AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Order 1 Rule 10 C.P.C read with Order 6 Rule 17 C.P.C (I.A 7351/94),
  • consequence.11. Section 92 of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • provisions of Section 92 C.P.C13.
  • SOCIETIES REGISTRATION ACT 1860
  • Order 39 Rules 1 and 2 C.P.C
  • clauses of Section 92 C.P.C
  • Order 1 Rule 8(1) C.P.C
  • Order 7 Rule 11 C.P.C
  • Order 1 Rule 8 C.P.C
  • Section 92 C.P.C14.
  • Section 92 C.P.C3.
  • Section 92 C.P.C4.
  • Section 92 C.P.C,
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Order 1 Rule 10 C.P.C read with Order 6 Rule 17 C.P.C (I.A 7351/94),
  • consequence.11. Section 92 of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • provisions of Section 92 C.P.C13.
  • SOCIETIES REGISTRATION ACT 1860
  • Order 39 Rules 1 and 2 C.P.C
  • clauses of Section 92 C.P.C
  • Order 1 Rule 8(1) C.P.C
  • Order 7 Rule 11 C.P.C
  • Order 1 Rule 8 C.P.C
  • Section 92 C.P.C14.
  • Section 92 C.P.C3.
  • Section 92 C.P.C4.
  • Section 92 C.P.C,
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The suit was filed by Plaintiff No. 1, who is the brother of Defendant No. 2, against Defendant No. 1, a society registered under the Societies Registration Act, 1860, and other defendants including members of the society's Board of Directors. Plaintiff No. 1 claimed a declaration that the suit property, Khosla Hospital, run by Defendant No. 1 society, is a public trust property and that neither the society nor its Board of Directors can transfer, sell, or change the management of the hospital. The suit was instituted under Section 92 of the Code of Civil Procedure (C.P.C) with leave of the Court. The plaintiff also sought interim injunctions to restrain defendants from alienating the hospital property and moved to add parties after alleged unauthorized transfer of management. Defendants filed an application to reject the plaint under Order 7 Rule 11 C.P.C and sought revocation of the leave granted to sue under Section 92 C.P.C, alleging the suit was false, frivolous, and motivated by personal vengeance. The Court heard the parties and considered the applications for amendment and rejection of the plaint.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the suit property, Khosla Hospital, constitutes a public trust property under Section 92 C.P.C.
  2. Whether the plaintiff was entitled to sue under Section 92 C.P.C and claim the reliefs sought, including a declaration that the hospital is a public trust and that it cannot be transferred or alienated by the defendants.
  3. Whether the leave granted to the plaintiff to sue under Section 92 C.P.C should be revoked.
  4. Whether the plaint should be rejected under Order 7 Rule 11 C.P.C for lack of cause of action and improper reliefs.
  5. Whether amendments to the plaint and addition of defendants were permissible after the alleged unauthorized transfer of management.

Arguments of the Parties

Plaintiff's Arguments

  • The plaintiff is a founder member and Vice Chairman of Defendant No. 1 society, which runs Khosla Hospital on land allotted by the Delhi Development Authority with public donations.
  • The hospital and other properties of the society are public trust properties used for charitable purposes and cannot be sold or transferred.
  • The plaintiff discovered an advertisement indicating possible transfer or sale, prompting the suit for declaration that the hospital is a public trust and to restrain defendants from alienating the property.
  • The plaintiff alleged that defendants violated an interim injunction by transferring hospital management to other parties, necessitating addition of those parties as defendants and a declaration that such transfer is legally ineffective.

Defendants' Arguments

  • The suit is false, frivolous, speculative, motivated by personal vengeance, and lacks cause of action.
  • The defendants have engaged in philanthropic activities and managed the society's assets diligently.
  • The plaintiff and defendants 2 to 4 resided together and the suit is instigated by a third party (Col. Khosla) with mala fide intentions to partition shared property and usurp plaintiff’s share.
  • The reliefs claimed do not fall within the ambit of Section 92 C.P.C and proper court fee was not paid.
  • Leave to sue under Section 92 C.P.C was obtained by misrepresentation and should be revoked.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Pragdatji Guru Bhagwandasji v. Ishwarlalbhai Narsibhai, A.I.R 1952 S.C 143 Only reliefs enumerated in Section 92 C.P.C can be claimed and granted in suits under that section; declaratory relief that property is a trust is not among them. The Court applied this precedent to hold that since the plaintiff’s reliefs did not fall within the specific reliefs under Section 92 C.P.C, the suit could not be maintained under that provision and the declaration sought was outside its scope.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analyzed the applicability of Section 92 C.P.C, which is designed for suits concerning breaches of public trusts of a charitable or religious nature, requiring specific conditions and reliefs enumerated in the section. The Court found that the plaintiff’s suit did not claim any relief enumerated under Section 92 C.P.C but sought a declaration that the hospital is a public trust and that the defendants cannot transfer or alienate it. Such a declaratory relief is not contemplated by the section unless ancillary to a main relief. The Court observed that the plaintiff failed to establish a cause of action under Section 92 C.P.C and that the leave granted to sue under this section was obtained by misrepresentation. Consequently, the Court revoked the leave and rejected the plaint under Order 7 Rule 11 C.P.C. Applications for amendment and addition of defendants were also rejected as the proposed amendments would change the nature of the suit, which was no longer maintainable. The Court noted that the plaintiff has other efficacious remedies available and dismissed all related applications as infructuous.

Holding and Implications

DISMISSED

The Court revoked the leave granted to the plaintiff to sue under Section 92 C.P.C and rejected the plaint for lack of cause of action and improper reliefs. Applications for amendment and addition of defendants were also dismissed. The suit was de-registered, effectively ending the proceedings. No new precedent was established; the decision strictly enforced the requirement that suits under Section 92 C.P.C must claim reliefs specifically enumerated therein and that declaratory reliefs outside that scope are impermissible. The direct effect is that the plaintiff cannot maintain this suit under Section 92 C.P.C and must seek other legal remedies if available.

    J.C. Khosla v. Khosla Medical Institute And Research Society Ltd.

    Mr. Devinder Gupta, J.— Plaintiff No. 1 is the brother of defendant No. 2 and defendants 3 and 4 are the wife and son respectively of defendant No. 2. Defendant No. 1 is a society registered under the Societies Registration Act, 1860 and it is not disputed that the society is a non-political, non-profit making and non-sactarian society. Its aims and objects, inter alia, are to establish, maintain, control and run Medical Research Centres in various systems of medicine and to render medical aid or relief and for the purpose aforesaid to open, establish, maintain, manage, control and conduct dispensaries, hospitals etc.

    2. The suit has been filed by the plaintiff under Section 92 C.P.C claiming a decree for declaration to the effect that the suit property is a public trust property, namely, Khosla Hospital, situated at Shalimar Bagh (West), Delhi, which is run by defendant No. 1 society as a public trust and neither defendant No. 1 nor its Board of Directors including defendants 2 to 4 can transfer or sell the property or change the management of the hospital through any means. Simultaneously, while filing the suit, a prayer was made seeking leave of the Court to institute the suit under Section 92 C.P.C

    3. On 22nd June, 1994, summons were directed to be issued to the defendants. On 4th July, 1994, it was clarified that permission sought for by the plaintiff to sue under Section 92 C.P.C had been granted. In I.A 7351/94, plaintiff has prayed for addition of certain defendants and for carrying on amendments to the plaint. In I.A 8008/94, the defendants have sought the rejection of the plaint under Order 7 Rule 11 C.P.C In the same application by necessary implication, the defendants have sought the revocation of the leave granted to the plaintiff for filing the suit under Section 92 C.P.C

    4. I have heard learned Counsel for the parties at length, who have taken me through the entire record.

    5. It is plaintiff's case that he is the founder member of defendant No. 1 society and is also its Vice Chairman. Defendant No. 2 is the President, defendant No. 3 is the Treasurer of the society and defendant No. 4 is a member of the Board of Directors. A plot of land was allotted to defendant No. 1 by the Delhi Development Authority at nominal lease money on which a building for hospital, namely, Khosla Hospital was raised for which donations of the public were used, which is a double storeyed building providing 125 beds facility and is well equipped with the latest equipment. According to the plaintiff, the hospital run by defendant No. 1 and other properties of defendant No. 1 society are public trust properties. The purpose for which defendant No. 1 is running a hospital is a public charitable purpose. The hospital is, therefore, a public trust. Plaintiff has further averred that hospital being a public trust cannot be sold. He happened to come across an advertisement in newspaper due to which necessity arose for filing the suit claiming a decree for declaration that the hospital which is being run by defendant No. 1 society is a public trust and that the same cannot be transferred, alienated or parted with in any manner whatsoever.

    6. Simultaneously, along with the suit, an application was also moved under Order 39 Rules 1 and 2 C.P.C praying for an interim order restraining the defendants from transferring, alienating or parting with possession of the suit property. According to the plaintiff, the defendants in violation of the ad interim order of injunction, which was granted on 22nd June, 1994, have transferred the management of the hospital and thus necessity arose for seeking addition of the parties to whom transfer had been made.

    7. In the application moved under Order 1 Rule 10 C.P.C read with Order 6 Rule 17 C.P.C (I.A 7351/94), it has been averred that defendants 2 to 4 have illegally and in disregard to the orders of the Court transferred the management to defendants 5, 6 and 7. As such, besides being granted permission to add them as parties, plaintiff may be permitted to add a prayer in the suit that the sale or transfer of the hospital or management of the hospital in favour of defendants 5 to 7 is of no legal consequence and confers no right on defendants 5 to 7.

    8. In the application moved by the defendants for rejection of the plaint (I.A 8008/94), it has been alleged that suit filed is false, frivolous, speculative, motivated and out of personal vengeance against defendants 2 to 4. Defendants have been carrying on a lot of philanthropic activities and have set up various social and educational institutions. Defendant society is managed and controlled by a Board of Directors. Lot of times and energy have been devoted by the defendants to help the society in acquiring its assets.

    9. It is further alleged that plaintiff No. 1 and defendants 2 to 4 have been residing together in property bearing No. 11, Prithvi Raj Road, New Delhi, which is jointly owned and possessed by them. Plaintiff No. 1, who is a bachelor was being attended by defendants 2 to 4 and their family members. The parties were having a common kitchen till December, 1993 when Col. Khosla, who is the third brother of plaintiff No. 1 and defendant No. 2, who has nothing to do with property No. 11, Prithvi Raj Road, New Delhi, instigated plaintiff No. 1 to separate his kitchen and file false and frivolous cases against the defendants. Col. Khosla wants to effect a partition of the property amongst the co-owners and then surreptiously to usurp plaintiff's share. His motive, actions and intentions are mala fide. Defendants have also made mention of the three litigation brought about at the behest of Col. Khosla. In this background, defedants state that suit of the plaintiff, apart from being false is frivolous and vexatious, disclose no cause of action and that none of the reliefs claimed in the suit falls within the ambit of Section 92 C.P.C Proper Court fee has also not been affixed. Plaintiff No. 2 has no direct interest with the affairs of the society. Leave of the Court has been obtained by mis-representing material facts and thus leave granted deserves to be revoked and in the alternative the plaint deserves to be rejected.

    10. In the amendment sought for as also in the original plaint, it may be noticed that the only relief claimed by the plaintiff is of declaration that suit property, namely, the hospital which is being run by a society is a public trust and that the defendants or the directors of defendant No. 1 have no right to sell, transfer, alienate the same in any manner and in the amendment additional prayer claimed is that the transfer effected by defendants 2 to 4 in favour of proposed defendants is of no consequence.

    11. Section 92 of the Code of Civil Procedure intended to provide proceedings of a special nature is applicable to cases in which there has been a breach of trust in relation to a public trust, whether express or constructive, of a charitable or religious nature. The aim of Section 92 is to protect the rights of public in such trust and to enable the public to stop the misuse of the income of chritable institutions. For the applicability of section 92 of the code, certain conditions must be satisfied, namely: there must exist a trust for public purposes of a charitable or religious nature; the plaintiff must allege that there is a breach of such trust, or that directions of the Court are necessary for the administration of the trust; the suit must be a representative one on behalf of the public and not by individuals for vindicating their own interest; and the reliefs claimed in the suit must be the reliefs mentioned in the section.

    12. The entire reading of the plaint in the instant case would show that the relief claimed in the suit is not the one which is mentioned in the section. In Pragdatji Guru Bhagwandasji v. Ishwarlalbhai Narsibhai, A.I.R 1952 S.C 143, it was held that in a suit framed under Section 92 C.P.C, the only reliefs which the plaintiff can claim and the Court can grant are those as are enumerated specifically in the different clauses of the section. A relief prayed for declaration that the property involved in the suit is a trust property does not come under any of these clauses. A suit under Section 92 C.P.C is a suit of special nature, which presupposes the existence of a public trust of a religious or charitable character. When the defendant denies the existence of a trust, a declaration that the trust does exist might be made as ancillary to the main relief claimed under the suit if the plaintiff is held entitled to it; but when the case of the plaintiff fails for want of cause of action, there is no warrant for giving him a declaratory relief under the provisions of Section 92 C.P.C

    13. In the instant suit, plaintiff has not made any prayer as enumerated in different clauses of Section 92 C.P.C As such, there is no question of even granting any ancillary relief of declaration. Plaintiff in fact wants a declaration in the suit, which is outside the scope of Section 92 C.P.C

    14. In view of the above, there is also no question of the plaintiff being permitted to add new defendants or to carry out amendment to the plaint, in view of the fact that the leave granted to the plaintiff ought to be revoked. Accordingly the prayer made in the application of the plaintiff for amendment (I.A 7351/94) is rejected and the defendants' application (I.A 8008/94) is allowed. Leave granted to the plaintiff to sue is revoked. Since leave has been revoked, there is no suit before the Court, which be de-registered and file consigned to the record.

    I.As 1854 and 1855/95

    15. I.A 1855/95 is an application under Order 1 Rule 8(1) C.P.C seeking leave of the Court to sue the defendants in representative capacity and I.A 1954/95 is an application seeking amendment of the plaint to convert the suit into one being filed in representative capacity.

    16. In view of the fact that leave under Section 92 C.P.C granted to the plaintiff earlier has been revoked, plaintiff cannot be permitted to amend his suit since the proposed amendment will change the entire nature and complexion of the suit. Moreover, I find that necessary averments as are required to be made seeking leave under Order 1 Rule 8 C.P.C for filing suit in representative capacity have not been made out in the application or in the body of the proposed plaint. When the proposed amendments are likely to change the entire nature of the suit, amendments cannot be allowed. Plaintiff has other adequate efficatious remedies available to him instead of seeking amendment to file such other suit as may be permissible in law. Both these applications are dismissed.

    I.As.6386/94, 7348/94, 7349/94 and 7350/94

    17. In view of the fact that the leave granted has been revoked, these applications are dismissed as infructuous.

    I.A 7614/94

    18. List for directions on 2nd August, 1995.

    Applications dismissed.
    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    J.C. Khosla v. Khosla Medical Institute And Research Society Ltd.
    (Jul 20, 1995)