu 188. has held as follows:

    “5. The learned counsel for the respondents urges that this Court is not competent to interfere in revision. I see no force in his contention. In this case the trial Court dismissed the suit on the ground that the plaintiff not being in possession was not competent to institute the suit. If the plaintiff is entitled, as he is in my opinion to institute such a suit under Section 9 of the Act, the finding of the trial Court to the contrary deprives him of his right, to relief provided by Section 9 of the Act and the trial Court thus failed to exercise jurisdiction which it ought to have exercised. This Court, therefore, is competent to interfere in such circumstances. Section 9 itself shuts out the remedy by way of appeal or review. If the intention of the legislature was to shut out a remedy by way of revision also it could have been similarly and specifically mentioned.”

    In Neyveli Lignite Corporation Ltd. v. K.S Narayana Iyer . AIR 1965 Madras 122. dealing with the scope of Section 9 of the old Act, the High Court of Madras has held as follows:

    “22. The only other question that remains for consideration is whether this Court can under its powers of revision, interfere with the decree passed in the present case. Normally where an alternative remedy by way of suit is available, this court seldom interfere in revision, but in the present case, if that course were to be adopted it would mean that the respondent who has no title to the property at all, should be allowed to go back and to squat on the property and be there so long as he is capable of delaying any suit that might be filed by the Corporation to evict him. We therefore consider that in the interests of justice this civil revision petition should be entertained.”

    This Court in Sri Ramakrishna Suvarna v. Smt. Shashi Hengsu . 1988 3 KLJ 139., though not expressed any opinion as to the maintainability of the Revision Petition, has however entertained a Revision Petition under Section 115 C.P.C against the judgment and decree passed in a suit filed under Section 6 of the Act.

    12. In view of the aforesaid Rulings, it is clear that, though a Revision Petition under Section 115 is seldom allowed where an alternate remedy by way of suit is available, in exceptional circumstances, depending upon the facts and circumstances of each case, this Court is not prohibited from entertaining a Revision Petition under Section 115 C.P.C Hence it is not possible to hold that this Revision Petition is not maintainable.

    13. Now, coming to the merits of the case, the judgment and decree is contrary to Section 6 of the Act and therefore it is without jurisdiction. It is seen from the judgment that the learned Civil Judge has disposed of the suit on the basis of the finding recorded on the additional issue without considering the evidence independently as regards Issue No. 1. The judgment and decree made without considering the evidence with respect to Issue No. 1 answering the said issue in the affirmative, on the basis of the finding on additional issue is without jurisdiction. The learned Civil Judge has further erred in answering Issue No. 2 in the affirmative, even though the Court has no jurisdiction to grant any decree for damages, in a suit for possession under Section 6 of the Act.

    14. Where a suit is filed for possession under Section 6 of the Act, what is required to be decided by the Court is the factum of possession of the plaintiffs of the suit property and their dispossession therefrom without his consent otherwise than in due course of law, and the institution of suit for possession within 6 months thereof. Section 6 does not require the Court to decide any question either as to the title of the parties to the suit property or as to any other right of I any party with respect to the suit property.

    15. It is seen from the judgment that the learned Judge has failed to frame and record proper issues even though the parties have led evidence on the question of possession and dispossession. The first issue, according to my considered opinion is not adequate for the purpose of adjudicating the real question in controversy in the suit. The issues should have been whether the plaintiffs prove that they were in possession of the suit shop and they have been dispossessed without their consent therefrom otherwise than in due course of law by the defendant and whether the suit has been instituted within 6 months from the date of dispossession. The question whether the defendant was a tenant or not is immaterial for the purpose of adjudicating the dispute in a suit filed under Section 6 of the Act. In case the plaintiffs fail to prove their possession and dispossession, the suit shall fail. No other points are required to be enquired into by the Court.

    16. The learned Civil Judge instead of recording a finding as to the possession of the plaintiffs of the suit property and their dispossession without their consent therefrom otherwise than in due course of law, has proceeded to dispose of the suit on the basis of his finding on additional issue. The additional issue relates to the relationship of tenant and landlord between the defendant and plaintiffs and the failure to prove the said issue by the defendant, would not enable the plaintiffs to get a decree under Section 6 of the Act, in the absence of any finding on Issue No. 1. This is what exactly has been done in this case by the learned Civil Judge. The judgment and decree is therefore without jurisdiction.

    17. In these circumstances, I think it is just and proper to frame necessary issues in the case and to remit the same to the Court of the first instance for fresh disposal in accordance with Section 6 of the Act. Accordingly I frame the following issues:

    (i) Whether the plaintiffs prove that they were in possession of the suit property and they have been dispossessed without their consent? and

    (ii) Whether the plaintiffs prove that the suit is instituted within 6 months from the date of their wrongful dispossession?

    As the parties have already adduced evidence on these issues, I do not think that it is necessary for the Court to receive any additional evidence. In view of the aforesaid issues being framed, the issues framed by the learned Judge as indicated in his judgment would not survive for consideration.

    18. In the result, I pass the following order-

    (i) The Revision Petition is allowed.

    (ii) The judgment and decree dated 9.12.1993 passed by the learned II Additional Civil Judge, Mysore, in O.S No. 292/87 is set aside.

    (iii) The suit is remitted to the Court of first instance for disposal afresh in terms as stated above. The learned Civil Judge is directed to dispose of the suit on or before 31st October 1994.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Mahboob Pasha v. Viswanatha Chetty
    (Jul 12, 1994)