Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Sections 46 and 56 of the Trade and Merchandise Marks Act (for short Act)
  • Rule 4 of the Trade and Merchandise Marks Rules, 1959 (for short Rules)
  • provisions of Sections 2(1) (h), 3, 5 and Rules 4, 5
  • Rule 6, the Registrar of Trade Marks
  • Section 56 and Section 108
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Sections 46 and 56 of the Trade and Merchandise Marks Act (for short Act)
  • Rule 4 of the Trade and Merchandise Marks Rules, 1959 (for short Rules)
  • provisions of Sections 2(1) (h), 3, 5 and Rules 4, 5
  • Rule 6, the Registrar of Trade Marks
  • Section 56 and Section 108
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner filed an application under Sections 46 and 56 of the Trade and Merchandise Marks Act seeking rectification of the registered Trade Mark No. 507445 dated 23rd March, 1989 in Class 9 of the IV Schedule. The trademark in question, KUNDAN/KUNDAN CAB, was registered in the name of respondent No. 1 and pertains to electrical accessories and fittings. The petitioner claimed prior use of the mark since 1980 and had earlier filed a suit for permanent injunction in the District Court, Delhi, against respondent No. 1. Respondent No. 1 counterclaimed and disclosed registration of the trademark in its favor. The petitioner then filed the present petition for rectification and cancellation of the registration.

The issue of territorial jurisdiction arose because respondent No. 2, a firm based in Chennai, initially filed the trademark application at the Chennai Trade Mark Registry and subsequently assigned the trademark to respondent No. 1. Respondents contended that the rectification petition must be filed in the Court at Chennai, the jurisdiction of the original Trade Mark Registry office.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Court in Delhi has territorial jurisdiction to entertain the petition for rectification of the registered trade mark when the original application was filed at the Chennai Trade Mark Registry.
  2. Whether the assignment of the trademark during the pendency of the application to a party located outside the jurisdiction of the original Trade Mark Registry affects the territorial jurisdiction of the Court.
  3. Interpretation of Section 3 clauses (a) and (b) of the Trade and Merchandise Marks Act regarding jurisdiction of High Courts in trademark matters.

Arguments of the Parties

Respondents' Arguments

  • The High Court having jurisdiction is defined under Section 2(1)(h) and Section 3(b) of the Act, which points to the High Court within whose appellate jurisdiction the Trade Mark Registry office where the application was filed is situated.
  • The trademark application was filed at the Chennai Trade Mark Registry, and the registration certificate was issued there; hence, the appropriate jurisdiction lies with the Chennai High Court.
  • The assignment of the trademark from respondent No. 2 to respondent No. 1 during the pendency of the application does not change the territorial jurisdiction.
  • Rules 4, 5, and 6 of the Trade and Merchandise Marks Rules, 1959, support that the appropriate office and jurisdiction remain with the Chennai Registry regardless of change in principal place of business or address for service.
  • Reliance was placed on three judgments: Priya Enterprises v. Prestige Housewares (India) Ltd., Satya Narayan Khub Chand v. Rama Chandra Laxmi Narayan, and Vikas Manufacturing Company v. Maharaj Manufacturing Company, which uphold this interpretation.

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The application for registration was initially filed by respondent No. 2 at Chennai, but the assignment to respondent No. 1 (based in Delhi) was allowed during the pendency of the application.
  • Since respondent No. 1 is situated in Delhi and holds the registration certificate, Section 3(a) of the Act applies, conferring jurisdiction on the Delhi Court.
  • The application for rectification should be treated as a suit under Section 107 of the Act, invoking Sections 56 and 108 relating to rectification and correction of the register.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Priya Enterprises v. Prestige Housewares (India) Ltd., 1998 PTC (18) 539 Jurisdiction of High Courts in trademark matters under the Act Supported the position that jurisdiction lies with the High Court within whose appellate jurisdiction the Trade Mark Registry office is situated
Satya Narayan Khub Chand v. Rama Chandra Laxmi Narayan, AIR 1977 AP 360 Territorial jurisdiction in trademark registration and rectification Reinforced the principle that assignment of trademark does not alter the jurisdiction of the original Registry office
Vikas Manufacturing Company v. Maharaj Manufacturing Company, 1981 PTC 87 Jurisdictional limits and assignment of trademarks Confirmed that assignment during pendency does not change the appropriate Registry office jurisdiction
Amrutanjan Ltd. v. Ashwin Fine Chemicals and Pharmaceuticals, 1991 (2) ALR 384 (MAD) Suit for injunction can be filed where trademark is registered Supported that civil action can be instituted at the place of registration despite infringement occurring elsewhere
K.B Venkatachala Mudaliar v. Vanaja Match Works, 1990 PTC 259 Place of registration as jurisdictional basis Reinforced jurisdiction based on Trade Mark Registry location
Ramu Hosieries rep. by M. Murugeshan v. Ramu Hosieries rep. by Pandela Ramu, 1999 PTC 183 Jurisdictional principle in trademark disputes Further supported the principle that jurisdiction is tied to the Registry office

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analyzed the jurisdictional provisions under Section 3 of the Trade and Merchandise Marks Act, focusing on clauses (a) and (b). Clause (a) applies only to trademarks registered before the commencement of the Act and thus was not applicable here. Clause (b), which applies to applications filed on or after the commencement of the Act, governs this case.

The trademark application was filed by respondent No. 2 at the Chennai Trade Mark Registry, with Chennai as the principal place of business disclosed in the application. The assignment of the trademark to respondent No. 1, located in Delhi, during the pendency of the application or after registration does not affect the territorial jurisdiction. The Court emphasized that the situs of the trademark registration remains the place where the application was originally made, which is Chennai.

The Court further noted that the legislative intent, reflected in Sections 2(1)(h), 3, 5 and Rules 4, 5, and 6, is to confine jurisdiction to a single Registry office to avoid multiplicity of proceedings and to provide clarity to parties. The Court also cited precedents confirming that even civil suits for injunction can be filed where the trademark is registered, irrespective of the location of the infringing activity.

Accordingly, the Court found the petition not maintainable in Delhi and concluded that the appropriate jurisdiction lies with the High Court of Madras at Chennai.

Holding and Implications

The Court's final decision is that the petition for rectification is not maintainable in the Delhi High Court and must be filed in the High Court of Madras at Chennai.

The direct effect of this decision is that the petitioner must present the rectification petition before the appropriate Court in Chennai. The Court did not establish any new legal precedent but reaffirmed the established principle that territorial jurisdiction for trademark matters is linked to the Trade Mark Registry office where the original application was filed and registered, unaffected by subsequent assignments to parties outside that jurisdiction.

    Lakha Ram Sharma v. Balar Marketing Pvt. Ltd. & Ors.

    A.K Sikri, J.— An interesting question relating to territorial jurisdiction of this Court has been posed in this case. The petitioner has filed the application under Sections 46 and 56 of the Trade and Merchandise Marks Act (for short ‘Act’) for rectification of the registered Trade Mark No. 507445 as of 23rd March, 1989 in Class 9 of the IV Schedule of the Act. The trade mark KUNDAN/KUNDAN CAB is the subject matter of the aforesaid registration which is registered in the name of the respondent No. 1. It is in respect of electrical accessories and fittings including electrical switches, main switches, fuse units, wires and cables and electrical irons. The petitioner claims that it has also been using the trade mark KUNDAN/KUNDAN CAB/KUDAN CABLES INDIA in respect of these very goods since 1980 and when the petitioner came to know that the respondent No. 1 was also using the same trade mark, the petitioner filed suit for permanent injunction in the Court of District Judge, Delhi. In the said suit, the respondent No. 1 filed counter claims and it was disclosed that the trade mark KUNDAN/KUNDAN CAB is registered in favour of the respondent No. 1. It is because of this reason, the present petition is filed by the petitioner for rectification and prayer is made the Trade Mark No. 507445 in Class 9 of IV Schedule be cancelled/expunged from the Register of Trade Marks.

    2. The question of territorial jurisdiction arises in the following circumstances:

    The respondent No. 2 herein, which is a firm, with its office at Chennai had filed an application for registration of the aforesaid trade marks. When the application was still pending, the respondent No. 2 assigned the trade mark KUNDAN in favour of respondent No. 1. This assignment application was allowed by the Registrar and accordingly the registration certificate was issued to the respondent No. 1. Since the application was filed in the Trade Mark Registry at Chennai, the objection of the respondents 1 and 2 is that the application for rectification can be filed in the Court at Chennai only.

    3. In support of the aforesaid submissions, learned Counsel for the respondents 1 and 2 submitted that Section 2(1) (h) of the Act defines High Court to mean the High Court having jurisdiction under Section 3. Under Section 3(b) of the Act, the High Court having jurisdiction under this Act shall be the High Court within the limits of whose appellate jurisdiction the Office of the Trade Mark Registry referred to in each of the following cases is situated present purposes Clause (b) is relevant and accordingly the application for registration of the said trade mark was made at the Trade Mark Registry at Chennai and it is in that office where the present trade mark is registered. Under Rule 4 of the Trade and Merchandise Marks Rules, 1959 (for short ‘Rules’) the appropriate office of the Trade Mark Registry for the purposes of making the application for registration or for filing an application for rectification or for any proceedings under the Act and Rules for the purposes of the said trade mark registration and the instant rectification is the Trade Mark Registry at Chennai. Further, the jurisdiction of the appropriate office cannot be altered by change in principal place of business or address for service under Rule 5. Under Rule 6, the Registrar of Trade Marks has entered the appropriate office of the Trade Mark Registry at Chennai as the appropriate office wherein the said trade mark has been registered and wherein the said application for registration was made. The same is also borne out by the advertisement of the said trade mark in the Trade Mark Journal No. 1045 at page 990 and a perusal thereof shows that the principal place of business and the appropriate office thereof is at Chennai as also for registration was also made before the Registrar of Trade Marks at Chennai. Under Section 5 of the Act, the Government of India has established Trade Mark Registries in five regions covering the whole of India having jurisdiction over their notified States and territories. The five regions having their respective Trade Mark Registries are at Bombay, Calcutta, Delhi, Ahmedabad and Chennai. The Registrar of Trade Marks at Chennai exercises jurisdiction over the States of Andhra Pradesh, Kerala, Tamil Nadu, Kamataka and the Union Territories of Pondicherry and Lakshadweep islands. The appropriate office of the Trade Mark Registry where the said trade mark was registered and the said registry is situate is at Chennai and the appropriate High Court as per Section 3 of the Act is at Chennai.

    4. In support of his submission learned Counsel relied upon the following three judgments as well:

    (1) Priya Enterprises v. Prestige Housewares (India) Ltd., 1998 PTC (18) 539.

    (2) Satya Narayan Khub Chand v. Rama Chandra Laxmi Narayan, AIR 1977 AP 360.

    (3) Vikas Manufacturing Company v. Maharaj Manufacturing Company, 1981 PTC 87.

    5. The submission of the learned Counsel for the petitioner, on that other hand, was that the application for registration was filed by the respondent No. 2 with the Chennai Office on 23rd March, 1989, it was published in the Journal on 16th December, 1992 and the application for assigning the trade mark by respondent No. 2 in favour of the respondent No. 1 was filed on 17th February, 1993 which was allowed on 14th April, 1993 itself. Thus the respondent No. 1 which is a party in Delhi, got itself substituted for respondent No. 2 and pursued with the application. The certificate of registration was granted on 15th November, 1994in favour of the respondent No. 1 which has its office at Delhi. On the basis of these facts, learned Counsel for the petitioner submitted that provisions of section 3(a) would get attracted as per which this Court has the territorial jurisdiction to try the instant petition.

    6. It was his further submission that the application for rectification has to be decided as a suit in view of the position laid down in Section 107 of the Act. He also referred to the other provisions relating to rectification and correction of the register i.e Section 56 and Section 108 of the Act.

    7. I have given my thoughtful consideration to the issue involved.

    8. Section 3 of the Act deals with the jurisdictional aspect and stipulates that as to which High Court shall have the jurisdiction to deal with the cases under different circumstances. Five different situations are mentioned in clauses (a) to (e) of section 3. We are not concerned with Clauses (c) to (e). Whereas the petitioner is relying upon Clause (a) of Section 3 the respondents 1 and 2 are taking shelter under Clause (b). In order to appreciate the rival's contention, it would be appropriate to reproduce the provisions of these two clauses in the first instance:

    “3. High Court having jurisdiction—The High Court having jurisdiction under this Act shall be the High Court within the limits of whose appellate jurisdiction the office of the Trade Marks Registry referred to in each of the following cases is situate, namely:

    (a) in relation to a trade mark on the Register of Trade Marks at the commencement of this Act, the office of the Trade Mark Registry within whose territorial limits the principal place of business in India of the proprietor of the trade mark as entered in the register at such commencement is situate;

    (c) in relation to a trade mark for which an application for registration of pending at or is made on or after the commencement of this Act, the office of the Trade Mark Registry within whose territorial limits the principal place of business in India of the applicant as disclosed in his application is situate.

    9. Clause (a) shall have no application in the present case simply because it is applicable in those cases where the trade mark has already been registered at the time of commencement of the Act and in that case the office of the Trade Mark Registry within whose territorial limit the principal place of business in India of the proprietor of the trade mark as entered in the register at such commencement is situate. This provision takes care of all those trade marks which were already registered at the time when this Act came into force and does not deal with applications for registration filed after the commencement of the Act. In the present case application for registration of trade mark was filed much after the Act came into force. The provisions of Clause (b) are clearly attracted in such case which, inter alia, deals with those situations also where the application for registration is made on or after the commencement of the Act. In that case the office of the Trade Mark Registry within whose territorial limits the principal place of business in India of the applicant as disclosed in his application is situate. Here the application was filed by the respondent No. 2 in the Trade Mark Registry at Chennai. The principal place of business as disclosed in his application was Chennai. Simply because during the pendency of the application, the assignment was made in favour of the respondent No. 1 would not alter the position in law. After all the application remained pending with the Trade Mark Registry at Chennai where it is ultimately registered and the register containing the registration of the respondent No. 1's trade mark is kept at Chennai.

    10. Let us now examine the position from another angle. In those cases where the registration is done by the Trade Mark Registry of a particular region and subsequently there is an assignment by the trade mark owner in favour of another party which is outside the jurisdiction of that Trade Mark Registry, such subsequent assignment would not alter or affect the position in any manner. The appropriate office of the Trade Mark Registry would continue to remain the same and this conclusion is inevitable on the combined reading of Sections 2(1)(h), 3(b) and 5 of the Act as well as Rules 4, 5 and 6 of the Rules. This is also the ratio of the three judgments cited by learned Counsel for the respondents 1 and 2. Therefore, emphasis is on the place where the application is made initially. After making the application assignment takes place during the pendency of the application or after the registration of the trade mark would not make any difference in law. Thus I find force in the arguments of learned Counsel for the respondents 1 and 2. Under Section 23(1)(d) of the Act, the trade mark when registered shall be registered as of the date of making of the said application and it is that date that shall be deemed to be the date of registration. The date on which the application for registration was made is March 23, 1989 which is clear from the Trade Mark Journal. The purpose of confining the trade mark registration to one jurisdiction/office for the purposes of its rectification under the provisions of Sections 2(1) (h), 3, 5 and Rules 4, 5 and 6 is, inter alia, to facilitate rectification proceedings so that an aggrieved party does not have to run around to various Courts should the assignment be effected in various different jurisdiction. Likewise, even the registered proprietor gets confined to one jurisdiction wherein the validity/removal of his mark can be determined. The Legislature has chosen the situs of the trade mark as the place for conferring territorial jurisdiction which continuous to be at the Trade Mark Registry at Chennai. Even in a civil action for injunction the suit can be filed at a place where the mark is registered even though the person infringing the registered mark does not carry out its impugned activities in that place. (Refer: ‘1. Amrutanjan Ltd. v. Ashwin Fine Chemicals and Pharmaceuticals, 1991 (2) ALR 384 (MAD); 2, K.B Venkatachala Mudaliar v. Vanaja Match Works, 1990 PTC 259 and 3. Ramu Hosieries rep. by M. Murugeshan v. Ramu Hosieries rep. by Pandela Ramu, 1999 PTC 183.

    11. Consequently this application which is filed by the petitioner is not maintainable in this Court and ought to have been instituted in the High Court of Madras at Chennai.

    12. The petition is accordingly returned for presentation before the appropriate Court.

    Petition returned for presentation before appropriate Court.
    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Lakha Ram Sharma v. Balar Marketing Pvt. Ltd. & Ors.
    (Oct 10, 2001)