Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Rule 8 of the Tamil Nadu Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulation) Rules, 1978 (hereinafter referred
  • TAMIL NADU URBAN LAND CEILING AND REGULATION ACT 1978
  • sub-rules (1) and (2) of Rule 8 of the Rules
  • provisions of Section 11(1) to (4),
  • sub-section (4) of section 9
  • sub-section (1) of section 7,
  • sub-rule (2) of Rule 8,
  • Rule 8 of the Rules.
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Rule 8 of the Tamil Nadu Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulation) Rules, 1978 (hereinafter referred
  • TAMIL NADU URBAN LAND CEILING AND REGULATION ACT 1978
  • sub-rules (1) and (2) of Rule 8 of the Rules
  • provisions of Section 11(1) to (4),
  • sub-section (4) of section 9
  • sub-section (1) of section 7,
  • sub-rule (2) of Rule 8,
  • Rule 8 of the Rules.
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The land comprised in Survey Nos. 402/4B (300 sq.mts), 402/4H (750 sq.mts), and 402/4J (4200 sq.mts) stood registered in the name of Thiru N. Nandagopal and remained vacant. Proceedings under the Tamil Nadu Urban Land (Ceiling & Regulation) Act, 1978 ("the Act") were initiated by issuance of notice under Section 7(2). Objections were raised and the proceedings culminated in issuance of a notice dated 27.4.1999 under Section 11(5) of the Act. The respondents contended that, because the Act was repealed on 16.6.1999, the proceedings lapsed as possession had not been taken in the manner known to law; the writ petitions were allowed by the High Court following the judgment reported in 2002 (2) CTC 716 (Allind Metal Fabricators Pvt. Ltd. vs. The Secretary to Government, Revenue Department, Government of Tamil Nadu). The State filed these appeals. The State's counsel asserted that symbolic possession was taken on 15.6.1999 (one day before repeal). The respondents denied valid physical possession and also contended that the mandatory service requirements of Section 11(5) read with Rule 8 of the Tamil Nadu Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulation) Rules, 1978 were not complied with. The court examined the records and reached the decision summarized below.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the statutory notice requirement under Section 11(5) of the Act read with Rule 8 of the Rules was complied with such that any possession taken by the State can be regarded as valid.
  2. Whether possession (including alleged symbolic possession) said to have been taken prior to the Repealing Act (16.6.1999) has the effect of preventing the respondents from obtaining the benefit of the Repealing Act.
  3. Whether symbolic possession, as opposed to physical possession, suffices to defeat the operation of the Repealing Act (the court noted this issue and left it open).

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's (State) Arguments

  • The State contended that symbolic possession of the land was taken on 15.6.1999, one day prior to the Repealing Act coming into force, and therefore the respondents cannot claim the benefit of the Repealing Act.
  • The State argued that because possession was taken prior to repeal, reliance on the Repealing Act by the respondents was not appropriate.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The respondents contended that only symbolic possession was taken and that physical possession as required by law was not taken; in the absence of valid physical possession, the Repealing Act applies to their benefit.
  • The respondents argued that notice under Section 11(5) of the Act was not issued and served in accordance with Rule 8 of the Rules; specifically, the requirements of sub-rules (1) and (2) of Rule 8 were not followed and only an affixture of the notice on the vacant site was made.
  • The respondents relied on judgments reported in 2009 (6) MLJ 1102 (S. Nasira Anjum and Others vs. State of Tamil Nadu) and 2009 (8) MLJ 522 (Sree Jayalakshmi Brick Industries vs. Special Commissioner & Secretary to Government) in support of the contention that absence of physical possession would entitle them to the benefit of the Repealing Act.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
2002 (2) CTC 716 (Allind Metal Fabricators Pvt. Ltd., vs. The Secretary to Government, Revenue Department, Government of Tamil Nadu, Madras) Followed by the High Court in allowing the writ petitions (as referenced in the impugned order). The impugned order had relied on this judgment in allowing the writ petitions; the present court noted that the High Court followed that decision.
2009 (6) MLJ 1102 (S. Nasira Anjum and Others vs. State of Tamil Nadu) Relied upon by respondents to support the contention that absence of physical possession means the Repealing Act applies. Cited by the respondents in support of their submission that symbolic possession alone is not sufficient; the court noted this authority in the submissions.
2009 (8) MLJ 522 (Sree Jayalakshmi Brick Industries vs. Special Commissioner & Secretary to Government) Relied upon by respondents to support the contention regarding insufficiency of symbolic possession and applicability of the Repealing Act. Cited by the respondents in their submissions; the court recorded reliance on this judgment by respondents.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court first addressed the compliance with the service requirements for the notice prescribed by Section 11(5) of the Act read with Rule 8 of the Rules. It set out the text of sub-rule (2) of Rule 8 as reproduced in the opinion, which contemplates that the draft statement together with the notice shall be served on the holder of the vacant lands and other persons likely to have any claim by sending the same by registered post to the addresses specified (including the address given in the statement under sub-section (1) of Section 7). The Rule provides that affixture of the notice is permissible only where efforts to serve by registered post are not successful (except where returned as refused, in which case it is deemed served).

The court examined the record and found that there was no notice sent through registered post; the only step taken was affixture of the notice on the vacant site. The court interpreted Rule 8 to mean that affixture is a last resort after making an attempt to serve the notice by registered post. Because the record did not show the mandatory attempts at service by registered post, the court concluded that any taking of possession by the State could not be regarded as valid in law so long as Section 11(5) read with Rule 8 was not complied with.

On that basis alone the court accepted the respondents' contention that, in the absence of possession taken in the prescribed manner, the provisions of the Repealing Act operate to their benefit. The court therefore found no reason to interfere with the impugned order allowing the writ petitions. The court expressly left open the broader question whether symbolic possession alone would suffice for the State's claim of taking over; that issue was not decided.

Holding and Implications

Core Holding: The writ appeals are dismissed. The court held that because the mandatory service requirements of Section 11(5) of the Act read with Rule 8 of the Rules were not complied with (no registered-post service; only affixture), the taking of possession by the State could not be treated as valid in law for the purposes of defeating the application of the Repealing Act; consequently the respondents are entitled to the benefit of the Repealing Act and the impugned order was upheld.

Direct Consequences:

  • The writ appeals filed by the State are dismissed.
  • The impugned High Court order allowing the writ petitions stands.
  • No costs were awarded. Connected miscellaneous petitions are also dismissed.

Broader Implications: The opinion does not undertake to lay down a new precedent beyond its application to the facts; the court expressly left open the question whether symbolic possession suffices, and did not decide that issue. No broader principle beyond the application of the statutory service requirement (Section 11(5) read with Rule 8) to the facts was promulgated in the opinion.

    The Government Of Tamil Nadu, Rep. By Its Secretary To Government, Revenue Department, Fort St. George Chennai-9. 2. The Special Commissioner And Commissioner (Land Reforms), Chepauk, Chennai-5. 3. The Assistant Commissioner, Urban Land Ceiling & Taxes, Chennai v. Nandagopal 2. Krishnappan 3. Nagammal 4. Govindu S

    Writ Appeal No.496 of 2010:-

    1. The Government of Tamil Nadu rep. by its Secretary to Government Revenue Department Fort St. George Chennai 600 009.

    2. The Special Commissioner and Commissioner (Land Reforms), Chepauk Chennai 600 005.

    2. The land comprised in Survey Nos.402/4B (300 sq.mts), 402/4H (750 sq.mts), and 402/4J (4200 sq.mts) stood registered in the name of one Thiru N.Nandagopal and the lands remained vacant. On the ground that holding of the land was more than the ceiling limit allowable to a family, action under the provisions of the Tamil Nadu Urban Land (Ceiling & Regulation) Act, 1978, (hereinafter referred to as the "Act") was initiated by issuance of notice under Section 7(2) of the Act. Objections were raised and ultimately the proceedings culminated into one of issuance of notice dated 27.4.1999 under Section 11(5) of the Act. With the grievance that on the date when the Act was repealed viz., 16.6.1999, the possession of the land in question was not taken in the manner known to law, the respondents approached this Court by contending that the proceedings initiated shall lapse after the Act had come into force and the writ petitions were allowed by following the judgment reported in 2002 (2) CTC 716 (Allind Metal Fabricators Pvt. Ltd., vs. The Secretary to Government, Revenue Department, Government of Tamil Nadu, Madras).

    3. As against the above common order dated 25.4.2005, the above appeals have been filed by the State. According to Mr.M.Dhandapani, learned Special Government Pleader, the symbolic possession of the land in question was taken on 15.6.1999, which was one day prior to the date of the Repealing Act, viz., on 16.6.1999. In the event possession is taken, the question of placing reliance on the Repealing Act does not arise and therefore, the learned Judge is not correct in placing reliance over a judgment, which related to a case, where possession was admittedly taken prior to the Repealing Act.

    4. On the other hand, Mr. AR.L.Sundaresan, learned Senior Counsel would submit that the respondents are entitled to the benefit of the Repealing Act on two grounds. Firstly, even in the counter affidavit filed by the State, it is contended that only a symbolic possession was taken and in the absence of physical possession taken by the authorities, the State cannot oppose the applicability of the Repealing Act. In support of the said contention, the learned Senior Counsel would rely upon the judgment of this Court reported in 2009 (6) MLJ 1102 (S. Nasira Anjum and Others vs. State of Tamil Nadu) and 2009 (8) MLJ 522 (Sree Jayalakshmi Brick Industries vs. Special Commissioner & Secretary to Government). Secondly, the learned Senior Counsel would submit that in any event, notice under Section 11(5) of the Act, which is a mandatory requirement before ever possession is taken has not been issued and served as per Rule 8 of the Tamil Nadu Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulation) Rules, 1978 (hereinafter referred to as the "Rules"). According to the learned Senior Counsel, except an affixture of the said notice made in the vacant site in question, the other requirements under sub-rules (1) and (2) of Rule 8 of the Rules were not followed.

    5. We have considered the submissions. We will first consider the second point relating to the service of notice. After the compliance of the provisions of Section 11(1) to (4), if the land is a vacant land, the competent authority may, by notice in writing, order any person who may be in possession of it to surrender or deliver possession thereof to the State Government or to any person duly authorised by the State Government in this behalf within thirty days of the service of the notice under section 11(5) of the Act. The manner in which such a notice should be served with the particulars is contemplated under Rule 8 of the Rules. The relevant Rule for the purpose of issuance and service of notice is sub-rule (2) of Rule 8, which reads as under:-

    " (2) (a) The draft statement together with the notice referred to in sub-section (4) of section 9 shall be served on-

    (i) the holder of the vacant lands, and

    (ii) all other persons, so far as may be known, who have, or are likely to have any claim to, or interest in, the ownership, or possession, or both, of the vacant lands, by sending the same by registered post addressed to the person concerned-

    (i) in the case of the holder of the vacant lands, to his address as given in the statement filed in pursuance to sub-section (1) of section 7, and

    (ii) in the case of other persons, at their last known addresses.

    (b) where the draft statement and the notice are returned as refused, by the addressee, the same shall be deemed to have been duly served on such person.

    ( c) Where the efforts to serve the draft statement and the notice, on the holder of the vacant lands or, as the case may be, on any other person referred to in clause (a), in the manner specified in the clause are not successful for reasons other than the reason referred to in clause (b), the draft statement and the notice shall be served by affixing copies of the same in a conspicuous place in the office of the competent authority and also upon some conspicuous part of the house (if any) in which the holder of the vacant lands or, as the case may be, the other person in known to have last resided or carried as business or personally worked for gain. "

    6. By that Rule, the draft statement together with the notice referred to in sub-section (4) of section 9 shall be served on the holder of the vacant lands, and all other persons, so far as may be known, who have, or are likely to have any claim to, or interest in, the ownership, or possession, or both, of the vacant lands by sending the same by registered post addressed to the person concerned. Only in the event the notice sent through registered post could not be served for any reason, the question of affixture would arise.

    7. In order to find out as to whether the notice as required under Section 11(5) of the Act read with Rule 8 of the Rules was served on the respondents or not, we called for the records and perused. Admittedly, there is no such notice sent through registered post, except the competent authority affixing the said notice on the vacant site, which should be only a last resort after making an attempt to send the notice by registered post and in spite of the same, they could not be served with the notice. In that view of the matter, even assuming that the possession is said to have been taken as contended by the learned Special Government Pleader, such taking over of possession cannot be considered to be valid in the eye of law so long as the provisions of Section 11(5) of the Act read with Rule 8 of the Rules was not complied with. On this ground alone, the contention of the respondents that in the event of physical possession not being taken in the prescribed manner, the provisions of the Repealing Act would come to the benefit of the respondents must be accepted.

    8. For the said reason, we are also of the considered view that the respondents are entitled to the benefit of the Repealing Act and accordingly, we find no reason to interfere with the impugned order. Accordingly, the writ appeals are dismissed. However, the issue as to whether the State could claim the taking over of symbolic possession and hence the question of physical possession is necessary or not is left open. No costs. Consequently, connected miscellaneous petitions are also dismissed.

    kb

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    The Government Of Ta... v. Nandagopal 2. Krishn...
    (Feb 22, 2011)