| Abdul Aziz Mohammad v. Union of India, 1984 Criminal Law Journal 1307 |
Authority for entertaining a writ petition to challenge a detention order even where the petitioner had not first surrendered; illustrates pre-execution relief in suitable cases. |
Cited by the learned Single Judge and relied upon as one basis for concluding that pre-execution challenges may in appropriate cases be entertained. |
| Hem Raj Sapra v. Administrator of Delhi, 1989 (2) Crimes 32 |
Holds that a writ was maintainable even though the detention order had not yet been executed. |
Referred to as supporting authority that pre-execution writs may be entertained. |
| Navin Kumar Kapoor v. The Administrator, Union Territory of Delhi, 1989(3) Delhi Lawyer 345 |
Another Division Bench decision holding that a writ was maintainable although the detention order had not been executed. |
Cited to show an established line of decisions permitting pre-execution relief in exceptional circumstances. |
| Hira Lal Somabhai Damania v. Dr. Gopal Singh and others, 1988 (1) Crimes 857 (Bombay) |
Illustrative decision relied on for guidance where pre-execution interference was considered. |
Mentioned as one of the guiding decisions for the proposition that pre-execution challenges may be entertained in suitable cases. |
| Ram Kishore Gupta v. Administrator, Union Territory of Delhi (Criminal Writ Petition No. 169/88) |
Earlier decision relied upon in subsequent Division Bench judgments that allowed pre-execution challenges in certain circumstances. |
Noted as part of the chain of decisions forming the jurisprudence on pre-execution challenges. |
| Lalit Kumar…Petitioner v. Union Of India & Ors., Criminal Writ No. 44/88 (decided 16 Feb 1989) |
Another earlier decision in the sequence supporting pre-execution consideration of detention orders. |
Referred to by the learned Single Judge and placed in the context of precedent allowing exceptional pre-execution interference. |
| Shri Ved Parkash v. State of Gujrat and Another, 1987(1) Crime 440 (Gujrat) |
Illustrated instances where pre-execution review had been permitted; provides guidelines. |
Quoted as affording useful guidance on when pre-execution challenges may be entertained. |
| The Additional Secretary to the Government of India and Others v. Smt. Alka Subhash Gadia and Another (Criminal Appeal Nos. 440 & 441 of 1989), decided 20 Dec 1990 |
Supreme Court: Generally it is not open to a detenu to challenge detention prior to execution, but in exceptional/genuine cases courts may exercise their powers at the pre-execution stage; exercise of discretion must be judicial and on well-settled principles. |
Referred to as the Supreme Court's "final word" that pre-execution interference is exceptional; this Court relied on that approach in allowing these petitions to be entertained pre-execution. |
| Sk. Nizamuddin v. State of W.B, AIR 1974 SC 2353 |
Authority cited for the proposition that delay in execution of detention orders can be fatal depending on facts and State's explanation. |
Cited by counsel for the appellants as part of the group of cases showing delay may vitiate detention; the Court considered this line of authority in assessing the effect of delay. |
| Omar Ahmed v. Union of India, 1984 Crl. LJ. 1915 |
One of the cases relied upon for the principle that unexplained delay can render a detention order invalid. |
Included among authorities cited by appellants on the effect of delay. |
| Man Mohan Singh v. Union of India and Ors., 1988 (1) Delhi Lawyer 171 |
Case cited in relation to consequences of delay in execution of detention orders. |
Listed by appellants' counsel as supporting authorities on delay. |
| Abdul Rehman v. State of Kerala and Ors., Judgment Today 1989 (3) S.C 444 |
Authority cited for the effect of delay in execution of detention orders. |
Referenced among cases relied on by appellants to show that delay may be fatal absent satisfactory explanation by the State. |
| Lalit Patudi…Petitioner v. Union Of India & Others, 41(1990) D.L.T 8 |
Authority cited in the context of delay affecting detention orders. |
Cited by counsel for appellants as part of supporting decisions on delay. |
| Ramesh Kumar Khaitan v. Union of India and Ors., Crl. W.P No. 559 of 1987 (decided 27-6-1988) |
Another decision relied upon for the principle that delay may invalidate detention orders. |
Referenced by appellants' counsel as part of the jurisprudence on delay and state explanation. |
| Anwar Ismail Aibani v. Union of India & Ors., Crl. W.P No. 375 of 1986 (decided 11-12-1986) |
Case cited on the consequences of delay in executing detention orders. |
Referred to among the authorities showing that unexplained delay can be decisive. |
| 1999 (3) JT 444 (as cited in text: "reported as 1989 (3) JT 444") |
Referred to in the text as a case where three months unexplained delay between passing the order and arrest led the Supreme Court to hold the delay cast doubt on genuineness of subjective satisfaction. |
Used by the court to support the proposition that unexplained delay throws doubt on genuineness of subjective satisfaction and may invalidate detention. |
| 1979 SC 541 = 1979 Cr. L.J 462 (unnamed in text) |
A Supreme Court case where the detenu had been declared absconder and steps under Section 7 (publish proclamations, display photographs etc.) had been taken; in such circumstances benefit was not given to the detenu despite delay. |
Distinguished by the court: the present cases lacked any evidence of resort to Section 7 steps or publication, so the benefit of that decision could not be taken by respondents. |