Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion — Dr. M.K. Sharma, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner filed a company petition under section 433 read with section 434 of the Companies Act seeking winding up of the respondent company for inability to pay a debt alleged to be Rs. 6,89,870.76. The petition alleged the respondent had admitted the liability but did not pay.

On 2.11.1993 the Company Judge held the winding up petition not maintainable and directed the petitioner to sue in a civil suit, if within limitation. The petitioner appealed (Company Appeal No. 32/1993). The Division Bench by order dated 29.11.1995 set aside the 2.11.1993 order and remitted the matter to the Company Judge, observing there was an admission of liability by the respondent and that the Company Judge should consider Section 433.

After remission the Company Petition was listed for admission on 10.4.1997. No counsel appeared for the respondent on that date; the petition was admitted and citation directed to be published in Delhi Gazette and two newspapers. Citations were published in early May 1997. On 12.9.1997 counsel representing the respondent's counsel appeared and the matter was re-notified for arguments on 2.12.1997. On 2.12.1997 counsel for the petitioner argued; no one appeared for the respondent and on 2.12.1997 the Company Judge wound up the respondent company, appointed the Official Liquidator and directed publication of the order (publication took place on 24.1.1998).

The respondent filed applications seeking recall/review of the orders dated 10.4.1997 and 2.12.1997, an application under Section 5 of the Limitation Act for condonation of delay, and an application to stay the orders. The present opinion disposes of those applications.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the orders dated 10.4.1997 (admission of petition) and 2.12.1997 (winding up order) should be recalled or reviewed.
  2. Whether delay in filing the applications for recall/review should be condoned under Section 5 of the Limitation Act.
  3. Whether a party should be relieved for non-appearance caused by the negligence or laches of its advocate under Order IX Rule 13 CPC.
  4. Whether the winding up petition was maintainable despite a pending or dismissed civil suit remedy (interaction between remedies under the Companies Act and civil suits).
  5. Whether the petition was barred by limitation, specifically whether the balance sheet and reply of 22.11.1991 constituted an acknowledgement under Section 18 of the Limitation Act, thereby making the petition within time.

Arguments of the Parties

Respondent / Applicants' Arguments

  • The application for recalling/reviewing was filed under Order IX Rule 13 CPC and the respondent should not be penalised for negligence of its counsel; the respondent had retained counsel and was unaware of counsel's non-appearance.
  • The respondent only became aware of the order dated 10.4.1997 upon receiving notices from the Registrar of Companies around end of January 1998; delay in filing the recall/review was thus explained and condonation under Section 5 Limitation Act was sought.
  • Reliance was placed on decisions (Bank of India v. Mehta Brothers; Messrs N.K. Private Ltd. v. Hotz Hotels; Rafiq v. Munshi Lal) for the proposition that an innocent litigant who entrusted the matter to an advocate should not suffer for the advocate's omissions.
  • Substantively, the respondent argued the company petition was not maintainable because an application under Order XII Rule 6 CPC in Suit No. 475/1990 had been dismissed; further the claim was disputed and/or barred by limitation.

Petitioner and Official Liquidator's Arguments

  • The petitioner opposed the recall/review and contended the admission and winding up orders require no interference; relied upon reply material and earlier proceedings.
  • The petitioner argued that there is no bar to maintaining both a civil suit and a company petition for winding up because the remedies are distinct; relied on authorities (State Bank of India v. Hegde and Golay Ltd.; Central Bank of India v. Sukhani Mining; V.K. Jain v. Richa Laboratories) to support maintainability.
  • The petitioner asserted the debt was acknowledged in the balance sheet and reply of 22.11.1991, which constitutes an acknowledgment under Section 18 Limitation Act, making the petition within time.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Bank of India v. Mehta Brothers and others, AIR 1991 Delhi 1994 Principle that an innocent litigant who entrusted the matter to counsel should not suffer for counsel's neglect (relied upon by respondent). Cited by respondent's counsel; court accepted the principle as settled law but held facts showed respondent had knowledge and laches of its own, so the principle did not entitle relief.
Messrs N.K. Private Ltd. v. Hotz Hotels (P) Ltd., 1974 Rajdhani Law Reporter 153 Same principle as above regarding relief when counsel's negligence caused non-appearance. Cited by respondent's counsel; court acknowledged the principle but found the respondent had actual or constructive knowledge of the hearings and was not entitled to relief.
Rafiq and another v. Munshi Lal and another, 1981 (3) SCR 509 Principle that a litigant should not be punished for his advocate's inaction (relied upon by respondent). Cited by respondent's counsel; court held that despite the principle being settled, the respondent showed negligence and/or wilful inaction and therefore relief was not appropriate.
State Bank of India v. Hegde and Golay Ltd., 1987 (62) Company Cases 239 Support for the proposition that civil suit for recovery and company winding up proceedings are distinct remedies. Cited by petitioner to show maintainability of the winding up petition notwithstanding civil suit; court agreed the remedies are distinct and petition was maintainable.
Central Bank of India v. Sukhani Mining and Engg. Industries Pvt. Ltd. and Others, 1977 (47) Company Cases 1 Authority for distinctness of remedies (civil suit and company petition) and maintainability of winding up petition. Cited by petitioner; court relied on same principle to hold the company petition was maintainable.
V.K. Jain v. Richa Laboratories (P) Ltd., 50 (1993) Delhi Law Times 378 Support for the proposition that recovery suit and winding up petition are separate remedies. Cited by petitioner; court accepted the reasoning and held petition maintainable despite dismissal of a civil application.
Larsen & Toubro Ltd. v. Commercial Electrical Works and others, 67 (1997) Delhi Law Times 387 Authority discussed regarding balance sheets/statements of account amounting to an acknowledgement of liability. Cited by court to support finding that the respondent's balance sheet and reply constituted an acknowledgement under Section 18 Limitation Act, making the petition within time.
ILR 33 Calcutta 1033 Held that a statement of accounts like a balance sheet constitutes acknowledgement of liability. Referred to in support of the proposition that the balance sheet constituted written acknowledgement for limitation purposes; used to conclude petition was within time.
Division Bench order dated 29.11.1995 (Appeal No. Co.A 32/1993) Recorded existence of admission by respondent in reply dated 22.11.1991 to the debt of Rs. 6,89,870.76. The court relied on that earlier Division Bench finding as corroborative material to conclude there was an admission/acknowledgement by the respondent.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded in two stages: first it examined procedural contentions about non-appearance and delay, then it considered the substantive merits (maintainability and limitation).

  1. Procedural chronology and publicity: The court noted the Company Judge directed listing on 10.4.1997; the respondent's counsel was absent on 10.4.1997 when petition was admitted and citation was ordered. Citations were published in the STATESMAN (5.5.1997), DAINIK VEER ARJUN (3.5.1997) and Delhi Gazette (8.5.1997). The respondent was represented on 12.9.1997 by another counsel and the matter was fixed for arguments on 2.12.1997; on 2.12.1997 no one appeared for respondent and winding up order was passed. Further publication occurred on 24.1.1998. The court emphasized these publications and actual representation on 12.9.1997 to infer knowledge.
  2. On the contention that the respondent should not suffer for its advocate's negligence, the court acknowledged the cited authorities establishing that principle but found the facts here showed both negligence of counsel and negligence/wilful inaction on the part of the respondent itself. The court observed that the respondent had constructive or actual knowledge of the admission of the petition and the dates (because of citations and actual attendance on 12.9.1997) and still took no steps. Thus the equitable principle relied upon did not apply to justify recalling or reviewing the orders.
  3. On maintainability and limitation the court examined the documentary material: the respondent's balance sheet for year ending 31.3.1990 listed the petitioner as a sundry creditor for Rs. 6,89,870.76, and the respondent's reply dated 22.11.1991 (signed by Director Subhash Sahni) transmitting that balance sheet to Registrar of Companies was treated as an admission/acknowledgement. The court recorded evidence of these facts, including testimony of R.C. Meena (Registrar of Companies office) and Ex. X-1 (list of creditors).
  4. The court treated the Division Bench's earlier order (29.11.1995) as recording admission of liability and cited precedent that a balance sheet or statement of accounts can constitute acknowledgement of liability. Applying Section 18 of the Limitation Act, the court held the petition filed on 14.5.1992 to enforce the liability acknowledged in the balance sheet was within limitation.
  5. Regarding the contention that dismissal of an application in the civil suit (Order XII Rule 6 or Order VI Rule 12 references in the opinion) barred seeking winding up, the court held the remedies are distinct: a civil suit for recovery and a company petition for winding up are separate and a creditor may pursue both remedies. Consequently dismissal of an application in the suit did not bar the company petition.
  6. The court declined to take notice of an affidavit filed by the respondent after conclusion of arguments (filed 4.5.1998 after hearing on 1.5.1998), stating it was both late and not sought nor permitted during arguments.
  7. On the totality of facts and evidence, the court concluded there was an acknowledgement and an inability to pay by the respondent; therefore the earlier orders admitting the petition and winding up the company were valid and justified. No ground existed to recall or review the orders.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The applications by the respondent seeking recall and/or review of the orders dated 10.4.1997 and 2.12.1997, the application under Section 5 Limitation Act for condonation of delay, and the application for stay are dismissed.

Consequences and immediate effects:

  • The winding up order of 2.12.1997 (and the admission order of 10.4.1997, which merged into the final order) stands; the Official Liquidator's appointment and the directions given in that order remain effective.
  • The court found the petition was within time because the respondent's balance sheet and reply of 22.11.1991 constituted an acknowledgement of the debt under Section 18 of the Limitation Act; therefore the petition was not barred by limitation.
  • The respondent was not entitled to relief for non-appearance because of both counsel's negligence and the respondent's own negligence/wilful inaction; hence equitable relief under Order IX Rule 13 CPC was refused.
  • The court refused to admit a post-argument affidavit filed by the respondent.
  • Administrative follow-up: the case is to be listed before the Hon'ble Company Judge for further orders after obtaining orders of the Hon'ble Chief Justice (as recorded by the court).

The opinion records that the principles relied upon by the respondent are settled law but, on the particular facts (publications, previous appearance, admissions), the respondent was not entitled to recall or review. The court did not set aside or modify the earlier orders and did not grant condonation or stay.

    Rishi Pal Gupta v. S.J Knitting And Finishing Mills Pvt. Ltd

    Dr. M.K Sharma, J.— By this order I propose to dispose of the applications filed by the respondent praying for recalling and/or review of the order dated 10.4.1997 and 2.12.1997 passed by this court in the connected Company Petition, the application filed by the respondent under Section 5 of the Limitation Act praying for condonation of delay in filing the aforesaid application praying for recalling and reviewing of the orders and also the application filed by the respondent praying for stay of the aforesaid orders passed by this court.

    2. The petitioner filed a petition in this court under section 433 read with section 434 of the Companies Act praying for winding up of the respondent company for their inability to pay the dues of the petitioner amounting to Rs. 6,89,870.76. It was stated in the petition that the aforesaid liability of the respondent company as due to the petitioner was admitted and that inspite of the aforesaid admission no payment was made which clearly established that the respondent company was unable to pay its debt.

    3. Notice was issued on the aforesaid petition and the matter was listed before this court for admission of the company petition. By order dated 2.11.1993 this court held that the winding up petition is not maintainable and that the remedy available with the petitioner was to file a suit provided the same is within limitation. An appeal was preferred as against the aforesaid order passed by this court which was registered as Company Appeal No. 32/1993. The Division Bench of this court by order dated 29.11.1995 set aside the order passed by the Company Judge on 2.11.1993 and remitted the matter back to the Company Judge again for disposal of the same in accordance with law in the light of the observations made by the Division Bench. The Division Bench, while considering the matter observed that there was an admission of the respondent of liability of dues payable to the petitioner to the extent of Rs. 6,89,870.76 and that the Company Judge should have considered the issue of applicability of the provisions of Section 433 of the Companies Act. It further observed that the view taken by the learned Company Judge that entries in books are not evidence is not correct as there was material to fix liability and that the said material is contained in the admission made by the respondent in its reply dated 22.11.1991

    4. After remission by the Division Bench the matter was listed before this court and on 10.4.1997 the Company Petition was listed for admission before the Company Judge. However, when the matter was called none appeared on behalf of the respondent and accordingly the Company Petition was taken up in the absence of the counsel for the respondent. On consideration of the facts and circumstances of the case the court was satisfied that a prima facie case has been made out by the petitioner that respondent is unable to pay the debt of the petitioner and in that view of the matter the petitioner was admitted and citation was directed to be published in Delhi Gazette as also in one issue each of the STATESMAN (English) and DAINIK VEER ARJUN (Hindi). In pursuance of the aforesaid order publication of citation was done in the said two newspapers as also in Delhi Gazette and the said citations have been placed on record. The citation was published in the STATESMAN on 5.5.1997, in DAINIK VEER ARJUN on 3.5.1997 and in Delhi Gazette on 8.5.1997 After publication of the aforesaid citation the matter was placed before this court on the next date i.e on 12.9.1997 when an Advocate was present representing the counsel for the respondent and in his presence the matter was directed to be re-notified for arguments on 2.12.1997 for passing final order. In terms of the aforesaid order the case was again listed on 2.12.1997 when arguments advanced by counsel for the petitioner were heard. Incidently none appeared on behalf of the respondent on that date. By order dated 2.12.1997 the Company Judge being satisfied that the requirements of Section 433, 434 and 439 were satisfied in the present case, the respondent company was directed to be wound up and Official Liquidator attached to this court was appointed as Liquidator of the company. The Liquidator was directed to take over into his custody and possession, the assets and records of the respondent company immediately and necessary communication was also directed to be sent to the Registrar of Companies and notice in the prescribed form of making the order was also directed to be published in the newspapers namely STATESMAN and DAINIK VEER ARJUN. In pursuance of the aforesaid order passed by this court publication has been done in the STATESMAN and in DAINIK VEER ARJUN on 24.1.1998

    5. Now the respondent has filed the aforesaid applications praying for recalling of the aforesaid orders dated 10.4.1997 and 12.9.1997 alongwith an application for condonation of delay in filing the said application as also for passing necessary orders staying the operation of the aforesaid two orders.

    6. I have heard Mr. Harish Uppal, learned counsel appearing for the applicants/respondent, the learned counsel appearing for the petitioner as also the Official Liquidator represented by Mr. S.K Luthra, Advocate.

    7. Mr. Uppal submitted before me that the application praying for recalling and/or review of the order has been filed by the respondent under the provisions of Order 9 Rule 13 CPC. He has submitted that for negligence and non-appearance of the counsel the respondent cannot be blamed and that the respondent cannot be made to suffer because of laches on the part of his Advocate. It was stated that the respondent paid fee to its counsel for representing it in the case and was not aware that he had been absenting from the case. Counsel further submitted that the delay in filing the aforesaid application has also been explained as the company was never aware of the order dated 10.4.1997 and became aware of the same only on pursuing the matter on receipt of the notices from the Registrar of Companies somewhere in the end of January 1998. In support of his aforesaid submissions the learned counsel for the respondent relied upon the decisions of this court in Bank of India v. Mehta Brothers and others, reported in AIR 1991 Delhi 1994; Messrs N.K Private Ltd.… v. Hotz Hotels (P) Ltd.…, reported in 1974 Rajdhani Law Reporter 153 and the decision of the Supreme Court in Rafiq and another v. Munshi Lal and another, reported in 1981 (3) SCR 509. Relying on the ratio of the aforesaid decisions the learned counsel submitted that an innocent litigant after doing everything in his power to effectively participate in the proceedings by entrusting the case to his advocate, should not be made to suffer for the inaction or deliberate omission of his agent.

    8. I have also heard the learned counsel appearing for the petitioner who has vehemently contested the aforesaid applications and urged that the orders passed by this court admitting the Company Petition and thereafter winding up the company do not call for any interference by this court. He also relied upon the replies filed by the petitioner to the aforesaid applications.

    9. The records of the case reveal that on 21.1.1997 the Company Judge directed the Company Petition to be listed on 10.4.1997 in the presence of counsel for both the parties. On 10.4.1997 when the Company petition was admitted by a speaking and reasoned order the counsel for the respondent remained absent. However, on the subsequent date i.e on 12.9.1997 the counsel for the respondent was represented by another counsel before the Court in whose presence the next date was notified, fixing the company petition for arguments. On 2.12.1997 the petition was taken up for final arguments and the order for winding up of the respondent company was passed. Even if it is assumed that the respondent had no knowledge of the date fixed i.e 10.4.1997 it cannot be believed that the respondent had no knowledge of the citation published in the two newspapers and Delhi Gazette as stated above in the first week of May, 1997. Citation in terms of the order dated 10.4.1997 was published in two newspapers and also in Delhi Gazette indicating therein that the petition has already been admitted and the same has been set down for hearing on 12.12.1997 In view of the publication of the citation in the two national newspapers it could be reasonably and logically deduced that the respondent had knowledge about the order passed on 10.4.1997 and fixing the matter for 12.9.1997 when in fact the counsel was present representing the counsel for the respondent.

    The principles decided by the decisions relied upon by the counsel appearing for the respondent are settled law and cannot be disputed. However, on consideration of the facts and circumstances of the case it is crystal clear that the respondent itself had definite knowledge of the dates fixed in the company petition atleast for 12.9.1997 as also 2.12.1997 Even in terms of the order passed on 2.12.1997 the citation was published in the STATESMAN and DAINIK VEER ARJUN on 24.1.1998 Inspite of the aforesaid publication the respondent/applicant did not file its present applications till 27.2.1998 In my considered opinion therefore, there was not only negligence and laches on the part of the counsel for the respondent/applicants in appearing in the case on 10.4.1997 and 2.12.1997 but also of the respondents who inspite of knowledge of the date for 2.12.1997 did not take any positive steps for its or its counsel's appearance in the case on the aforesaid date. On passing of the order dated 2.12.1997 the order dated 10.4.1997 legally got merged with the order dated 2.12.1997 I am, therefore, satisfied that there is negligence and/or wilful inaction on the part of the respondent/applicants also in contesting the matter and therefore, they are not entitled to any sympathetic consideration from this court.

    10. Inspite of the aforesaid position since I heard the counsel appearing for the petitioner as also the counsel appearing for the respondents on the merits of the case including the issue as to whether any review of the two orders is called for in the present case, I therefore, propose to deal with, adjudicate and decide the same as well.

    11. In orders dated 10.4.1997 and 2.12.1997 reference has been made to the admission of the respondent to the extent of the amount claimed in the company petition. The respondent company admitted its liability to the extent of the amount claimed in the petition. The aforesaid admission was made by the respondent in its reply dated 22.11.1991 which was signed by Shri Subhash Sahni, one of the Directors of the respondent company. The petitioner, in support of his contention that the respondent company had admitted its liability examined one Shri R.C Meena, Senior Technical Assistant, Office of the Registrar of Companies. He has deposed that notice was issued on 17.9.1991 to the respondent company by the Registrar of Companies in pursuance of a complaint filed by the petitioner. He also deposed that in pursuance of the said notice a reply was sent by the respondent company dated 22.11.1991 which was signed by Shri Subhash Sahni, Director of the respondent company. A photo copy of the list of the creditors as admitted by the respondents was also proved by him and marked as Ex.X-1. The Ex.X-1 gives details of the balance sheet of the respondent company as on 31.3.1990 and in the list of sundry creditors attached thereto the name of the petitioner company appears at page 3 wherein the amount of Rs. 6,89,870.76 was shown due and payable to the petitioner. The Division Bench of this court in Appeal No. Co.A 32/1993 have also held that there is an admission of liability by the respondents to the extent of Rs. 6,89,870.76 which is contained in the admission made by the respondents in its reply dated 22.11.1991 On consideration of the aforesaid materials this court came to the conclusion that the respondent is indebted to the petitioner to the aforesaid extent of Rs. 6,89,870.76 and that the said company is unable to pay its debt.

    12. Counsel appearing for the respondent however, submitted before me that the company petition filed by the petitioner is not maintainable as his application under Order 12 Rule 6 of the Code of Civil Procedure has been dismissed in Suit No. 475/1990. He submitted that in view of the aforesaid position the discretionary relief under the Companies Act could not have been granted to the petitioner, since the petitioner is not entitled to avail two alternative remedies at the same time. He further submitted that the claim was disputed claim and there was no admission as held by this court. He further submitted that the claim of the petitioner as raised in the Company petition is also barred by limitation and, therefore, the aforesaid orders passed by this court are not sustainable.

    13. Learned counsel appearing for the petitioner refuted all the allegations and submitted that there is no bar to maintain both - a civil suit for recovery of debt and also filing a petition in the Company Court for winding up orders as the two remedies are distinct and separate. He further submitted that the claim made by the petitioner in the present petition is within the period of limitation as there was an acknowledgement of the debt in the balance sheet and therefore, the present petition filed by the petitioner for enforcing a liability of the company acknowledged in the balance sheet is indisputably within time. In support of his contention the learned counsel relied upon the decisions in State Bank of India v. Hegde and Golay Ltd., reported in 1987 (62) Company Cases 239; Central Bank of India v. Sukhani Mining and Engg. Industries Pvt. Ltd. and Others, reported in 1977 (47) Company Cases page 1, a decision of this court in V.K Jain… v. Richa Laboratories (P) Ltd.…., reported in 50 (1993) Delhi Law Times 378. It is now well settled law that the remedy of recovery of money through a civil suit is distinct from that of the remedy provided for winding up of a company for non-payment of its debt under Section 434 of the Companies Act. In the winding up proceedings the final order passed is to wind up the company which is not only beneficial for the petitioner but is also beneficial to all the shareholders, creditors or contributories of the companies. The purpose of filing a recovery suit and a winding up petition are separate and distinct and therefore, even when a civil suit for recovery of a debt is filed there is no bar for the creditors to file a petition in the Company Court for winding up of the defaulting company, Therefore, in my considered opinion the Company Petition filed by the petitioner is maintainable.

    14. The respondent in its balance sheet for the year ending 31.3.1990 has admitted that the petitioner is one of the sundry creditors of the respondent company and its name is shown in the list of sundry creditors in the said balance sheet. The respondent has also admitted its liability in its reply dated 22.11.1991 whereunder it has transmitted the said balance sheet to the Registrar of Companies. The Division Bench of this court has also in its order dated 29.11.1995 recorded that there is an admission of liability by the respondent to the extent of Rs. 6,89,870.76 and that the said liability was acknowledged by the respondent in its reply dated 22.11.1991 In view of the aforesaid acknowledgement of debt in the balance sheet as also in the reply sent by the respondent through one of its Directors constituting acknowledgement in writing within the meaning of Section 18 of the Limitation Act, the petition presented by the petitioner on 14.5.1992 to enforce a liability of the company acknowledged in the balance sheet for the year ending 31.3.1990 is indisputably within time. Reference may also be made to a decision of this court in Larsen & Toubro Ltd. v. Commercial Electrical Works and others, reported in 67 (1997) Delhi Law Times 387 wherein this court referred to the decision reported in ILR 33 Calcutta 1033 wherein it was held that a statement of accounts like balance sheet would constitute acknowledgement of liability. The decisions relied upon by the counsel for the respondent also have taken the same view with which I respectfully agree.

    15. In view of the aforesaid position I hold that the claim of the petitioner as raised in the present petition is not barred by time and the same could have been adjudicated upon by this court. In my considered opinion the fact that the application of the petitioner under Order 6 Rule 12 CPC in the suit was dismissed, cannot debar him from seeking winding up of the respondent company through a company petition on the basis of the aforesaid admission and acknowledgement of debt made by the respondent.

    16. The respondent, after the conclusion of arguments and hearing on 1.5.1998, has filed an affidavit on 4.5.1998 Since the said affidavit has been filed after conclusion of arguments, I propose not to take notice of the aforesaid affidavit. Since the respondent was neither asked for nor was given any liberty to file any such affidavit during the course of arguments nor any order in respect of the same was recorded on 1.5.1998, the said affidavit, in my considered opinion, cannot be noticed.

    17. On consideration of the entire facts and circumstances of the case I am satisfied that there was an acknowledgement of debt by the respondent which the respondent has failed to pay to the petitioner and therefore, the orders passed by this court admitting the company petition to hearing and finally winding up the respondent company are valid and justified. No ground has been made out to either recall or review any of the aforesaid orders passed by this court and therefore, no interference is called for. The applications stand dismissed as such.

    The case be now listed before the Hon'ble Company Judge for further orders after obtaining orders of Hon'ble the Chief Justice.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Rishi Pal Gupta v. S.J Knitting And Finishing Mills Pvt. Ltd
    (May 18, 1998)