Factual and Procedural Background
This opinion arises from a reference made by the Income-tax Appellate Tribunal, Delhi Bench ‘A’, to the High Court under Section 66(1) of the Indian Income-tax Act, 1922. The assessee, a Hindu Undivided Family (HUF) with the Karta Seth Banarsi Dass Gupta residing at Meerut, filed two applications under Section 66(1) arising out of Income-tax Appeals Nos. 1978 and 1979 of 1963-64, relating to assessment years 1956-57 and 1957-58. The Commissioner of Income-tax, Delhi (Central), also filed applications under the same section and appeals.
The assessment orders for the two years were passed by the Income-tax Officer at Meerut. The assessee appealed to the Appellate Assistant Commissioner, Meerut, who partly allowed the appeals. The assessee then appealed to the Income-tax Appellate Tribunal, Delhi Bench, which also partly allowed the appeals. Applications under Section 66(1) were filed by both parties requesting the Tribunal to refer questions of law to the High Court. The Tribunal referred seven questions of law to the High Court by a common order dated 28th March 1969.
At the hearing of the reference, the Commissioner raised a preliminary objection that the Delhi High Court lacked jurisdiction to entertain the reference as the proper High Court should have been the High Court of Allahabad, since the place of assessment and residence/business of the assessee was Meerut in Uttar Pradesh.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the Delhi High Court has jurisdiction to entertain a reference under Section 66(1) of the Indian Income-tax Act, 1922, when the assessing Income-tax Officer’s office is located in Meerut, Uttar Pradesh?
- What is the proper High Court to which the Income-tax Appellate Tribunal should refer questions of law arising under Section 66(1) when the Tribunal Bench has jurisdiction over more than one State?
- What is the correct basis for determining the jurisdiction of the Appellate Tribunal Benches and the corresponding High Courts for references under Section 66?
Arguments of the Parties
Commissioner of Income-tax's Arguments
- The Delhi High Court lacks jurisdiction to entertain the reference because all members of the HUF reside and carry on business in Meerut, Uttar Pradesh.
- The assessment orders were passed by the Income-tax Officer at Meerut and appeals were disposed of by the Appellate Assistant Commissioner at Meerut.
- Therefore, the proper High Court for the reference under Section 66(1) is the High Court of Allahabad, not Delhi High Court.
- Relied on the decision of the Madras High Court in Commissioner of Income-tax Madras v. S. Sivaramakrishna Iyer, which held that in absence of statutory provisions, jurisdiction should be determined by principles akin to Section 64, i.e., place of business or residence of the assessee.
Assessee's Arguments
- Suggested that the jurisdiction of the High Court should be based on the location of the Appellate Tribunal Bench that heard and determined the appeal.
- On this basis, since the Delhi Bench heard the appeals, the Delhi High Court should have jurisdiction to entertain the reference.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent |
Rule or Principle Cited For |
Application by the Court |
| Commissioner of Income-tax Madras v. S. Sivaramakrishna Iyer (1) 70 I.T.R 860 |
Determination of proper High Court jurisdiction where Tribunal has jurisdiction over multiple States; absence of statutory provision leads to application of principles akin to Section 64 of the Act (place of business or residence of assessee). |
The Court noted the decision but distinguished its applicability, holding that the basis for jurisdiction of the Appellate Tribunal Bench (location of assessing officer’s office) should be adopted instead of Section 64 principles for determining High Court jurisdiction under Section 66. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court examined the provisions of the Indian Income-tax Act, 1922, particularly Sections 5, 5A, 30, 33, 64, and 66, along with the Appellate Tribunal Rules of 1946 and 1963, and the Standing Orders Nos. 1 of 1954 and 1967 issued by the President of the Appellate Tribunal. It analyzed the jurisdictional framework for Income-tax Officers, Appellate Assistant Commissioners, and the Appellate Tribunal Benches.
The Court emphasized that the jurisdiction of an Income-tax Officer is determined by the place where the assessee carries on business or resides (Section 64). However, the jurisdiction of an Appellate Tribunal Bench is not determined by the place of residence or business of the assessee but by the location of the office of the assessing Income-tax Officer, as clarified in the explanation to the Standing Orders.
Although the appeals were heard by the Delhi Bench, the Court reasoned that the appeals were likely transferred from the Allahabad Bench to the Delhi Bench pursuant to the Standing Order No. 1 of 1967, which altered jurisdictional boundaries to include Meerut within the Delhi Bench’s jurisdiction. The Court accepted the presumption that official acts were done in accordance with law, thereby confirming the Delhi Bench’s jurisdiction to hear the appeals and related Section 66 applications.
Regarding the High Court to which questions of law under Section 66(1) should be referred, the Court noted that the Act does not expressly specify the High Court when the Tribunal Bench has jurisdiction over multiple States. The Court considered the Madras High Court’s decision but found it unsuitable to apply the Section 64 basis (place of business or residence) for High Court jurisdiction in this context.
The Court held that the proper basis for determining the High Court jurisdiction for references under Section 66 is the same as that adopted for determining the jurisdiction of the Appellate Tribunal Bench, namely, the location of the assessing Income-tax Officer’s office. This approach aligns with the statutory scheme, the Standing Orders, and the intermediate nature of references under Section 66, which are finally disposed of by the Tribunal Bench after the High Court’s decision.
Applying this principle to the present case, since the assessment was made by the Income-tax Officer at Meerut (in Uttar Pradesh), the proper High Court for the reference is the High Court of Allahabad, not the Delhi High Court. Therefore, the Delhi High Court lacks jurisdiction to entertain the reference.
Holding and Implications
Preliminary objection upheld.
The Court declined to answer the reference, holding that the Delhi High Court had no jurisdiction to entertain the reference under Section 66(1) of the Indian Income-tax Act, 1922, as the proper High Court was the High Court of Allahabad due to the location of the assessing officer’s office in Meerut, Uttar Pradesh. The statement of case was returned to the Delhi Bench for appropriate action in light of this judgment. The parties were directed to bear their own costs.
This decision directly affects the parties by clarifying the jurisdictional limits of High Courts in references under Section 66(1) but does not establish any new precedent beyond confirming the application of existing statutory provisions and Standing Orders.
Show full summary ...