Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of Article 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of Article 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion (Judgment by SATISH K. AGNIHOTRI, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant filed an intra-court appeal against the order dated 01.09.2014 in W.P. No. 32804 of 2012, by which the writ petition filed by the appellant was dismissed.

The salient undisputed facts in the record are:

  • The appellant's father, Thiru M. Danapal, was employed as a Gang Mazdoor in the office of the Assistant Divisional Engineer, Highways, C&M, Cheyyar, and died in harness on 28.09.1989.
  • The father's normal date of retirement (superannuation) would have been 31.03.1991.
  • The appellant was about 17½ years old at the time of his father's death and became eligible for consideration after six months, but did not apply immediately.
  • The appellant submitted an application for compassionate appointment on 02.04.1997 to the office of the third respondent; it was forwarded and received by the first respondent on 27.07.1998.
  • No response was communicated to the appellant until a letter dated 17.10.2012 from the office of the second respondent rejecting the application.
  • On the dismissal of the writ petition by the Single Judge (who relied on Bhawani Prasad Sonkar v. Union of India and others), the appellant brought the present intra-court appeal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the appellant's application for compassionate appointment, filed in 1997 (received 1998), was barred by limitation given the applicable government order(s) and relevant law governing compassionate appointments.
  2. Whether the delay by administrative officers in taking a decision on the application (from 1997/1998 until rejection in 2012) disentitles the respondents to rely on the limitation or otherwise renders the rejection improper.
  3. Which government order/policy governs the appellant's claim — the earlier G.O.Ms.No.560 (03.08.1977) operative at the time of death or the later G.O.Ms.No.120 (26.06.1995) — and whether the subsequent amendment affects the appellant's claim.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The appellant contended that delay in making the application arose because the father had three wives and several children, and time was required to resolve that dispute before filing on 02.04.1997.
  • It was urged that the respondents had considered the application (it was assigned Serial No. 195 in the waiting list) and therefore, because respondents took time to consider the application from 1997 until the 2012 communication, the application ought not to have been dismissed on the ground of delay.

Respondents' Arguments

  • Compassionate appointment is intended to provide immediate succor and relief to dependants of the deceased employee; it cannot be granted outside the compassionate appointment policy, rules, and regulations.
  • The application had been listed but no decision was taken; the fact that the respondents took time to consider the application does not permit ignoring the prescribed time limits under the policy.
  • At the time of the deceased employee's death (1989) the applicable policy was G.O.Ms.No.560 dated 03.08.1977, which permitted consideration only up to the presumptive date of superannuation; that date was 31.03.1991 in this case, and the appellant filed only after that date.
  • Although G.O.Ms.No.120 dated 26.06.1995 later prescribed a three-year limit, the respondents argued that the case is governed by the earlier G.O. (G.O.Ms.No.560) operative at the time of death, and the appellant's application was therefore correctly rejected as time-barred.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Bhawani Prasad Sonkar v. Union of India Used by the Single Judge as authority to hold that an application for compassionate appointment can be barred by delay/limitation. The Single Judge relied on this decision to conclude the petitioner's application was time-barred; the present court noted that reliance and upheld the limitation reasoning in the facts of this case.
Umesh Kumar Nagpal v. State of Haryana Explains the object of compassionate employment: to enable the family to tide over the sudden crisis; compassionate employment is not a vested right and cannot be claimed after lapse of a reasonable period which must be specified in rules. The court cited and quoted this decision to establish the legal principle that compassionate employment is to meet immediate crisis and cannot be claimed indefinitely; this principle supported rejection as time-barred.
Jagdish Prasad v. State of Bihar Referred to as an authority approving the proposition that compassionate employment is not a vested right and cannot be granted after lapse. The court noted this decision (among others) as having referred with approval to the principle stated in Umesh Kumar Nagpal, thereby reinforcing the limitation principle.
Haryana SEB v. Hakim Singh Referred to in support of the settled proposition about the limited, humanitarian object of compassionate employment and temporal limitation on claims. Used by the court along with other authorities to show consistent Supreme Court view that compassionate employment cannot be claimed after the crisis is over or after an unreasonable lapse.
State of U.P v. Paras Nath Referred to as part of a line of cases approving the principle limiting compassionate employment to the immediate crisis period. Noted by the court as part of the earlier judicial pronouncements that reinforce the limitation principle.
Director of Education (Secondary) v. Pushpendra Kumar Referred to for the same settled proposition about the object and temporal limitation of compassionate employment. Referenced by the court along with other decisions to show judicial consistency on the subject.
State of J&K v. Sajad Ahmed Mir Included among decisions that referred with approval to the principle that compassionate employment is to tide over immediate penury and is not a vested right. Used as supportive authority in the chain of cases cited by the court to justify the limitation-based approach.
CCE & Customs v. Prabhat Singh Referred to as part of the jurisprudence approving the temporal and humanitarian scope of compassionate employment. Noted by the court as one of the decisions reinforcing the settled legal position relied upon to dismiss the appeal.
Mgb Gramin Bank v. Chakrawarti Singh Restates that appointments must adhere to Articles 14 and 16; compassionate employment is an exception for immediate relief, not a vested right, requires examination of family's condition, and must not be kept pending for years. The court relied on this recent pronouncement to emphasize that compassionate appointments should be immediate, cannot be claimed as a matter of right, and it is improper to keep such cases pending for years — supporting dismissal on the ground of inordinate delay.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded through the following analytical steps, based on the record and cited authorities:

  1. Verified undisputed factual matrix: death of the father on 28.09.1989, the father's presumptive superannuation date of 31.03.1991, the appellant's age (approx. 17½) at the time of death and his actual application dates (02.04.1997 filed; 27.07.1998 received by first respondent).
  2. Examined the relevant government order operative at the time of death, G.O.Ms.No.560 dated 03.08.1977, which permitted consideration of dependants' cases only up to the presumptive date of superannuation of the deceased employee (illustrated by an example in the order).
  3. Applied that rule to the facts: since the deceased's presumptive superannuation was 31.03.1991, any application should have been made on or before that date under G.O.Ms.No.560; the appellant's application came well after (about five years after that date), thus defeating the very purpose of compassionate appointment.
  4. Noted the subsequent amendment by G.O.Ms.No.120 dated 26.06.1995 which prescribed a three-year time limit for applications, but held that the case is to be governed by the government order prevailing at the time of the employee's death (G.O.Ms.No.560), not by the later amendment.
  5. Considered authoritative judicial pronouncements (including Umesh Kumar Nagpal and the line of cases cited thereafter) establishing that compassionate employment is meant to meet an immediate crisis, is not a vested right, and cannot be granted after the crisis has passed or after a reasonable period; the Court used these precedents to reinforce the temporal limitation on claims.
  6. Addressed the appellant's contention about administrative delay in considering the application: the court acknowledged that officers did not act promptly (which defeats the purpose of compassionate appointment) but held that administrative inaction did not cure the fact that the application itself was filed beyond the permissible period. The court nevertheless reserved liberty to the appellant to approach a competent forum for damages or compensation for the administrative delay, if advised.
  7. Emphasized constitutional constraints: compassionate appointment is an exception to ordinary public employment and must still respect Articles 14 and 16; appointments made in violation of those constitutional mandates or outside the policy cannot be validly sustained.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The writ appeal is DISMISSED. No costs were awarded.

Implications and immediate consequences:

  • The rejection of the appellant's application for compassionate appointment (communication dated 17.10.2012) is upheld because the application was filed after the period permitted by the government order applicable at the time of the deceased's death.
  • The court reaffirmed the settled legal position that compassionate employment is intended to provide immediate relief to a dependent family and is not a vested right; claims brought after the lapse of the permissible period cannot be sustained.
  • The court recognized administrative delay in considering the application and expressly reserved liberty to the appellant to seek damages or compensation before a competent forum under the provisions of law, but that administrative delay did not validate a time-barred compassionate appointment claim.
  • No new precedent was created by this decision; the court applied existing government orders and established Supreme Court precedents to the facts before it and reached the conclusion that the appellant's claim was time-barred.

    D.Sankar v. The Chief Director

    (Judgment of the court was made by SATISH K. AGNIHOTRI, J.) The instant intra-court appeal is directed against the order dated 01.09.2014 passed in W.P.No.32804 of 2012, wherein and whereunder the writ petition filed by the appellant / writ petitioner was dismissed.

    2. The indisputable facts leading to filing of the instant appeal are that the father of the appellant, namely, Thiru M.Danapal, while working as Gang Mazdoor in the office of the Assistant Divisional Engineer, Highways, C&M, Cheyyar, died in harness on 28.9.1989. The date of the retirement of Thiru M.Danapalm from service was on 31.3.1991 on attaining the age of superannuation. The appellant, at the time of death of his father, was about 17-1/2 years. Thereafter, the appellant made an application for compassionate appointment on 2.4.1997 in the office of the third respondent, which was further forwarded to the first respondent and received on 27.7.1998. It appears that the appellant was not communicated any response before a letter dated 17.10.2012 from the office of the second respondent, rejecting the application for compassionate appointment, was sent to him. Feeling aggrieved, the appellant came up with the instant writ petition, seeking for the relief to quash the said letter and consequently, to direct the respondents to consider and appoint the petitioner on the post of Office Assistant in the first respondent Department on compassionate ground.

    3. The learned Single Judge, examining all facts of the case, relying on a decision of the Supreme Court Bhawani Prasad Sonkar v. Union of India and others1, came to the conclusion that the application of the petitioner was barred by limitation on having been filed after a period of nine years from the date of death of the deceased employee, i.e., father of the petitioner.

    4. The learned counsel appearing for the appellant before us would submit that the application ought not to have been dismissed on the ground of delay in making the application for compassionate appointment as his father had three wives having several children. Thus, some time was taken to resolve the dispute before making an application on 2.4.1997. Thereafter, the application of the appellant was taken into consideration and as averred in the counter affidavit of the respondents, was assigned Serial No.195 in the waiting list applications. It is further urged that since the respondents had taken time to consider the application from 1997 till the impugned communication dated 17.10.2012, the application ought not to have been thrown out at this stage on the ground of delay.

    5. On the other hand, the learned counsel appearing for the respondents would submit that the purpose of compassionate appointment is to provide immediate succor and relief to the dependent member of the family of the deceased employee. Secondly, no compassionate appointment can be granted dehors the compassionate appointment policy, rules and regulations. It is further contended that the application was listed, but decision was not taken. Thus, it cannot be contended by the appellant that since there was delay in taking decision, the compassionate appointment policy should be ignored. It is lastly contended that at the time of death of the deceased employee, relevant policy was G.O.Ms.No.560, Labour and Employment Department dated 03.08.1977, which provides for making an application till the date of superannuation of the deceased employee in normal course. It was subsequently amended by G.O.Ms.No.120 dated 26.06.1995, providing the time limit for making an application, i.e., three years. Since the application was filed after G.O.Ms.No.120 was introduced, the application of the appellant was rightly rejected.

    6. We have heard the learned counsel for the parties, carefully examined the pleadings and documents appended thereto.

    7. The facts that the father of the appellant died in harness on 28.09.1989 is not in dispute. It is also not in controversy that in normal course, the father of the appellant would have retired from service on 31.3.1991 on his attaining the age of superannuation. Filing of the application for compassionate appointment on 2.4.1997 in the office of the third respondent, which was forwarded and received in the office of the first respondent on 27.7.1998 was not doubted by either party. It is true that at the time of death of the father of the appellant, the age of the appellant, taking his date of birth as on 20.2.1972 was 17-1/2 years. The appellant became eligible for consideration immediately after six months. However, he had chosen to file the application to consider him for appointment only after about a period of nine years. G.O.Ms.No.560 dated 3.8.1977, which was prevalent at that point of time at the time of death of the deceased employee, provides as under :

    (1)(b)In future, requests for appointment of dependants of the Government servants who died prior to 15.2.1972 can be considered favourably and proposals sent to Government in the following type of cases:

    At the time of consideration of his dependant's case for appointment the Government servants presumptive date of superannuation (i.e., had he lived) should not have been reached. In otherwords, the grant of the concession would be considered only upto the presumptive date of superannuation of the Government servant. For example, if a Government servant dies in 1965 and the date of his superannuation would have been 1.10.1981 if he were alive, his dependent can apply for a post on the date prior to 1.10.1981 only.

    8. In the case on hand, the deceased employee in the normal course would have retired from service on 31.3.1991. Thus, in view of the aforestated time schedule prescribed under the aforestated G.O dated 3.8.1977, the appellant was permitted to make application only till 31.3.1991. But the appellant had made an application only after five years from that date. Thus, the very purpose of granting compassionate appointment in case of untimely death of the employee in harness stands defeated. Thereafter, the policy was amended by G.O.Ms.No.120 dated 26.6.1995, wherein it was provided that the application for appointment on compassionate grounds should be made within three years of the death of the Government servant. Secondly, maximum age limit for such appointment be raised to 50 in the case of widows of the deceased Government servants. But, the case on hand would be governed by the earlier Government Order which was prevalent at the time of death of the father of the appellant, not the subsequent Government order.

    9. As far as the question of rejecting the application belatedly is concerned, there is no dispute that the application of the appellant for compassionate appointment was received beyond the time limit. Thus, it was rightly rejected. However, since the officers had not taken action immediately which is required to be done, particularly in case of the application for compassionate appointment, liberty is reserved to the appellant/ writ petitioner to take recourse to the competent forum for claiming damages / compensation, if so advised, under the provisions of law. At this stage, we must observe that the lackadaisical attitude of the officers in not considering the application at the earliest defeats the purpose of the application. Thus, the officers are expected to discharge their functions properly, keeping in view the fact that they are trustees of public faith and interest.

    10. The compassionate appointment is not an appointment in accordance with the constitutional scheme of employment. Consideration of the application in violation of the provisions of Article 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India cannot be held as legal way of appointment. However, it is well settled proposition of law that to provide succor and immediate relief to the dependent family, who had fallen in penury and suffering on account of untimely death of the Government employee in harness, the Government is held as competent to frame a proper policy to consider the applications of dependent family members of the deceased employee for appointment on compassionate basis. However, in absence of the same, no appointment on compassionate basis may be held as proper and valid.

    11. In Umesh Kumar Nagpal Vs. State of Haryana and others2, the Supreme Court had observed as under :

    2.....The whole object of granting compassionate employment is thus to enable the family to tide over the sudden crisis. The object is not to give a member of such family a post much less a post for post held by the deceased. What is further, mere death of an employee in harness does not entitle his family to such source of livelihood. The Government or the public authority concerned has to examine the financial condition of the family of the deceased, and it is only if it is satisfied, that but for the provision of employment, the family will not be able to meet the crisis that a job is to be offered to the eligible member of the family..... It was further held as under :

    6.For these very reasons, the compassionate employment cannot be granted after a lapse of a reasonable period which must be specified in the rules. The consideration for such employment is not a vested right which can be exercised at any time in future. The object being to enable the family to get over the financial crisis which it faces at the time of the death of the sole breadwinner, the compassionate employment cannot be claimed and offered whatever the lapse of time and after the crisis is over.

    12. The aforesaid proposition of law was referred to with approval in the subsequent decisions of the Supreme Court, i.e., Jagdish Prasad v. State of Bihar3, Haryana SEB v. Hakim Singh4, State of U.P v. Paras Nath5, Director of Education (Secondary) v. Pushpendra Kumar6, State of J&K v. Sajad Ahmed Mir7, Bhawani Prasad Sonkar v. Union of India1, and CCE & Customs v. Prabhat Singh8.

    13. Recently, in Mgb Gramin Bank v. Chakrawarti Singh. Singh9, it was held as under:

    6.Every appointment to public office must be made by strictly adhering to the mandatory requirements of Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution. An exception by providing employment on compassionate grounds has been carved out in order to remove the financial constraints on the bereaved family, which has lost its breadearner. Mere death of a Government employee in harness does not entitle the family to claim compassionate employment. The Competent Authority has to examine the financial condition of the family of the deceased employee and it is only if it is satisfied that without providing employment, the family will not be able to meet the crisis, that a job is to be offered to the eligible member of the family. More so, the person claiming such appointment must possess required eligibility for the post. The consistent view that has been taken by the Court is that compassionate employment cannot be claimed as a matter of right, as it is not a vested right. The Court should not stretch the provision by liberal interpretation beyond permissible limits on humanitarian grounds. Such appointment should, therefore, be provided immediately to redeem the family in distress. It is improper to keep such a case pending for years. Thus, the law is well settled that the appointment on compassionate ground is to tide over the penurious condition of the dependent family members of the deceased employee dying in harness, in accordance with the policy.

    14. As a sequel, for the reasons mentioned herein-above, the writ appeal is dismissed. No costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    D.Sankar v. The Chief Director
    (Mar 10, 2015)