(Per
: HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE AKIL KURESHI)
This
petition filed in the nature of public interest litigation raises
challenge to the manner in which the respondents-the State
Government as well as the State Election Commission have decided to
conduct election of Councilors to different Municipal Corporations
in the State of Gujarat. Sole objection of the petitioner is that
when the local area of Municipal Corporation is divided into
different wards, each ward must have one Councilor and policy of
having multi-member wards (three number in present case) is
constitutionally invalid.
Briefly
stated, facts are as follows :
2.1 Undisputedly
in six Municipal Corporations situated in the State of Gujarat
namely, Ahmedabad, Surat, Rajkot, Jamnagar, Bhavnagar and Vadodara,
term of elected bodies of the Corporations would be over in October
December 2010 and the elections for the new Corporations therefore,
would be held shortly to elect new bodies of the Corporations. For
such a purpose, the State Election Commission has already undertaken
task of delimitation by issuing notification on 29.1.2010. The
election programme is not yet announced. For holding such elections,
State Government has issued notifications determining the number of
wards and the number of Councilors in the different Municipal
Corporations as also providing for reservation of seats in favour of
different reserved categories. By way of example, we have on record
one such notification dated 7.5.2010 filed along with the affidavit
dated 11.6.2010 at Annexure-G which reads as follows :
NOW,
THEREFORE, in exercise of the powers conferred by sub clause(a) of
clause(iii) of sub-section (3) of section 5 read with
sub-sections(4), (5), (6) and (7) of the said section 5 of the said
Act so far as the City of Surat is concerned, the Government of
Gujarat hereby determines that.-
(1) the
City of Surat shall be divided into Thirty-eight Wards having one
Hundred Fourteen Councilors and the Municipal Corporation of Surat
shall consist of One Hundred Fourteen elected Councilors.
(2) out
of the One Hundred Fourteen seats of councilors;-
(i) Four
seats shall be reserved for persons belonging to the Scheduled
Castes out of which One seat shall be reserved for women belonging
to the Scheduled Castes.
(ii) Four
seats shall be reserved for persons belonging to the Scheduled
Tribes out of which One seat shall be reserved for women belonging
to the Scheduled Tribes;
(iii) Eleven
seats shall be reserved for the persons belonging to the Backward
Classes out of which Four seats shall be reserved for women
belonging to Backward Classes;
(iv) Thirty-eight
seats shall be reserved for the women (including the number of seats
reserved for the women belonging to Scheduled Castes, Scheduled
Tribes and the Backward Classes referred to as above.)
2.2 It
is primarily the case of the petitioner that provision for electing
three Councilors from each ward is unconstitutional and even
otherwise legally impermissible. In the original form, entire thrust
of the petitioner's challenge was that above formula of three
Councilors representing one ward is violative of democratic
principle of one man one vote . The petitioner contended
that by virtue of Constitutional amendment and addition of various
provisions made for conduct of elections to different local bodies
of self-governance and in particular by addition of Article 243R in
the Constitution, elections to Municipalities have to be held in the
same manner as elections to State Legislative Assembly. The
petitioner has therefore, contended in the petition that :
...It
is stated that as already provided by Article 243R, seats in a
Municipality have to be filled up by persons chosen by direct
elections from territorial constituencies. These territorial
constituencies although are constituencies in their nature
equivalent to the constituencies as bifurcated in a Vidhansabha or
in a Legislative Assembly, however, constituencies in a municipal
area are known as Wards. Thus, only nomenclature of the
constituencies chances whereas in all manner and procedure the
constituencies remain the same as the State and the Central
elections. Therefore, there should be only one representative who
can be elected in one constituency. However, the scenario today is
that in every constituency in a municipal area, known as Wards, 3
people are elected as representative of one single territorial
constituency, thereby 3 votes are cast by one person for election of
three people on one, which should be in the right spirit only one
person i.e. only one representative should be elected from one
constituency i.e. Ward.
2.3 The
petitioner has relied on several decisions of this Court as well as
the Apex Court to contend that principle of one man one vote
is accepted as one of the basic principles of democracy in India.
2.4 The
sole substantive prayer made in the petition, therefore, at the time
of filing of the petition was as follows :
In the premises aforesaid, the petitioner therefore, prays as under
:-
(A) This
Hon'ble Court may be pleased to issue appropriate writ of mandamus
or any other appropriate writ, order and/or direction directing the
respondents to follow the mandate of the Constitution of India, 1950
and follow the rule of one man one vote in the coming elections.
2.5 While
the arguments in this petition were being heard, certain provisions
were pointed out by the respondents which permitted Municipal wards
to be multi-member wards. The petitioner therefore, filed Civil
Application No. 6587/2010 seeking amendment in the petition
challenging vires of such statutory provisions. In the amendment
application, petitioner has prayed for addition to corresponding
prayers as also for addition of certain grounds in support of such
prayers.
2.6 Considering
the fact that the challenge of the petitioner to statutory
provisions rested entirely on legal contentions, we had proceeded to
hear learned advocates for all sides on such issues without calling
for formal reply. We had also issued notice to learned Advocate
General in view of challenge to the statutory provisions and heard
him as well.
2.7 Civil
Application No.6587/2010 for amendment however, to complete the
formalities is hereby allowed. Petitioner shall carry out the
amendments accordingly without any delay.
2.8 In
the amended form, petitioner has challenged vires of Section
5(3)(iii)(a) and Sections 29A(2)(a) and 29A(3)(a) of the Bombay
Provincial Municipal Corporation Act, 1949 (here-in-after referred
to as the BPMC Act ) as also Rule 4 of the Bombay Provincial
Municipal Corporations (Delimitation of Wards in the City and
Allocation of Reserved Seats) Rule, 1994 ( here-in-after referred to
as the Delimitation Rules of 1994 and Rule 2(b) of Gujarat
Municipal Corporation Wards Committee Functions, Duties, Territorial
Areas and Procedure for Transaction of Business Rules, 2007
(here-in-after referred to as the Wards Committee Rules 2007).
2.9 In
nutshell, the case of the petitioner is that providing for three
Councilors to be elected from each ward of the Municipal
Corporation violates the principle of one man one vote . Same
is opposed to the Constitutional mandate of holding elections to the
Municipalities in the same manner as State Legislative Assembly and
lastly the statutory provisions providing for multi-member wards
are in conflict with provisions of Article 243R and 243S(4)(a) and
(4)(b) of the Constitution of India.
2.10 Respondents
have opposed the petition by filing different replies. Different
Municipal Corporations joined as respondents are largely formal
parties. Main contesting parties however, are the State Election
Commission and the State Government.
2.11 On
behalf of the State Election Commission, its Deputy Election
Commissioner has filed affidavit dated 19.6.2010. Relying on various
statutory provisions, it is contended that determination of number
of wards and number of Councilors to be elected from each ward is a
function statutorily vested in the State Government. It is pointed
out that under Article 243ZA of the Constitution, the State
Legislature is competent to make provisions with respect to all
matters relating to or in connection with the elections to
Municipalities and the State Election Commission has to hold and
conduct the elections only in accordance with the law made by the
State Legislature. It is further stated that notifications have been
issued by the State Government in exercise of powers under Section 5
of the BPMC Act dividing different Municipal Corporations into
number of wards. For example, by notification dated 23.3.2010, city
of Ahmedabad is divided into 64 wards and number of Councilors to be
elected is 192. Notification also provides for number of reserved
seats in different categories. Similar notifications have also been
issued with respect to other Municipal Corporations also. It is
further contended that preliminary notifications delimiting the
wards for various Corporations have been issued on 2/3.6.2010. It is
pointed out that entire exercise of conducting election is to be
completed within a rigid time frame.
2.12 State
Government has also filed an affidavit dated 23.6.2010 contending
inter-alia that petitioner has neither shown his locus standi nor is
the petition filed bona fide. It is pointed out that in exercise of
powers under Section 5 of the BPMC Act, State Government has already
published notification dividing the Municipal Corporation into
different wards and number of Councilors to be elected from each
ward. Reference is made to Article 243ZG, wherein it is provided
that validity of any law relating to the delimitation of
constituencies or the allotment of seats to such constituencies,
made or purporting to be made under Article 243ZA shall not be
called in question in any Court. It is contended that process of
election has already commenced and the present petition therefore,
in view of provisions contained under Article 243ZG is not
maintainable.
Appearing
for the petitioner, learned senior advocate Shri Yatin Oza
vehemently contended that electing three Councilors from each ward
of a Municipal Corporation is directly in conflict of democratic
principles of one man one vote . He further contended that the
election to the Municipal Corporation is to be conducted in the same
manner as State Legislative Assembly, wherein different
constituencies is represented by one single member and no more. He
relied on the provisions contained under Article 243R and 243S(4)
of the Constitution to contend that constitutional provisions for
conducting of election to Municipal Corporation does not envisage
multi-member wards. He therefore, contended that the statutory
provisions particularly, section 5 of the bpmc act and Rule 4 of
the Delimitation Rules of 1994, providing to the contrary is
unconstitutional and therefore, invalid.
3.1 Counsel
for the petitioner relied on decision of the Division Bench of this
Court, in case of Rameshchandra Ramanbhai Patel and anr. v.
Collector, Kheda and ors. reported in 20(1) GLR 191 wherein the
Bench examined the question of applicability of the principle of
one man one vote in India.
3.2 Counsel
further referred to Division Bench decision of this Court in case of
Vishnubhai Natvarlal Patel v. State of Gujarat reported in
1980(2)GLR 189, wherein the principle of one man one vote was
applied in context of question of what basis should be adopted for
delimitation of constituencies for election to Municipal
Corporations under the BPMC Act.
3.3 Counsel
also relied on decision in case of Kishansing Tomar v.
Municipal Corporation of the City of Ahmedabad and others
reported in (2006) 8 Supreme Court Cases 352, wherein the Apex Court
emphasized the need to hold timely election to Municipal Corporation
and to ensure that newly elected body is brought into existence
before the term of the outgoing elected councilors is over.
On
the other hand, learned Advocate General Shri Kamal Trivedi
appearing in response to the notice of the Court regarding the vires
of the statutory provisions contended that none of the provisions of
the Constitution and in particular Article 243R or 243S prohibit
multi-member wards in the Municipal Corporation. As per the
statutory scheme of elections to the Municipal Corporations, it is
left to the State Legislature to make laws in respect of all matters
relating to or in connection with elections to the Municipalities.
He further pointed out that Entry-5 of List-II of the Constitution
pertains to local Government i.e. constitution and powers of
Municipal Corporations etc. and other local authorities for the
purpose of local self-government or village administration. He
therefore, contended that the statutory provisions contained in the
BPMC Act and Rules made thereunder providing for multi-member wards
in Municipal Corporations is within the competence of the State
Legislature and is not opposed to any of the Constitutional
provisions. Vires of such provisions are therefore, required to be
upheld.
4.1 He
pressed in service the principles of harmonious construction for
interpretation of statute, and contended that statutory provisions
under challenge can harmoniously coexist with the provisions made in
Article 243R and 243S of the Constitution. In support of his
contention, he relied on the decision of the Apex Court in case of
Ashokkumar Thakur v. Union of India reported in (2008) 6
SCC 1, wherein it is observed that it is a well settled principle
of the Constitutional interpretation that while interpreting the
provisions of the Constitution, effect shall be given to the all
the provisions of the Constitution and no provision shall be
interpreted in a manner as to make any other provisions in the
Constitution inoperative or otiose.
4.2 He
further contended that in view of provisions made in Article 243ZG
of the Constitution challenge to statutory provisions is not
maintainable. He relied on the decision of the Apex Court in case of
State of U.P. v. Pradhan Sangh Kshettra Samiti reported in
1995 Supp(2) SC 305, wherein the Apex Court observed that :
45.
What is more objectionable in the approach of the High Court is that
although clause(a) of Article 243-O of the Constitution enacts a bar
on the interference by the courts in electoral matters including the
questioning of the validity of any law relating to the delimitation
of the constituencies or the allotment of seats to such
constituencies made or purported to be made under Article 243-K and
the election to any panchayat, the High Court has gone into the
question of the validity of the delimitation of the constituencies
and also the allotment of seats to them.
Learned
Additional Advocate General Shri Tushar Mehta appearing for the
State in addition to adopting the arguments made by the learned
Advocate General further elaborated on the interpretation of Article
243R and 243S(4) of the Constitution and contended that even within
the language used in the said provisions, multi-member wards in
Municipal Corporation can be envisaged.
On
behalf of the State Election Commission, learned advocate Shri
Anjaria contended that the Election Commission is required to
undertake the process of delimitation and allocation of seats as per
the statutory provisions. The Constitutional provisions require the
State Election Commission to constitute newly elected body to such
Corporation before the expiry of the term of the outgoing elected
body. He pointed out that term of the existing body of Ahmedabad
Municipal Corporation expires in October 2010 and for other
Municipal Corporations in December 2010. Any intervention by the
Court at this stage would delay the process of holding elections.
6.1 He
further contented that provisions of Article 243R are independent of
Article 243S and interpretation of Article 243S cannot govern the
interpretation of Article 243R. Constitution of wards committees has
nothing to do with the question whether the Municipal Corporation
can have multi-member wards or a single member ward.
Having
thus heard learned advocates for the parties, we find that in the
present petition we are called upon to decide two issues. First
question is whether the prescription of multi-member wards in the
Municipal Corporation violates democratic principle of one man
one vote . Second controversy is whether statutory provisions
which provide for multi-member wards in different Municipal
Corporations in the State are ultra vires the Constitution.
Before
considering the rival submissions and recording our interpretation,
it would be useful to take note of relevant Constitutional and
statutory provisions.
8.1 In
the year 1993, through amendments to the Constitution, Part-IX and
Part-IXA as they stand in the present form were introduced
containing Articles 243 to 243ZG. Whereas Part-IX pertains to
Panchayats, Part-IXA pertains to Municipalities. Different Articles
in these parts contain detailed provisions for constitution and
composition of bodies of self-governance such as Panchayats and
Municipalities.
Article
243P(a) defines the term 'Committee' as follows :
(a)
"Committee" means a Committee constituted under article
243S;
Term
'Municipality' is defined under Article 243P(e) as follows :
(e)
"Municipality" means an institution of self-government
constituted under article 243Q;
Article
243Q provides for constitution of Municipalities and envisages a
Municipal Corporation for a larger urban area.
Article
243R provides for composition of Municipalities. Article 243R reads
as follows :
243R.
Composition of Municipalities.- (1) Save as provided in clause (2),
all the seats in a Municipality shall be filled by persons chosen by
direct election from the territorial constituencies in the Municipal
area and for this purpose each Municipal area shall be divided into
territorial constituencies to be known as wards.
The Legislature of a State may, by law, provide-
(a)
for the representation in a Municipality of-
(i)
persons having special knowledge or experience in Municipal
administration;
(ii)
the members of the House of the People and the members of the
Legislative Assembly of the State representing constituencies which
comprise wholly or partly the Municipal area;
(iii)
the members of the Council of States and the members of the
Legislative Council of the State registered as electors within the
Municipal area;
(iv)
the Chairpersons of the Committees constituted under clause (5) of
article 243S:
Provided
that the persons referred to in paragraph (i) shall not have the
right to vote in the meetings of the Municipality;
(b)
the manner of election of the Chairperson of a Municipality.
Article
243S pertains to constitution and composition of Wards Committees
etc. Article 243S reads as follows :
243S.
Constitution and composition of Wards Committees, etc.- (1) There
shall be constituted Wards Committees, consisting of one or more
wards, within the territorial area of a Municipality having a
population of three lakhs or more.
The Legislature of a State may, by law, make provision with respect
to-
(a)
the composition and the territorial area of a Wards Committee;
(b)
the manner in which the seats in a Wards Committee shall be filled.
A member of a Municipality representing a ward within the territorial
area of the Wards Committee shall be a member of that Committee.
Where a Wards Committee consists of-
(a)
one ward, the member representing that ward in the Municipality; or
(b)
two or more wards, one of the members representing such wards in the
Municipality elected by the members of the Wards Committee, shall be
the Chairperson of that Committee.
Nothing in this article shall be deemed to prevent the Legislature of
a State from making any provision for the constitution of Committees
in addition to the Wards Committees.
Article
243U pertains to duration of Municipalities. In particular clause(1)
of Article 243U provides that every Municipality, unless sooner
dissolved under any law for the time being in force, shall continue
for five yeas from the date appointed for its first meeting and no
longer.
Article
243ZA pertains to elections of Municipalities. Article 243ZA reads
as follows :
243ZA.
Elections to the Municipalities.- (1) The superintendence,direction
and control of the preparation of electoral rolls for, and the
conduct of, all elections to the Municipalities shall be vested in
the State Election Commission referred to in article 243K.
Subject to the provisions of this Constitution, the Legislature of a
State may, by law, make provision with respect to all matters
relating to, or in connection with, elections to the Municipalities.
Article
243ZF gives extension for a limited period to laws which are
inconsistent with the provisions contained in Part-IXA. Article
243ZF read as follows :
243ZF.
Continuance of existing laws and Municipalities.-Notwithstanding
anything in this Part, any provision of any law relating to
Municipalities in force in a State immediately before the
commencement of the Constitution (Seventy-fourth Amendment) Act,
1992, which is inconsistent with the provisions of this Part, shall
continue to be in force until amended or repealed by a competent
Legislature or other competent authority or until the expiration of
one year from such commencement, whichever is earlier:
Provided
that all the Municipalities existing immediately before such
commencement shall continue till the expiration of their duration,
unless sooner dissolved by a resolution passed to that effect by the
Legislative Assembly of that State or, in the case of a State having
a Legislative Council, by each House of the Legislature of that
State.
Article
243ZG bars interference by courts in electoral matters. Article
243ZG reads as follows :
243ZG.
Bar to interference by courts in electoral matters.-Notwithstanding
anything in this Constitution,-
(a)
the validity of any law relating to the delimitation of
constituencies or the allotment of seats to such constituencies, made
or purporting to be made under article 243ZA shall not be called in
question in any court;
(b)
no election to any Municipality shall be called in question except by
an election petition presented to such authority and in such manner
as is provided for by or under any law made by the Legislature of a
State.]
Entry
5 to List-II i.e. State List to Schedule 7 to the Constitution
pertains to local Government and reads as follows :
5.
Local government, that is to say, the constitution and powers of
municipal corporation, improvement trusts, district boards, mining
settlement authorities and other local authorities for the purpose
of local self-government or village administration.
8.2 Section
5 of the BPMC Act pertains to constitution of Corporation. Relevant
provisions thereof read as follows :
Each Corporation shall consist of councilors chosen by direct
election.
(3)Where
general election is to be held immediately after,-
(i)
a larger urban area as specified under clause(2) of Article
243Q of the Constitution of India, is made, or
(ii)
the census is taken under the Census Act, 1948 and the relevant
figures of which have been published, or
(iii)
the limits of a City are altered-
(a)
the State Government shall, by notification in the Official gazette,
determine the number of wards into which the City shall be divided,
the number of councillors to be elected to the Corporation and the
number of seats to be reserved in favour of the Scheduled Castes,
the Scheduled Tribes, the Backward Classes and Women as provide in
this section, and
(b)
the State Election Commission thereafter shall carry out the
determination of the boundaries of the wards and the allocation of
seats reserved in favour of the Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes,
the Backward Classes and Women among the wards in the prescribed
manner.
Section
29A of the BPMC Act pertains to constitution of Wards Committee.
Part of Section 29A insofar as the same is relevant for our purpose
reads as under :
29A.(1)
Where the population of the City is three lakhs or more, there shall
be constituted by the [Municipal Corporation, subject to the rules
made by the State Government] Wards Committee or Committees
consisting of one or more wards within the territorial area of
Corporation.
(2)Each
Wards Committee shall consist of -
(a)
Councilors of the Corporation representing a ward within the
territorial area of the Ward Committee;
Provided
that a person shall be disqualified for being appointed, and for
being a member of the Wards Committee, if under the provisions of
this Act or any other law for the time being in force, he would be
disqualified for being elected as, and for being, a councillor.
The Wards Committee shall at its first meeting after its
constitution under sub-section(1) and at its first meeting in the
same month in each succeeding year shall elect,-
where
the Wards Committee consists of -
(a)
one ward, the Councillor representing that ward in the Corporation;
or
(b)
two or more wards, one of the Councillors representing such wards in
the Corporation elected by the members of the Wards Committee, to be
the Chairperson of that Committee.
8.3 In
exercise of powers conferred under Sub-section(1) of Section 456
read with section 5 of the bpmc act, the State has framed the
Delimitation Rules of 1994. Rule 2 of the Delimitation Rules of
1994 provides for constitution of wards. Rule 2 reads as follows :
2.
The Wards shall be constituted in such a manner that the population
in all the wards is, as far as practicable, equal, in particular,
the population of a ward shall not vary by more than ten percent
from the average wards population of the city.
Rule
4 of the Delimitation Rules of 1994 reads as follows :
4.
All Wards shall be multi-member wards with three councillors to be
elected from each ward.
First
adverting to the issue of one man one vote, we may recall that it is
the case of the petitioner that by providing for multi-member wards
, the State as well as Election Commission have breached the said
democratic principle.
Insofar
as applicability of one man one vote in our Country is concerned,
even the counsel for the respondents did not raise any serious
dispute. This principle having its origin in American judgements, is
also accepted in Indian context as held by the Division Bench of
this Court in case of Rameshchandra Ramanbhai Patel and
anr.(supra), observing :
24.
It would thus appear that the principle, which must be taken to have
been established beyond doubt or debate, so far as this country is
concerned, is that whenever the stature requires selection of
persons to be made by popular election to perform governmental
functions, whether at the Union or State or local level, each vote
must have an equal value and that when members of such elected
bodies are chosen from separate constituencies, each constituency
must be established on a basis which will ensure, as far as
practicable, that equal number of constituents can vote for
proportionately equal number of representatives. The rule is so
deeply entrenched in our election jurisprudence that any deviation
therefrom would require strict justification on rational or
permissible grounds and any wrongful dilution thereof must be
jealously guarded against.
Question
however, is whether the prescription of multi-member wards in
Municipal elections breaches this principle. We are unable to concur
with the contention of the counsel for the petitioner that one man
one vote means in all its rigidity that in every election no matter
what the statutory scheme, each voter must caste vote in favor of
only one candidate and any deviation therefrom invariably and
necessarily be considered as breach of the said principle. One
man one vote principle has many manifestations and as long as
each eligible voter is allowed to caste his vote and the value of
such vote is no more or less than the value of other voters, this
principle would be sufficiently protected. In large number of
elections to different democratic institutions in our Country, as
well as outside there are different methods of voting which have all
stood the test of one man one vote principle. This issue was
examined at considerable length by a Single Judge of this Court in
Special Civil Application No.1870/2006 and connected matters by
order dated 4-6.9.2006. In the said decision examining the
applicability of one man one vote principle for election of
Federal Cooperative Society, following observations were made :
43. In
order to do so, one may notice the concept of one man one vote
principle. Though the democratic governemts have existed in the
world since a fairly long time, right to vote without any
discrimination of race, caste, creed or religion is of a relatively
recent development. Till quite recently, in number of countries,
certain communities did not have full voting rights. Right to vote
for women also was recognized much later on. One man one vote
principle in its refined form is an origination of United States of
America. From the Article titled "Defying One-person, One-Vote
: Prisoners and the "Usual Residence" Principle by Rosanna
M. Taormina, one finds that on the basis of the Article 1, section 2
of the United States Constitution which provides that the House of
Representatives shall be composed of Members chosen every second
year by the People of the several States and representatives shall
be apportioned among the several States according to their
respective members, the Supreme Court of United States has formulated
the principle of one person one vote. In doing so, the Court relied
on the equal protection clause of the Fourteenth Amendment to extend
the one-person, one-vote requirement to state legislative districts.
In the year 1963 and 1964, the US Supreme Court decided three
landmark redistricting cases which are credited with the development
of the phrase and principle, "one person, one vote".
History and development of this principle of one-man one-vote have
been noted by a Division Bench of this Court in the case of Harji
Chaku v. Mamlatdar, Lalpur, (15 GLR 64)(supra). It is further
observed that this principle is accepted as valid principle by our
Courts also. The Court however hinted that in federal analogy, some
compromise or concession is inherent.
43.1 In
Unites States of America, election to the President is held based on
plurality voting which has come to be known as first-past-the-post
method in which a candidate getting majority of votes in a State
irrespective of the margin of majority carries the entire electorate
of the State in his tally for the Presidential election. It can be
easily seen that under such a system, it is possible to envisage a
situation, and in fact situations have arisen in the past when a
candidate getting lesser number of popular votes gets elected to the
Presidential post whereas his rival while getting higher number of
votes may get defeated. (Source: On Democracy by Robert A. Dahl)
44. One-man
one-vote principle has many facets. It does not carry a rigid
meaning that every citizen shall vote once for one single candidate
and every such vote shall have equal weightage. Under the Indian
democracy itself, one-man, one-vote principle manifests in number of
situations. For election to the members of the State Legislature or
to the house of the people, every adult citizen who is otherwise
qualified to vote casts a vote once in favour of one single
candidate. This system, however, is criticized by the critics
since in multi-facet contests in large number of cases, candidates
with less than 50 per cent popular votes end up getting elected. In
other words, though majority of the voters exercising their franchise
may have voted against a candidate, he gets elected by having
cornered more votes than any other candidate. To eliminate this
element, in some of the European countries for Presidential
elections, a different pattern of franchise is adopted whereby
initially voters vote for a single candidate. Upon counting if a
candidate gets more than 50% votes, he is declared elected. If not,
only two candidates with highest number of tally of votes remain in
fray and rest of the candidates get eliminated. For these two
candidates, the electors vote all over again and whoever gets
majority of the votes is declared elected. (Source: Voting Procedures
Under Uncertainty: By Hannu Nurmi)
45. For
election to the members of the Upper House of Parliament also called
council of States, a complex method of single transferable vote is
adopted. In this method, one candidate makes multiple choices and
depending on the quotient required for getting elected, the counting
takes place to ensure that the single largest group in the Assembly
does not corner all seats by its sheer majority.
46. For
election to the President of the Country, a very different
methodology is adopted. Article 55 of the Constitution provides
inter alia, that as far as practicable, there shall be uniformity in
the scale of representation of different States at the election of
the President. To ensure that, following provisions are made in
Article 55 of the Constitution:...
....It
can thus be seen that in democratic set up, one-man one-vote is
being implemented in different fashion to suit different
requirements. Every system is open to criticism of not being able to
fully fulfill the aspirations of the electorates. Often,
allegations are made of manipulation in arrangement of
constituencies in such a way that prospects of election of a
candidate are improved. This method of redistricting (referred to
as delimitation in India) in American parlance, is called
"Gerrymandering".
47. The
crux of the matter is that one-man one-vote principle cannot
be seen superficially providing for simple formula where one
single voter votes for a single candidate but it has many different
manifestations.
It
may be noted that the said decision came to be confirmed by the
Division Bench of the High Court.
In
the present case, statutory provisions provide that three
Councillors shall be elected from each ward of a Municipal
Corporation. Each voter has to caste vote once but has to indicate
his preference for three candidates, who according to him are best
suited to represent the ward. We do not see how this methodology is
opposed to principle of one man one vote . Weightage of vote
caste each voter is the same. Simply because each voter is asked to
show his preference for three candidates to represent the ward, that
by itself does not bring about any inequality in weightage of the
votes caste by different voters. This contention of the petitioner
therefore, deserves to be turned down.
Coming
to the question of validity of statutory provisions, as already
noted, List-II i.e. State List to Schedule-7 pertains to local
government i.e. constitution and powers of Municipal Corporations
etc. and other local authorities for the purpose of self -government
or village administration. It can thus be seen that the State
Legislature is competent to make laws concerning local government
such as constitution and powers of Municipal Corporations and other
local authorities of local self-government. The State Legislature
thus was competent to provide for laws governing the constitution of
Municipal Corporations which necessarily include the manner and
method of holding elections to such Municipal Corporations. It was
therefore, in exercise of such powers that the State Legislature has
made provisions for constitution of Corporations under Section 5 of
the BPMC Act.
13.1
Under Sub-section(1) of Section 456 of the BPMC Act, the State
Government has the power to make rules for carrying out the purposes
of the Act. In exercise of such powers read with Section 5 of the
BPMC Act, the Delimitation Rules of 1994 have been framed.
13.2 Under
Sub-section 5(3)(iii)(a) of the BPMC Act, the State Government is
authorized by notification in the official gazette to determine the
number of wards into which the city shall be divided, number of
Councillors to be elected to the Corporation and number of seats to
be reserved in favor of Scheduled Castes, the Scheduled Tribes, the
Backward classes and women. We may briefly note at this stage that
this provision itself envisages multi-member wards. If each
Municipal ward had to have one and only one Councillor, there was no
need to authorise the Government separately to determine number of
wards in a city and number of councillors that to be elected to the
Corporation.
13.3 This
position is made further clear under Rule 4 of the Delimitation
Rules of 1994, where it is provided that all Wards shall be
multi-member wards with three councillors to be elected from each
ward.
We
do not find that the above provisions contained in the BPMC Act and
Rules framed thereunder are in any manner opposed to the
Constitutional provisions. Clause(1) of Article 243R provides that
all seats in the Municipality shall be filled by persons chosen by
direct election from the territorial constituencies for which
purpose Municipal area shall be divided into territorial
constituencies called wards. Clause(1) of of Article 243R thus
provides for division of larger municipal area into different wards
and for direct election to elect representatives from such wards
14.1 Sub-clause(2)
of Article 243R permits the State Legislature to make laws for
representation in a Municipality by nomination of persons having
special knowledge or experience in municipal administration and such
other categories.
14.2 Article
243R thus provides for composition of municipalities through elected
as also nominated members, if so, provided by the State Legislature.
Article 243R is thus complete code for composition of
Municipalities.
14.3 On
the other hand, Article 243S pertains to constitution and
composition of Wards Committees. It provides inter-alia for
constitution of Wards Committees consisting of one or more wards
within the territorial area of Municipality having a population of
three lakhs or more. Clause(3) of Article 243S provides that a
member of a Municipality representing a ward within the territorial
area of the Wards Committee, shall be a member of that Committee.
Clause(4) of Article 243S in particular, provides that where a
Wards Committee consists of one ward, the member representing that
ward shall be the chairperson of that Committee and if the Wards
Committee consists of two or more wards, one of the members
representing such wards in the Municipality who is elected by
members of the Wards Committee, shall be the Chairperson of that
Committee. It is true that clause(4) of Article 243R is worded in
such a way that it refers to wards of the Municipalities having a
single representative. However, Clause(2) of Article 243S permits
the State Legislature to make laws making provisions with respect to
composition and territorial area of the Wards Committee and the
manner in which the seats shall be filled. It is therefore, for the
State Legislature to make suitable legislation providing for
composition of the Wards Committee and the manner in which the Wards
committee of a multi-member wards shall elect its chairperson. In
any case, we are of the view that such difficulties in working out
the provisions of Article 243S in case of multi-member wards cannot
govern the interpretation of Article 243R of the Constitution. As
already noted, Article 243R pertains to composition of
Municipalities whereas Article 243S pertains to constitution and
composition of Wards Committee. Both operate in different fields.
Interpretation of Article 243S therefore, cannot govern the
provisions contained in Article 243R.
14.4 To
reiterate, in our view Article 243R which makes detailed provision
for composition of Municipalities nowhere restricts the power of
State Legislature to provide for multi-member wards in
Municipalities. The Constitutional provisions do not prohibit
multi-member wards and as already noted the State Legislation is
competent to make laws with respect to election to the
Municipalities. Therefore, providing for multi-member wards through
validly formulated State Legislation, in our view is not
impermissible. None of the provisions contained in the BPMC Act or
the Delimitation Rules of 1994 which are under challenge in this
petition violate constitutional provisions. We have already held
that State is competent to make laws with respect to municipal
elections. Thus when we find that State neither lacks competence nor
in our view any of the statutory provisions are in conflict with
Article 243R or 243S of the Constitution or any other provision,
challenge to the vires of said provisions must fail. We therefore,
hold that Section 5(3)(iii)(a) and Sections 29A(2)(a) and 29A(3)(a)
of the Bombay Provincial Municipal Corporation Act, 1949, as also
Rule 4 of the Bombay Provincial Municipal Corporations (Delimitation
of Wards in the City and Allocation of Reserved Seats) Rule, 1994
and Rule 2(b) of Gujarat Municipal Corporation Wards Committee
Functions, Duties, Territorial Areas and Procedure for Transaction
of Business Rules, 2007 are constitutionally valid.
In
case of Goa Glass Fibre Limited v. State of Goa and another
reported in (2010) 6 Supreme Court Cases 499, it was observed that :
It is well settled that a statute can be invalidated or held
unconstitutional on limited grounds viz. on the ground of the
incompetence of the legislature which enacts it and on the ground
that it breaches or violates any of the fundamental rights or other
constitutional rights and on no other grounds. (See State of A.P. v.
Mc. Dowell and Co. and Kuldip Nayar v. Union of India.)
15.1 Principle
of presumption of Constitutionality of a statutory provision has
been long accepted by the Courts in India. In case of the State
of Jammu & Kashmir v. Triloki Nath Khosa and others reported
in AIR 1974 Supreme Court 1, five Judge Bench of the Apex Court
noted that with approval observations made in the previous judgement
in case of AIR 1958 SC 538 as under :
"That
where a party seeks to impeach the validity of a rule made by
a competent authority on the ground that the rules offend Art. 14
the burden is on him to plead and prove the infirmity is too well
established to need elaboration." The burden thus is on the
respondents to set out facts necessary to sustain the plea of
discrimination and to adduce "cogent and convincing evidence"
to prove those facts for "there is a presumption that every
factor which is relevant or material has been taken into account in
formulating the classifications.
It
was further observed that :
25.
Thus, it is no part of the appellants burden to justify the
classification or to establish its constitutionality. Formal
education may not always produce excellence but a classification
founded on variant educational qualifications is, for purposes of
promotion to the post of an Executive Engineer, to say the least,
not unjust on the fact of it and the onus therefore cannot shift
from where it originally lay.
Above
principles of presumption of constitutionality would also persuade
us not to declare the statutory provisions challenged in the present
petition as ultra vires.
We
have discussed at some length the scheme of the statutory provisions
including the Constitutional provisions for conducting elections to
the Municipal Corporation and found that no illegality has been
committed. Reference to Article 170 of the Constitution which
pertains to composition of the Legislative Assemblies, therefore,
would not be necessary.
We
may recall that counsel for the respondents have relied on Article
243ZG to contend that validity of above statutory provisions cannot
be called in question. We are doubtful whether the provisions under
challenge can be stated to be those relating to the validity of
any law relating to the delimitation of constituencies or the
allotment of seats to such constituencies . Prima facie, it
appears that providing for multi-member wards in Municipalities is
neither a law relating to delimitation of constituencies nor
allotment of seats to such constituencies. However, in view of our
conclusion that even otherwise said statutory provisions are not
ultra vires, we do not dilate any further on this aspect of the
matter leaving it open to be judged in an appropriate case in
future.
In
the result, petition fails. Same is dismissed. Civil Application
also stands dismissed accordingly.
(S.J.Mukhopadhaya,C.J.)
(Akil
Kureshi,J.)
(raghu)
Top