Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The appeal concerns whether the appellant, as the pawnor of certain shares pledged in favour of respondent No. 5-Bank, is entitled to dividends, rights, and bonus shares issued in respect of those pledged shares. The shares originally stood in the joint names of respondent No. 2 and his brothers (respondents Nos. 3 and 4). Respondent No. 2 and the appellant formed a partnership named New Shares Corporation, which pledged 91 of these shares as security for an overdraft account with respondent No. 5-Bank.

In a prior suit, it was held that only 1/3rd of respondent No. 2’s interest in the shares was validly pledged. The bank was entitled to recover the decretal amount by sale of these validly hypothecated shares but not from the defendants personally in case of shortfall. The appellant filed Suit No. 179 of 1955 seeking declaration that the shares belonged exclusively to the partnership and were available for payment of the firm's debts. The suit was decreed only as regards 1/3rd share of respondent No. 2 and dismissed for the other shares. Respondents Nos. 3 and 4 sold their interest to respondent No. 1.

Punjab National Bank Ltd. issued bonus and right shares and declared accumulated dividends on the original shares. Respondent No. 1 filed a suit for partition of his 2/3rd interest in all shares including bonus, right shares, and dividends. Respondent No. 5 contested, claiming all shares were pledged by New Shares Corporation and that the earlier suit’s decision was not binding on it. Issues were framed regarding the binding nature of the prior decision, ownership of the shares, entitlement to dividends and bonus shares, and relief.

The learned Sub Judge decided in favour of respondent No. 1 on ownership and held that the appellant was not entitled to interest in 1/3rd of the pledged shares or accretions except to the extent allowed by the High Court. The appellant filed the present appeal challenging this judgment.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the pledge in favour of respondent No. 5-Bank extends to the right shares, bonus shares, and accumulated dividends declared in respect of the pledged shares?
  2. Whether the appellant, as pawnor, is entitled to dividends, right shares, and bonus shares issued on the pledged shares?

Arguments of the Parties

Respondent No. 5-Bank's Arguments

  • Respondents Nos. 2 and 4 had no interest in the original shares as all were pledged by New Shares Corporation as rightful owner.
  • The decision in Suit No. 179 of 1955 was not binding on the bank.
  • The interest of appellant and respondent No. 2 in the shares, including bonus, right shares, and dividends, was subject to the bank’s pledge.
  • Hence, no partition could take place in respect of these shares or accretions.

Appellant's Arguments

  • The shares were pledged only to the extent of 1/3rd interest of respondent No. 2 and the appellant retained ownership of the accretions.
  • The bank, as pawnee, only acquires special property in the pledged shares and does not become owner of dividends, bonus, or right shares issued subsequently.
  • The principle of pledge under the Indian Contract Act does not transfer general property to the pawnee.
  • Reference to the judgment in Shri Raja Kakarlapudi Venkata Sudarsana Sundara Narasayyamma Garu and others v. Andhra Bank Ltd to distinguish pledge from mortgage and sale.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Shri Raja Kakarlapudi Venkata Sudarsana Sundara Narasayyamma Garu and others v. Andhra Bank Ltd Distinction between pledge and mortgage; pledgee acquires only special property, mortgagee acquires general property subject to redemption. Used to clarify that the bank as pawnee has only special property in pledged shares and does not acquire rights to dividends, bonus, or right shares.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analyzed the nature of pledge under sections 172 and 176 of the Indian Contract Act, emphasizing that pledge is a bailment for security where the pawnee acquires only special property and not general ownership. The pawnee’s rights are limited to retention and sale of the pledged goods upon default, after notice. The Court distinguished pledge from mortgage and sale, the latter involving transfer of general property.

The Court rejected the Sub Judge’s application of principles applicable to mortgages and transfers of shares by sale to the case of pledge. It held that any accretions such as dividends, bonus shares, or right shares issued on the pledged shares remain the property of the pawnor unless there is a contract to the contrary. Since no such contract existed, the bank had no right to these accretions.

The Court thus modified the Sub Judge’s judgment to exclude the bank’s interest in dividends, right shares, and bonus shares relating to the 1/3rd of the pledged shares, affirming the appellant’s entitlement to them.

Holding and Implications

Appeal allowed.

The Court held that the pledge in favour of respondent No. 5-Bank did not extend to dividends, right shares, or bonus shares issued in respect of the 1/3rd interest in the pledged shares. Consequently, the appellant is entitled to these accretions. The judgment and decree of the Sub Judge were modified accordingly. The appellant was also granted costs of the appeal.

This decision clarifies that in the absence of contrary contract, a pawnee’s rights do not include accretions on pledged shares, preserving the pawnor’s general ownership rights in such accretions. No new precedent beyond this case’s facts was expressly established.

    M.R Dhawan v. Madan Mohan And Others S

    P.N Khanna, J.:— The only question involved in this appeal is whether the appellant, who is the pawnor of certain shares in favour of respondent No. 5-Bank, is entitled to the dividends and the right, and bonus shares issued, in respect of the said pledged shares.

    The facts giving rise to this appeal are as follows : 101 shares of the Punjab National Bank Limited of the value of Rs. 100 per share originally stood in the joint names of respondent No. 2 and his brothers respondents Nos. 3 and 4. Respondent No. 2 entered into a partnership with the appellant under the name of New Shares Corporation.

    This firm, New Shares Corporation, had an overdraft account with the Hindustan Commercial Bank Ltd., respondent No. 5. As a security in the said account, 91 shares out of the said 101 shares of the Punjab National Bank Ltd. were pledged by the said firm with respondent No. 5, who, in a suit for the recovery of money due, obtained a decree for the amount found due to it. It was, however, held by the High Court in the said suit, that only 1/3rd right of respondent No. 2 in those shares had been pledged, as the share of respondents Nos. 2 and 4 could not be pledged by respondent No. 2. Allowing the benefit of section 17 of the Displaced Persons (Debts Adjustment) Act LXXI of 1951, it was held that the Bank was entitled to recover the decretal amount by the sale of shares to the extent that they are validly hypothecated and not from the defendants personally in case of short fall.

    The present appellant then filed a suit (Suit No. 179 of 1955) for the declaration that the said shares were the exclusive property of the partnership, New Shares Corporation, and these belonged to him and respondent No. 2, in the ratio of their respective shares in the firm and were available for payment of firm's debts and for adjustment of the amounts due to him from respondent No. 2. The said suit was decreed only as regards 1/3rd share of respondent No. 2 and was dismissed as regards 2/3rd share of respondents Nos. 3 and 4. Respondents Nos. 3 and 4, in the meantime, sold their interest in the said shares in favour of respondent No. 1.

    In respect of the said total 101 shares, the Punjab National Bank Ltd., issued 444 shares of Rs. 25 each paid up and 190 right shares of Rs. 425 each. Besides, certain sums were lying with the Punjab National Bank Ltd. as accumulated dividends.

    Respondent No. 1. Shri Madan Mohan then filed this suit, out of which the present appeal has arisen, for the partition of his 2/3rd interest in all the aforesaid shares, including the bonus and right shares, aforesaid, as also in the accumulated dividends. Respondent No. 5 was the main contesting party in the suit. According to it, respondents Nos. 2 and 4 had no interest in the original shares, all of them having been pledged in its favour by the new Shares Corporation as rightful owner. The decision in the earlier suit No. 179/55, according to it, was not binding upon it and, at any rate, all the interest of the appellant and respondent No. 2 in the said shares including their interest in the bonus and right shares and in the accumulated dividends was subject to its pledge. Hence, no partition could take place at all. The following issues were framed:—

    1. Whether the defendant No. 5 (now respondent No. 5) is not bound by the decision in suit No. 179 of 1955 ?

    2. If not, is the plaintiff (now respondent No. 1) the owner of 2/3rd shares in dispute ?

    3. Whether the defendant No. 1 (now the appellant) is entitled to any interest in the shares dividends, bonus and right shares ?

    4. Relief.

    The learned Sub Judge decided issue No. 1 against the respondent No. 5-Bank. Issue No. 2 was decided in favour of the plaintiff-respondent No. 1. Regarding issue No. 3, the learned Sub Judge held that the whole interest of respondent No. 2 had been pledged in favour of respondent No. 5 Bank and as such, appellant defendant No. 1, was not entitled to any interest in 1/3rd of the 91 shares originally hypothecated (should be pledged) or any accretion in the form of right or bonus shares or in the accumulated dividends except to the extent allowed by the High Court in Judgment dated 2-3-1960. The appellant-defendant No. 1 has come up in appeal against the said judgment and decree dated the 21st January, 1961 of the learned Sub Judge, Ist Class, Delhi.

    The only question that now arises for consideration is, as to whether the pledge in favour of the respondent No. 5 extended also to the right shares, bonus shares and the accumulated dividends declared in respect of 1/3rd of 91 shares of the Punjab National Bank Ltd., which was pledged with respondent No. 5.

    The learned Sub Judge, while answering the above question, has based his judgment on, what he calls as ‘principle of law in the case of mortgages’ and has also discussed the rights, as between the buyer and seller in the case of a transfer of shares. The distinction between the pledge, the mortgage and the sale has not been properly appreciated by him. Pledge is defined in section 172 of the Indian Contract Act which is re-produced as follows :—

    “The bailment of goods as security for payment of a debt or performance of a “promise is called ‘Pledge’. The bailor as in this case called the ‘pawnor’. The bailee is called the ‘pawnee’.”

    Under Section 176 of the Contract Act—

    “If the pawnor makes default in payment of the debt, of performance, at the stipulated time of the promise, in respect of which the goods were pledged, the pawnee may bring a suit against the pawnor upon the debt or promise, and remain the goods pledged as a collateral security, or he may sell the thing pledged, on giving the pawnor reasonable notice of the sale.

    If the proceeds of such sale are less than the amount due in respect of the debt or promise, the pawnor is still liable to pay the balance. If the proceeds of the sale are greater than the amount so due, the pawnee shall pay over the surplus to the pawnor.”

    It is, thus, clear that pledge is a kind of bailment and security. Its primary purpose is to put the goods pledged in the power of the pawnee to reimburse himself for the money advanced, when on becoming due it remains unpaid, by selling the goods after serving the pawnor with a due notice. The pawnee at no time becomes the owner of the goods pledged. He has only a right to retain the goods until his claim for the money advanced thereon has been satisfied, with a power to sell the goods pledged, after due notice in case of default by the pawnor. It is only a special property in the goods pledged, which is acquired by the pawnee, leaving the general property intact with the pawnor. In the case of a mortgage, however, an interest in the mortgaged property is transferred in favour of the mortgagee subject to the right of redemption of the mortgagor. The learned counsel for the appellant has referred to a judgment in the case of Shri Raja Kakarlapudi Venkata Sudarsana Sundara Narasayyamma Garu and others v. Andhra Bank Ltd. It was observed in the said case :

    “The essential distinction, therefore, between a pledge and a mortgage is that unlike a pledgee a mortgagee acquires general property in the thing mortgaged subject to the right of redemption of the mortgagor. In other words, the legal estate in the goods mortgaged passes on to the mortgagee. But a pledgee has only the special property in the goods pledged, namely, the right of retainer of the goods as security, and in case of default he must either bring a suit against the pawnor or sell the goods after giving a reasonable notice.”

    It will, thus, be seen that the pawnee acquires a right, after notice, to dispose of the goods pledged. This amounts to his acquiring only a “special property” in the goods pledged. The general property therein remains in the pawnor and wholly reverts to him on payment of the debt or performance of the promise. Any accretion in the shape of dividends, bonus or right shares, issued in respect of the pledged shares will, therefore, be, in the absence of any contract to the contrary, the property of the pawnor.

    In the case of a sale, “the property” in the goods is transferred from the buyer to the seller. Reference may be made to section 4 of the Sale of Goods Act. “Property”, according to section 2(11) of the Sales of Goods Act, means the “general property in goods and not merely a special property.” It is, thus, clear that if only special property passes, it may amount to a pledge. It becomes a sale only when the general property in the goods passes. The contention of the learned counsel for the respondents that in the case of a transfer of shares, the transferee becomes entitled to all the dividends declared after the contract of transfer and to the bonus or right shares, if any, therefore, has no relevance; because in the case of a transfer which is a sale, general property is transferred to the buyer which does not happen in the case of a pledge. The general property having, thus, remained in the pawnor, he remains entitled to all the dividends that may be declared on the shares and to the bonus and right shares that may be issued in respect of the shares pledged.

    There being no contract to the contrary in this case, respondent No. 5 has no right or interest in the accumulated dividends declared in respect of 1/3rd of the 91 shares of the Punjab National Bank Ltd., pledged in favour of respondent No. 5, nor to the right shares or the bonus shares issued in respect of the same. The result is that the appeal is accepted and the judgment and decree of the learned Sub Judge is modified so as to exclude in favour of the appellant the right and bonus shares and dividends declared in respect of 1/3rd of 91 shares of the Punjab National Bank Ltd., originally pledged with respondent No. 5. The appellant shall be entitled to costs of this appeal.

    S.K Kapur J.—I agree.

    A.N.K Appeal allowed.
    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    M.R Dhawan v. Madan Mohan And Others S
    (Feb 13, 1969)