Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Smart Summary

Summary of Opinion by V. Kameswar Rao, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

This writ petition challenges the order dated 30.07.2009 of the Central Administrative Tribunal (Principal Bench, New Delhi) in O.A. No. 536/2009, which allowed the Original Application filed by the respondent. The respondent's O.A. had attacked a communication dated 04.07.2008 from the petitioner rejecting his request for financial upgradation under the Assured Career Progression Scheme (ACPS).

Relevant employment facts (as stated in the opinion): the respondent was appointed as a Rakshak in the Railway Protection Force on 30.03.1968 in the grade Rs. 70-85. He was medically de-categorized and thereafter absorbed as Khallasi on 20.04.1979 (grade Rs. 196-232). He received promotions: Recorded Sorter (04.09.1986; Rs. 210-270), Record Lifter (08.02.1987; Rs. 225-308), and Senior Record Lifter (June 1996) in the grade Rs. 950-1400, subsequently revised by the Fifth Pay Commission to Rs. 3050-4590. The pay of Rakshak was also revised by the Fifth Pay Commission to Rs. 3050-4590.

The respondent superannuated on 31.01.2004. Following the Fifth Pay Commission recommendations, the Government issued instructions for grant of financial upgradation under ACPS. An earlier order dated 19.01.2007 denied the respondent's ACPS claim on the ground that a DoP&T circular of 2001 had no applicability; the respondent challenged that order in O.A. No. 950/2007. The Tribunal allowed that O.A. and directed a fresh order addressing the respondent's contentions. A subsequent communication dated 04.07.2008 again rejected the respondent's claim, leading to the Tribunal proceedings culminating in the impugned 30.07.2009 order.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the respondent, who was medically de-categorized from the post of Rakshak and later absorbed and promoted to posts that placed him in the pay scale Rs. 3050-4590, is entitled to financial upgradation under the ACPS in view of the DoP&T clarification (2001) and the Government instructions arising from the Fifth Pay Commission.
  2. Whether the petitioners' refusal to grant ACPS benefits on the ground that the respondent was not selected/promoted as Clerk before 21.12.1997, and because he was absorbed as Khallasi and subsequently promoted, is legally tenable.
  3. Whether the clarification (annexed at page 33/33A of the paper book) should be applied retrospectively to the respondent's claim and treated as part of the original claim if it is not inconsistent.

Arguments of the Parties

Respondent's Position

  • The respondent asserted entitlement to ACPS financial upgradations: the first upgradation to the grade Rs. 4500-7000 and the second upgradation to the grade Rs. 5000-8000, after 12 and 24 years of service respectively (as claimed by him in the proceedings).
  • Implicit in the challenge is the reliance on the DoP&T clarification and the principle that past service in the grade of Rakshak (Rs. 3050-4590) should be counted when determining eligibility for ACPS, where subsequent postings/promotions place the employee in the same pay scale he earlier held prior to medical de-categorization.

Petitioners' (Respondent-Authorities') Position

  • By the communication dated 04.07.2008, the petitioners rejected the respondent's claim on the basis that the DoP&T circular of 2001 had no applicability to him.
  • The petitioners also took the position that because the respondent had not been selected/promoted as a Clerk before 21.12.1997, had been absorbed as Khallasi, and had subsequently received promotions, his claim for ACPS financial upgradation was not tenable.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court reviewed the DoP&T clarification annexed to the record (page 33/33A). The clarification states, in effect, that because the pay of Rakshak and Clerk is the same (Rs. 3050-4590 as revised), Rakshaks who were medically de-categorized and absorbed against an alternative post and subsequently promoted to a post that carries the same scale (Rs. 3050-4590) may be granted financial upgradation under ACPS by counting their past service in the grade of Rakshak, subject to other prescribed conditions.

Applying the clarification to the facts, the court observed that the respondent, although he had received three promotions culminating in the Senior Record Lifter post in the revised scale Rs. 3050-4590, did not obtain promotion to a grade above Rs. 3050-4590 (the Rakshak scale). The court reasoned that there is no material distinction, for purposes of the clarification, between being designated a Clerk or a Khallasi where the employee was medically de-categorized and is currently in the identical pay scale of Rs. 3050-4590.

The Tribunal's analysis — adopted by the court — included the following legal-interpretive points:

“A clarification issued under the scheme would relate back to the date when the original claim is formulated and if it is not inconsistent, the same would be treated as a part of it. On literal construction, which is a beneficial one in the present case ... the promotion has put him to pay scale, which he enjoyed earlier had there not been any medical de-categorization. Accordingly, keeping in view the stagnation, as these three promotions earned would not be treated as removing the stagnation but to achieve to the pay scale he has lost by way of medical de-categorization, the ACP has been allowed to him.”

The court agreed with the Tribunal's conclusion that the three promotions did not constitute advancement to a grade genuinely higher than the Rakshak pay scale, but rather restored the respondent to the pay scale he had previously held before medical de-categorization. Therefore, the promotions should not be treated as removing the stagnation that arose from the de-categorization; instead, ACPS benefits ought to be granted to mitigate the loss caused by medical de-categorization.

On this basis, the court found no infirmity in the Tribunal's ultimate conclusion directing the petitioners to grant the ACPS benefits with arrears to the respondent, and it dismissed the writ petition.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The writ petition is dismissed. The court upheld the Tribunal's order allowing the Original Application and directing the petitioners to grant the respondent the benefits of ACPS (financial upgradations) with arrears.

Implications:

  • The direct effect is that the respondent is entitled to the ACPS financial upgradations as directed by the Tribunal, with arrears payable in accordance with that direction.
  • The court relied on and applied the DoP&T clarification as a permissible interpretation benefiting the respondent and treating that clarification as relating back to the date of the original claim where it is not inconsistent.
  • The opinion does not purport to lay down any new legal precedent beyond affirming the Tribunal's application of the clarification to these facts; no broader implications or novel legal principles are discussed in the text beyond the immediate effect on the parties.

No costs were awarded.

    Union Of India Petitioner v. Sh. Raghubir Singh

    V. KAMESWAR RAO, J.

    1. The challenge in the Writ Petition is to the order dated 30.07.2009 passed by the Central Administrative Tribunal, Principal Bench, New Delhi (the Tribunal) in O.A No. 536/2009, whereby the O.A filed by the respondent herein was allowed. The challenge in the O.A was to the communication dated 04.07.2008 issued by the petitioner rejecting the request of the respondent for grant of benefits under the ACPS.

    2. The brief facts are that the respondent was appointed as a Rakshak in Railway Protection Force (RPF) on 30.03.1968 in the grade of Rs. 70-85. He was medically de-categorized. Pursuant thereto, he was appointed as Khallasi on 20.04.1979 in the grade of Rs. 196-232. On 04.09.1986, he was promoted as Recorded Sorter in the grade of Rs. 210-270. He was further promoted as Record Lifter in the grade of Rs. 225-308 with effect from 08.02.1987 and finally as Senior Record Lifter in June, 1996, in the grade of Rs. 950-1400, which was revised by the 5th Pay Commission to Rs. 3050-4590. It may be relevant to note here that the pay of Rakshak was revised by the 5 Pay Commission to Rs. 3050-4590.

    3. The petitioner has since superannuated on 31.01.2004

    4. Pursuant to the recommendation of the 5 Pay Commission, the Government had issued instructions for grant of financial upgradation under the Assured Carrier Progression Scheme. An order dated 19.01.2007 was passed by the petitioner whereunder the request of the respondent for grant of financial upgradation was turned down on the ground that the circular issued by the DoP&T in 2001 has no applicability. The respondent challenged that order in O.A No. 950/2007. The O.A was allowed and the petitioners were directed to pass a fresh order dealing with all the contentions of the respondent. This direction of the Tribunal resulted in a communication dated 04.07.2008, addressed to the respondent from the office of the Divisional Railway Manager being passed, whereby the request of the respondent for grant of benefits under the ACPS was again rejected. It is the case of the respondent that he is entitled to the first financial upgradation in the grade of Rs. 4500-7000 and second financial upgradations in the grade of Rs. 5000-8000 after 12 and 24 years of service respectively.

    5. The petitioners, while rejecting the claim of the respondent, vide their communication dated 04.07.2008, in so far as the applicability of circular 2001 (PS No. 11466 PCV 107) and the respondent's stand stated that since the respondent was not selected/promoted as Clerk before 21.12.1997 and was absorbed as Khallasi and further he got promotions, therefore the claim of the respondent is not tenable.

    6. We have seen the clarification issued in this regard, which is annexed at page 33/33A of the paper book.

    7. The clarification, inter-alia, stipulates that since the pay of Rakshak and clerk is the same i.e Rs. 3050-4590, and Rakshaks who on being medically de-categorized and absorbed against alternative post and subsequently promoted to the post of Clerk may be granted financial upgradation in the present post under the ACPS duly counting their past service in the grade of Rakshak subject to fulfilment of other prescribed conditions. The purport/spirit underlying the clarification is that those Rakshaks, who have been medically de-categorized and absorbed against the alternative post and subsequently promoted to the same scale of Rakshak i.e Rs. 3050-4590, would be eligible for financial upgradation in the present post under ACP scheme.

    8. In the present case, it is seen that even though the respondent had got three promotions and the last one to the post of Sr. Record Lifter in the revised pay scale of Rs. 3050-4590, the same being the scale of Rakshak from which the respondent was medically de-categorized, he did not get promotion to a grade which is over and above the grade of Rakshak i.e Rs. 3050-4590. The clarification stipulates that a clerk who is in the grade of Rs. 3050-4590 is entitled to be granted financial upgradation under the ACPS scheme. We don't see any difference between a person being a clerk or a Khallasi as long as the person was medically de-categorized and is in the grade of Rs. 3050-4590 to be entitled to the benefit of clarification. The Tribunal while allowing the O.A has in para 4 & 5 of the impugned order has held as under:

    “In our considered view, a clarification issued under the scheme would relate back to the date when the original claim is formulated and if it is not inconsistent, the same would be treated as a part of it. On literal construction, which is a beneficial one in the present case as Rakshak, who had been in a higher pay scale equivalent to that of Clerk, on being medically de-categorized when adjusted on a post, which carries much lower pay scale than what he earned as a promotion and reached to the stage, as such, the promotion has put him to pay scale, which he enjoyed earlier had there not been any medical de-categorization. Accordingly, keeping in view the stagnation, as these three promotions earned would not be treated as removing the stagnation but to achieve to the pay scale he has lost by way of medical de-categorization, the ACP has been allowed to him.”

    In the above view of the matter, applicant, who by way of a promotion, has reached the pay scale of Rs. 3050-4590 of a Clerk, which he enjoyed as a Rakshak, is clearly covered by the clarification, which is a rejection of his request by the respondents, is neither reasonable nor justifiable and against the very circular, which had been adopted by the respondents and applied in so many cases. The very act of the respondents is also against the spirit of ACP scheme.

    9. Apart from what has been stated by us in Para Nos. 7 & 8 above, we also agree with the conclusion of the Tribunal that on being medically de-categorized the respondent was adjusted to a post which carries much lower pay scale than what he earned as a promotion. The three promotions earned by the respondent would not be treated as removing the stagnation but to achieve to the pay scale he has lost by way of medical de-categorization, ACP has to be allowed to him. We don't find any infirmity in the ultimate conclusion of the Tribunal whereby the Tribunal direct the petitioners to grant both the benefits of ACP with arrears. We dismiss the present Writ Petition.

    10. No costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Union Of India Petitioner v. Sh. Raghubir Singh
    (May 6, 2013)