| Dharam Dass Sonpar v. Union of India (R.S.A. 70‑D of 1965 decided 18 Feb 1970) |
Consideration whether services could be terminated under rule 5 CCS (TS) Rules; the Division Bench held the appointment was permanent and CCS(TS) Rules applied only to lower subordinates. |
The Court distinguished the decision on facts: there the appointee was found to be permanent; the present petitioner was found to have been appointed temporarily, so the Dharam Dass decision was not directly applicable to support petitioner’s case. |
| Ratnakar Vishwanath Joshi v. Life Insurance Corporation of India & Others (Civil Writ 349 of 1972 decided 26 July 1974) |
Orders may have the authority/force of law depending on criteria (administrative or statutory orders). |
The Court relied on the criteria from this decision to observe that the Delhi Administration's order creating 40 temporary ASI posts had authority of law and could validly create temporary posts. |
| Nanak Chand v. State of U.P., 1971 S.L.R. 661 |
Held that section 2 of the Police Act permits creation of temporary posts in the police force. |
The Court cited this Full Bench decision to support the proposition that the Police Act allows temporary posts and appointments thereto (thus validating the creation of the 40 temporary ASI posts). |
| Ghatgo and Patil Concern's Employees' Union v. Ghatgo and Patil (Transports) Pvt. Ltd., 1968-1 S.C.R. 300 |
Contracts of employment are valid where not contrary to any law. |
The Court used this principle to state that the contractual recital excluding PPR 12.8(1) was lawful and not against public policy where Police Act/PPR permitted temporary appointment. |
| Faqir Chand v. Ram Rattan Bhanot, AIR 1973 S.C. 921 |
Principles concerning contracts and public policy (cited in relation to whether terms contrary to law would be void). |
Referenced to show that if Police Act/PPR had prohibited temporary appointment, an exclusion could be void; but because temporary posts were permitted, these authorities did not defeat the appointment. |
| Murlidhar Aggarwal v. State of U.P., 1974 — 2 S.C.C. 472 |
Authority on public policy of contractual terms in service appointments (cited alongside Faqir Chand). |
Cited in the same context: to show that contractual exclusion of PPR benefits would be invalid only if contrary to law; not the case here because temporary appointments were lawful. |
| Harishankar Bagia v. State of Madhya Pradesh, AIR 1954 S.C. 465 |
Principle that different rules may be read together and applied according to their respective spheres. |
The Court invoked the principle to support the approach that Punjab Police Rules (special) and CCS (TS) Rules (general) can coexist, each operating in their respective fields (e.g., PPR for many matters, CCS(TS) Rule 5 for termination where PPR is silent). |
| R.C. Roy v. Union of India, ILR (1971) I Delhi 584 |
Laid down criteria to determine when termination is simple termination versus when it is punishment attracting Article 311(2). |
The Court applied the criteria from R.C. Roy to analyse whether termination here was a routine administrative termination or punishment; concluded it was routine termination in the course of administration. |
| Samsher Singh v. State of Punjab (Civil Appeal No. 2289 of 1970 decided 23 Aug 1974) |
Authoritative guidance (seven‑Judge Bench) on when termination may amount to punishment; quoted passage explaining that termination may (in certain facts) amount to removal within Article 311(2). |
The Court relied on the observations of Ray, C.J., to explain that where adverse material are opinions about suitability (routine), termination can be administrative; but where termination follows charges, Article 311(2) protections apply. Applied this to find no violation here. |
| R.L. Butail v. Union of India, 1970-2 S.C.C. 876 |
Principle that subjective opinions in confidential reports cannot form the basis of formal charges. |
The Court cited this decision to hold that the confidential report's remarks were expressions of opinion and could not be the basis for charges requiring a departmental inquiry. |
| Champaklal v. Union of India, AIR 1964 S.C. 1854 |
Government does not terminate an employee's service without reason; termination for inadequacy is permissible. |
Invoked to support the proposition that ending the service of an unsuitable employee as compared to others is not discriminatory and can be done in routine administration. |
| State of U.P. v. Sughar Singh, 1974-1 S.C.C. 218 |
Termination without cause may amount to double punishment or discrimination; censures that are final cannot later be turned into grounds for further punishment. |
The Court distinguished Sughar Singh: the earlier censures were a closed chapter here and could not become the foundation of termination; termination followed routine administrative assessment (confidential report) rather than a fresh punitive proceeding. |