Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant is the State of Gujarat, which filed this Letters Patent Appeal against the judgment and order dated April 9, 2002 of the learned single Judge in Special Civil Application No. 8913 of 2001.

The respondent was employed in the State Irrigation Department as a Chowkidar on a daily-wage basis. His services were terminated on February 15, 1999 on the ground that no work was available. He raised an industrial dispute that was referred to the Labour Court, Kalol as Reference (LCK) No. 330 of 1999.

By award dated September 15, 2000, the Labour Court set aside the termination order and ordered reinstatement with continuity in service and other benefits, except back wages. The State challenged that award before the High Court by way of Special Civil Application No. 8913 of 2001. The learned single Judge dismissed the writ petition, refusing to consider a jurisdictional contention raised for the first time in that writ jurisdiction. The State has now challenged that dismissal by Letters Patent Appeal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Irrigation Department of the State is an "industry" under the Industrial Disputes Act such that the Labour Court had jurisdiction to entertain a reference concerning a workman employed therein.
  2. Whether the Letters Patent Appeal is maintainable when the writ petition before the single Judge invoked Article 226 and/or Article 227 of the Constitution and was dismissed on merits.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant-State of Gujarat (as advanced by Shri Pancholi, Assistant Government Pleader)

  • The learned single Judge erred in refusing to consider the State's jurisdictional contention that the Irrigation Department is not an "industry" and therefore the Labour Court had no jurisdiction to entertain the Reference.
  • Relied on the Honourable Supreme Court judgment in Executive Engineer (State of Karnataka) v. K. Somasetty (1997 (5) SCC 434 : 1997-II-LLJ-698) which held that the Irrigation Department is not an "industry".
  • Relied further on Division Bench authority in Shankerji Chelaji Thakor v. State of Gujarat (2000-II-LLJ-239 (Guj)) which similarly held the Irrigation Department is not an "industry".
  • Contended that the writ petition invoked jurisdiction under Articles 226 and 227, so Letters Patent Appeal was maintainable; relied on Lokmat Newspapers Pvt. Ltd. v. Shankarprasad (AIR 1999 SC 2423 : 1999 (6) SCC 275 : 1999-II-LLJ-600).
  • Submitted that subsequent Supreme Court decisions since 1995 (including Union of India v. Jai Narain Singh and State of Himachal Pradesh v. Suresh Kumar Verma) consistently held that an Irrigation Department of the State is not an "industry", and thus the Labour Court lacked jurisdiction.

Respondent-Workman (as advanced by Shri Adeshra)

  • Raised a preliminary objection to the maintainability of the Letters Patent Appeal, contending that the single Judge exercised powers under Article 227 in refusing interference with the Labour Court award; therefore LPA would not be maintainable.
  • Contended that the Supreme Court in K. Somasetty did not consider an earlier Supreme Court judgment in Des Raj v. State of Punjab (AIR 1988 SC 1182 : 1988 (2) SCC 537 : 1988-II-LLJ-149) and suggested that if the earlier authority had been considered, the later bench might have taken a different view. Noted that a single Judge had referred a matter to the Division Bench in view of the purported conflict between the two Supreme Court decisions.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Executive Engineer (State of Karnataka) v. K. Somasetty and Ors., 1997 (5) SCC 434 : 1997-II-LLJ-698 Held that the Irrigation Department of the State Government cannot be said to be an "industry". The Court relied on this Supreme Court authority as one of the direct judgments establishing that the Irrigation Department is not an "industry", supporting the conclusion that the Labour Court lacked jurisdiction.
Shankerji Chelaji Thakor v. State of Gujarat, 2000-II-LLJ-239 (Guj) Division Bench view that the State's public welfare functions are sovereign and the State is not an "industry" under the Industrial Disputes Act; also noted the project had closed and the daily-wage appointee had no right to the post. The Court noted that this Division Bench decision followed the later Supreme Court view and applied it to confirm that the Labour Court lacked jurisdiction in the present case.
Lokmat Newspapers Pvt. Ltd. v. Shankarprasad, AIR 1999 SC 2423 : 1999 (6) SCC 275 : 1999-II-LLJ-600 Explains that where jurisdiction under both Articles 226 and 227 is invoked, and the writ petition is dismissed on merits, it is not correct to treat the single Judge's exercise as only under Article 227 for purpose of LPA maintainability. The Court applied this principle to hold that the Letters Patent Appeal was maintainable because the writ petition had invoked Article 226 as well as Article 227.
Des Raj v. State of Punjab, AIR 1988 SC 1182 : 1988 (2) SCC 537 : 1988-II-LLJ-149 An earlier Supreme Court view (as reported) that was said to treat the relevant service as an "industry". The respondent relied on this decision to argue conflict with later authority; the Court observed the existence of this earlier view but concluded that subsequent Supreme Court decisions had taken a consistent contrary view.
Prakashkumar Prahladbhai Patel v. District Primary Education Officer, 2000 (3) GLR 2467 (Full Bench) Full Bench authority of the High Court referenced by counsel as relevant to whether a reference made by a single Judge would be rendered redundant. The Court acknowledged the Full Bench judgment and stated it would not express an opinion on whether the reference made by the single Judge was redundant; left that matter for determination when it arises.
Union of India v. Jai Narain Singh, 1995 Supp. (4) SCC 672 : 1996-II-LLJ-750 One of the Supreme Court decisions relied upon in later judgments to support the view that an Irrigation Department is not an "industry". The Court treated this as part of a series of later Supreme Court decisions whose consistent view weighed decisively in concluding that the Irrigation Department is not an "industry".
State of Himachal Pradesh v. Suresh Kumar Verma, AIR 1996 SC 1565 : 1996 (7) SCC 562 Another Supreme Court decision relied on as part of consistent authority that the Irrigation Department is not an "industry". The Court relied on this decision as part of the consistent Supreme Court jurisprudence that led to the conclusion that the Labour Court lacked jurisdiction.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court addressed two principal strands of analysis: (1) the preliminary objection to maintainability of the Letters Patent Appeal and (2) the jurisdictional question whether the Irrigation Department is an "industry".

On maintainability, the Court examined the averments and the nature of jurisdiction invoked in the original writ petition. Applying the principle from Lokmat Newspapers that where both Articles 226 and 227 are invoked and a petition is dismissed on merits it cannot be treated as an exercise solely under Article 227, the Court concluded that the learned single Judge had exercised jurisdiction under Article 226 as well as Article 227. Therefore, the Letters Patent Appeal was maintainable and the preliminary objection raised by the respondent was rejected.

On the jurisdictional issue, the Court considered the line of Supreme Court authorities. While noting the earlier decision in Des Raj, the Court observed that since 1995 there have been three later Supreme Court decisions (including Union of India v. Jai Narain Singh and State of Himachal Pradesh v. Suresh Kumar Verma and K. Somasetty) that consistently held the Irrigation Department of the State is not an "industry". The Division Bench of the High Court had also followed that later view in Shankerji Chelaji Thakor. Given this consistent later Supreme Court jurisprudence and the Division Bench follow-up, the Court concluded it was bound to accept that the Irrigation Department is not an "industry" and consequently the Labour Court had no jurisdiction to entertain the Reference in relation to the respondent-workman.

The Court declined to enter into the question whether the reference made by the learned single Judge (purportedly to resolve conflict) was redundant in view of the Full Bench judgment in Prakashkumar Prahladbhai Patel's case, stating that it would leave that question to be decided when that matter arises. The Court also admonished counsel for making submissions about a reference without placing the order of reference on record.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Letters Patent Appeal is allowed. The Court's core rulings are as follows:
The judgment and order dated April 9, 2002 passed by the learned single Judge in Special Civil Application No. 8913 of 2001 is quashed and set aside.
The writ petition (Special Civil Application No. 8913 of 2001) is accepted, and the impugned judgment and award of the Labour Court dated September 15, 2000 in Reference (LCK) No. 330 of 1999 is quashed and set aside on the ground that the Labour Court had no jurisdiction because the Irrigation Department of the State is not an "industry".

Direct consequences and practical implications:

  • The Labour Court's reinstatement order in favor of the respondent-workman has been set aside; the State's appeal succeeds on the jurisdictional ground.
  • The Letters Patent Appeal is allowed with no order as to costs. Civil Application No. 7639 of 2002 does not survive and the rule issued on that Civil Application stands discharged with no costs.
  • The respondent-workman was informed that he remains free to pursue any alternative remedies available to him under law and challenge his dismissal before any appropriate forum; the Court expressly noted that its decision rested solely on the question of jurisdiction and did not address the merits of the dismissal.
  • No novel precedent was laid down by this Court in the opinion; rather, the decision follows and applies the later, consistent Supreme Court authorities and the Division Bench of this High Court on the precise legal question whether a State Irrigation Department constitutes an "industry".

Note: This summary is strictly confined to the material and reasoning contained in the provided opinion and does not add facts or inferences beyond that text.

    State Of Gujarat v. Deenanji Bidhaji Thakore .

    Shethna, J.

    1. The appellant-State of Gujarat, by this Letters Patent Appeal, has challenged the judgment and order dated April 9, 2002, passed by the learned single Judge of this Court (Coram: D.H. WAGHELA, J.) in Special Civil Application No. 8913 of 2001.

    2. The respondent-workman was working in the Irrigation Department of the State of Gujarat as Chowkidar, on daily wage basis. His services were terminated on February 15, 1999, on the ground that no work was available. He, therefore, raised an industrial dispute which, ultimately, was referred to the Labour Court, Kalol, registered as Reference (LCK) No. 330 of 1999. The Labour Court by its award dated September 15, 2000, set aside the order of termination of the respondent-workman and ordered to reinstate the workman in service with all other benefits, except back wages.

    3. The aforesaid award passed by the Labour Court was challenged by the appellant-State of Gujarat before this Court by way of Special Civil Application No. 8913 of 2001. Before the learned single Judge of this Court, a specific contention was raised that the workman was working in the Irrigation Department of the State of Gujarat, which is not an "industry", therefore, the Labour Court had no jurisdiction to entertain the Reference and pass award in favour of the respondent-workman. In support of the said contention, reliance was placed on the judgment of the Honourable Supreme Court in the case of Executive Engineer (State of Karnataka) v. K. Somasetty and Ors., reported in 1997 (5) SCC 434 : 1997-II-LLJ-698. However, the learned single Judge of this Court, in absence of any such contention raised before the Labour Court, refused to consider same for the first time in his writ jurisdiction and dismissed the writ petition. This has been challenged in this Letters Patent Appeal by the appellant-State of Gujarat.

    4. Learned Assistant Government Pleader, Shri Pancholi, appearing for the appellant-State of Gujarat, vehemently, submitted that the learned single Judge committed an error in rejecting the contention raised by the appellant before him that the Irrigation Department of the State is not an "Industry", therefore, the Labour Court had no jurisdiction to entertain the Reference and pass the award. He submitted that when a neat question of jurisdiction was raised before the learned single Judge of this Court in the writ petition, then, he should have permitted the appellant-State to raise it and decided the same in accordance with laws. He submitted that the Honourable Supreme Court in case of K, Somasetty (supra), has held that Irrigation Department of the State Government cannot be said to be an "Industry". He further submitted that, relying on the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in K. Somasetty's case (supra), Division Bench of this Court in case of Shankerji Chelaji Thakor v. State of Gujarat, 2000-II-LLJ-239 (Guj), also held that the Irrigation Department of the State Government is not an "Industry". He, therefore, submitted that this appeal be allowed and the order passed by the learned single Judge dismissing the writ petition, i.e. Special Civil Application No. 8913 of 2001, be quashed and set aside and the writ petition filed by the appellate-State be accepted and the impugned award passed by the Labour Court be quashed and set aside.

    5. Learned counsel, Shri Adeshra, appearing for the respondent-workman, however, raised a preliminary objection regarding the maintainability of this Letters Patent Appeal. He submitted that the impugned award passed by the Labour Court was challenged by the appellant-State of Gujarat before this Court under Article 227 of the Constitution and the learned single Judge of this Court, in exercise of his powers under Article 227, refused to interfere with the award and dismissed the petition. Therefore, Letters Patent Appeal would not be maintainable. As against that, the learned Assistant Government Pleader, Shri Pancholi, submitted that the appellant-State of Gujarat had filed writ petition not only under Article 227 of the Constitution, but it was filed also under Article 226 and in such type of cases, where the petition was filed under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution, then Letters Patent Appeal would certainly be maintainable. In support of his contention, he has relied on the judgment of the Honourable Supreme Court in case of Lokmat Newspapers Pvt. Ltd. v. Shankarprasad, AIR 1999 SC 2423 : 1999 (6) SCC 275 : 1999-II-LLJ-600. In that case, Honourable Supreme Court has observed that, it was open to the respondent to invoke the jurisdiction of the High Court both under Articles 226 and 227. Once such a jurisdiction was invoked and when the writ petition was dismissed on merits, it cannot be said that the learned single Judge has exercised his jurisdiction only under Article 227. The aforesaid conclusion was arrived at by the Honourable Supreme Court from the relevant averments made in the writ petition and the nature of jurisdiction invoked by the respondent.

    6. In the instant case, from the relevant averments made in the writ petition and the jurisdiction invoked by the appellant is original petitioner, it is clear that the learned single Judge of this Court has exercised his jurisdiction under Article 226 and also under Article 227 of the Constitution. Thus, in our, considered opinion, on facts of the present case, it is clear that in the instant case, Letters Patent Appeal is maintainable. Thus, the preliminary objection raised by learned counsel Shri Adeshra is rejected.

    7. Learned counsel, Shri Adeshra, then contended that the Honourable Supreme Court, while deciding the case of K. Somasetty (supra) had not considered its earlier judgment in the case of Des Raj v. State of Punjab, reported in AIR 1988 SC 1182 : 1988 (2) SCC 537 : 1988-II-LLJ-149. He submitted that, if the previous judgment of the Honourable Supreme Court was cited and considered in the later as judgment, then, the subsequent Bench of the Honourable Supreme Court might not have taken the view that Irrigation Department of the State is not an "Industry". He also submitted that, recently, a learned a single Judge of this Court has referred one matter to the Division Bench in view of the aforesaid conflicting judgments of the Honourable Supreme Court reported in 1988-II-LLJ-149 (supra) and 1997-II-LLJ-698 (supra).

    8. Shri Pancholi, learned Assistant Government Pleader for the appellant, firstly, submitted that without placing any such order on record, learned counsel Shri Adeshra should not have made such submission. He, then submitted that even if such reference is made, then also in view of Full Bench judgment of this Court in case of Prakashkumar Prahladbhai Patel v. District Primary Education Officer, 2000 (3) GLR 2467, reference, if any, made by the learned single Judge of this Court, on this point, would become absolutely redundant and it should not deter this Court from deciding this appeal on the question of jurisdiction. Shri Pancholi further submitted that, in Des Raj's case (supra), the Supreme Court took a view that it was an "Industry". However, later on, in case of K. Somasetty (supra), the Honourable Supreme Court has clearly held that Irrigation Department of the State is not an "Industry". For taking that view, the Honourable Supreme Court has relied upon its previous two judgments (1) Union of India v. Jai Narain Singh, 1995 Supp. (4) SCC 672 : 1996-II-LLJ-750 and (2) State of Himachal Pradesh v. Suresh Kumar Verma, AIR 1996 SC 1565 : 1996 (7) SCC 562. Thus the Hon'ble Supreme Court, right from 1995, in as many as three judgments, took the consistent view that Irrigation Department of the State cannot be said to be an "industry". He, therefore, submitted that, as laid down by the Honourable Supreme Court, this Court has to follow later judgments of the Honourable Supreme Court.

    9. We are in complete agreement with the submission made by learned Assistant Government Pleader, Shri Pancholi. After the judgment of the Honourable Supreme Court in Des Raj's case (supra), there are as many as three judgments of the Honourable Supreme Court and in all the three judgments the Honourable Supreme Court has taken a consistent view that the Irrigation Department of the State Government is not an "Industry". This consistent view of the Honourable Supreme Court expressed since 1995 onwards was also followed by the Division Bench of this Court in Shankerji Chelaji Thakor's case (supra), wherein it has been observed that:

    "The function of public welfare of the State is a sovereign function. It is the constitutional mandate under the Directive Principles that the Government should bring about welfare State by all executives and legislative actions. Under these circumstances, the State is not an "industry" under the Industrial Disputes Act. Even otherwise, since the project has been closed, the respondent has no right to the post since he had been appointed on daily wages."

    10. In view of the above, when there are three later direct judgments of the Honourable Supreme Court on this point and when those judgments have been followed by Division Bench of this Court in 2001, then, we are of the considered opinion that the reference made by the learned single Judge on this point should not come in our way in deciding the issue before us. We are not inclined to express any opinion on the reference made by the learned single Judge of this Court, whether such reference is redundant or not in view of the Full Bench judgment of this Court in the case of Prakashkumar Prahladbhai Patel's case (supra), as submitted by learned Assistant Government Pleader, Shri Pancholi. As and when that matter comes up before the Court, the same will have to be decided in accordance with law.

    11. However, when there are as many as three later judgments of the Honourable Supreme Court on this point, namely, that Irrigation Department of the State is not an "Industry", followed by the Division Bench of this Court in Shankerji Chelaji Thakor's case in 2001, then we have no option but to accept this Letters Patent Appeal, as the Irrigation Department of the State of Gujarat is not an "Industry". Thus, therefore, the Labour Court had no jurisdiction to entertain the Reference.

    12. Before, parting, we may only state that without the order of reference on hand, learned counsel should not have made submission that the learned single Judge of this Court has made a reference on this point.

    13. In view of the above discussion, the judgment order dated April 9, 2002 passed by the learned single Judge of this Court, dismissing Special Civil Application No. 8913 of 2001 is hereby quashed and set aside and the writ petition, i.e. Special Civil Application No. 8913 of 2001 is accepted and the impugned judgment and award passed by the Labour Court on September 15, 2000 in Reference (LCK) No. 330 of 1999, setting aside the dismissal order of the respondent-workman from service and reinstating him in service with continuity in service is hereby quashed and set aside on the ground that the Labour Court had no jurisdiction to entertain reference in case of a workman of the Irrigation Department of the State. Accordingly, Letters Patent Appeal is allowed with no order as to costs. Civil Application No. 7639 of 2002 does not survive as the main appeal is dismissed. Hence, Rule issued on Civil Application stands discharged with no costs.

    14. At this stage, learned counsel, Shri Adeshra, for the respondent-workman submitted that he may be allowed to challenge the impugned order of dismissal before any other appropriate forum. For that, our permission is not necessary, as without going into the merits of the case, only on the ground of jurisdiction, we have allowed this Letters Patent Appeal. The respondent-workman can always avail any other alternative remedy available to him under the law and challenge his order of dismissal before appropriate forum by way of appropriate proceedings.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    State Of Gujarat v. Deenanji Bidhaji Thakore .
    (Apr 9, 2003)