Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • section 24(2) of the Indian Income-tax Act, 1922.
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • section 24(2) of the Indian Income-tax Act, 1922.
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion (B.N. Kirpal, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

The Income-tax (Tribunal) referred two questions of law to this Court under section 256(1) of the Income-tax Act: one referred at the instance of the Revenue and one at the instance of the assessee. Both references arise from appellate proceedings against assessment determinations for (primarily) the assessment year 1965–66, with cross-reference to an earlier assessment year 1964–65 in respect of one issue.

First matter (assessee's reference): During assessment year 1965–66 the assessee paid commission to M/s Standard Electrode Corporation. Out of the total commission paid a sum of Rs. 1,42,289 was disallowed by the Income-tax Officer as not legally warranted. The Appellate Assistant Commissioner agreed, noting absence of evidence that any service was rendered by the Corporation warranting commission on grounds of commercial expediency, following a prior conclusion for assessment year 1964–65. The Tribunal upheld the disallowance. The Tribunal therefore referred, at the assessee's instance, the question whether evidence existed to justify the Tribunal's finding that the expenditure of Rs. 1,42,289 was not proved to be wholly and exclusively for business purposes.

Second matter (Revenue's reference): For assessment year 1965–66 the assessee claimed expenditure of Rs. 3,12,704 on issue of debentures, of which Rs. 2,61,918 was claimed as business expenditure. The Income-tax Officer disallowed the claim on the view that the debentures were issued to raise funds for setting up a new steel unit (manufacture of M.S. special alloy wires and billets), an activity not akin to the assessee's usual business and which had not started working in that year. The Appellate Assistant Commissioner held the steel unit to be a new business (citing separate books, staff, building and separate financial management). The Tribunal, however, applying the test for whether two activities constitute the same business, found unity of management, unity of control and a common fund and allowed the claim. The Revenue referred to this Court the question whether the Tribunal was justified in holding that the steel manufacturing activity was an extension of the existing business and allowing the deduction of Rs. 2,61,918.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether there was any evidence before the Tribunal to justify the finding that the assessee had not proved that the expenditure of Rs. 1,42,289 (part of the commission paid to M/s Standard Electrode Corporation) was an expenditure incurred wholly and exclusively for the purposes of business?
  2. Whether, on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the Tribunal was justified in holding that the business of manufacture of M.S. special alloy wires and billets was an extension of the existing business and not a new business, and in allowing a deduction of Rs. 2,61,918 on account of expenditure incurred for raising loans by issue of debentures?

Arguments of the Parties

Assessee's Arguments

  • With respect to the commission disallowance: the assessee contested the disallowance and sought reference of whether there was evidence before the Tribunal to find that the Rs. 1,42,289 was not proved to be wholly and exclusively for business purposes. (The opinion records the reference but does not set out detailed factual testimony from the assessee beyond contesting the disallowance.)
  • With respect to the debenture expenditure: the assessee contended that the proposed manufacture of alloy steel billets was not a new business but an extension of the existing manufacturing business. It argued that the debenture proceeds formed part of the company’s aggregate funds and were inextricably mixed with other funds so that the debenture receipts could not be separately identified.

Revenue / Commissioner of Income-tax's Arguments

  • Regarding the commission: Revenue maintained the disallowance, which had been affirmed by the Income-tax Officer, the Appellate Assistant Commissioner and the Tribunal (and was earlier upheld by this Court in relation to assessment year 1964–65).
  • Regarding the debenture issue: the Revenue (Income-tax Officer) maintained that the debentures were issued specifically to raise funds for setting up a new steel unit that was not akin to the assessee’s existing activities and had not commenced functioning in the relevant year; hence the expenditure was not allowable as business expenditure. The Commissioner pursued this view before the Tribunal and referred the question to this Court when the Tribunal allowed the claim.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Modi Industries Ltd. v. Commissioner of Income-tax, I.T.R. No. 64 of 1982; [1993] 200 ITR 329 (judgment dated Aug 6, 1992) Earlier decision in the assessee's case for assessment year 1964–65 upholding disallowance of commission. The court applied this earlier decision to conclude that there was evidence before the Tribunal to justify the disallowance of Rs. 1,42,289; answered the assessee's question against the assessee and in favour of the Revenue.
Commissioner of Income Tax, Madras v. Prithvi Insurance Co. Ltd., [1967] 63 ITR 632 (SC) Adopting Rowlatt J.'s test (Scales): whether there is interconnection/interlacing/interdependence/ unity between two businesses — indicated by common management, organisation, administration, fund and place of business. The court relied on this authority (and its formulation of the decisive factors) when analysing whether the steel activity was an extension of the existing business; tribunal findings of common management and common fund were treated as decisive under this precedent.
Scales v. George Thompson and Co. Ltd., [1927] 13 TC 83 Test for determining whether two activities constitute the same business: presence of interconnection, interlacing, interdependence, unity. The court noted that the Tribunal applied this test and accepted the Tribunal's factual finding that the requisite unity/interlacing existed between the businesses.
Hooghly Trust (P) Ltd. v. CIT, West Bengal, Etc., [1969] 73 ITR 685 (SC) Reaffirmation that common management, organisation, administration, fund and place of business indicate interconnection and therefore the same business. The court cited this case to reinforce the principle that where the Tribunal finds such commonalities, they support a conclusion that the activities form the same business; the court accepted the Tribunal's factual findings on unity.
Produce Exchange Corporation Ltd. v. CIT, [1970] 77 ITR 739 (SC) Decisive test is unity of control rather than the nature of the lines of business; unity of control can render diverse activities one business. The court relied on this authority to hold that the Tribunal was correct in emphasising unity of control and therefore treating the new activity as an extension of the existing business.
B.R. Limited v. V.P. Gupta, CIT, [1978] 113 ITR 647 (SC) Unity of control and interlacing/dovetailing between businesses indicate they constitute the same business. The court cited this decision as supporting the proposition that unity of control and interlacing are determinative and applied that principle to the facts where unity of control and a common fund were found by the Tribunal.
Standard Refinery and Distillery Ltd. v. CIT, [1971] 79 ITR 589 (SC) Where business and share transactions are managed by a common organisation, use a common fund and are part of the business activity, the decisive test remains unity of control rather than the nature of the activities. The court invoked this case to support the importance of unity of control and common fund in concluding that diverse activities can be treated as the same business; used as direct precedent to uphold the Tribunal's unity-based conclusion.
L.M. Chhabda and Sons v. CIT, [1967] 65 ITR 638 (SC) Stated it was for appellants to establish that different ventures constitute parts of the same business; absence of evidence on unity of control, interrelation, same staff, etc., would make that impossible. The court noted this decision, observed that Chhabda did not refer to Prithvi Insurance and was not followed in several subsequent Supreme Court decisions; it distinguished Chhabda on the facts because, in the present case, the Tribunal had found unity of control and common fund on the evidence.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court addressed each referred question separately and applied the law strictly as reflected in the record and in the precedents cited in the proceedings.

First question (commission disallowance):

  1. The disallowance of Rs. 1,42,289 arose after the Income-tax Officer, the Appellate Assistant Commissioner and the Tribunal concluded the expense was not legally warranted or was not shown to be for business purposes.
  2. The Court noted that in respect of assessment year 1964–65 an identical question had been decided against the assessee by this Court in Modi Industries Ltd. (I.T.R. No. 64 of 1982; [1993] 200 ITR 329).
  3. Given the prior decision upholding an equivalent disallowance, the Court concluded that there was evidence before the Tribunal on which it legitimately came to the conclusion that the sum should be disallowed.
  4. Accordingly, the Court answered the question in favour of the Revenue and against the assessee.

Second question (debenture-issue expenditure and whether new business):

  1. The Court set out the factual findings and the divergent views at different levels: Income-tax Officer disallowed the claim treating the steel unit as a new business; the Appellate Assistant Commissioner regarded it as a new business due to separate books, staff, building and financial management; the Tribunal, applying the Scales/Prithvi test, found unity of management, unity of control and a common fund and allowed the claim.
  2. The Court then reviewed relevant Supreme Court authorities (Prithvi Insurance; Produce Exchange; Hooghly Trust; B.R. Ltd.; Standard Refinery) that consistently emphasise that the decisive test is unity of control and that common management, common organisation, common administration, common fund and common place of business furnish the interconnection/interlacing required to treat different activities as the same business.
  3. The Court considered L.M. Chhabda but observed that it did not consider or refer to Prithvi Insurance and was not relied upon in several subsequent Supreme Court decisions; the court therefore treated Chhabda as distinguishable on the facts where the Tribunal had affirmative findings of unity of control and common fund.
  4. Because the Tribunal's findings of common management, unity of control and a common fund were based on evidence on record and the Department did not challenge these findings of fact, the Court accepted the Tribunal's conclusion that the manufacture of the special alloy wires and billets was an extension of the existing manufacturing business rather than a new business.
  5. On that basis the Court answered the question in the affirmative in favour of the assessee, thereby sustaining the Tribunal's allowance of Rs. 2,61,918 as business expenditure.

Holding and Implications

Holding — First question: Answered in favour of the Revenue and against the assessee; the disallowance of Rs. 1,42,289 in respect of commission paid to M/s Standard Electrode Corporation was held to be supported by evidence and is upheld.

Holding — Second question: Answered in the affirmative and in favour of the assessee; the Tribunal was justified in holding that manufacture of M.S. special alloy wires and billets was an extension of the existing business (not a new business) and in allowing a deduction of Rs. 2,61,918 for debenture-issue related expenditure.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on parties: The disallowance of Rs. 1,42,289 (commission) stands against the assessee. The allowance of Rs. 2,61,918 (debenture-issue expenditure) stands in favour of the assessee as sustained by the Tribunal and this Court.
  • The Court applied and relied on existing Supreme Court authorities emphasising unity of control, common management and common fund as determinative factors in deciding whether disparate activities constitute the same business. The decision affirms application of those principles to the facts where the Tribunal has made factual findings of unity of management and common fund and where those factual findings were not challenged.
  • There is no indication in the opinion that the Court intended to lay down a novel or differing legal principle; rather it applied established precedent to the facts. The opinion records the decision: "There will be no order as to costs."

This summary is based exclusively on the content of the provided opinion and does not add information beyond what is stated in that text.

    Commissioner Of Income-Tax v. Modi Industries Ltd. (No. 3)

    B.N Kirpal, J.:— Two questions of law have been referred to this court by the Income-tax (Tribunal) under section 256(1) of the Act, one question has been referred at the instance of the Revenue and the other at the instance of the assessee.

    2. The question which has been referred at the instance of the assessee is as follows:

    “Whether there was any evidence before the Tribunal to arrive at the finding that the applicant had not proved that the expenditure of Rs. 1,42,289 representing a part of the commission paid to M/s. Standard Electrode Corporation was an expenditure incurred wholly and exclu-sively for the purposes of business?”

    3. This reference is in respect of the assessment year 1965–66. Some commission had been paid by the assessee to M/s. Standard Electrode Corporation. Out of the total amount so paid, a sum of Rs. 1,42,289 was disallowed. This Corporation had been appointed as the sole selling agent of the assessee-company for a period of five years with effect from July 27, 1963, vide resolution of the board of directors of the assessee-com-pany dated July 27, 1963. The Income-tax Officer came to the conclusion that the expense to the extent of Rs. 1,42,289 was not legally warranted and the same was disallowed. The Appellate Assistant Commissioner, in appeal, came to the con-clusion that there was no evidence to show that M/s. Standard Electrode Corporation rendered any service for which they could be paid commis-sion on the ground of commercial expediency. This conclusion of the Appellate Assistant Commissioner was in consonance with the earlier decision for the assessment year 1964–65.

    4. In further appeal to the Income-tax Tribunal, the disallowance was upheld. The Tribunal also followed a similar view which had been taken by it in the assessee's case in respect of an earlier assessment year 1964–65. As the reference had been made in respect of the assessment year 1964–65, for the present year in question, viz., 1965–66, the aforesaid question of law was again referred by the Tribunal, at the instance of the assessee.

    5. In respect of the assessment year 1964–65, a similar question of law was answered against the assessee by this court in I.T.R No. 64 of 1982 (Modi Industries Ltd. v. Commissioner Of Income-Tax, [1993] 200 ITR 329), vide judgment dated August 6, 1992. The effect of this was that the disallowance of the com-mission paid to M/s. Standard Electrode Corporation was upheld. Following the said decision the only conclusion which we can arrive at is that there was evidence before the Tribunal on which it could legitimately come to the conclusion that the sum of Rs. 1,42,289 should be disallowed. The aforesaid question is, therefore, answered in favour of the Revenue and against the assessee.

    6. The question which has been referred at the instance of the Rev-enue is as follows:

    “Whether, on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the Tribunal was justified in holding that the business of manufacture of M.S special alloy wires and billets was an extension of business and not a new business and allowing a deduction of the sum of Rs. 2,61,918 on account of expenditure incurred for raising of the loans by the issue of debentures?”

    7. Briefly stated the facts are that the assessee had claimed an expen-diture of Rs. 3,12,704 consisting of underwriting commission, brokerage, cost of stamp paper, registration charges, advertisements and expenses on the issue of prospectus. Out of this a sum of Rs. 2,61,918 was claimed as business expenditure. The Income-tax Officer found that the said expenditure included a provision of Rs. 50,786 made for registration expenses of the debenture trust deed which was to be got registered in the following year. He, therefore, considered the claim of Rs. 2,61,918, out of the total claim of Rs. 3,12,704, on merits. This claim was disallowed by the Income-tax Officer who held that debentures in this case were specially issued for raising funds for being used in setting up a new steel unit which did not start working during this year and in setting up this unit the assessee had engaged itself in an activity which was not akin or related to its usual business.

    8. The assessee thereafter filed an appeal before the Appellate Assis-tant Commissioner and contended that the business of manufacture of alloy steel billets, which was sought to be undertaken, was not a new one but was an extension of the existing business. It was submitted that the debenture amount received formed part of the aggregate sums of the company and they were so inextricably mixed up that the amount received by way of issue of debentures could not be separately identified.

    9. The Appellate Assistant Commissioner, however, came to the con-clusion that the business of manufacture of alloy steel and billets was a new business and he came to this conclusion for the following reasons:

    “(i) The nature of the items to be manufactured was not in any way connected with the items already manufactured by the assessee-company and with a view to finance the scheme, the Controller of Capital Issues was approached for the issue of 7 per cent, debentures of the face value of Rs. 60 lakhs out of which Rs. 50 lakhs were actually issued.

    (ii) Separate books of account were maintained for this unit which had a separate staff to manage and control its day to day activities.

    (iii) A separate factory building was constructed adjoining the other units in which the steel unit was erected.

    (iv) The financial management was also separate from the other units because the amount loaned from the head office was separately shown in the balance-sheet and separate profits were worked out for this unit on the basis of its financial sets of account. Till the unit started production a separate account was maintained in the central office set of books.”

    10. A further appeal was filed by the assessee to the Tribunal. The Tribunal referred to the decision of the Supreme Court in the case of Commissioner Of Income Tax, Madras v. Prithvi Insurance Co. Ltd., [1967] 63 ITR 632, wherein the Supreme Court had followed the observations of Rowlatt J. in the case of Scales v. George Thompson and Co. Ltd., [1927] 13 TC 83, where the test for determining whether it was the same business or not had been enunciated. This test was whether there was any interconnection, any interlacing, any interdependence, any Unity at all embracing those two businesses? The test laid down by Rowlatt J. was kept in view by the Tribunal and it came to the conclusion that “on facts we have found that the management of the new business and the earlier business was the same and there was unity of control and a common fund”.

    11. The claim of the assessee was accordingly allowed by the Tribunal. It is thereafter that the Commissioner of Income-tax filed an application and the aforesaid question of law has been referred to this court.

    12. In order to decide the question so referred it is necessary to deal with various decisions which have been cited at the Bar.

    13. In Prithvi Insurance Co. Ltd.'s case, [1967] 63 ITR 632 (SC) the assessee was carrying on the business of life insurance as well as general insurance. A question arose whether the unabsorbed losses of one type of business (life insurance) could be set off against the profits of the general insur-ance business. After referring to the aforesaid observations of Rowlatt J. the Supreme Court came to the conclusion, in that case (at page 638):

    “That interconnection, interlacing, interdependence and unity are furnished in this case by the existence of common management, common business organisation, common administration, common fund and a common place of business.”

    14. In Hooghly Trust (P) Ltd. v. Cit, West Bengal, Etc, [1969] 73 ITR 685 (SC), a similar question again arose. The assessee in that case acted as a distributing agent of the Government for cloth and cement. The cloth business had been started in 1946 and the same was brought under Governmental control thereafter. The assessee had also been doing business in several other commodities and the question arose whether different commodities in which the business was being done could be regarded as the same business or different businesses. The Tribunal decided in favour of the assessee but the High Court came to a different conclusion and it held that the inference drawn by the Appellate Tribunal was not warranted by the facts on record and that the cloth business was separate from the appellant's business in the general section notwithstanding that there was some interconnection of expenses or control. The assessee thereafter filed an appeal to the Supreme Court and the Supreme Court came to the conclusion that in the absence of a proper question about the validity of the findings of facts arrived at by the Tribunal, it was not open to the High Court to accept the findings of the Appellate Assistant Commissioner or to come to any independent conclusion itself on facts. The Supreme Court further reaffirmed the principle enunciated in Prithvi Insurance Co.'s case, [1967] 63 ITR 632 (SC) and came to the conclusion that if there was common management, common business organisation, common administration, common fund and common place of business then, one could come to the conclusion that there was interconnection, interlacing and interdependence which would mean that it was the same business. In Produce Exchange Corporation Ltd. v. CIT, [1970] 77 ITR 739 (SC), the appellant-company carried on business as a dealer in diverse commodities and also in stocks and shares. It suffered losses in the sale of shares and it claimed to carry forward and set off the same against the profits of subsequent years from transactions in other commodities. While the Tribunal had found that there was complete unity of control and shares were one out of a number of commodities in which the company dealt in the ordinary course of business and that there was no element of diversity or distinction or separateness about the transaction in shares, and, accordingly, upheld the claim, the High Court, on the other hand, on a reference, held that the essential matter to be consi-dered was the nature of the two lines of business and not merely their unity of control and, therefore, the Tribunal, according to the High Court, had erred in holding that the whole trading activity formed one business. The Supreme Court, on appeal, reversed the decision of the High Court and came to the conclusion that the decisive test was unity of control and not the nature of the two lines of business. It further came to the conclusion that the Tribunal was right in holding that the share business and other businesses carried on by the appellant-company constituted the same business within the meaning of section 24(2) of the Indian Income-tax Act, 1922. In arriving at this conclusion the Supreme Court referred to the aforesaid observations of Rowlatt J. in Scales' case, [1927] 13 TC 83 and also to the principles laid down by the Supreme Court itself in Prithvi Insurance Co.'s case, [1967] 63 ITR 632.

    15. To similar effect is another decision of the Supreme Court in the case of B.R Limited v. V.P Gupta, Cit, CIT, [1978] 113 ITR 647. In that case the appellant-company had incurred a loss in the business of import and sale of fabrics in the calendar year 1952. It closed down that business and in the following year it started the business of exporting cotton textiles and earned profits therein. A question arose whether it was the same business or not for the purpose of setting off of carried forward loss. The Supreme Court following its decisions in Produce Exchange Corporation's case, [1970] 77 ITR 739 (SC) and Prithvi Insurance Co.'s case, [1967] 63 ITR 632 (SC) came to the conclusion that (at page 654):

    “Thus, the unity of control and the other circumstances adverted to above show that there was dovetailing or interlacing between the business of import and the business of export carried on by the assessee and that they constitute the same business.”

    16. In coming to this conclusion, the Supreme Court, while referring to the case of Produce Exchange Corporation, [1970] 77 ITR 739 (SC), observed that the decisive test was the unity of control and not the nature of the two lines of business.

    17. From the aforesaid observations of the Supreme Court in the cases of Prithvi Insurance Co. Ltd., [1967] 63 ITR 632, Produce Exchange Cor-poration Ltd., [1970] 77 ITR 739 and B.R Ltd., [1978] 113 ITR 647, it would clearly follow that the nature of the lines of business is not relevant but what is of importance is the unity of control and interlacing of the two businesses.

    18. In Standard Refinery and Distillery Ltd. v. CIT, [1971] 79 ITR 589 (SC), the assessee-company owned a distillery and had acquired a sugar refinery. During the period in question the assessee also purchased and sold shares of a sugar and gur refining company and had suffered a loss therein. The question which arose for consideration before the Supreme Court was whether the loss so suffered in the sale of shares could be carried forward and set off against the income from sugar manufacturing and distillery. The Tribunal had found that there was a single trading and profit and loss account of the business. The share transaction as well as the business had been dealt with by a common organisation, the business of the company as well as the transaction in shares were attended to as a part and parcel of the business of the company and a common fund was utilised both for business purposes as well as for the purpose of purchase of shares. It was in view of this finding of fact that the Supreme Court observed that the concepts of interconnection and inter-lacing, interdependence and unity were not free from ambiguity. It then referred to the decision in the cases of Prithvi Insurance. Co. Ltd., [1967] 63 ITR 632 (SC) and Produce Exchange Corporation Ltd., [1970] 77 ITR 739 (SC) and held that the Supreme Court had ruled “that the decisive test was unity of control and not the nature of the two lines of business”. Following its earlier decisions, the Supreme Court in the case of Stan-dard Refinery and Distillery Ltd., [1971] 79 ITR 589 came to the conclu-sion that the assessee was entitled to set off losses in the sale of shares against the income from sugar manufacturing and distillery. The prin-ciple on which this decision was based was that there was unity of control between the two types of business.

    19. Learned counsel for the Commissioner, however, has strongly relied upon a decision of the Supreme Court in the case of L.M Chhabda and Sons v. CIT, [1967] 65 ITR 638. At the outset we would like to point out that the Supreme Court in Chhabda's case, [1967] 65 ITR 638 did not consider or refer to its earlier decision in Prithvi Insurance Co. Ltd.'s case, [1967] 63 ITR 632 (SC) and, surprisingly, Chhabda's case, [1967] 65 ITR 638 (SC) is not referred to by the Supreme Court in its four subsequent decisions in the cases of Produce Exchange Corporation Ltd., [1970] 77 ITR 739 (SC), B.R Ltd., [1978] 113 ITR 647 (SC), Hooghly Trust (P) Ltd., [1969] 73 ITR 685 (SC) and Standard Refinery and Distillery Ltd., [1971] 79 ITR 589 (SC). Perhaps the reason for the case of Chhabda, [1967] 65 ITR 638 (SC) not being referred to was that the Supreme Court held in that case that (at page 642):

    “It was for the appellants to establish that different ventures constitute parts of the same business. There is in this case no evidence about unity of control and management, or interrelation of the business, or employment of the same staff to run the business, or the possibility of one theatre being closed without affecting the rest of the business.”.

    20. In the present case, however, the finding of fact arrived at by the Tribunal, on the basis of evidence on record, is that the management of the new business and the earlier business was the same and there was also unity of control and a common fund. Shri Rajendra submits that this finding is without any basis. But the Department has not challenged the correctness of this finding. The assessee, as noted by the Income-tax Officer, is engaged in the manufacture of various commodities like sugar, vanaspati, soaps, paints and varnish, torch, lantern, etc. All that the assessee did now was to start manufacturing a new commodity. In a larger sense the business of the assessee remained the same, viz., the business of manufacture. It was already manufacturing diverse items and a new item was added to this business. The facts found by the Tribunal are that there was complete unity of control and there was a common fund and these factors have been regarded as most material by the Supreme Court as is evident from the case of Standard Refinery and Distillery Ltd., [1971] 79 ITR 589 (SC) and the other cases referred to therein. In view of the above the only conclusion which can be arrived at, therefore, is that the Tribunal was justified in holding that the business of manufacture of special alloy wires and billets was an extension of the business and not a new business. The question referred is, therefore, answered in the affirmative and in favour of the assessee.

    21. There will be no order as to costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Commissioner Of Income-Tax v. Modi Industries Ltd. (No. 3)
    (Oct 12, 1992)