AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • S. 58 of the Himachal Pradesh Tenancy and Land Reforms Act (hereinafter
  • S. 46 of the Himachal Pradesh Land Revenue Act
  • provisions of S. 58 of the Tenancy Act
  • S. 46 of the H.P Land Revenue Act.
  • SPECIFIC RELIEF ACT 1963
  • S. 58 of the Tenancy Act
  • S. 31 of the Tenancy Act
  • PUNJAB TENANCY ACT
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • S. 58 of the Himachal Pradesh Tenancy and Land Reforms Act (hereinafter
  • S. 46 of the Himachal Pradesh Land Revenue Act
  • provisions of S. 58 of the Tenancy Act
  • S. 46 of the H.P Land Revenue Act.
  • SPECIFIC RELIEF ACT 1963
  • S. 58 of the Tenancy Act
  • S. 31 of the Tenancy Act
  • PUNJAB TENANCY ACT
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This appeal was filed by the defendant against the judgment and decree dated 17 March 1980 of the District Judge, Hamirpur and Una Districts at Una, which dismissed the defendant's appeal and thereby confirmed the judgment and decree dated 6 August 1979 of the Senior Sub-Judge, Una. The trial decree had declared the plaintiff to be in actual cultivating possession of 11 Kanals 7 Marlas of land in village Nandpur (Khasra Nos. 669, 670, 671, 672 and 674), holding him to be a tenant under the defendant, and granted consequential relief in the form of a permanent prohibitory injunction restraining the defendant from interfering with the plaintiff's possession.

The plaintiff's claim was based on entries in the jamabandi (Ex. P-3 for 1968-69 and Ex. P-I for 1973-74) showing him as cultivating the land as a tenant. A subsequent correction in the revenue records in Rabi 1976, effected after an order of the Assistant Collector Second Grade dated 25 April 1976 (Ex. D-I) and a Patwari Roznamcha Waquati report dated 11 May 1976 (Ex. D-3), showed the defendant in cultivating possession; the plaintiff alleged that correction to be wrongful and sought declaration and injunction under the law.

The defendant resisted the suit, pleading that the plaintiff was never in possession, asserting the correctness of the revenue officer's order, and relying on a purported written admission by the plaintiff before the Panchayat on 3 April 1974 that he was not in possession. The defendant also challenged the Civil Court's jurisdiction.

The trial court found the plaintiff to be in possession as a tenant and held the Revenue Officer's order ineffective against the plaintiff's rights; the lower appellate court confirmed those findings. During this second appeal an application under Order 41 Rule 27 CPC (C.M.P. No. 1032 of 1980) was moved by the defendant to admit additional evidence; the application was directed to be heard at final hearing. Both original parties died during the pendency and their legal representatives were substituted.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Civil Court had jurisdiction to entertain and decide a suit by a person claiming to be a tenant when the landowner denied that status (i.e., whether S. 58 of the Himachal Pradesh Tenancy and Land Reforms Act barred the suit).
  2. Whether the order dated 25 April 1976 by the Assistant Collector Second Grade (Ex. D-I), and the consequent change in revenue entries, was legally effective and operative against the plaintiff's rights.
  3. Whether the document dated 3 April 1974 (purporting to be an admission before the Panchayat that the plaintiff was not in possession) constituted a valid relinquishment of tenancy rights under S. 31 of the Tenancy Act.
  4. Whether the defendant should be permitted to adduce additional evidence under Order 41 Rule 27 CPC during the pendency of the appeal (specifically the report of the Field/Girdawar Kanungo dated 11 Dec. 1975 and the summon of 18 Nov. 1976).

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments (Defendant)

  • The suit was barred by S. 58 of the Himachal Pradesh Tenancy and Land Reforms Act because the plaintiff claimed to be a tenant (i.e., Civil Court lacked jurisdiction).
  • There was cogent and convincing evidence that the plaintiff was not in possession and that the defendant was in possession.
  • The plaintiff had admitted in writing before the Panchayat on 3 April 1974 that he was not in possession; on that basis the Assistant Collector Second Grade passed Ex. D-I on 25 April 1976 directing correction of revenue entries in favour of the defendant, and the Patwari's Roznamcha Waquati (Ex. D-3) recorded the change in Rabi 1976.
  • The courts below erred in discarding the Assistant Collector's order (Ex. D-I) when that order was based on the Girdawar's report; the defendant sought to produce the Girdawar (Field Kanungo) report and related summon by way of additional evidence under O. 41 R. 27 CPC to fill gaps in the trial record.

Respondent's Arguments (Plaintiff / Respondent's Legal Representatives)

  • The plaintiff's status as tenant was not admitted by the defendant; therefore a Civil Court could properly entertain the suit.
  • The correction made in the revenue records was incorrect; the plaintiff was aggrieved by the revenue entry and could seek relief under S. 46 of the Himachal Pradesh Land Revenue Act and by declaration under the Specific Relief Act, 1963.
  • The defendant should not be permitted to lead additional evidence at this stage merely to cure lacunae in its case, particularly when that evidence was within the defendant's knowledge and could have been produced at trial.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Raja Durga Singh v. Tholu, AIR 1963 SC 361 Interpreting provisions pari materia with S. 58 of the Tenancy Act to show that suits by persons claiming to be tenants, where landlord denies that status, are not barred from Civil Court jurisdiction. The Court relied on the Supreme Court's observation to conclude that S. 58 does not bar a suit where the landlord disputes the plaintiff's status as tenant; this supported the conclusion that the Civil Court had jurisdiction to entertain the declaration/injunction suit.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded in a stepwise legal analysis based strictly on the materials and pleadings before it:

  1. Jurisdiction under S. 58 Tenancy Act: The court examined S. 58 and concluded that it does not bar suits where the landlord disputes the claimant's status as tenant. The court relied on the Supreme Court's interpretation in Raja Durga Singh v. Tholu to hold that the legislature intended to bar only suits where there is no dispute about the landlord-tenant relationship. Because the defendant denied the plaintiff's tenancy and possession, Civil Court jurisdiction was properly invoked.
  2. Remedy under S. 46 of the Himachal Pradesh Land Revenue Act: The court noted S. 46 gives a person aggrieved by an entry in a record of rights a right to institute a suit for declaration of his rights (by reference to the Specific Relief Act). The plaintiff had challenged the change in revenue entries and was therefore entitled to seek declaration in Civil Court.
  3. Validity and evidential basis of the Revenue Officer's order (Ex. D-I): The Assistant Collector's order recorded that possession of the owner was established on the basis of a Girdawar's report. The court held that the order was ineffectual against the plaintiff because it was not founded on evidence independently recorded by the Revenue Officer; the Girdawar Halqa (Field Kanungo) who prepared the report was not examined at trial and the report was not proved. Therefore the lower courts were justified in treating Ex. D-I as insufficient to oust the entries in jamabandi or the plaintiff's rights.
  4. Evidentiary weight of jamabandi entries and other evidence: The jamabandi copies (Ex. P-3 for 1968–69 and Ex. P-I for 1973–74) consistently showed the plaintiff as cultivating the land as a tenant. The court observed that presumption of truth attaches to revenue records and, on the material before the trial court, rightly concluded that the plaintiff was in possession as a tenant.
  5. Purported relinquishment dated 3 April 1974: The document relied on by the defendant as a written admission was not put to the plaintiff in cross-examination, was not tendered or proved in evidence, and purported to effect a relinquishment of tenant rights. The court held that S. 31 of the Tenancy Act bars such relinquishments in favour of the landowner and that the provision had retrospective effect predating the document; consequently the document was ineffective and, in any event, not proved.
  6. Oral evidence from defendant and new case at trial: The court noted that some oral evidence suggested the defendant was then in occupation, but treated that as a new case raised during trial and did not displace the presumption arising from prior revenue entries and the material on record.
  7. Application under O. 41 R. 27 CPC to adduce additional evidence: The court found the application to be an afterthought intended to fill lacunae in the defendant's case. The evidence sought (Girdawar report and summon) was within the defendant's knowledge and no satisfactory explanation was offered for its late production. The court concluded that allowing the application would not serve any useful purpose and therefore dismissed it.

Holding and Implications

Holding:

Appeal dismissed.

Implications:

  • The judgment and decree of the Senior Sub-Judge dated 6 August 1979 and the appellate judgment dated 17 March 1980 were affirmed: the plaintiff was held to be in cultivating possession of the suit land as a tenant and was entitled to a declaration and a permanent prohibitory injunction restraining the defendant from interfering with that possession.
  • The Assistant Collector's order (Ex. D-I) and the consequent Rabi 1976 change in revenue entries were held ineffective against the plaintiff's rights because they were not supported by proved evidence (the Girdawar was not examined and his report was not proved).
  • The defendant's application to admit additional evidence under Order 41 Rule 27 CPC was dismissed as an afterthought; the evidence was within the defendant's knowledge and could and should have been produced earlier.
  • No separate or new legal principle was laid down by the court beyond its application of existing statutory provisions (S. 46 of the Himachal Pradesh Land Revenue Act, S. 31 and S. 58 of the Tenancy Act) and the cited Supreme Court authority; the decision confirmed the trial and appellate courts' findings on the facts and law in this case.
  • No costs were awarded to either party.

    Babu Ram (Deceased) And Others v. Shri Pohlo Ram (Deceased) And Others

    1. This is defendant's appeal against the judgment and decree passed on March 17, 1980, by District Judge, Hamirpur and Una Districts at Una, dismissing his appeal and thereby confirming the judgment and decree passed on August 6, 1979, by Senior Sub-Judge, Una, by which suit of plaintiff-respondent was decreed for declaration with a consequential relief of injunction.

    2. Plaintiff claimed a decree for declaration on the basis that he was in actual cultivating possession of 11 Kanals 7 Marlas of land comprised in Khasra Nos. 669, 670, 671, 672 and 674 situate in village Nandpur, Tehsil Amb., district Una, as a tenant under the defendant and the correction made in the revenue records in Rabi 1976 showing the defendant to be in cultivating possession was factually wrong, illegal, unauthorised, ineffective and inoperative against his rights and as on the basis of this wrong entry in the revenue records, defendants had intention to interfere with his possession, therefore, as a consequential relief a decree for permanent prohibitory injunction restraining the defendant from causing any interference with his possession was also sought. Suit was resisted by the defendant by taking a plea that plaintiff was never in possession of the suit land and the same was in his possession. The Revenue Officer had rightly passed the order for correction of entry in his name after deleting the wrong entry which had earlier appeared in revenue records showing the plaintiff to be in possession. It was further pleaded that the plaintiff had admitted, in writing, before the Panchayat that he was not in possession of the property. Jurisdiction of the Civil Court to entertain and decide the suit was also challenged by the defendant.

    3. The trial Court held the plaintiff to be in possession of the suit property as a tenant on payment of rent under the defendant. It also held the order passed by the Revenue Officer ordering the correction to be ineffective and inoperative against the rights of the plaintiff and negatived the plea of the defendant that the plaintiff ever gave up the possession of the suit property. Suit was held to be entertainable by a Civil Court. In view of these findings, suit of the plaintiff was decreed. The lower appellate Court confirmed the findings recorded by the trial Court and dismissed the appeal. The defendant has challenged the judgments and decrees of the Courts below in this regular second appeal.

    4. During the pendency of appeal, an application under O. 41, R. 27 of the C.P.C (C.M.P No. 1032 of 1980) was filed by the defendant seeking permission to lead additional evidence. The application came up before the Court for consideration on October 14, 1980, when it was ordered that the same would be heard and decided at the time of final hearing of the appeal. It may be mentioned that during the pendency of the appeal before this Court both, the plaintiff as well as defendant, have expired and their respective legal representatives have been brought on record of the appeal.

    5. I have heard the learned counsel for the parties. Learned counsel for the appellants urged before me that in view of the averments made in the plaint, in which the plaintiff had claimed a decree for declaration that he was a tenant on the suit land, Civil Court had no jurisdiction to entertain and decide the suit. It was further urged that there was cogent and convincing evidence adduced by the defendant on record to show that plaintiff was not in possession of the suit property and before the Panchayat the plaintiff had, on April 3, 1974, admitted by giving a document in writing that he was not in possession of the property and on the basis of this document, an order Ex. D-I was passed on April 25, 1976, by the Assistant Collector Second Grade, ordering the correction of entries in revenue records by showing the defendant to be in possession. It was on the basis of this order that change was affected in Khasra Girdawari in Rabi 1976 and for which report in Roznamcha Waquati was also made by the Patwari on May 11, 1976 vide copy Ex. D-3. The learned counsel for the appellant further urged that the Courts below were not right in discarding the order passed by the Assistant Collector Second Grade on the ground that it was based upon the report of Girdawar Kanungo, who had not been produced in the witness-box. It was, for this reason that application under O. 41, R. 27 of the Civil P.C had been made seeking to produce by way of additional evidence the report of Field Kanungo dated Dec., 11, 1975 along with a copy of summon dated Nov., 18, 1976, by which Assistant Collector Second Grade had asked the plaintiff to appear before him to show cause as to why the correction in revenue records be not made in favour of the defendant.

    6. Learned counsel for the respondents, on the other hand, urged that the status of the plaintiff was not admitted by defendant and, therefore, there was no bar for Civil Court to entertain and decide the suit and moreover incorrect entry had appeared in the revenue record against the plaintiff, therefore, suit for declaration in a Civil Court was competent and maintainable in view of S. 46 of the H.P Land Revenue Act. It was further contended that defendant could not be permitted to lead additional evidence merely to fill in the lacuna in the case especially when such evidence was within the knowledge of the defendant and could have been easily produced in the trial Court.

    7. I see much force in the arguments advanced by the learned counsel for the respondent-plaintiffs. The argument of the learned counsel for the appellants that the suit is barred under S. 58 of the Himachal Pradesh Tenancy and Land Reforms Act (hereinafter to be called as the Tenancy Act) is not tenable. There is no clause in S. 58 of the Tenancy Act which provides for a suit by or against a person claiming himself to be a tenant and whose status as a tenant is not admitted by the land owner. The legislature barred only those suits from the cognizance of Civil Court where there is no dispute between the parties about the relationship of landlord and tenant. It was a suit filed by the plaintiff claiming himself to be in possession of the property as a tenant under the defendant and defendant had not admitted the status of the plaintiff as such, rather, it was pleaded that the plaintiff was not at all in possession. The provisions contained in the Punjab Tenancy Act, as applicable to Himachal Pradesh, which are pari materia with the provisions of S. 58 of the Tenancy Act came up for consideration before the Supreme Court in Raja Durga Singh v. Tholu, AIR 1963 SC 361. The Supreme Court observed in its report as under (at page 363):—

    “…..There is no entry or item relating to a suit by or against a person claiming to be a tenant and whose status as a tenant is not admitted by the landlord. It would, therefore, be reasonable to infer that the legislature barred only those suits from the cognizance of a Civil Court where there was no dispute between the parties that a person cultivating land or who was in possession of land was a tenant…..”

    In view of the specific pleadings and as observed by the Supreme Court in Durga Singh's case (supra), Civil Court undoubtedly had jurisdiction to entertain and decide the suit. Moreover, plaintiff had felt aggrieved by an entry made in the revenue records on the basis of an order passed by Revenue Officer. S. 46 of the Himachal Pradesh Land Revenue Act provides that if a person considers himself aggrieved as to any right of which he is in possession by an entry in a record of right or any periodical record, he can institute a suit for declaration of his rights under Chap. VI of the Specific Relief Act, 1963. The Courts below, as such, were right in their view that Civil Court had jurisdiction to entertain and decide the suit.

    8. The next argument of the learned counsel for the appellant that order dated April 25, 1976, was incorrectly discarded also has no force. Assistant Collector Second Grade, merely recorded in his order that on the basis of report of Girdawar possession of owner was established, therefore, an order was made for change of entry in revenue records. The Courts below were right by discarding this order on the ground that it was not based upon any evidence independently recorded by the Revenue Officer but was based upon a report of Girdawar Halqa, who had not been examined as a witness. The defendant was aware of the report of Girdawar Halqa but the same was not proved on record. Even the report of Girdawar Halqa would not have been relevant in the absence of his own statement. Any order effecting change in revenue record is always subject to decision by a Civil Court, as provided in S. 46 of the Himachal Pradesh Land Revenue Act. In this case parties led evidence independently. Ex. P-3 is the copy of jamabandi for the year 1968-1969 in which the plaintiff is shown to be in cultivating possession of the property as a tenant. This entry was repeated in the next jamabandi, Ex. P-I, for the year 1973-1974. Change in entries in revenue records appeared for the first time in Rabi 1976, on the basis of the aforementioned order Ex. D-I. Learned counsel for the appellants placed much reliance upon document dated April 3, 1974 and urged that plaintiff had, in fact, admitted before the Panchayat that he was not in possession of the suit property. This document cannot be considered at all for various reasons. Firstly, it purports to relinquish the rights as a tenant. S. 31 of the Tenancy Act puts a clear bar for such relinquishments by a tenant in favour of landowner and this provision has been inserted in the Tenancy Act with retrospective effect, that is, much prior to the date when the document came into existence and as such is ineffective. Secondly, the document was not put to the plaintiff when he, appeared in the witness box, nor it was tendered in evidence. It was also not proved in accordance with law.

    9. The oral evidence examined in this case on behalf of the defendant is to the effect that the plaintiff was earlier cultivating the land but the same was now in occupation of defendant. It was totally a new case which was sought to be made during the trial of the suit. The defendant had, in fact, originally taken up a stand that the plaintiff was not in possession of the property. Presumption of truth is attached to the entries made in the revenue records. When the plaintiff was shown to be recorded as a tenant on the property in the year 1968-1969 and also in the year 1973-1974, the Courts below rightly came to the conclusion, on the material available on record, that the plaintiff was in possession of the property as a tenant and were right in granting decree in his favour.

    10. The application for adducing additional evidence cannot be allowed in the facts and circumstances of the case. It has been moved merely to fill in lacunae and is an after-thought. The defendant was aware of this evidence and no reason has been assigned as to why the same could not be produced earlier. In my view, no useful purpose will be served even if the application is allowed and the evidence sought to be brought on record is permitted to be adduced. The application, as such is dismissed.

    11. For the reasons stated above, the appeal has no force and the same is dismissed. No costs.

    Appeal dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Babu Ram (Deceased) And Others v. Shri Pohlo Ram (Deceased) And Others
    (Dec 14, 1990)