AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 11(2) of BSF Act 1968 read with Rule 177 of BSF Rule 1969,
  • Civil Procedure Code in this regard. Order-5 Rule 17 of the CPC
  • BSF Act and Rules. Under Section 48 of the BSF Act,
  • Section of Government Medical College, Jammu
  • section 62 sub clause-2 of the BSF Act 1968.
  • sub Rule 11(2) of Rule 177 of the BSF Rules,
  • section 62 of the BSF Act 1968
  • Sub section (2) of section 11,
  • Rule 22 of the BSF Rules.
  • sub-rule (2)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 11(2) of BSF Act 1968 read with Rule 177 of BSF Rule 1969,
  • Civil Procedure Code in this regard. Order-5 Rule 17 of the CPC
  • BSF Act and Rules. Under Section 48 of the BSF Act,
  • Section of Government Medical College, Jammu
  • section 62 sub clause-2 of the BSF Act 1968.
  • sub Rule 11(2) of Rule 177 of the BSF Rules,
  • section 62 of the BSF Act 1968
  • Sub section (2) of section 11,
  • Rule 22 of the BSF Rules.
  • sub-rule (2)
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner challenged an order dated 31 January 2001 which dismissed him from service. The dismissal order stated that the petitioner (No. 831030028 HC Mohinder Singh, 'C' coy) had been overstaying without leave with effect from 1 November 1999, that show cause notices had been issued (including by letter dated 1 January 2001), and that dismissal was imposed under Section 11(2) of the BSF Act 1968 read with Rule 177 of the BSF Rules, 1969 because trial in the BSF Court was not possible in his absence. The period 1 November 1999 to 31 January 2001 was treated as “Dies Non” and the petitioner was struck off the unit’s strength effective 31 January 2001 (AN).

A Court of Inquiry under section 62 of the BSF Act was constituted on 7 December 1999 and completed on 30 December 1999. The petitioner did not participate in the inquiry, citing inability to join because of pain in his left leg, and did not present himself for examination at the Base Hospital despite being asked to do so. The petitioner had attended OPD/Physiotherapy at the Government Medical College, Jammu from 9–12–1999 to 20–12–1999. After failing to procure his presence, he was declared a deserter under section 62(2).

A show cause notice dated 1 January 2001 was sent by registered post to an address given in the record (House No. 642, Gandhi Nagar / House No. 642-A, P.O. Gandhi Nagar, District Jammu). The registered envelope was returned with an endorsement that the addressee had left his residence without address. The petitioner did not reply to the show cause notice, and the dismissal order was passed. The petitioner appealed to the Director General, BSF, and also filed the present writ petition before the appeal outcome was known.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the show cause notice was served on the petitioner in compliance with Rule 22 of the BSF Rules.
  2. Whether a Court of Inquiry in accordance with section 62 of the BSF Act was held in the present case.
  3. Whether the petitioner had provided sufficient cause for overstaying leave and whether that cause was considered by the respondents.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner’s Arguments

  • The show cause notice was not served on him as required under Rule 22 of the BSF Rules; the notice was sent to an address (House No. 642) where he was no longer residing because that house stood in his brother’s name and had been sold on 9 May 2000.
  • Because the notice was not served at his then-current address, in law it must be presumed that no show cause notice was served and therefore the dismissal violates Rule 22.
  • The petitioner also contended he had given sufficient cause for overstaying, which respondents did not take into account (this is listed among his grievances in the petition).

Respondents’ Contentions

  • The respondents relied on the address given by the petitioner at the time of joining service and served the notice at that address; the petitioner did not inform them of any change of address.
  • The respondents explained available procedural modes of imposing penalties under the BSF Act and Rules:
    • Under Section 48 (trial by Security Force Court) punishment including dismissal may be awarded;
    • Under Section 53 a Commandant may award minor punishment;
    • Under Section 11 (administrative action) a person may be dismissed or removed from service administratively;
    • Section 62 provides for a Court of Inquiry when a person is absent without authority for 30 days and a declaration of absence/desertion may follow.
  • They asserted they had followed procedure by issuing the show cause notice by registered post to the official address and, after the registered post was returned unclaimed (addressee left without address), they proceeded to pass the removal order since the addressee was not traceable.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court reviewed the procedural facts and statutory framework and proceeded as follows:

  1. Statutory and rule framework:
    • Rule 22 of the BSF Rules requires that when it is proposed to terminate service of a person (other than an officer) the person shall be given an opportunity to show cause in the manner specified; exceptions exist where trial/notice is impracticable but for reasons to be recorded in writing.
    • Section 62 of the BSF Act prescribes constitution of a Court of Inquiry where a person remains absent without authority for 30 days, and sub-clause (2) allows declaration of deserter if the person does not surrender or is not apprehended.
    • Sub-section (2) of Section 11 of the BSF Act and sub-rule 11(2) of Rule 177 empower the Commandant to dismiss or remove persons and prescribe that procedure under Rule 22 should be followed before dismissal.
  2. On the facts, the court accepted that the registered post containing the show cause notice was sent to the address on record and that the registered envelope was returned with an endorsement that the addressee had left without address. The court found that the show cause notice was not actually served on the petitioner.
  3. The court noted that the BSF Act/Rules do not specify a mode of substituted service in such circumstances, and therefore guidance from the Civil Procedure Code (Order 5 Rule 17 CPC) is relevant: if a defendant cannot be found, the copy of notice must be affixed to some conspicuous part of the house in which the defendant ordinarily resides. The respondents had not adopted that procedure.
  4. The court considered that although the petitioner had some responsibility to inform the respondents of any change of address, that did not absolve the respondents from making reasonable efforts to ascertain or effect service (for example by affixing notice or attempting other measures). The respondents made no attempt to locate a new address.
  5. Because no effective service of the show cause notice was proved, Rule 22 was not complied with in substance. This non-compliance deprived the petitioner of an opportunity to reply to the show cause notice before the dismissal order was passed.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The court concluded that there had not been sufficient compliance with Rule 22 of the BSF Rules and therefore allowed the writ petition.

DISPOSITION: The impugned order dated 31 January 2001 (dismissing the petitioner) was quashed. The respondents were directed to serve a fresh show cause notice on the address to be provided by the petitioner and, after hearing him, to proceed in the matter.

Implications: The direct effect is to set aside the dismissal order and to require the respondents to give the petitioner a fresh opportunity to be heard by serving a fresh show cause notice at an address provided by him and then proceeding after hearing. The opinion does not state or purport to establish a broader binding precedent; it addresses compliance with the procedural requirements of Rule 22 in the circumstances of this case.

    Mohinder Singh Petitioner v. Union Of India & Ors S

    JUDGMENT

    The petitioner has called in question order dated 31-1-2001 removing him from service. For facility of reference the said order is quoted below:

    “I have personally gone through the case of overstayal against No. 831030028 HC Mohinder Singh ‘C’ coy of this unit who is overstaying himself without leave with effect from 01.11.1999 He was giving an opportunity through show cause Notice vide this office letter No. Ett/71.Bn/SCN/2000/2126-28 dated 07.9.2000 and No. Estt/71 Bn/SCN/2k/01 dated 01.1.2001 which he has not availed of. I am satisfied that he is overstaying himself without any reasonable cause and that his further retention in service is not desirable. I, therefore, dismiss him from service with effect from 31st Jan’ 2001 (AN) in terms of Section 11(2) of BSF Act 1968 read with Rule 177 of BSF Rule 1969, since it was not possible to try in BSF Court to his absence.

    2. The period of absence of the U.O w.e.f 01.11.99 to 31.1.2001 is hereby treated as “Dies Non” for all purpose.

    3. He is struck off strength of this unit with effect from 31st Jan’ 2001 (AN).”

    The order of dismissal dated 31.1.2001 was preceded by a show notice which was issued on 1.1.2001 The extracts of show cause notice are also quoted hereinbelow:

    “Sub: SHOW CAUSE NOTICE”

    You have been overstaying from leave w.e.f Ist Nov’ 99 (FN). After considering the reports relating to your overstayal from leave. I am satisfied that your trial by a Security.

    Force Court is impracticable but am of the opinion that your further retention in service is undesirable. I, therefore, tentatively purpose to dismiss you from the service. If you have anything to urge in your defence against the imposition of the proposed penalty, you may do so within 30 days of the receipt of this letter or by 30 Jan 2001, whichever is earlier. In case no reply is received within the stipulated period, it would be presumed that you have no defence to put forward and exparte decision will be taken into matter.”

    This show cause notice is stated to have been served upon petitioner by registered post on the following address:

    “Mohinder Singh,

    House No. 642-A, P.O Gandhi Ngr.

    District Jammu(J&K)”

    On petitioner's failure to submit reply to the show cause notice, the order of his removal from service was passed.

    The grievance of the petitioner in the writ petition are :

    a) that show cause notice has not been served to him as required under Rule-22 of the BSF Rules.

    b) that no Court of Inquiry in accordance with section 62 of the BSF Act has been held in the present case.

    c) that petitioner had given sufficient cause for having over stayed, which was not taken into account by the respondents.

    The petitioner proceeded on 15 days casual leave with effect from 11-10-1999 to 30-10-1999 and was required to resume his duty on Ist November, 1999. The petitioner did not join his duty and overstayed his leave. He was directed to resume his duty vide following 71 BN BSF registered letters :

    i) Estt/71 Bn/OSL/99/1211 dated 4-11-99.

    ii) Estt/71 Bn/OSL/99/1235 dated 18-11-99

    iii) Estt/71 Bn/OSL/99/1297 dated 7-12-99

    After 30 days of absence of the petitioner, Court of Inquiry under section 62 of the BSF Act 1968 was constituted vide 71 BN BSF Order No. Estt/71.BN/COI/99/26513-15 dated 7-12-1999 and the same was completed by the Presiding Officer on 30-12-1999. The petitioner has shown his inability to join the enquiry because of pain in his left leg. He was informed by the respondents that he can come to Base Hospital, Jammu for treatment since he is located in Jammu town. The petitioner did not response to this also. It is also found on fact that petitioner has shown his inability to get himself examined at the Base Hospital, Jammu while he had been attending the OPD and Physiotherapy Section of Government Medical College, Jammu from 9-12-1999 to 20-12-1999. After having failed to procure the presence of petitioner, he was declared as deserter under section 62 sub clause-2 of the BSF Act 1968. Before imposing penalty of removal from service, recourse to Rule-22 was taken by issuing show cause notice to the petitioner. Show cause notice was issued to the petitioner on 1-1-2001 through registered post on the address indicated supra. The report on the registered envelope states that the addressee has left his residence without address. The registered letter is returned back. Since the addressee is not traceable, there is no signature of the addressee on the acknowledgement. It is also averred that having failed to procure the presence of petitioner, the order of removal from service was passed. Petitioner filed an appeal against the order of removal before the Director General, BSF. Without waiting for the out come of the appeal, the present writ petition has been filed.

    I have heard the learned counsel for the parties and perused the record.

    Petitioner states that he has not been served copy of the show cause notice. It is further stated in the petition that petitioner was living in H. No. 642 alongwith his brother situated at Gandhi Nagar. The said residential house stood in the name of his brother who sold it on 9-5-2000. He placed copy of the sale deed alongwith the petition. The notice was served to the petitioner on the same address, when admittedly he was not living there. As such it should be presumed in law that no show cause notice has been served on the petitioner and the order of dismissal has been passed in violation Of Rule 22 of the BSF Rules. On the other hand the contention of the respondents is that address given by the petitioner at the time of his joining his service, is the one on which notice has been served. The petitioner has not informed the respondents regarding the change of his address. It is further contended that there are three modes of imposing penalty under the BSF Act and Rules. Under Section 48 of the BSF Act, the petitioner can be awarded punishment by a Security Force Court, which includes dismissal from service. Under Section 53 of the BSF Act minor punishment can be awarded by the Commandant.

    Independent of the aforesaid provisions, the petitioner can also be dismissed from service under Section 11 of the BSF Act which is construed as an administrative action.

    Section 62 of the BSF Act can be invoked once a person remains absent from duty without any authority for a period of 30 days. On his being absence, court of inquiry is required to be conducted. The said court of inquiry on being satisfied of the fact of such absence being without any authority or other sufficient cause, shall make declaration of such absence and the period thereof, and the Commandant of the unit to which the person belongs shall make a record thereof in the manner prescribed.

    Sub Clause 2 of the Act provides that if the person declared absent does not afterwards surrender or is not apprehended, he shall be deemed to be deserter. Under sub Rule 11(2) of Rule 177 of the BSF Rules, the Commandant may, under Sub section (2) of section 11, dismiss or remove from the service any person under his command other an officer or a subordinate officer. Before the order of dismissal of such person is passed, procedure as prescribed under Rule-22 of the aforesaid Rules, is required to be followed. Rule-22 is quoted below:

    “22. Dismissal or removal of persons other than officer on account of misconduct.-

    (1) When it is proposed to terminate the service of a person subject to the Act other than an officer, he shall be given an opportunity competent to dismiss or remove him, to show cause in the manner specified in sub-rule (2) against such action:

    Provided that this sub-rule shall not apply-

    (a) where the service is terminated on the ground of conduct which has led to his conviction by a criminal court or a Security Force Court; or

    (b) where the competent authority is satisfied that, for reasons to be recorded in writing, it is not expedient or reasonably practicable to give the person concerned an opportunity of showing cause.

    (2) When after considering the reports on the misconduct of the person concerned, the competent authority is satisfied that the trial of such a person is inexpedient or impracticable, but, is of the opinion that his further retention in the service in undesirable, it shall so inform him together with all reports adverse to him and he shall be called upon to submit, writing, this explanation and defence: Provided that the competent authority may withhold from disclosure may such report or portion thereof, if, in his opinion, its disclosure is not in the public interest.

    (3) The competent authority after considering his explanation and defence if any may dismiss or remove him from service with or without pension: Provided that a Deputy Inspector-General shall not dismiss or remove from service, a Subordinate Officer of and above the rank of a Subedar.

    (4) All cases of dismissal or removal under this rule, shall be reported to be Director-General.”

    In order to sustain the order of dismissal, rule-22 is to be complied with, which envisages issuance of show cause notice.

    There is no dispute that notice has been served to the petitioner on the address given by him at the time of joining the service, which was House No. 642-Gandhi Nagar, Jammu. It is also not in dispute that the petitioner has not informed the respondents regarding the change of his address. But the fact remains that show cause notice admittedly has not been served on the petitioner. To this extent, the endorsement on the registered envelope clearly shows that the addressee has left without address. Mode of service has not been provided under the BSF Act or Rules. One has to resort to the Civil Procedure Code in this regard. Order-5 Rule 17 of the CPC says that in case the respondent/defendant cannot be found, copy of the notice must be affixed on the outer door or some other conspicuous part of the house in which the defendant ordinarily resides or carries on business or personally works for gain. This procedure has not been adopted by the respondents. The case of the petitioner was that the house was sold by his brother where he was living prior to said sale. The new occupier of the said house could have informed the petitioner once the notice was affixed on some other conspicuous part of the house.

    To sum up, it is clear that no show cause notice has been served to the petitioner, which has resulted in non-compliance of Rule 22 of the BSF Rules. There might have been fault of the petitioner not to inform the respondents about the change of his address, but the fact remains that no effort was made by the respondents to locate the new address of the petitioner. The effect of non-compliance of this procedure, has denied the petitioner to reply to the show cause notice, which has resulted in his removal from service. I accordingly, hold that there has not been sufficient compliance of Rule-22 of the BSF Rules.

    I therefore, allow this writ petition and quash the impugned order and direct the respondents to serve the petitioner fresh show cause notice on the address to be provided by him. Respondents will, after hearing the petitioner, proceed in the matter.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Mohinder Singh Petitioner v. Union Of India & Ors S
    (Jan 2, 2009)