Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Order IX Rule 9 read with Section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • SECTION 36 WEST BENGAL PREMISES TENANCY ACT 1956
  • WEST BENGAL PREMISES TENANCY ACT
  • provisions of West Bengal Premisses Tenancy Act, 1956.A
  • Rule 10 of Order VIII of the Code of Civil Procedure,
  • Rule 5(2) and Rule 10 of Order 8
  • sub-section (3) of Section 17
  • Rule 9 of Order VIII CPC.5.
  • Rule 10 of Order VIII CPC
  • Order VIII Rule 10 CPC
  • Rule 10 of Order VIII
  • Rule 1 or Rule 9
  • sub-rule (3).
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Order IX Rule 9 read with Section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • SECTION 36 WEST BENGAL PREMISES TENANCY ACT 1956
  • WEST BENGAL PREMISES TENANCY ACT
  • provisions of West Bengal Premisses Tenancy Act, 1956.A
  • Rule 10 of Order VIII of the Code of Civil Procedure,
  • Rule 5(2) and Rule 10 of Order 8
  • sub-section (3) of Section 17
  • Rule 9 of Order VIII CPC.5.
  • Rule 10 of Order VIII CPC
  • Order VIII Rule 10 CPC
  • Rule 10 of Order VIII
  • Rule 1 or Rule 9
  • sub-rule (3).
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

This is a defendant's appeal against the Judgment and decree dated 30-6-1988 in Original Suit No. 22 of 1987 on the file of the Civil Judge, Gadag. The Judgment of the Court was delivered by Chandrakantaraj Urs, J.

The undisputed facts as set out in the judgment under appeal are:

  • The plaintiff filed a suit for declaration of title and possession of the suit land.
  • The defendant was served with notices and entered appearance through counsel on 7-8-1987.
  • The suit was adjourned on 7-9-1987, 9-10-1987, 9-11-1987 and 4-12-1987 for the purpose of filing the written statement.
  • On 4-12-1987, the defendant's counsel retired; a new counsel appeared and sought further time; the case was adjourned to 22-1-1988.
  • On 22-1-1988 no written statement had been filed and that fact was recorded in the order sheet.
  • The case was then adjourned for evidence on various dates (12-2-1988, 26-2-1988, 17-6-1988 and 29-6-1988).
  • On 29-6-1988, the plaintiff's counsel induced the Court to proceed to pass Judgment and decree in favour of the plaintiff in terms of Order VIII Rule 10 CPC because no written statement had been filed; arguments were heard and the suit was posted for Judgment on 13-6-1988; Judgment and decree were pronounced on 30-6-1988.
  • Before Judgment (and after it was reserved), the defendant's counsel filed an application under Order IX Rule 9 read with Section 151 CPC to set aside the order “W.S not filed” recorded on 22-1-1988; that application was dismissed at trial as the plaintiff's counsel relied on the Supreme Court ruling in Arjunasingh v. Mahendra Kumar AIR 1964 SC 993.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the trial Court was correct in proceeding to pass Judgment and decree without proof of the plaint allegations, i.e., without recording any evidence for the plaintiff and without receiving or proving documents filed with the plaint in accordance with the procedure for receipt of evidence by Civil Courts during the trial.
  2. Whether Rule 10 of Order VIII CPC permits a suit to be decreed merely because the defendant failed to file a written statement, even when the plaintiff's case has not been proved by evidence.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • Mr. Adi, learned Counsel for the appellant, contended that nothing in the language of Rule 10 of Order VIII suggests that a suit may be decreed without proof of the plaint allegations.
  • He relied upon certain decisions of the Supreme Court to support the contention that the plaintiff must still prove his case even if the defendant fails to file a written statement.

Respondent / Plaintiff's Arguments

  • The opinion states that the plaintiff's counsel placed reliance on the ruling of the Supreme Court in Arjunasingh v. Mahendra Kumar AIR 1964 SC 993 when opposing the application to set aside the record that the written statement was not filed.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court in This Case
Arjunasingh v. Mahendra Kumar, AIR 1964 SC 993 Authority relied upon by the plaintiff's counsel at trial to resist the defendant's application to set aside the record that no written statement had been filed. The trial Court's application to set aside the "W.S. not filed" entry was dismissed at trial because the plaintiff's counsel relied on this ruling. The appellate court records this fact but does not treat that reliance as finally dispositive of the necessity of proof of the plaint.
State of Karnataka v. Hemraj Achalchand, ILR 1985 KAR 951 Interpretation of 'Judgment' under Order VIII (Rule 5(2) and Rule 10) and the requirement that the court must apply its mind and manifest that application on the record when decreeing a suit where the defendant has not filed a pleading. The Court cited this decision for the proposition that a 'Judgment' must manifest application of mind and must disclose that the Judge has considered whether, assuming the plaint facts are admitted, the plaintiff is entitled to the relief. The appellate bench relied on the requirement of application of mind as a minimal essential.
Modula India v. Kamakshya Singh Deo, 1988 4 SCC 619 General principle that a plaintiff must prove his case even where no defendant appears; the defendant should ordinarily be permitted to cross-examine the plaintiff's witnesses and address arguments, subject to safeguards and limitations. The Court followed and applied the principles articulated in this Supreme Court decision to conclude that the plaintiff must prove his case and that the defendant should be permitted to cross-examine the plaintiff's witnesses subject to limitations. On that basis the appellate Court set aside the Judgment and decree and remitted the matter for further proceedings.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court's analysis proceeded in these principal steps, drawn from the text of the opinion:

  1. The Court extracted and reproduced Rule 10 of Order VIII CPC, which states that where a party from whom a written statement is required fails to present it within the time permitted, "the Court shall pronounce Judgment against him, or make such order in relation to the suit as it thinks fit, and on the pronouncement of such Judgment, a decree shall be drawn up."
  2. The Court observed that the 1976 amendment clarified that the Court is empowered to pronounce a decree on the date the defendant fails to perform the act required (i.e., file a written defence). However, the Court stated that "beyond that, it does not make any other change."
  3. The Court considered the Division Bench decision in State of Karnataka v. Hemraj Achalchand, which emphasized that the term 'Judgment' requires manifestation of the Judge's application of mind and that the Court must disclose that it has considered whether, if plaint facts are taken to be admitted, the plaintiff is entitled to relief. The appellate bench observed that the requirement of application of mind is a "minimal essential."
  4. On the basis of the language of Rule 10 and the authorities, the Court held that nothing in Rule 10 does away with the requirement that the plaint allegations must be proved even when there is implied admission by non-denial, where the defendant is placed ex parte, or where the defendant has not filed pleadings within the prescribed time.
  5. The Court then examined the Supreme Court decision in Modula India v. Kamakshya Singh Deo. The appellate Court quoted the Supreme Court's conclusion that "where a plaintiff comes to the Court he must prove his case" and that completely eliminating the assistance of a defendant would handicap the Court in discovering the truth. The Supreme Court in that case permitted the defendant, in appropriate circumstances, to cross-examine the plaintiff's witnesses and address arguments subject to safeguards and limitations.
  6. Applying these principles, the appellate Court concluded that the Judgment and decree under appeal were liable to be set aside. The matter was to be remitted to the trial Court to proceed from the stage at which it recorded that the written statement had not been filed. The trial Court was directed to examine the plaintiff or his witnesses in support of the plaint allegations and to permit the defendant to cross-examine such witnesses in light of the Supreme Court decision, subject to the limitations on scope of cross-examination.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The appeal is allowed to the extent indicated: the Judgment and decree under appeal are set aside and the matter is remitted to the trial Court with directions to proceed as stated.

Direct effect on the parties:

  • The trial Court's decree in favour of the plaintiff dated 30-6-1988 is set aside.
  • The matter is remitted to the trial Court to proceed from the stage where it recorded that the written statement was not filed.
  • The trial Court is directed to examine the plaintiff or his witnesses in support of the plaint allegations and, if the defendant desires, to permit the defendant to cross-examine those witnesses in accordance with the limitations and safeguards explained by the Supreme Court in the cited authority (Modula India v. Kamakshya Singh Deo).

Broader implications:

The opinion applies existing principles from authoritative decisions to the facts of the case and directs a remand for proof of the plaint and regulated cross-examination. The opinion does not state that it is creating a new rule of law beyond applying the precedents it discusses; its direct consequence is the remittal and directions for further trial proceedings.

Order accordingly.

    Mallayya v. Totayya

    The Judgment of the Court was delivered by

    Chandrakantaraj Urs, J.:— This is a defendant's appeal against the Judgment and decree dated 30-6-1988 in Original Suit No. 22 of 1987 on the file of the Civil Judge, Gadag.

    2. The undisputed facts, which are set out in the course of the Judgment under appeal may be stated briefly and they are as follows:

    In the course of this Judgment, we will refer to the parties by the ranks assigned to them in the trial Court.

    The plaintiff filed a suit for declaration of title and possession of suit land. The suit was registered and defendant was served with notices. He entered appearance through Counsel on 7-8-1987. On 7-9-1987, 9-10-1987, 9-11-1987 and 4-12-1987 the suit was adjourned for the purpose of filing written statement. But on 4-12-1987 Counsel for defendant retired from the case and a new Counsel appeared for the defendant and sought further time to file the written statement. The case was adjourned to 22-1-1988. On 22-1-1988, no written statement was filed and that fact was recorded in the order sheet. Thereafterwards, the case was adjourned for evidence. On 12-2-1988, 26-2-1988, 17-6-1988 and 29-6-1988 presumably the case was adjourned for the evidence of the plaintiff. However, on the last mentioned date, the Counsel for the plaintiff appears to have induced the Court to proceed to pass Judgment and decree in favour of the plaintiff in terms of Order VIII Rule 10 CPC as no written statement had been filed. Arguments were heard and the suit was posted for Judgment on 13-6-1988. It was before Judgment and after it was reserved for Judgment, the defendant's Counsel filed an application under Order IX Rule 9 read with Section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure to set aside the order “W.S not filed” recorded on 22-1-1988. But that application came to be dismissed as the plaintiff's Counsel placed reliance on the ruling of the Supreme Court in the case of Arjunasingh v. Mahendra Kumar . AIR 1964 SC 993.. Therefore, the Judgment was pronounced decreeing the suit on 30-6-1988.

    3. Mr. Adi, learned Counsel for the appellant, before us contends that nothing in the language of Rule 10 of Order VIII is suggestive that a suit may be decreed without proof of the plaint allegations. He has relied upon certain decisions of the Supreme Court to support that contention. Therefore, the only question that falls for our determination in this appeal is whether the trial Court was correct in proceeding to pass the Judgment and decree without proof of plaint allegations i.e, without recording any evidence for the plaintiff, but acting on the documents filed along with the plaint, without proof of those documents, without those documents being received in evidence in accordance with the procedure laid down for receipt of evidence by Civil Courts during or in the course of trial?

    4. Before examining the decided cases of the Supreme Court relied upon by Mr. Adi, it would be useful to extract Rule 10 of Order VIII of the Code of Civil Procedure, which is as follows:

    VIII. 10. Procedure when party fails to present written statement called for by Court:— Where any party from whom a written statement is required under Rule 1 or Rule 9 fails to present the same within the time permitted or fixed by the Court, as the case may be, the Court shall pronounce Judgment against him, or make such order in relation to the suit as it thinks fit, and on the pronouncement of such Judgment, a decree shall be drawn up.

    The language employed after the 1976 amendment clearly demonstrates that the old law that in a suit in which summons to the defendant was issued only for settlement of issues and the Court could not, in the absence of the appearance of the defendant or contest by defendant, proceed to pass Judgment on the very date indicated in the summons for appearance, has been put an end to and the Court is empowered to proceed to pass a decree on the very date on which the defendant falls to perform an act, which is required to be performed i.e, enter his defence in writing. Beyond that, it does not make any other change, in our view.

    This question fell for consideration before a Division Bench of this Court in the case of State of Karnataka v. Hemraj Achalchand . ILR 1985 KAR 951.. In the said case, the defendant State of Karnataka failed to appear on the date that was set down for settlement of issues, namely, 17-1-1974. In that position, the Court proceeded to note the following in the order sheet.

    “Defendant absent. Placed ex parte. Suit decreed as prayed for.”

    On appeal, a Division Bench of this Court speaking through Venkatachallah, J., as he then was in this Court (now a Judge of the Supreme Court) expressed himself for the Bench in the following manner:

    “The expression ‘Judgment’ in Rule 5(2) and Rule 10 of Order 8 has the same connection as it has in its definition in Section 2(9) CPC. A ‘Judgment’ means ‘the statement given by the Judge of the grounds of a decree or order.’ The power of the Court to require any fact, which must otherwise be taken to have been admitted by non-traverse to be proved otherwise than by such deemed admission, itself implies and carries with it the need for an application of the mind to all circumstances relevant to the issue including the one referred to in sub-rule (3). Such application of the mind must be manifest from the record of the proceedings. It may, indeed, happen in a conceivable case that if all the facts contained in the plaint are taken to be admitted even then, the plaintiff may not be entitled, in law, to the relief he claims. The Court must apply its mind and make it manifest that it has done so.

    4. The Court need not write an elaborate Judgment. There can, in the very nature of things, be no hard and fast rule, valid for all occasions, prescribing what document, to be eligible to be called a ‘Judgment’ in cases where defendant does not file a pleading and where the Court proceeds to pronounce a ‘Judgment’ on the basis of facts contained in the plaint, must contain. It must necessarily depend on the facts and circumstances of each case. However, there are certain minimal essentials inherent in the idea of a ‘Judgment’ as defined in Section 2(9) CPC. This much at least, it must disclose: that Judge has applied his mind to the nature of the suit-claim and to the aspect whether, it the facts contained in the plaint are taken to be admitted, the suit-claim is entitled to succeed. This is apart from cases where, in the circumstances, a Judge feels the need to call for proof of facts independently of the admission by non-traverse.”

    (Emphasis supplied)

    and allowed the appeal for want of application of mind by the Court below.

    While we certainly cannot disagree with the conclusions reached by the learned Judges, we have no doubt that nothing in the language employed in Rule 10 of Order VIII CPC does away with the requirements of proof of the plaint allegations despite implied admission by non-denial either while expressly traversing the plaint allegations or where the defendant is placed ex parte or where the defendant has not filed pleadings within the prescribed time in terms of Rule 9 of Order VIII CPC.

    5. The Supreme Court had occasion to consider the same question in the case of Modula India v. Kamakshya Singh Deo . 1988 4 SCC 619. In the said case, the provisions of West Bengal Premises Tenancy Act, 1956 fell for consideration. The questions formulated by the Hon'ble Supreme Court itself was such, which called for the examination of nature and scope of the rights available to a defendant, whose defence had been struck off in the context of certain provisions of West Bengal Premisses Tenancy Act, 1956.

    A Full Bench of the Calcutta High Court by a majority of two to one had taken the view that the defendant in a suit for eviction cannot have the right of cross-examination excepting on the point of notice under Section 36 of the West Bengal Premises Tenancy Act, 1956 when defence had beer struck out under sub-section (3) of Section 17 of the said Act. We may briefly state the said sub-section (3) of Section 17 did no more than deny the right of defence to the tenant, who was in arrears of rent. After exhaustively discussing the provisions of the said West Bengal Premises Tenancy Act and earlier cases of the Supreme Court and the High Court of Calcutta on the subject, the Supreme Court observed as follows:

    “12 …………

    (d) …………

    We have considered the contentions urged on behalf of both the parties and the respective view points of the two lines of decisions of the High Court. We have also perused the decisions of this Court to which reference has been made. Though none of them is a direct decision on the issue before us, the observations made, in so far as they enunciate general principles and relate to analogous statutory provisions are most helpful and instructive. After giving careful thought to all the aspects, we have come to the conclusion that the view expressed in the case under appeal by Ramendra Mohan Dutta, Acting Chief Justice, is preferable to the view taken by the other two learned Judges. It is a more liberal and equitable view and also one consistent with the requirements of justice in such cases. We proceed now to set out the reasons for our conclusion.

    To us it appears that the basic principles that where a plaintiff comes to the Court he must prove his case should not be whittled down even in a case where no defendant appears. It will at once be clear that to say that the Court can only do this by looking the plaintiff's evidence and pleadings supplemented by such question as the Court may consider necessary and to completely eliminate any type of assistance from the defendant in this task will place the Court under a great handicap in discovering the truth or otherwise of the plaintiff's statements. For after all, the Court on its own motion, can do very little to ascertain the truth or otherwise of the plaintiff's averments and it is only the opposite party that will be more familiar with the detailed facts of a particular case and that can assist the Court in pointing out defects, weaknesses, errors and inconsistencies of the plaintiff's case.

    We, therefore, think that the defendant should be allowed his right of cross-examination and arguments. But we are equally clear that this right should be subject to certain important safeguards.

    For the above reasons, we agree with the view of Ramendra Mohan Datta, A.C.J, that even in a case where the defence against delivery of possession of a tenant is struck off under Section 17(4) of the Act, the defendant, subject to the exercise of an appropriate discretion by the Court on the facts of a particular case, would generally be entitled.

    (a) to cross-examine the plaintiff's witnesses, and

    (b) to address argument on the basis of the plaintiff's case.

    We would like to make it clear that the defendant would not be entitled to lead any evidence of his own nor can his cross-examination be permitted to travel beyond the very limited objective of pointing out the falsity or weaknesses of the plaintiff's case. In no circumstances, should the cross-examination be permitted to travel beyond this legitimate scope and to convert itself virtually into a presentation of the defendant's case either directly or in the form of suggestions put to the plaintiff's witnesses.

    (Emphasis supplied by us)

    Therefore, on the facts of the present case, we should have no hesitation to come to the conclusion that the Judgment and decree under appeal are liable to be set aside and the matter remitted to the trial Court to be proceeded further from the stage at which it recorded that written statement was not filed, in accordance with law.

    6. In the result, the appeal is allowed to the extent indicated above. The matter is remitted with a direction that the trial Court should proceed to examine the plaintiff or his witnesses in support of the plaint allegations and if the defendant desires to cross-examine that witness, he shall be permitted to do so in the light of the decision of the Supreme Court relied upon by us and subject to the limitations imposed by the Supreme Court on the scope of cross-examination.

    Order accordingly.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Mallayya v. Totayya
    (Jan 30, 1989)