Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 269 UL(3) of the Income Tax Act
  • Income Tax Act, 1961 (for short the Act)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 269 UL(3) of the Income Tax Act
  • Income Tax Act, 1961 (for short the Act)
Smart Summary

Judgment Summary — Arun Kumar, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

An agreement to sell a plot of land (No. 115, Sector 36-A, Chandigarh) was executed on 25 October 1989 between the petitioners (vendees/purchasers) and respondent No. 3 (vendor) for Rs. 15,00,000, with Rs. 1,50,000 paid at agreement. On 5 November 1989 the vendor and vendee filed Form No. 37(I) and the agreement with respondent No. 2 (the Appropriate Authority) to obtain “No Objections” under Chapter XX C of the Income Tax Act.

On 8 June 1990 respondent No. 2 passed an order for pre-emptory purchase and took possession on 20 June 1990. The petitioners challenged that order by a writ petition filed in July 1990. Pursuant to an order in that writ, respondent No. 2 paid the balance consideration of Rs. 13,50,000 to the vendor on 28 February 1992.

On 23 January 1995 the earlier writ petition was allowed and the Appropriate Authority's order was set aside, but the matter was remanded to the Appropriate Authority for fresh consideration in view of the Supreme Court decision in C.B. Gautam v. Union of India & Ors. Following the remand, the petitioners were served with a show-cause notice (5 April 1995), replied (18 April 1995), and on 27 April 1995 the Appropriate Authority passed a fresh order for purchase. The petitioners again challenged that order by a writ petition filed 23 May 1995.

On 25 May 1995 the Court ordered maintenance of status quo; possession remained with the Appropriate Authority. The writ petition was finally disposed on 13 February 1998, quashing the 27 April 1995 order and directing the Appropriate Authority to issue the No Objection Certificate under Section 269UL(3) of the Income Tax Act.

In October 1998 the Appropriate Authority filed the present application seeking directions that the petitioners and/or the vendor be directed to repay Rs. 13,50,000 with interest at 18% p.a. from 28 February 1992 to enable issuance of the No Objection Certificate. The petitioners and vendor resisted liability. At a hearing on 16 April 1999 the petitioners offered to deposit Rs. 13,50,000, were ordered to do so within two weeks, and deposited the sum on 23 April 1999.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Appropriate Authority (respondent No. 2) is entitled to interest on the sum of Rs. 13,50,000 paid to the vendor with effect from 28 February 1992.
  2. If interest is due, whether that liability falls on the petitioners (purchasers), the vendor (respondent No. 3), or both.

Arguments of the Parties

Appropriate Authority's (Applicant's) Arguments

  • The Authority submitted that it was deprived of the sum of Rs. 13,50,000 for a long period and therefore is entitled to interest on that amount from 28 February 1992 until payment.
  • The Authority contended it acted bona fide in discharging statutory functions and that payment of Rs. 13.5 lacs was in pursuance of those functions; it could not enjoy the property or put it to use while also being deprived of the funds.
  • Reliance was placed on the Karnataka High Court decision Appropriate Authority & Ors. v. Mass Traders Pvt. Ltd. & Ors. (1993) 202 ITR 741, wherein interest was directed to compensate the government for deprivation of funds caused by interim orders.

Vendor's (Respondent No. 3) Arguments

  • The vendor argued that under the agreement to sell she was entitled to receive the balance sale consideration; she had given possession on 20 June 1990 and later received the balance on 28 February 1992.
  • The vendor emphasized that she did not challenge the Appropriate Authority's order nor obtain interim relief; she was entitled to the money under the statutory scheme and calling upon her to pay interest would effectively wipe out the sale consideration.
  • The vendor submitted that the statutory scheme envisions timely payment to the vendor and that she should not be penalized by being required to return or pay interest on a sum rightly due to her.

Purchasers' (Petitioners') Arguments

  • The purchasers contended they were deprived of possession of the property for a long period and the earnest money paid at the agreement stage was never reimbursed.
  • They argued that they lawfully challenged the Appropriate Authority's orders and succeeded on both occasions, demonstrating their legal right to challenge; seeking status quo was necessary to protect their interest.
  • On equitable grounds the purchasers noted personal hardship (advanced age, disrupted plans to construct a house) and the nearly ten-year delay in enjoyment of the property; they maintained they should not be required to pay interest.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
C.B. Gautam v. Union of India & Ors. (Supreme Court) Authority for remanding the matter to the Appropriate Authority for fresh consideration. The writ petition was remanded to the Appropriate Authority for fresh consideration in view of this Supreme Court decision; the Court acted on that authority in sending the matter back.
Appropriate Authority & Ors. v. Mass Traders Pvt. Ltd. & Ors., (1993) 202 ITR 741 (Karnataka High Court) Authority for awarding interest to compensate the government where an interim order deprived the government of the use of large sums and prevented auction/recovery. The Court considered the reasoning and quotations from this decision but expressly declined to accept its approach here; the Court disagreed with compelling purchasers to compensate the Appropriate Authority by way of interest in the present facts.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the positions of all three parties and concluded that none of them could be faulted on the facts. The analysis proceeded in these steps:

  1. The Appropriate Authority: the Court accepted that the Authority acted in bona fide discharge of statutory duties in passing orders of peremptory purchase and in paying the balance sale consideration; the Authority's conduct was not blameworthy despite the orders being subsequently set aside by the Court.
  2. The Vendor: the Court observed the vendor had surrendered possession on 20 June 1990 and was entitled, under the agreement and the statutory scheme, to receive the balance sale consideration. She had not challenged the order and it was just and fair that she receive the consideration; requiring her to pay interest would deprive her of both the property and the sale consideration.
  3. The Purchasers: the Court found that the purchasers were within their legal rights to challenge the Appropriate Authority’s orders and to seek maintenance of status quo to protect their interest in the property. They had been deprived of possession for many years, had to keep the balance sum ready and available, and suffered loss of use of the property and delay in personal plans.
  4. On the comparative equities, the Court reasoned that deprivation of the use and fruits of the property suffered by the purchasers was a greater harm than any likely interest the Authority could have earned on the moneys. The purchasers could not have utilized the funds for other investments while the dispute persisted.
  5. Having weighed the competing equities and considered the Karnataka High Court authority relied upon by the Appropriate Authority, the Court declined to adopt the view that purchasers should be called upon to compensate the Appropriate Authority by paying interest simply because they had obtained interim relief (status quo). The Court found it inequitable to require either the vendor or the purchasers to pay interest in the circumstances.
  6. The practical fact that the petitioners had deposited the amount (Rs. 13,50,000) on 23 April 1999 was noted; in light of the deposit and the equitable considerations, the claim for interest was rejected.

Holding and Implications

Holding:

THE PRAYER FOR AWARD OF INTEREST ON THE SUM OF RS. 13,50,000 IS REJECTED.

Directives and immediate consequences:

  • The Appropriate Authority (respondent No. 2) is directed to issue the "No Objection Certificate" in terms of Section 269UL(3) of the Income Tax Act forthwith, and in any event not later than four weeks from the date of the order.
  • The Appropriate Authority is directed to simultaneously deliver possession of the property to the vendee (the petitioners) upon issuance of the No Objection Certificate.
  • There will be no order as to costs.

Implications beyond the parties: The Court expressly rejected the specific approach taken in the Karnataka decision cited by the Appropriate Authority in the particular facts before it. The decision resolves the dispute between the parties by denying interest and ordering issuance of the No Objection Certificate, but the opinion does not announce a broader rule beyond its reasoning applied to these facts.

    Jaspal Kaur & Ors. v. Union Of India.

    Arun Kumar, J.— This order will dispose of an application filed by respondent No. 2, the Appropriate Authority under the Income Tax Act, 1961 (for short the Act) seeking certain directions. It is necessary to give a brief background before the application can be disposed of.

    An agreement to sell with respect to property being a plot of land bearing No. 115, Sector 36-A, Chandigarh, was entered into between the petitioners in the writ petition and respondent No. 3 on 25th October, 1989. The consideration agreed upon was Rs. 15 lacs out of with a sum of Rs. 1,50,000/- was paid by the petitioners (purchasers) to respondent No. 3 (vendor) at the time of the agreement. On 5th November, 1989 the vendor and the vendee filed a statement in Form No. 37(I) alongwith an agreement to sell with respondent No. 2, the Appropriate Authority for obtaining the “No Objections in terms of Chapter XX C of the Act. On 8th June, 1990, respondent No. 2 passed an order for pre-emptory purchase of the property. Possession of the property was delivered to respondent No. 2 on 20th June, 1990 in pursuance of the said order. The petitioners, vendees challenged the said order by filing a writ petition in this Court in July, 1990. In pursuance of an order passed in the said writ petition the balance amount of sale consideration, i.e Rs. 13,50,000/- was paid by respondent No. 2 to the vendor, respondent No. 3 on 28th February, 1992. On 23rd January, 1995 the said writ petition filed by the petitioners was allowed and the order of the Appropriate Authority was set aside. The case was, however, remanded back to the Appropriate Authority for fresh consideration in view of the decision of the Supreme Court in C.B Gautam v. Union of India & Ors. In view of the remand order the petitioners were served with a shew cause notice dated 5th April, 1995 requiring the petitioners to show cause why the property be not acquired. The petitioners filed a reply to the show cause notice on 18th April 1995. On 27th April 1995 a fresh order for purchase of the property was passed by the Appropriate Authority. This order was again challenged by the petitioners by way of the present writ petition filed on 23rd May, 1995.

    On 25th May, 1995 this Court passed an order regarding maintenance of status quo with respect to the property which continued to be in possession of the Appropriate Authority all through. The writ petition was finally disposed of on 13th February, 1998 when this Court quashed the order dated 27th April, 1995 and directed the Appropriate Authority to issue the “No Objection Certificate” in terms of Section 269 UL (3).

    The present application was filed in October 1998 by the Appropriate Authority praying that the petitioners and/or respondent No. 3 be directed to repay the amount of Rs. 13,50,000/- alongwith interest @ 18% per annum w.e.f, 28th February, 1992 till the date of payment to the Appropriate Authority to enable the Appropriate Authority to issue the “No Objection Certificate” as per directions of this Court contained in the judgment dated 13th February, 1998. The application is resisted by the petitioners as well as respondent No. 3 in as much as both the parties have denied their liability to pay any interest as demanded by respondent No. 2 on the sum of Rs. 13,50,000/- When this application came up for hearing before this Court on 16th April, 1999, the petitioners, i.e, vendors showed their readiness and willingness to deposit the entire amount of Rs. 13,50,000/-. Accordingly this Court directed the petitioners to deposit the amount with the Chief Commissioner of Income Tax, Chandigarh within two weeks from the said date. We are informed that the amount of Rs. 13,50,000/- was deposited by the petitioners with the said Authority on 23rd April, 1999.

    The only question with remains for consideration now is the claim of respondent No. 2 regarding interest on the said amount of Rs. 13,50,000/- w.e.f 28th February, 1992 when the said amount was paid by respondent No. 2 to respondent No. 3 in view of the order of pre-emptory purchase of the property passed by respondent No. 2. According to learned counsel for the applicant, i.e the Appropriate Authority, the Authority was deprived of this amount for a long period and it should be entitled to interest thereon. It is further submitted that the Authority was acting in bona fide discharge of its statutory functions and the payment of amount of Rs. 13.5 lacs was in pursuance of the same. The petitioners challenged the actions of the Authority and also obtained an order of status quo with respect to the property as a result whereof the applicant could not enjoy the property of put it to any use. Thus according to the learned counsel neither the property was available with the applicant for any use or enjoyment while at the same time it was deprived of the amount of Rs. 13.5 lacs paid as consideration. On this basis the learned counsel has tried to justify the claim for interest. He has relied on a decision of the Karnataka High Court reported in Appropriate Authority & Ors. v. Mass Traders Pvt. Ltd. & Ors., (1993) 202 ITR 741. Our attention has been drawn particularly to the following observations contained in the said judgment:—

    “By directing respondent No. 1 to pay interest, we are not penalising respondent No. 1 for filing the writ petition. Respondent No. 1 is required to compensate the Central Government for the type of interim order which it has obtained thereby disabling the Central Government from auctioning the property and recovering the amount and depriving the Central Government of the use of the large sum of Rs. 1,84.06.325. This large sum is lying with the owner of the property and the Central Government is deprived of the same. Therefore, it is necessary for the first respondent to deposit the entire consideration amount with moderate interest to compensate the Central Government.”

    Both the parties to the transaction, i.e the vendor as well as the vendee have denied any liability regarding payment of interest to respondent No. 2.applicant. On behalf of the vendor it has been submitted that in terms of the agreement to sell the vendor was entitled to receive the balance sale consideration. The vendor parted with the possession of the property on 20th June, 1990. She received the balance sale consideration on 28th February, 1992 even though the order regarding pre-emptory purchase of the property was passed on 8th June, 1990. After the possession of the property was handed over to the Appropriate Authority on 20th June, 1990, the vendor lost her property while it did not receive the balance sale consideration, the payment where of was delayed upto 28th February, 1992. The learned counsel submits that the vendor was to receive the balance sale consideration in any case and, therefore, there was no question for the vendor being called upon to pay any interest on the balance amount of sale consideration received by the vendor. For all practical purposes so far as the vendor is concerned, the transaction was over for her when possession of the property was delivered to the Appropriate Authority and the balance sale consideration was received by her from the said Authority. The vendor neither challenged the order of the Appropriate Authority in any manner nor obtained any interim orders. The learned counsel for the vendor further submitted that even as per the scheme of the Act the vendor is to receive the balance sale consideration in a time bound manner which shows that it was always intended that the vendor should not be deprived of the money. Another aspect which has been highlighted by the counsel for the vendor is that if the vendor is called upon to pay any interest the entire sale consideration will be practically wiped out.

    Coming to the contentions raised on behalf of the purchasers, denying liability to pay any interest, it has been urged that the purchasers have been deprived of possession of the property for such a long time. They paid the earnest money in pursuance of the agreement right at the stage of the agreement. This amount was never reimbursed to the purchasers. So far as the petitioners' role in challenging the orders of the Appropriate Authority is concerned, the petitioners submit that on both the occasions they succeeded in their challenge and the orders of the Appropriate Authority were set aside which shows that the petitioners had taken up a right cause and the orders of the Appropriate Authority were not in accordance with the law on both the occasions. The petitioners were exercising their legal rights and they cannot be blamed for that. On equitable aspect the petitioners have submitted that they have already been deprived of the possession of the property for such a long time. They are old people and because of the delay they have not been able to plan their affairs properly. They intended to construct a house on the plot subject-mailer of the controversy for their residence. The whole scheme has been delayed by nearly ten years.

    We have considered the rival contentions of learned counsel for the parties. In the facts and circumstances of the case it appears that neither of the three parties can be faulted. So far as the Appropriate Authority is concerned it was acting in bona fide discharge of its statutory duties and it cannot be blamed for having passed the orders regarding peremptory purchase of the property. Law has taken its course and the orders were ultimately set aside by the court. That should not be taken to mean that the action of the Authority was not bona fide. The vendor, i.e respondent No. 3 cannot be held liable in any manner for payment of any interest to the Appropriate Authority. The vendor had to received the sale consideration of the property. She handed over the possession of the property to the Appropriate Authority and it was just and fair that she should have received the balance sale consideration. Moreover asking her to pay any interest on the said amount at this stage will only mean that she will be deprived of both, the property as well as the sale consideration because the entire amount will be wiped off by way of payment of interest.

    Coming to the case of the purchasers we are of the view that no fault can be found with their actions in dealing with the property which they intended to purchase all through. The petitioners were within their legal rights to challenge the order of acquisition and their stand is vindicated by the fact that the orders of peremptory purchase passed by the Appropriate Authority were quashed by the Court on both the occasions. The petitioners were always ready and willing to pay the balance sale consideration. To protect their interests in the property, the petitioners cannot be faulted for seeking the orders for maintenance of status quo the respect to the properly. Unless such an order was passed by the Court, the property would have gone beyond the reach of the petitioners. The department would have put the property to auction and third party interest would have intervened.

    With due respect we are unable to agree with the reasoning contained in the judgment in Karnataka Appropriate Authority v. Mass Traders Pvt. Ltd. We are unable to persuade ourselves to the idea of purchasers being called upon to compensate the Appropriate Authority for having obtained the order of maintenance of status quo with respect to the property. Seeking such an order was fully justified. Unless such an order was passed the property would have gone out of the hands of the petitioners. The amount of balance consideration paid by the Appropriate Authority to the vendee was in accordance with their statutory liability on account of having passed an order of peremptory purchase of the property. At best it can be said that the purchasers did not have to part with the amount of Rs. 13.5 lacs which was the balance sale consideration and this money remained with them. In our view deprivation of the use and fruits of the property to the purchasers, i.e the petitioners herein was a greater loss to them as compared to the mearge amount of interest which assumably they could have earned on that amount. The purchasers had to keep the amount always ready and available and they could not have utilised the amount for other investments. We feel it would be inequitable to ask the purchasers to pay any interest whatsoever on this amount. As already noted the amount of Rs. 13.5 lacs has already been deposited by the petitioners with respondent No. 2 on 23rd April, 1999. The prayer of respondent No. 2 for award of interest on the amount of Rs. 13,50,000/- is accordingly rejected. Respondent No. 2 is directed to issue the “No Objection Certificate” in terms of Section 269 UL(3) of the Income Tax Act forthwith, not later than four weeks from the date of this order and simultaneously deliver the possession of the property to the vendee. There will be no order as to costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Jaspal Kaur & Ors. v. Union Of India.
    (Aug 11, 1999)