Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Judgment Summary — Regular Second Appeal filed by Smt. Satya Devi

Factual and Procedural Background

Two suits were instituted and later consolidated for trial: (a) Civil Suit No. 305 of 1993 (Partap Singh v. Smt. Suhli Devi etc.) — a suit for possession by way of specific performance brought by Partap Singh; and (b) Civil Suit No. 199 of 91 (Smt. Suhli Devi v. Milkhi Ram etc.) — a suit for declaration with consequential relief of permanent prohibitory injunction brought by Smt. Suhli Devi. The courts ordered that evidence recorded in the suit titled Partap Singh v. Suhli Devi etc. would also be read in the other suit.

By a common judgment and decree dated 16-12-1997 the trial Court decreed both suits: it granted Partap Singh specific performance against Smt. Suhli Devi, Smt. Satya Devi and Milkhi Ram on payment of a balance consideration; held Smt. Suhli Devi to be owner in possession; declared the sale deed executed by Milkhi Ram in favour of Smt. Satya Devi illegal and void (resulting from undue influence and misrepresentation); restrained the defendants from interfering with Smt. Suhli Devi’s possession; and held contrary revenue entries to be illegal.

Aggrieved, Smt. Satya Devi (defendant in both suits) filed a single appeal before the District Judge, Hamirpur on 27-1-1998. In that memorandum of appeal she included the common judgment and a certified copy of the decree in the suit filed by Smt. Suhli Devi but did not file the certified copy of the decree-sheet in the suit filed by Partap Singh. The District Judge dismissed that appeal on merits by judgment dated 26-5-2004. Smt. Satya Devi then filed the present regular second appeal in this Court challenging the judgments and decrees of the Courts below.

A preliminary objection was raised in this Court that the appeal was not maintainable because only one of the two decrees (although decreed by a single judgment) had been assailed before the lower appellate court; consequently the other decree had become final and barred further proceedings. After hearing arguments and considering the record, the Court addressed the maintainability of the present appeal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether an appeal is maintainable where two connected suits were decreed by a common judgment but the appellant filed only one appeal and accompanied the memorandum of appeal with a certified copy of the decree in respect of only one of those suits (i.e., whether the omission to file the certified copy of the decree in the other suit means that no appeal was effectively filed against that decree).
  2. Whether the finality of the decree in one connected suit (by reason of no appeal having been filed against it) operates as res judicata and bars an appeal against the decree in the other connected suit.
  3. Whether any substantial question of law arises for determination in the present appeal.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Jagat Dhish, Bhargava v. Jawahar Lal Bhargava, AIR 1961 SC 832 The requirement under Order 41, Rule 1, CPC (as applicable at the relevant time) that the memorandum of appeal must be accompanied by a certified copy of the decree appealed from is mandatory; in absence of such decree the appeal is incomplete, defective and incompetent. The Court relied on this authority to hold that because the appellant filed only the certified copy of the decree of Smt. Suhli Devi's suit (and not the decree of the Partap Singh suit) the appeal before the District Judge could be treated as an appeal only against the decree in Smt. Suhli Devi's suit and not against the decree in Partap Singh's suit.
Premier Tyres Limited v. Kerala State Road Transport Corporation, 1993 Supp (2) SCC 146 : AIR 1993 SC 1202 Where two connected suits are tried together and the findings recorded in one suit become final (in the absence of an appeal), that finality precludes the court from proceeding with an appeal in the other connected suit — res judicata principles apply. The Court invoked this principle as part of the legal foundation for concluding that the decree in the Partap Singh suit, which was not appealed, had become final and therefore precluded maintenance of the present appeal against the decree in the other consolidated suit.
Ram Parkash v. Smt. Charan Kaur, RSA No. 215 of 1987 (High Court order dated 18-9-1996) Applied the same legal proposition that where connected suits have been tried together and findings in one suit become final due to non-appeal, the appeal in the other suit is barred by res judicata. The High Court decision was cited as a directly analogous precedent and its reasoning was reproduced and relied upon by the Court in the present matter to support dismissal of the appeal on grounds of res judicata.
Ram Parkash v. Smt. Charan Kaur, AIR 1997 SC 3760 (Supreme Court order dismissing Special Leave Petition) The Supreme Court affirmed the High Court's view that the decree of dismissal in the connected suit (not appealed) operates as res judicata under Section 11, CPC, thereby precluding the second appeal attacking the decree in the other suit. The Court relied on the Supreme Court's order upholding the High Court to reinforce that the finality of a finding in a connected suit (due to non-filing of appeal) creates a legal bar to entertaining an appeal in respect of the other suit.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded in a step-by-step manner based strictly on facts and legal provisions cited in the record:

  1. Both suits had been consolidated and were decreed by a common judgment dated 16-12-1997. The appellant (Smt. Satya Devi) was a defendant in both suits.
  2. The memorandum of appeal filed by Smt. Satya Devi before the District Judge included the common judgment and only the certified copy of the decree in the suit filed by Smt. Suhli Devi; it did not include the certified copy of the decree-sheet in the suit filed by Partap Singh.
  3. The appeal was filed before the Code of Civil Procedure (Amendment) Act, 1999 came into force; therefore the pre-amendment provisions of Order 41, Rule 1, CPC applied — which required that a memorandum of appeal be accompanied by a certified copy of the decree appealed from (and unless dispensed with by the appellate court, the certified copy of the judgment).
  4. Relying on Jagat Dhish Bhargava (AIR 1961 SC 832), the Court observed that the requirement to file the decree with the memorandum of appeal is mandatory; absence of a decree copy renders the appeal incomplete and incompetent in respect of that decree.
  5. Because only the decree in Smt. Suhli Devi's suit accompanied the memorandum of appeal, the Court concluded the appeal before the District Judge operated only against that decree and not against the decree in the Partap Singh suit.
  6. Consequently, the decree in the Partap Singh suit, being unappealed, became final between the parties. The Court then examined whether that finality barred the present regular second appeal.
  7. The Court applied the legal principle (as stated in Premier Tyres and followed in Ram Parkash) that where connected suits are tried together and the findings in one suit become final due to non-appeal, the finality operates as res judicata and precludes proceeding with an appeal in the other suit. The High Court's own prior decision in Ram Parkash and the subsequent dismissal of the Special Leave Petition by the Supreme Court (AIR 1997 SC 3760) were cited as confirming authority.
  8. On that basis, and noting that no substantial question of law arose in the present appeal, the Court concluded that the present regular second appeal was not maintainable and ought to be dismissed.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The present appeal filed by Smt. Satya Devi is DISMISSED.

Implications and direct consequences:

  • The decree passed by the trial Court in the civil suit Partap Singh v. Smt. Suhli Devi etc. has become final between the parties because no appeal was filed against it by Smt. Satya Devi.
  • The findings recorded in that final decree operate as res judicata and barred the Court from entertaining the appeal against the decree in the connected suit (Smt. Suhli Devi's suit) that was unsuccessfully appealed before the District Judge.
  • The appeal is dismissed on maintainability and res judicata grounds and the Court held that no substantial question of law arose for determination; the order therefore resolves the dispute between the parties without creating a new precedent beyond applying established authorities.
Appeal dismissed.

    Smt. Satya Devi v. Partap Singh & Ors.

    JUDGMENT

    1. This regular second appeal has been filed by defendant-appellant Smt. Satya Devi against the judgments and decrees of the Courts below, whereby the two suits, one filed by Partap Singh and the other Smt. Suhli Devi were decreed and the sale deed in favour of Smt. Satya Devi was held to be illegal and void and the appeal filed by Smt. Satya Devi, was dismissed by the learned District Judge.

    2. The facts which are relevant for the decision of the present appeal are that, two suits were filed before the trial Court. One suit was filed by Partap Singh plaintiff against Smt. Suhli Devi, Smt. Satya Devi and Milkhi Ram, as defendants. It was a suit for possession by way of specific performance. The other suit was filed by Smt. Suhli Devi plaintiff against Milkhi Ram, Smt. Satya Devi and Partap Singh as defendants. It was a suit for declaration with consequential relief of permanent prohibitory injunction. Both the suits were consolidated, vide order dated 20-9-1995 and it was directed that the evidence shall be recorded in the suit titled as Partap Singh v. Suhli Devi etc. and that the evidence recorded in the said suit shall also be read as evidence in the other suit filed by Smt. Suhli Devi against Milkhi Ram etc. After hearing both sides, the learned trial Court decreed both the suits. A decree for possession, by way of specific performance of the agreement to sell dated 14-12-1996 was passed in favour of Partap Singh plaintiff and against Smt. Suhli Devi, Smt. Satya Devi and Milkhi Ram defendants, on payment of the balance consideration of Rs. 11,000/- and Smt. Suhli Devi was held to be owner in possession of the suit land. Furthermore, the sale deed executed by Milkhi Ram as general attorney of Smt. Suhli Devi in favour of Smt. Satya Devi was, held to be illegal and void and without consideration, being the result of undue influence and misrepresentation and defendants Milkhi Ram and Smt. Satya Devi were restrained from interfering with the possession of Smt. Suhli Devi over the suit land by way of decree for permanent prohibitory injunction and the revenue entries to the contrary were also held to be illegal.

    3. Aggrieved against the aforesaid judgments and decrees dated 16-12-1997 passed by the trial Court decreeing both the suits, Smt. Satya Devi defendant filed only one appeal before the District Judge, Hamirpur. In the memorandum of appeal, it was alleged that it was an appeal against the judgment and decrees dated 16-12-1997 in the civil suits Partap Singh v. Smt. Suhli Devi etc. and Smt. Suhli Devi v. Milkhi Ram etc. In the said memorandum of appeal filed by Smt. Satya Devi, Partap Singh was shown as plaintiff-respondent, whereas Smt. Suhli Devi and Milkhi Ram were shown as defendants, while Smt. Satya Devi was shown as the appellant. In the said memorandum of appeal, when the particulars of the suit against which the appeal was filed were mentioned, Smt. Satya Devi appellant had mentioned the particulars of only Civil Suit No. 305 of 1993 RBT 382/1994, which was the suit filed by Partap Singh against Smt. Suhli Devi etc. and the particulars of the other suit filed by Smt. Suhli Devi, had not been given in the memorandum of appeal, where the particulars of the suit appealed against are required to be given. However, in the prayer clause it was prayed that the judgment and decrees in both the suits be set aside and the appeal be accepted. Along with the said memorandum of appeal, Smt. Satya Devi had filed certified copy of the common judgment dated 16-12-1997 and also the certified copy of the decree framed by the trial Court in the civil suit Smt. Suhli Devi v. Milkhi Ram etc. The certified copy of the decree sheet in the other suit filed by Partap Singh against Smt. Suhli Devi etc. had not been filed along with the memorandum of appeal. After hearing both sides, the learned District Judge dismissed the said appeal filed by Smt. Satya Devi, on merits. Aggrieved against the same, Smt. Satya Devi filed the present regular second appeal in this Court, showing Partap Singh and Smt. Suhli Devi as the plaintiffs-respondents. In the memorandum of appeal, reference was made to the judgment and decree dated 26-5-2004 passed by the learned District Judge affirming the judgment and decrees dated 16-12-1997 passed by the trial Court in both the suits. In the prayer clause it was prayed that the appeal be allowed, the judgment and decrees of the Courts below be set aside and the suits filed by Partap Singh and Smt. Suhli Devi plaintiff be dismissed.

    4. Notice was ordered to be issued to respondents Nos. 1 and 2 and the records, were also requisitioned. On April 1, 2005 when the appeal came up for hearing before this Court, a preliminary objection was raised by the learned counsel appearing for the contesting respondents, with regard to the maintainability of the appeal on the ground that out of the two decrees passed by the trial Court by a single judgment, only one was assailed before the lower appellate Court whereby the decree in the other suit had become final and in the face of such a decree, the present appeal cannot be maintained. Accordingly, the case was adjourned for hearing the parties on the said preliminary objection. On 28-12-2005 when the matter came up for hearing before me, part arguments were heard and the case was adjourned for remaining arguments.

    5. I have heard the learned counsel for the parties and have gone through the records carefully.

    6. As referred to above, there were two suits, one filed by Partap Singh and the other filed by Smt. Suhli Devi. Both the suits were consolidated and it was directed that the evidence recorded in the one suit shall be treated as the evidence recorded in the other suit. Thereafter, both the suits were decreed by a common judgment and decree, dated 16-12-1997. Aggrieved against the same, Smt. Satya Devi, who was the defendant in both the suits, had filed only one appeal before the District Judge. Along with the memorandum of appeal, certified copy of the common judgment dated 16-12-1997 was filed along with the certified copy of one of the decrees i.e the decree in Civil Suit No. 199 of 91.RBT 18/95 in the suit titled as Smt. Suhli Devi v. Milkhi Ram etc. The certified copy of the decree sheet in the other suit, bearing Civil Suit No. 305 of 1993.RBT 3.82/94 in the suit titled as Partap Singh v. Smt. Suhli Devi etc. was not filed along with the memorandum of appeal. The said appeal was filed on 27-1-1998, i.e prior to the coming into force of the Code of Civil Procedure (Amendment) Act, 1999, which came into force with effect from 1-7-2002. Thus, the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, prior to its amendment in 1999 and 2002, was applicable at the relevant time, according to which the memorandum of appeal was required to be accompanied by a certified copy of the decree appealed from and unless the appellate Court dispenses with the same, also the certified copy of the judgment on which it was founded. In Jagat Dhish, Bhargava v. Jawahar Lal Bhargava, AIR 1961 SC 832, the Hon'ble Supreme Court after considering the aforesaid provisions of order 41, Rule 1, CPC had held as under (Park 5 of AIR):

    “Therefore there is no doubt that the requirement that the decree should be filed along with memorandum of appeal is mandatory, and in the absence of the decree the filing of the appeal would be incomplete, defective and incompetent”.

    7. In view of the provisions of order 41, Rule 1, CPC, as applicable at the relevant time and in view, of the law laid down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the aforesaid authority, in my opinion, it would be clear that the appeal which was filed by Smt. Satya Devi before the District Judge, Hamirpur could be treated as an appeal only against the decree passed by the trial Court in the suit filed by Smt. Suhli Devi, inasmuch as, only the copy of the decree passed by the trial Court in the suit filed by Smt. Suhli Devi was filed along with common judgment and the memorandum of appeal and the copy of, the decree passed by the trial Court in the other suit filed by Partap Singh, was not filed along with the memorandum of appeal and the copy of the common judgment.

    8. Once it is found that the appeal filed by Smt. Satya Devi before the District Judge was only against the decree passed by the trial Court in the suit filed by Smt. Suhli Devi against Milkhi Ram etc. and no appeal was filed against the decree passed by the trial Court in the other suit filed by Partap Singh against Smt. Suhli Devi etc., in my opinion, it would be clear that the decree passed by the trial Court in the civil suit Partap Singh v. Smt. Suhli Devi etc. had become final between the parties, since the decree passed in the suit filed by Partap Singh was not appealed against by Smt. Satya Devi and the appeal was filed only against the decree which was passed in the suit filed by Smt. Suhli Devi.

    9. Once it is found that the decree passed by the trial Court in the civil suit filed by Partap Singh was not appealed against by Smt. Satya Devi and the said decree had become final between the parties, the next question that comes up for consideration is as to whether the present regular second appeal filed by Smt. Satya Devi against the judgments and decrees of the Courts below would be maintainable, especially when in this Court as well only one appeal has been filed, against the judgment and decree dated 26-5-2004 passed by the District Judge, whereby the appeal filed by Smt. Satya Devi was dismissed. As referred to above, this appeal shall be treated as the appeal filed by Smt. Satya Devi against the decree passed in favour of Smt. Suhli Devi and not against the decree in the other suit filed by Partap Singh.

    10. In Ram Parkash v. Smt. Charan Kaur, RSA No. 215 of 1987 decided on 18-9-1996, a similar point had arisen before this Court. In the said case, two suits were filed. One suit was filed by Arjan Singh against Ram Parkash, while the other suit was filed by Ram Parkash against Aijan Singh. The suit filed by Arjan Singh was dismissed by the trial Court, but the appeal filed by Arjan Singh was allowed by the first appellate Court and the suit filed by Arjan Singh was decreed. On the other hand, the suit filed by Ram Parkash had also been dismissed by the trial Court and the appeal filed by Ram Parkash was also dismissed by the first appellate Court. Ram Parkash challenged the judgment and decree of the first appellate Court, whereby the suit filed by Arjan Singh was decreed but Ram Parkash did not challenge the judgment and decree passed by the Courts below, whereby his suit was dismissed by the Courts below. While hearing arguments in the appeal filed by Ram Parkash it came up for consideration before this Court as to whether the said appeal filed by Ram Parkash was maintainable and whether the appeal was barred by principles of res judicata. After considering the law laid down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court, in the case Premier Tyres Limited v. Kerala State Road Transport Corporation 1993 Supp (2) SSC 146 : AIR 1993 SC 1202 and other authorities on the subject, it was held by this Court as under:

    “Thus, on the basis of the aforesaid factual as well as legal proposition, it can safely be said that where two connected suits have been tried together and the findings recorded in one of the suit have become final in absence of an appeal, the appeal preferred against the findings recorded in the other suit would definitely be barred by the principles of res judicata. This is the ratio of the above cited case law decided by the Apex Court of the country. Thus, there is absolutely no necessity to go into other aspects of the appeal, especially when on factual side, as detailed above, the decree, not appealed against by the present appellant, passed by the first appellate Court, has become final between the parties, which has created a legal bar for the maintainability of the present appeal whereby the decree passed in the other suit has been assailed.”

    11. Aggrieved against the dismissal of the appeal by this Court, aforesaid Ram Parkash filed Special Leave Petition before the Hon'ble Supreme Court. The Hon'ble Supreme Court vide detailed order dated 3-2-1997 dismissed the Special Leave Petition and upheld the aforesaid order passed by this Court. The order passed by the Hon'ble Supreme Court, while dismissing the Special Leave Petition, is reported as Ram Parkash v. Smt. Charan Kaur, AIR 1997 SC 3760. In the said authority, after reproducing the aforesaid concluding paragraph of the judgment passed by this Court, it was held by the Hon'ble Supreme Court that the High Court was right in concluding that the decree of dismissal of the suit against the petitioner would operate as res judicata under Section 11, CPC in the appeal against which the petitioner had filed the second appeal. Similar view as taken by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in AIR 1993 SC 1202 (supra), holding that the finality of finding recorded in the connected suit, due to non filing of an appeal, precluded the Court from proceeding with the appeal in the other suit.

    12. In view of the law laid down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the aforementioned authorities and keeping in view the facts and circumstances of the present case, in my opinion, the present appeal filed by Smt. Satya Devi is liable to be dismissed, since Smt. Satya Devi had filed only one appeal against the two decrees, whereby the suits filed by Partap Singh and Smt. Suhli Devi had been decreed by the trial Court and only one appeal was filed against the decree passed in the suit filed by Smt. Suhli Devi and in this manner, the decree passed in the suit filed by Partap Singh became final between the parties and the findings recorded therein would be res judicata in the appeal filed by Smt. Satya Devi against the decree in the suit filed by Smt. Suhli Devi.

    13. For the reasons recorded above, in my opinion, the present appeal filed by Smt. Satya Devi is liable to be dismissed, especially when no question of law much less a substantial question of law arises for determination in this appeal. Hence the present appeal is dismissed.

    Appeal dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Smt. Satya Devi v. Partap Singh & Ors.
    (Jan 4, 2006)