AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The decree-holder filed the present execution petition seeking execution of a decree for Rs. 35,00,000 together with interest at 18% per annum from 9 November 2002 and costs. The underlying suit, initiated by Plaintiff No.1 (the decree-holder) against the defendants (now judgment debtors), sought reliefs including injunctions against passing off and copyright infringement, rendition of accounts and damages arising from alleged misuse of the mark "ABRO" and use of the marks "ABRO" and "AMBRO".

While that suit was pending the parties reached an out-of-court settlement recorded in a settlement deed. By a joint application enclosing the settlement deed, the court on 19 July 2002 passed a decree in terms of the settlement deed and ordered that the settlement deed form part of the decree. The present proceedings concern execution of the decree based on that settlement deed.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether entries, erasures and overwritings in the judgment debtors' despatch register and the alleged manipulation of records amounted to misrepresentation/non-disclosure constituting a material default or breach of the settlement deed.
  2. Whether, on such breach/default, the decree-holder is entitled to the money decree for Rs. 35,00,000 in terms of the settlement deed made part of the decree dated 19 July 2002.
  3. What procedural steps should follow if the court finds such a breach (for example, directions as to disclosure of assets and property listings).

Arguments of the Parties

Decree-holder's Arguments

  • The decree-holder located a despatch register of the judgment debtors showing entries indicating dealing and marketing in products under the trademark "ABRO".
  • It was contended that the judgment debtors manipulated the register and records to give a false picture and thereby failed to disclose full and correct particulars as required by the settlement deed.
  • The decree-holder placed a copy of the despatch register on record (the original was produced before the Local Commissioner and later produced by the judgment debtors' counsel), and pointed to apparent erasures and overwritings (e.g., deletions of "ABRO" or "AMBRO" and replacement with other brand names) as evidence of misrepresentation and non-disclosure.
  • On that basis the decree-holder asserted entitlement to the Rs. 35,00,000 money decree pursuant to the settlement deed's stipulation that such sum would be recoverable on occurrence of a default by the judgment debtors.

Judgment Debtors' Arguments

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the judgment debtors' legal arguments. It records that the judgment debtors' counsel produced the original despatch register during arguments, but no substantive defense argumentation is recorded in the text provided.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined the settlement deed (which was incorporated into the decree) and the relevant operative clauses:

  • Article 1(a) acknowledged the judgment debtors' violation of the rights of Abro Industries Inc./decree-holder by use of identical/deceptively similar trade names, trademarks, labels and packages and related wrongful conduct causing loss and litigation.
  • Article 1(b) recorded that particulars disclosed by the judgment debtors were attached as Annexure 'C' and contained their representation that they had "never ever directly/indirectly manufactured, advertised and/or supplied any products with the trade mark ABRO"; it further provided that failure to make full, complete and correct disclosure or misrepresentation in respect of trademarks ABRO/AMBRO would be a material default attracting consequences including execution of the agreed money decree.
  • Article 4(c) provided that the judgment debtors jointly and severally agreed that a money decree of Rs. 35,00,000 could be passed in favour of the decree-holder on occurrence of a default, and set out the procedure (demand notice requiring payment within a week) and stated that the money decree was not to be construed as a conditional decree.
  • Articles 5 and 7 included further undertakings by the judgment debtors regarding absence of offending stock after seizure and that failure to disclose or any misrepresentation would constitute a default with immediate consequences including execution of the money decree.

The court inspected the despatch register entries (the original of which had been produced during arguments) and identified clear erasures and overwritings on several pages: examples included erasure of "ABRO" on page 2, overwriting in the second entry on page 3 (either "ABRO" or "AMBRO" erased and replaced), erasure of "ABRO" and replacement by "QSS" on page 5 while "Ambro Brand" appeared elsewhere on that page, and further erasures on page 23. The court characterized these erasures and overwritings as misrepresentations and misstatements on the face of the records.

Applying the settlement deed's terms, particularly the decree-holder's entitlement to the agreed money decree upon material default or misrepresentation, the court concluded that the judgment debtors had failed to disclose fully and correctly and had made misrepresentations concerning the use/supply of products bearing the marks "ABRO" and "AMBRO". The court found this to be a material default/breach of the settlement deed, thereby invoking the stipulated consequence of entitlement to the Rs. 35,00,000 decree.

On that basis the court held the decree-holder entitled to the money decree and directed ancillary procedural steps: the judgment debtors were ordered to file affidavits disclosing their assets within eight weeks, and the decree-holder was directed to submit a list of the judgment debtors' immovable/movable properties. The court renotified the matter for 12 August 2004.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The court held that the decree-holder is entitled to a decree for the sum of Rs. 35,00,000/- in terms of the settlement deed incorporated into the decree.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: the judgment debtors were found to have committed a material default/breach of the settlement deed and are subject to execution of the Rs. 35,00,000 decree; they were directed to file affidavits disclosing their assets within eight weeks, and the decree-holder must submit a list of the judgment debtors' movable and immovable properties.
  • No broader legal or precedent implications are discussed in the opinion; the decision applies the contractual and decretal terms of the settlement deed to the specific factual finding of misrepresentation and non-disclosure in the despatch register.

Renotify date recorded in the opinion: 12 August 2004.

    Abro Industries Inc. Decree-Holder v. K. V. International And Others Judgment-Debtors

    Dr. Mukundakam Sharma, J.:—The decree-holder has filed the present execution petition praying for execution of the decree for a sum of Rs. 35 lakhs together with interest thereon at the rate of 18% per annum from November 9, 2002 upto the date of payment and also the cost of taking out the execution.

    2. The decree-holder/plaintiff No. 1 filed a suit in this court against the judgment debtors/defendants seeking for a decree restraining passing of the goods of the defendants as that of the plaintiff and also for restraining infringement of copyright and also for a decree of rendition of accounts and for payment of damages. The subject-matter of the suit included misuse of the decree-holder's mark ‘ABRO’ by the judgment debtors by use of the marks ‘ABRO’ and ‘AMBRO’. During the pendency of the aforesaid suit in this court the parties arrived at a settlement out of court. The terms and conditions of settlement between the parties were recorded in a settlement deed executed between the parties. After arriving at the aforesaid settlement which is recorded in the settlement deed, a joint application was filed in this court by the plaintiff and the defendants who are the decree-holder and the judgment debtors, respectively, herein enclosing therewith a copy of the settlement deed. By order dated July 19, 2002, this Court passed a decree in the suit in terms of the settlement deed and also passed an order that the settlement deed would form part of the decree. Since the aforesaid decree based on the settlement deed is sought to be executed through this Court it would be necessary to extract a part of the said settlement deed which was made a part of the decree dated July 19, 2002.

    3. Article 1(a) of the said settlement deed stipulated that the judgment debtors (parties of the second part) acknowledges the violation on their part of the rights and entitlements of the Abro Industries Inc/decree-holder and Elegant Industries (parties of the first part) resulting from use by the judgment debtors of the trade names, trademarks, labels and packages identical/deceptively similar to those of Abro Industries Inc. and Elegant Industries or which are imitation thereof, and wrongdoing on their part in representing themselves as connected or concerned with Abro Industries Inc. as agent, licensee or otherwise, which resulted in loss and damage to the business and reputation of Abro Industries Inc. and Elegant Industries and led to the disputes and the litigation. It was also stated in Article 1(b) of the said settlement deed that particulars of disclosure made by the judgment debtors were attached as Annexure ‘C’ and that the said judgment debtors represented and confirmed that they never ever directly/indirectly manufactured, advertised and/or supplied any products with the trade mark ABRO. It was also confirmed by them that on their failure to make full, complete and correct disclosure therein in respect of the trademark AMBRO, and failure of their representation that they had never ever manufactured, advertised and supplied any products with the trademark ABRO would be a material default/breach of the settlement deed and the consequences attributable to such breach/default would immediately follow including execution of money decree as agreed to in the said settlement deed. In Article 4(c) of the settlement deed it was agreed to by the parties, which was also made a part of the decree, that the judgment debtors further jointly and severally agreed that a money decree in the sum of Rs. 35 lakhs could be passed in favour of the decree-holder No. 1. It was agreed that the execution of the said decree would be in the manner as provided as under:—

    “The Parties of the Second Part (judgment debtors) jointly and severally agree to pay All (Abro Industries Inc/decree holder) without any demur or protest the sum of Rs. 35,00,000/- (Rupees Thirty Five Lacs), on the occurrence of a default by any of the Parties of the Second Part of any of the terms of this Deed as determined by All in its sole discretion. The aforesaid amount of Rs. 35,00,000/- (Rupees Thirty Five Lacs) shall be recoverable by All under this decree on the occurrence of a default by any of the Par ties of the Second Part of any of the terms of this Deed as deter mined by All in its sole discretion. In such eventuality, before executing the decree through the competent court of law, All will make a demand upon the Parties of the Second Part or any one or more of them, by serving upon them a notice, requiring them to make the full payment of the aforesaid decreetal amount of Rs. 35,00,000/- within a week of the date of the notice. The notice will state that a default has occurred under the Deed (with or without specifying the particulars of the default) and the failure to comply with the said notice, shall entitle All to execute the decree like any other money decree against the Parties of the Second Part. It is ex pressly understood between the Parties that the aforesaid money decree for payment of Rs. 35,00,000/- on a default under this Deed is not to be understood or construed as a conditional decree in any manner”

    In Article 5 of the said settlement deed it was stipulated that the judgment debtors confirm that after the seizure of the infringed material from their factory by the local commissioner they did not have any more offending products, labels, cartons, blocks, literature, stationery or any other offending articles and material in their stock or possession for purpose of destruction/erasure by the Parties of the First Part. In Article 7 it was also stipulated that the judgment debtors agree and undertake that failure on the part of the judgment debtors or any of them to disclose full and correct particulars in any matter or making any misrepresentation or misstatement by the judgment debtors or any of them would be a default/breach of the settlement deed on the part of the judgment debtors and the consequences attributable to such breach/default would immediately follow including execution of money decree as agreed.

    4. It is stated in the petition that the decree-holder came across a despatch register of the judgment ‘debtors and from the said register it was apparent that the judgment debtors were dealing and marketing also in products under the trademark ABRO. It was also pointed out that the judgment debtors have manipulated the said records and have given a wrong picture to the decree-holder. It is, therefore, contended that as the judgment debtors manipulated the records and did not disclose full and correct particulars and as they made a misrepresentation or misstatement which resulted in default/breach of the settlement deed, therefore, the decree-holder is entitled to get a decree of Rs. 35,00,000/- in terms of the stipulation in the settlement deed. In support of the said contention the decree-holder has placed on record a copy of the despatch register the original of which was produced before the Local Commissioner and which was signed by him and a copy of which was obtained by the decree-holder. On the prayer of the decree-holder the original despatch register was called for by this court which was, however, no produced. However, during the course of arguments counsel appearing for the judgment debtors produced the original despatch register which was received. My attention is drawn to page 2 of the said register. There appears a clear erasure of the word ‘ABRO’ on the said page, 2, whereas at page 3 there is a clear overwriting in the second entry. There was either a word ‘ABRO’ or ‘AMBRO’ on the said page which was erased and over it some other brand/trade name is written. Similarly, at page 5, ‘ABRO’ brand is erased and in its place ‘QSS’ brand is written by way of misstatement which is apparent on the face of the records and is indicated from the same, whereas at the bottom there is an entry ‘Ambro Brand’ as against the total boxes 204. At page 23 also, in the third entry thereof showing packing of 192.box and total packages being 60 boxes, there is again erasure of either ‘ABRO’ brand or ‘AMBRO’ brand.

    5. The aforesaid erasures and overwritings have been done by the judgment debtors by way of misrepresentation and misstatement and, therefore, it is held that the judgment debtors failed to disclose fully and correctly all particulars to the decree-holder and in view of the same the decree-holder becomes entitled to a decree for an amount of Rs. 35,00,000/- in terms of the stipulations in the settlement deed. It was a categorical statement coming from the judgment debtors, which is recorded in the settlement deed, that the judgment debtors had never ever directly/indirectly manufactured, advertised and/or supplied any products with the trademark ‘ABRO’. The said statement stands belied by the entries made in the aforesaid despatch register of the judgment debtors. Therefore, to that extent also there is misrepresentation and misstatement by the judgment debtors and since they have failed to make full, complete and correct disclosures in respect of marks ‘ABRO’ and ‘AMBRO’, there is a material default and breach of the settlement deed which entitles the decree-holder to get a decree for an amount of Rs. 35,00,000/-.

    6. In terms of the aforesaid discussions and observations, I accordingly hold that the decree-holder is entitled to a decree of Rs. 35,00,000/-. In terms of the stipulations in the settlement deed, the said decree is executable by filing an execution petition in terms of which this execution petition is filed. Accordingly, the judgment debtors are directed to file an affidavit in this court disclosing their assets to this court within eight weeks. The decree-holder is also directed to submit a list of immovable/movable properties of the judgment debtors.

    7. Renotify on 12th August, 2004.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Abro Industries Inc. Decree-Holder v. K. V. International And Others Judgment-Debtors
    (May 27, 2004)