Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2010 DHC 1279-DB
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2010 DHC 1279-DB
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Legal Opinion Summary — Veena Birbal, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioners challenged actions relating to compensation under the Land Acquisition Act. Petitioners (petitioner No.1 and Sh. Manoj Kumar; later petitioners Nos.2 and 3 as legal heirs of Sh. Manoj Kumar) were owners of agricultural land forming part of specified khasra numbers, measuring 12 bighas and 5 biswas. A notification under Section 4 was issued on 23.5.2002 followed by a declaration under Section 6 with Section 17(1) on 17.12.2002. An award (No. 16/03-04) was made in favour of the petitioners on 1.10.2003. In October 2003, 80% of the compensation (Rs. 1,87,10,194/- as per the pleadings) was paid, but a balance (Rs. 9,98,203/- plus interest) remained unpaid.

Petitioners sought information under the Right to Information Act regarding any supplementary award; after appeals and a second appeal, respondent disclosed a supplementary award dated 27.10.2004 assessing compensation for trees. Petitioners sought release of that compensation but it was not paid. Respondent stated that certain compensation previously awarded (for illegal superstructures) contravened Section 24 Clause 8, and on directions, a review was undertaken producing a Review Award dated 14.7.2004 which reduced compensation in respect of illegal structures. Petitioners filed these writ petitions seeking quashing of the Review Award and release of the balance/supplementary payments; one of the petitioners also filed W.P.(C) No. 381/2009 challenging the Review Award.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the respondent had the competence under the Land Acquisition Act to review and modify the original award (challenge under provisions such as Section 12 and the limited correction power under Section 13A was raised by petitioners).
  2. Whether petitioners were entitled to the balance of the award and the compensation under the supplementary award, given the respondent's contention that compensation previously paid included amounts for illegal superstructures that must be neglected under Section 24 Clause 8 of the Act.
  3. Whether the writ petitions were barred by delay and laches in the petitioners' prosecution of their claims.
  4. Whether the High Court should exercise its discretionary jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution in the circumstances of this case, where large public money was involved and multiple similarly situated parties had not challenged the Review Award.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The review (Review Award dated 14.7.2004) of the original award dated 1.10.2003 was illegal and contrary to Section 12 of the Land Acquisition Act because once an award is pronounced and filed in the Collector's office it becomes final and conclusive between the Collector and person interested.
  • There is no statutory power conferred on the Collector to review the award; review can only be for arithmetical or clerical errors under Section 13A within six months, and the changes made were on the merits, not mere clerical corrections.
  • Petitioners sought release of the balance payment and alleged non-payment despite representations and an RTI process to discover the existence of a supplementary award.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The original award dated 1.10.2003 disallowed or mis-assessed compensation because it included compensation for illegal superstructures; this was contrary to Section 24 Clause 8 of the Act, and on directions from the appropriate authority (including the Secretary, Land and Building and approval of the Lt. Governor) the matter was re-examined and revised by the Review Award dated 14.7.2004, reducing compensation by Rs. 45,67,005/-.
  • A supplementary award dated 27.10.2004 (No.16-A/04-05) assessed compensation for trees at Rs. 45,36,781.64. Because petitioners had already received payment in excess as per the revised computation, they were not entitled to any further payment under the supplementary award.
  • Notices were issued to interested parties regarding re-examination but the interested parties did not appear before the Land Acquisition Collector (LAC).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
State Of Orissa v. Rajakishore Das, (1996) 4 SCC 221 The principle that unauthorized construction (constructed without permission) does not attract compensation; the State is not bound to pay compensation for structures erected unauthorisedly and which may be ordered to be demolished. The court relied on this authority to support the proposition that compensation for illegal/unautorised structures cannot be allowed; the precedent reinforced the rejection of petitioners' claim for compensation in respect of illegal superstructures.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's analysis proceeded by applying the statutory framework and facts as pleaded and on record:

  1. Admitted factual matrix: The court accepted that the initial award in respect of land and superstructure was made on 1.10.2003 after proceedings under Section 11 and after issuance of notices under Sections 9 and 10; a notice under Section 50 was also issued to the Requisitioning Department, which did not appear or adduce evidence.
  2. Nature of dispute: The core dispute concerned compensation for structures (farm houses and appurtenant constructions) on agricultural land and whether some structures were illegal and thus excluded from compensation.
  3. Statutory provision: The court cited and reproduced Section 24 Clause 8 of the Act which states that the Court shall not take into consideration "any increase to the value of the land on account of its being put to any use which is forbidden by law or opposed to public policy." The court observed that compensation for illegal structures is to be neglected under this provision.
  4. Evidence and pleadings: The Review Award recorded findings about constructions (ground, first and second floors) being in contravention of Building Bye-laws and identified other illegal structures (swimming pool, servant quarters, garage, statues). The petitioners had not denied these averments in rejoinder nor produced material to show compliance with sanction plans or Building Bye-laws.
  5. Principle against allowing benefit from illegal acts: The court held that petitioners cannot take advantage of their own illegal acts and that technicalities cannot defeat express statutory provisions; given the absence of material to the contrary, the deductions in the Review Award were justified.
  6. Reliance on precedent: The court referred to State Of Orissa v. Rajakishore Das to underline the principle that unauthorized construction does not attract compensation and that the authorities are not bound to pay for such construction.
  7. Delay and laches: The court observed a significant delay — the Review Award dated 14.7.2004 and the present petition filed in January 2009 (about four and a half years later). The court found the petitioners' explanation for the delay (stating they learned of the Review Award only in December 2008) inconsistent with their own contemporaneous representation dated 8.1.2007; the court found the explanation unbelievable and concluded the petitions were liable to be dismissed on the ground of delay and laches.
  8. Policy and public interest considerations: The court noted that large public money was involved and that approximately eleven other landowners had similar reductions in compensation under review awards and had not challenged them within five years. Exercising discretionary writ jurisdiction under Article 226 was therefore inappropriate in the court's view.
  9. Other submissions: The court reviewed authorities relied upon by petitioners and found them not relevant to the facts of the present case. The petitioners' separate prayer to refer the matter to the Civil Court was not pressed at argument and so was not considered.

Holding and Implications

Holding: Both writ petitions are dismissed.

Implications:

  • Direct effect: The Review Award dated 14.7.2004, which reduced compensation for illegal superstructures, stands; petitioners' claims for release of the alleged balance and the supplementary award were rejected as a consequence of the court's decision and its findings regarding illegality of structures, lack of supporting record by petitioners, and delay/laches.
  • Reference to civil court: The petitioners' request to make a reference to the Civil Court was not pressed and therefore was not adjudicated upon by the court.
  • Precedential effect: The opinion does not purport to lay down a new principle of law beyond application of existing statutory provision (Section 24 Clause 8) and precedent; no novel precedent was established by this decision.
Writ Petitions dismissed.
To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Naresh Kumar & Ors. v. Govt. Of Nct Of Delhi .

    Veena Birbal, J.— The present two petitions are filed by the petitioners seeking directions for quashing of review award No. 16/03-04 dated 14.7.2004 and for release of balance payment to the petitioners in respect of award No. 16/03-04 dated 1.10.2003 and supplementary award 16-A/04-05 dated 27.10.2004 along with interest and other consequential benefits and to forthwith make the reference filed by the petitioners to the civil Court.

    2. The case of the petitioners is that petitioner No. 1 and Sh. Manoj Kumar were the owners of land forming part of Khasra No. 17 min., 18/1 min., 18/2 min., 19 min. and 20/1 min., in all measuring 12 bighas and 5 biswas. A notification under Section 4 in respect of said land under Land Acquisition Act (hereinafter referred to as ‘the said Act’) was issued on 23.5.2002 The said notification was followed by a declaration under Section 6 along with Section 17(1) of the said Act on 17.12.2002 On 1.10.2003, respondent made an award bearing No. 16/03-04 in favour of petitioners. In October, 2003, 80% of the compensation as ascertained by the respondent i.e Rs. 1,87,10,194/- was released to the petitioner No. 1 and Sh. Manoj Kumar out of total amount of Rs. 1,97,08,397/-. Balance amount of compensation of Rs. 9,98,203/- along with interest was not paid. Sh. Manoj Kumar expired on 6.9.2005 Petitioner Nos. 2 and 3 are the legal heirs of Sh. Manoj Kumar. Petitioners made various efforts to get the balance compensation released in their favour but the same was not released.

    3. On 11.10.2007, petitioners filed an application under Right to Information Act to know about supplementary award, if any, passed in the matter. No information was provided to petitioners. Ultimately, petitioner had to file an appeal before the appellate authority under Right to Information Act. Despite that, same was not provided. Petitioners filed Second Appeal before Central Information Commission under the aforesaid Act. On receipt of the said application, respondent furnished information vide letter dated 18.12.2007 that a supplementary award was passed in the matter on 27.10.2004 wherein compensation of trees was assessed in their favour. Thereafter, petitioner made representation for release of said compensation but the same was not released.

    4. On 18.3.2008, petitioner filed the present petition i.e for the release of compensation in respect of supplementary award in their favour. Notice of the said petition was issued to respondents vide order dated 18.3.2008 In response to same, respondent filed counter affidavit stating that at the time of making award dated 1.8.2003, certain compensation was awarded in contravention of Section 24 of the Act as compensation for illegal super structure on the land of the petitioners was awarded whereas no compensation ought to have been awarded to them in respect of said structures. Accordingly, the review of earlier award dated 1.8.2003 was done and fresh Review award on 14.7.2004 was passed. On coming to know of the said stand of the respondent, petitioner filed the second writ petition i.e W.P(C) No. 381/2009 challenging the said Review Award.

    5. Learned Counsel for petitioner has contended that action of the respondent in making review award dated 1.10.2003 is illegal and in contravention of provisions of Section 12 of the said Act. It is contended that as soon as the award is pronounced and filed in the Collector's Office, the award becomes final and conclusive between the Collector and person interested. It is further contended that under the said Act, the power of review of the award has not been conferred upon any authority as such review award is illegal being contrary to statute. It is contended that review of the award can be done only under Section 13 A of the Act which permits removal of arithmetical and clerical errors within a period of six months. It is contended that beyond that, nothing can be done by the Collector. It is further contended that what has been done in the present case is not permissible under the law as change has been made on merits and the same are not arithmetical or clerical errors in any manner.

    6. The stand of respondent is that in the earlier award No. 16/03-04 dated 1.10.2003, compensation was assessed in respect of land and super structure of petitioners at Rs. 1,97,08,397/- out of which petitioners have already received Rs. 1,87,13,782/-. The said award included compensation for illegal structure which was in contravention of Section 24 Clause 8 of the Act as such on the directions of appropriate authority, compensation of Rs. 45,67,005/- was reduced in respect of illegal structures vide Review Award dated 14.7.2004 The further case of the respondent is that supplementary award No. 16-A/04-05 of 16/03-04 was made on 27.10.2004 in respect of trees on the land acquired and the compensation of which was assessed at Rs. 45,36,781.64. It is contended that as the petitioners have already received payment in excess as per award dated 1.10.2003, they are not entitled for any further payment in the supplementary award.

    7. We have considered the submissions made and perused the record.

    8. It is admitted position that initially award was made/announced on 1.10.2003 by the respondent in respect of land and super structure existing on it. Proceedings for determination of compensation was done under Section 11 of the Act by respondent. Before proceeding to determine the compensation, notices under Sections 9 and 10 of the Act were issued to interested parties. Notice under Section 50 of the Act has also been issued to Requisitioning Department to appear and to adduce the evidence for determining the compensation but none appeared before LAC on behalf of Requisitioning Department nor adduced any evidence. The interested parties filed their claims including the present petitioners. The land is an agricultural land on which there exist farm houses. The dispute is about the compensation awarded for the structures on the land.

    9. The case of the respondent is that review of the award was done as certain compensation in respect of illegal structure on the land was awarded in contravention of Section 24 Clause 8 of the Act and the Secretary, Land and Building had requested the Office of the respondent to re-examine the evaluation of super structure of the farm house keeping in view the Building Bye-laws relating to the maximum floor area of dwelling unit in respect of farm house. There was also approval of the Lt. Governor in this regard. It is also the stand of respondent that notice was issued to all the interested parties but they did not appear.

    10. The review award dated 14.7.2004 shows that petitioner had constructed ground floor, first floor and second floor in contravention of Building Bye-laws. Besides above, there were illegal structures like swimming pool, servant quarters, garage, statues etc. The value assessed by PWD has been revised keeping in view the permissible limits as per MCD norms. The compensation in respect of illegal structures was deducted and the final compensation of super structure was assessed as Rs. 49,39,195/-. Section 24, Clause 8 of the Act is very clear. The same is reproduced as under:

    24. Matters to be neglected in determining compensation.—But the Court shall not take into consideration—

    “xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx eighthly, any increase to the value of the land on account of its being put to any use which is forbidden by law or opposed to public policy.”

    11. Under the said provision, compensation for illegal structure is to be neglected. The factum of there being illegal structure is not in dispute. Petitioner has annexed the copy of Review Award with the writ petition. In the said review award, reasons for deduction are given. Petitioner has not stated anything in this regard in the petition nor has filed rejoinder denying the said averments. Further nothing is placed on record to show that structure existing at the time of acquisition were in accordance with Sanction Plan of MCD or that construction was done as per Building Bye-laws. Petitioners cannot be allowed to take advantage of their own illegal acts. Technicalities cannot be allowed to defeat the express provisions of a Statute. Provisions of Section 24, Clause 8 are very clear. Huge public money is involved. It will not be in the public interest also to accept the contention of petitioner.

    12. In State Of Orissa v. Rajakishore Das, (1996) 4 SCC 221, it has been held that:

    “……….The construction was unauthorized. Nonetheless, the High Court directed the payment of compensation. We find that the approach of the High Court is clearly illegal. Having recorded the finding that the respondent had constructed the building without permission of any authority and since the Government is entitled to have the unauthorized construction demolished, unless the owner himself voluntarily demolishes and takes the value of the building structure is salvage material, the High Court ought to have held that the respondent had proceeded unauthorisedly in constructing the building having had the knowledge of the acquisition. Therefore, the authorities are not bound by such construction. Consequently, the State is not bound to pay compensation of the value of such a building constructed unauthorisedly. The judgment and order passed by the High Court directing payment of compensation of Rs. 90,000 is clearly illegal.”

    13. It may also be mentioned that initial award was made on 1.10.2003 and Review Award was made on 14.7.2004 whereas present petition is filed in January, 2009 i.e after a lapse of about four and a half years. As per the case of the petitioner, he has come to know about the Review Award only on 15.12.2008 when the respondent filed counter affidavit in one of the present two petitions i.e 2185/2008 stating that Review Award has been made.

    14. The stand taken by the petitioner to explain the delay is unbelievable. As per petitioner's own case, petitioner had filed representation for release of balance amount under award dated 1.10.2003.supplementary award dated 27.10.2004 before the respondent for the first time on 8.1.2007 It is unimaginable that if a person has to take payment and that too of a heavy amount, he will not take steps for 2-3 years as has been done in the present case. The above shows that petitioner had the knowledge that payment awarded to him under supplementary award has been adjusted with the review award dated 14.7.2004 due to which petitioner had not taken any steps earlier. Further, stand of petitioner is that he has come to know of Supplementary Award only on 18.12.2007 when information was supplied to him under the Right to Information Act. Even this has been wrongly stated. The representation dated 8.1.2007 annexed with the petition contradicts the said stand. The same shows that petitioner had already requested respondent in this regard. Thus, the stand taken by the petitioner to explain the delay is not believable. Petition is liable to be dismissed on the ground of delay and laches alone.

    15. Further, learned Counsel for the respondent has submitted that Review Award is made in respect of other land owners i.e about 11 in number. Their compensation for illegal structures is also reduced. None has challenged the same despite five years having passed.

    16. The question of large public amount is involved. The exercise of jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution of India is in the discretion of the Court. We do not find it a fit case to exercise such a discretion in the present case.

    17. We may mention that we have gone through the judgment relied upon by Counsel for petitioner. The same have no relevancy to the facts of the present case.

    18. The prayer of petitioners about making reference to the Civil Court for adjudication is not pressed at the time of arguments. Accordingly, the same is not dealt herewith. Both the writ petitions have no merits and the same are dismissed.

    Writ Petitions dismissed.
    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Naresh Kumar & Ors. v. Govt. Of Nct Of Delhi .
    (Mar 4, 2010)