| Newab Behram Jung v. Haji Sultan Ali Shustry, ILR 27 Bombay 572 |
Section 129 of the Code empowers High Courts to make procedural rules for original side, which prevail over inconsistent Code rules. |
Affirmed that High Court rules prevail over inconsistent Code provisions. |
| Virupaksha Rao Naidu v. M. Ranganayaki Ammal, AIR 1925 Madras 1132 |
Section 129 grants High Courts power to regulate original side procedure, overriding inconsistent Code provisions. |
Supported the primacy of High Court Original Side Rules over Code rules. |
| Umeshchandra Banerji v. Kunjilal Biswas, AIR 1930 Calcutta 685 |
Reinforced that High Court procedural rules prevail over inconsistent Code provisions. |
Used to confirm the established principle of rule supremacy. |
| Gowal Das Sidany v. Luchmi Chand Jhawar, AIR 1930 Calcutta 324 |
Same principle as above regarding rule supremacy. |
Further supported the primacy of High Court Original Side Rules. |
| In re: Ram Dayal De, AIR 1932 Calcutta 1 |
Same principle on High Court procedural rules. |
Confirmed consistent application of section 129 principles. |
| Shaw & Co. v. B. Shamaldas & Co., AIR 1954 Calcutta 369 |
High Court rules prevail over inconsistent Code rules. |
Supported the Court's conclusion on rule hierarchy. |
| Manickchand Durgaprasad v. Pratabmull Rameswar, AIR 1961 Calcutta 483 |
Same principle regarding rule supremacy. |
Used to corroborate the Court's view. |
| Mool Chand and another v. Kamta Prasad and others, AIR 1961 Allahabad 595 |
High Court procedural rules prevail over Code provisions. |
Supported the primacy of the Original Side Rules. |
| Bademian Saheb and another v. P.M. Jankan Saheb, AIR 1938 Madras 438 |
Section 157 of the Code concerning continuance of rules under earlier Codes. |
Distinguished by the Court as irrelevant to the present issue. |
| Arunachala Reddiar v. Muthusadasiva Mudaliar and others, AIR 1950 Madras 261 |
Section 157 related to continuation of old rules. |
Held not applicable to the question of Original Side Rules vs. Code. |
| Union of India and another v. Ram Kanwar and others, AIR 1962 SC 247 |
Rules made by High Courts/Supreme Court regulating procedure are 'special law'. |
Used to interpret Section 4(1) of the Code regarding procedural rules. |
| Punjab Co-operative Bank Ltd., Lahore v. Official Liquidators, AIR 1941 Lahore 257 |
Procedural rules as special law under Section 4(1) of the Code. |
Supported the interpretation of Original Side Rules as special procedural law. |
| Deities of Sri Audinarayana Swamy and Anjenayaswami Temples of Donepudi v. R. Hanumacharyulu and others, AIR 1962 A.P 245 |
High Court procedural rules as special law under Section 4(1). |
Supported the Court's reasoning on the applicability of Original Side Rules. |
| Shevaram Thadharam Jaisinghani v. Indian Oil Corporation Ltd., AIR 1969 Bombay 117 |
Relationship between Sections 122 and 129 of the Code and framing of original side rules. |
Discussed but the Court preferred Section 129 as the proper source of original side rules. |