Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • Transactions (Prohibition) Act, 1988 (hereinafter called as the Act)
  • Property Act, 1988)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • Transactions (Prohibition) Act, 1988 (hereinafter called as the Act)
  • Property Act, 1988)
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

Mahinder Singh filed a suit for partition against Shri Pardaman Singh and others concerning properties originally owned by Sardar Anoop Singh, who died in 1941. The properties included extensive agricultural land in various villages and urban properties such as houses and shops. After Anoop Singh's death, disputes arose among the parties, leading to an arbitration award in 1985 which recognized joint ownership of agricultural land and garden by the plaintiff and some defendants, but did not award any property to Smt. Sahib Kaur, widow of Anoop Singh. The plaintiff alleged that certain properties, including a house in New Delhi, were purchased from Joint Hindu Family funds but were registered in Sahib Kaur’s name as a benami transaction. Following Sahib Kaur’s death in 1981, defendant No. 4 claimed ownership of the house and other valuables through a purported Will, which the plaintiff contended was forged. The plaintiff sought partition and recovery of the property, while defendant No. 4 claimed the property was self-acquired by Sahib Kaur and could not be partitioned.

The legal issue of whether the suit was barred under Section 4 of the Benami Transactions (Prohibition of the Right to Recover Property) Act, 1988 was framed as a preliminary issue on 4th October 1991.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the suit is barred under Section 4 of the Benami Transactions (Prohibition of the Right to Recover Property) Act, 1988, thereby rendering the suit liable to be dismissed.

Arguments of the Parties

Plaintiff's Arguments

  • The house in question was purchased out of Joint Hindu Family funds, but the sale deed was executed in the name of Smt. Sahib Kaur out of love and respect, making her a benamidar (nominee) without any independent ownership rights.
  • Smt. Sahib Kaur had no independent source of income and was managing the agricultural land and property on behalf of the family.
  • The property is therefore a joint Hindu family property, and Sahib Kaur could not have validly bequeathed it by Will to defendant No. 4.
  • The suit is not barred by Section 4 of the Benami Transactions Act because the property was held by Sahib Kaur as a trustee or in a fiduciary capacity for the benefit of the family members.
  • The intention of the parties and the nature of the transaction fall within the exceptions under Section 4(3) of the Act.

Defendant No. 4's Arguments

  • The property was acquired by Smt. Sahib Kaur with her own resources and constructed with assistance from Shri Pardaman Singh, making it her self-acquired property.
  • The gold and silver ornaments belonged to Sahib Kaur, and she had the right to bequeath them by Will.
  • The plaintiff and other defendants parted ways with Sahib Kaur during her lifetime and took away their articles.
  • The registered Will dated 7th March 1978 is valid and cannot be challenged.
  • The property cannot be partitioned as it was in Sahib Kaur’s physical possession as her self-acquired property.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Thakur Bhim Singh (dead) by LRs v. Thakur Kan Singh and Thakur Kan Singh v. Thakur Bhim Singh (dead) by LRs, (1980) 3 SCC 72, AIR 1980 SC 727 Principle that a benami transaction is established by proving that purchase money came from a person other than the person in whose name the property is held; intention inferred from circumstances and relationship. The court applied this principle to assess whether the property was held benami by Sahib Kaur, considering the plaintiff’s assertion that purchase money came from Hindu Undivided Family funds and the nature of the relationship.
Mithilesh Kumar v. Prem Behari Khare, AIR 1989 SC 1247 Consideration of the retrospective applicability of the Benami Transactions Act and the necessity of reliable evidence to establish a benami transaction. The court relied on this precedent to hold that the question of whether the property was benami requires evidence and cannot be decided at the preliminary stage; thus, the suit cannot be dismissed solely on Section 4 grounds without trial.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court analyzed the preliminary objection under Section 4 of the Benami Transactions Act by examining the factual matrix presented by the plaintiff and defendants. It emphasized that the burden of proving a benami transaction lies on the party asserting it. The court noted that the plaintiff pleaded the property was purchased from Hindu Undivided Family funds and that Sahib Kaur was a benamidar holding the property in a fiduciary capacity. The court acknowledged that intention behind the transaction must be inferred from relationships and circumstances, as per the cited precedent.

Relying on the Supreme Court decision in Mithilesh Kumar, the court held that the applicability of Section 4 cannot be determined without evidence and cannot be a ground for dismissal at the preliminary stage. The court also observed that the question of whether a female can be a coparcener under Hindu law requires full factual analysis and evidence. Therefore, the preliminary issue was to be decided along with other issues on merits after evidence is led.

Holding and Implications

The court held that the suit is not barred under Section 4 of the Benami Transactions (Prohibition of the Right to Recover Property) Act, 1988 at the preliminary stage.

The direct effect of this decision is that the suit for partition and recovery of property will proceed to trial where the issue of benami transaction and ownership will be decided on evidence. The court did not set any new precedent but followed existing principles that require full evidence before dismissing a suit on benami grounds.

    Shri Mahinder Singh v. Mr. Pardaman Singh .

    In view of the objections raised, the following preliminary issue was framed on 4th October, 1991 :

    “Whether the suit is barred under S. 4 of the Benami Transactions (Prohibition of the Right to Recover Property Act, 1988) and as such the suit is liable to be dismissed.”

    2. In order to decide this objection, the brief facts of the case are that :

    Mahinder Singh filed a suit for partition against Shri Pardaman Singh and others. It is an accepted case of the parties that Sardar Anoop Singh, father of defendants 1, 2 and 4 and husband of Smt. Sahib Kaur owned about 3,000 bighas of agricultural land in villages Luku, Roda, Noorpur Thal, in Tehsil Khushab, District Sargodha and in village Saiyanwala in Tehsil and district Lyallpur in addition to a garden measuring about 30 bighas and a number of houses and shops in Sargodha, Roda and Noorpur. Sardar Anoop Singh died on 5th September, 1941.

    3. It is the allegation of the plaintiff that dispute arose between the parties after the death of Anoop Singh and an arbitrator was appointed who made and published his award on 18th August, 1985. Per the award agricultural land garden remained joint property of the plaintiff and defendants 1 and 2. No property was awarded to Smt. Sahib Kaur widow of Sardar Anoop Singh. She was only entrusted a sum of Rs. 15,000/- for the education and marriage of the two daughters namely Kulwant Kaur and Gulshan, defendant No. 4 and the wife of defendant No. 3 respectively. Defendant No. 1 came to Delhi but on account of communal disturbances and the partition of the country, he did not go back to Sargodha. Sahib Kaur and the plaintiff joined him as a member of the Joint Hindu Family. Defendant No. 1 joined service in November, 1947. In January, 1948 plaintiff also joined service. Other children were school going. Sahib Kaur had no source of income. The family had a common hotch potch in which the salary of the plaintiff and defendant No. 1 used to be put. The re-habilitation authorities in 1947 made temporary allotment of 20 acres of land to the plaintiff and defendant No. 2 jointly in village Gola, Tehsil and District Ambala in lieu of the agricultural land left by them in West Pakistan. In 1950, after verification of the claims for agricultural lands from the revenue record received from the West Pakistan, the rehabilitation authorities, Government of India, allotted to the plaintiff and defendant No. 2 jointly 361 bighas of agricultural land in villages, Pheruwala, Tehsil Jagadhari, District Ambala and 302 bighas of agricultural land in village Niharsi, Tehsil and District Ambala. In 1951, the rehabilitation authorities made permanent allotment of about 600 bighas of agricultural land jointly in favour of the plaintiff and defendant No. 2 in village Niharsi cancelling the allotment in their favour in village Pheruwala. Similarly, the earlier allotment in favour of defendant No. 1 in village Pheruwala was cancelled and permanently allotted him three pieces of land having a total area of 36 standard acres in villages Bilaspur, Marwa Kalan and Nainawali in Tehsil Jagadhari, District Ambala.

    During 1948-49, Smt. Sahib Kaur alone used to receive the agricultural income from the land allotted to the plaintiff and defendant No. 2 but used the same for common purposes. Till 1953, she had been receiving income from the land allotted to the plaintiff and defendant No. 2 in Village Niharsi and used to put in a common pool. Till the middle of 1956, it was Sahib kaur alone who was exclusively managing the land allotted to the plaintiff and defendant No. 2 and was receiving the income. In 1956 plaintiff and defendant No. 2 divided the agricultural land between themselves and the said Sahib Kaur went on managing the land of defendant No. 2 and had been receiving the income till 1971. In 1949, out of the savings effected from the common hotch potch, plaintiff purchased a plot bearing No. 3-A/129, Regar Pura (now known as Sat Nagar), Karol Bagh, New Delhi for a sum of Rs. 2,000/- but in order to avoid disputes and differences amongst the members of the said Joint Hindu Family, he got the sale deed of the said plot executed in the name of his mother, Smt. Sahib Kaur. The ground floor of the said house was constructed in 1950 with the Joint Hindu Family funds and the first floor portion was constructed in 1951 from the same Funds. Thus, according to the plaintiff, Sahib Kaur did not have any right, title or interest in the said house. She was merely a named lender or benamidar. The said house, in fact, is a joint property of the plaintiff, defendants 1 and 2 or alternatively it is a joint Hindu family property. The Joint Hindu Family also owned jewellery which was brought by them while migrating from Pakistan to India. Sahib Kaur had taken a locker in 1948 on rent in the Delhi Safe Deposit Company Ltd. and kept the said jewellery there. The plaintiff had also entrusted to Smt. Sahib Kaur his wife's gold ornaments weighing about 15 tolas along with one set of silver Jug and tumblers and decoration ornamental pieces of silver, all weighing about 200 tolas, for safe custody. Similarly, defendant No. 2 entrusted to his mother four gold rings weighing about 3 tolas for wearing which were kept in the locker. Sahib Kaur died on 22nd August, 1981. On her death defendant No. 4 and her husband tried to take possession of 3A/29 wrongfully and illegally. It was in September, 1981 that defendant No. 4 proclaimed that Sahib Kaur had made a Will in her favour bequeathing the property bearing No. 3-A/29. Defendant No. 4 tried to take forceable possession of house No. 3-A/29 and has in fact removed gold ornaments and silver from the locker on the basis of a forged ‘Will’ purported to have been executed by late Smt. Sahib Kaur.

    4. According to plaintiff since Sahib Kaur had no right, title or interest in the said house which is a Joint Hindu Family property, therefore, she could not Will it in favour of defendant No. 4 nor she could dispose of gold ornaments, silver articles and other household goods belonging to and purchased from the Joint Hindu Family funds. On the basis of the alleged forged and fabricated ‘Will’ defendant No. 4 has no right in the house and articles.

    5. Defendant No. 4 has denied that House No. 3-A/29 was purchased from the Joint Hindu Family funds. According to her it was acquired by Sahib Kaur with her own resources and thereafter, constructed the same with the assistance and help of Shri Pardaman Singh. Therefore, it is a self acquired property of Sahib Kaur. The gold ornaments and silver ornaments also belonged to her, and therefore, she was within her right to bequeath it in favour of any person. So far as, plaintiff and defendants 1 and 2 are concerned, they parted company with Sahib Kaur during her life time and took away all articles. So far as agricultural land is concerned, it is they who had been managing the same and deprived Sahib Kaur her share of income and profit from the said properties. She had been owning this house as her own property throughout her life. It was in her physical possession. Therefore, this registered Will dated 7th March, 1978 cannot be challenged nor this property can be partitioned. She also executed another Will dated 30th September, 1978 which is being probated in the Court of District Judge.

    6. The Benami Transactions (Prohibition) Act, 1988 (hereinafter called as the ‘Act’) came into force on September 5, 1988. S. 3 of the Act creates prohibition of the benami transactions. S. 4 stipulates prohibition of the right to recover property held benami. S. 4 reads as follows :

    Section 4

    “Prohibition of the Right to recover property held benami (1) No suit, claim or action to enforce any right in respect of any property held benami against the person in whose name the property is held or against any other person shall lie by or on behalf of a person claiming to be the real owner of such property.

    (2) No defence based on any right in respect of any property held benami, whether against the person in whose name the property is held or against any other person, shall be allowed in any suit, claim or action by or on behalf of a person claiming to be the real owner of such property.

    (3) Nothing in this Section shall apply

    (a) where the person in whose name the property is held is a coparcener in a Hindu Undivided family and the property is held for the benefit of the coparceners in the family; or

    (b) where the person in whose name the property is held is a trustee or other person standing in a fiduciary capacity, and the property is held for the benefit of another person for whom he is a trustee or towards whom he stands in such capacity.”

    7. The burden of showing that a transfer is a benami transaction lies on the person who asserts that it is such a transaction. The governing principle for determining the question whether a transaction is benami or not is to be proved by proving that the purchase money came from a person other than the person in whose favour the property is transferred. In fact the purchase is prima facie to be inferred. The intention of the person who contributed towards the money has to be inferred from the circumstances and relationship of the parties and the motive governing their action in bringing about the transaction and their subsequent conduct. This is as per Thakur Bhim Singh (dead) by LRs v. Thakur Kan Singh and Thakur Kan Singh v. Thakur Bhim Singh (dead) by LRs., reported in (1980) 3 SCC page 72, AIR 1980 SC 727. The plaintiff in this case has pleaded that the house in question was purchased by the plaintiff out of the Hindu Undivided Family Funds. It was out of the love and affection and respect to the mother that he got the sale deed effected in her name. Sahib Kaur had in fact no independent source of income. She was managing the agricultural land and administering the property which was a joint property of the plaintiff and defendants 1 and 2. Therefore, she had no right to bequeath this property which was purchased from the Hindu Undivided Family Funds. Mr. Lonial, learned counsel therefore, contended that the suit as such will not be prohibited nor hit under Sub-Sec. (1) of S. 4 of the said Act. Sahib Kaur was holding the property as trustee for her sons. This can be proved from the fact that the purchase money was given by the plaintiff. The intention of the parties can be inferred when the plaintiff out of love for mother even though contributed the purchase money still got the plot registered in the name of his mother. This proves the relationship of the plaintiff and Sahib Kaur. By the surrounding circumstances he will prove that his case falls under the exception clause of S. 4 of the Act. The assertion of the defendant that the property was purchased by Sahib Kaur cannot be accepted because Sahib Kaur had no independent source of income. Mr. Lonial therefore contended that the mere fact that he has used the word benami would not throw his case out of the Court nor hit under S. 4 of the Act because he can prima facie establish that the plaintiff landed the purchase money for the benefit of himself and defendants 1 and 2 and it was because of the relationship between him and Sahib Kaur that he recorded her name in the sale deed.

    8. Mr. Lonial in order to strengthen his argument has placed reliance on the decision of the Supreme Court in the case of Mithilesh Kumar v. Prem Behari Khare, reported in AIR 1989 S.C page 1247. In that case, the Court was dealing with the applicability of the Act retrospectively. The decree passed by the trial court as well as affirmed by the appellate court was set aside because there was a finding based on the appreciation of the material on record that the transaction was benami. But in the case in hand, it is yet to be proved by a reliable evidence as to whether the property in suit was purchased benami or not and what were the intention of the parties when the same was purchased. For arriving at this conclusion one has to go through the merits of the case. Before arriving at any decision it is necessary that the parties should lead evidence. Merely on the ground of S. 4 itself the suit cannot be thrown out at this preliminary stage. The question whether a female can be a coparcener or not will also be decided after the full facts are placed on record and after the evidence is led. Hence this issue will be decided along with other issues on merits.

    Order accordingly.
    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Shri Mahinder Singh v. Mr. Pardaman Singh .
    (Apr 2, 1992)