Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The assessee entered into a lease agreement dated September 6, 1985, for an immovable property at No. 123, Usman Road, Madras, involving payment of a Rs. 10 lakhs interest-free advance and rent payable over a 22-year period with a renewal clause. Subsequently, the assessee sub-leased the same property on September 10, 1985, to another company for 20 years, also receiving a Rs. 10 lakhs interest-free advance and rent payments. The issue arose whether the sub-leasing constituted a "transfer" under section 2(47) of the Income-tax Act, 1961, thereby triggering capital gains tax on the consideration received.

The Assessing Officer held that the transfer of leasehold rights amounted to transfer of a capital asset and assessed capital gains tax. The Commissioner of Income-tax and the Income-tax Appellate Tribunal, however, held that there was no transfer of a capital asset and deleted the addition of Rs. 8,26,876 as short-term capital gains. The Revenue appealed against this decision before the court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the transaction of lease and sub-lease in the present case constitutes a "transfer" within the meaning of section 2(47) of the Income-tax Act, 1961.
  2. Whether the consideration received by the assessee on sub-leasing the property amounts to short-term capital gains taxable under the Income-tax Act.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The leasehold interest held by the assessee qualifies as a "capital asset" under section 2(14) of the Income-tax Act.
  • Section 45 mandates that any profits arising from transfer of a capital asset are taxable as capital gains.
  • The term "transfer" under section 2(47) includes extinguishment of any rights therein, which occurs upon sub-leasing.
  • By sub-leasing, the assessee extinguished his leasehold rights and transferred a capital asset, thereby incurring capital gains tax liability.
  • Relied on several precedents to support that transfer of leasehold rights amounts to transfer of a capital asset.

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the respondent's legal arguments as the respondent neither appeared in person nor engaged counsel.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
R.K Palshikar (Huf) v. Commissioner Of Income Tax, M.P, Nagpur, [1988] 172 ITR 311 (SC) Transfer by way of lease amounts to transfer of a capital asset attracting capital gains tax. Affirmed that lease creates an interest in land and extinguishes the transferor's rights, constituting a transfer under the Act.
A.R Krishnamurthy v. CIT, [1989] 176 ITR 417 (SC) Confirmed that leasehold interests are capital assets and their transfer is taxable. Supported the principle that leasehold rights are capital assets and their transfer triggers capital gains.
A. Gasper v. Commissioner Of Income Tax, Calcutta, [1979] 117 ITR 581 (Cal) and [1991] 192 ITR 382 (SC) Extinguishment of tenant's rights under tenancy law constitutes transfer of a capital asset. Held that surrender of rights extinguishes capital asset rights attracting capital gains tax.
A.R Krishnamurthy and A.R Rajagopalan v. CIT, [1982] 133 ITR 922 (Mad) Leasehold rights held by an assessee constitute capital assets; transfer by lease amounts to transfer of capital asset. Held that rights created by lease are capital assets and their transfer is taxable.
Commissioner Of Income-Tax v. Pramia Engineering Pvt. Ltd., [1993] 202 ITR 298 (Cal) Transfer of leasehold rights is a transfer of capital asset attracting capital gains tax. Reinforced the principle that leasehold transfers are taxable transfers.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined the statutory definitions and relevant case law to determine whether sub-leasing amounted to a transfer of a capital asset. It noted that under section 2(14) of the Income-tax Act, "capital asset" includes any property held by an assessee, not limited to ownership. The leasehold interest, therefore, qualifies as a capital asset.

Section 2(47) defines "transfer" to include extinguishment of rights. The court reasoned that by sub-leasing, the assessee extinguished his leasehold rights in favour of a third party, effectively transferring his capital asset interest.

The court relied on precedents where the Supreme Court and High Courts had held that leasehold rights constitute capital assets and that their transfer by lease or sub-lease amounts to a transfer liable to capital gains tax. It distinguished the earlier findings of the Commissioner of Income-tax and the Income-tax Appellate Tribunal, concluding that their interpretation was incorrect.

Accordingly, the court restored the order of the Assessing Officer, affirming that the transaction was a transfer attracting capital gains tax.

Holding and Implications

The appeal by the Revenue is allowed. The court held that the transaction of lease and sub-lease constitutes a transfer of a capital asset under section 2(47) of the Income-tax Act, 1961, and the consideration received by the assessee is liable to be assessed as short-term capital gains.

The decision reverses the findings of the Commissioner of Income-tax and the Income-tax Appellate Tribunal, thereby restoring the Assessing Officer's addition. The ruling directly affects the parties by confirming tax liability on the sub-lease transaction. The opinion does not establish a new precedent but follows established principles from prior case law.

    Commissioner Of Income-Tax v. Sujatha Jewellers

    R. Balasubramanian, J.:— The Revenue is the appellant in this appeal, which stands admitted on the following question of law:

    “Whether, on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the Income-tax Appellate Tribunal is right in law in holding that the transaction of lease and sub-lease involved herein is not a transfer falling within the definition under section 2(47) of the Income-tax Act, 1961, and in deleting the addition of Rs. 8,26,876 assessed as short-term capital gains ?”

    2. The following facts are not in dispute:

    “The assessee has taken on lease an immovable property at No. 123, Usman Road, Madras, under a lease agreement dated September 6, 1985. Under that agreement, the assessee has to pay a sum of Rs. 10 lakhs to the lessor as interest-free advance; the lease is to be for a period of 22 years; rent for the first 15 years is fixed at Rs. 20,350 per month and for the remaining seven years, the monthly rent payable is Rs. 84,428; there is a renewal clause; the assessee has subleased the property by lease deed dated September 10, 1985 in favour of another company for a period of 20 years; under that sub-lease agreement, the sub-lessee has to pay a sum of Rs. 10 lakhs as interest-free advance to the assessee; the rent payable for the first 15 years is Rs. 77,500 per month and for the remaining period, the rent payable is Rs. 92,500 per month.”

    3. On the abovenoted admitted facts, the question that was raised before the Deputy Commissioner of Income-tax was, whether transfer of leasehold rights in the land by the assessee in favour of the sub-lessee would amount to transfer of a capital asset at the hands of the assessee and if so, the consideration paid by the sub-lessee to the assessee would partake of the character of capital gains and be assessable to tax as such. The Assessing Officer held that the transfer of lease by the assessee would amount to transfer of a capital asset; the consideration received by the assessee under that transaction would partake of the character of capital gains and therefore be liable to tax.

    4. The assessee went up in appeal before the Commissioner of Income-tax, who, by his order dated September 25, 1989, in I.T.A No. 43 of 1989-90, found that there was no transfer of capital asset by the assessee when he sub-leased the property in favour of a, third party and therefore no capital gain is involved at the hands of the assessee in respect of the transfer effected by him as indicated earlier. The Revenue went up in appeal before the Income-tax Appellate Tribunal in I.T.A No. 4462.MDS of 1989 and the Appellate Tribunal agreed with the findings of the Commissioner of Income-tax. The assessment year concerned in this case is 1986-87.

    5. Though the respondent has been served, they are neither appearing in person nor engaged any counsel. Heard the learned counsel appearing for the appellant. Learned counsel for the appellant, by taking us through the definition of “capital asset” in section 2(14) of the Income-tax Act, would contend that the property of any kind in the hands of the assessee, except those provided in that section itself, would be a “capital asset”. Therefore the leasehold interest of the assessee is a capital asset. Then she took us through section 45 of the Income-tax Act. A reading of that section shows that “any profits or gains arising from the transfer of a capital asset effected in the previous year shall,… be chargeable to income-tax under the head ‘Capital gains’, and shall be deemed to be the income of the previous year in which the transfer took place”. She also took us through section 2(47) of the Income-tax Act highlighting as to what “transfer” means. The expression “transfer” is defined in section 2(47) of the Income-tax Act, among other things, as hereunder:

    “the extinguishment of any rights therein (sub-clause (ii) of clause 47 of section 2).”

    6. Therefore, her submission is that, the assessee had acquired an interest in the land by having the lease in his favour; by sub-leasing the property, he had transferred the interest in the and in favour of a third party; by such sub-lease, the assessee's rights in the capital asset had been extinguished; there is an element of transfer of a capital asset in the hands of the assessee and therefore any gains or profits made out of such transfer has to be brought under the caption “Capital gains” and accordingly taxed. Learned counsel brought to our notice the following judgments to contend that the transfer of a lease would amount to transfer of a capital asset:

    (a) R.K Palshikar (Huf) v. Commissioner Of Income Tax, M.P, Nagpur, [1988] 172 ITR 311 (SC);

    (b) A.R Krishnamurthy v. CIT, [1989] 176 ITR 417 (SC);

    (c) A. Gasper v. Commissioner Of Income Tax, Calcutta, [1979] 117 ITR 581 (Cal);

    (d) A. Gasper v. Commissioner Of Income Tax, Calcutta, [1991] 192 ITR 382 (SC);

    (e) A.R Krishnamurthy and A.R Rajagopalan v. CIT, [1982] 133 ITR 922 (Mad); and

    (f) Commissioner Of Income-Tax v. Pramia Engineering Pvt. Ltd., [1993] 202 ITR 298 (Cal).

    7. Let us now examine the case on the merits. It is needless to state that transferring an immovable property by way of a lease creates an interest in the land. According to section 2(14) of the Income-tax Act, the words “capital asset” mean, “property of any kind held by an assessee”. Therefore it does not necessarily mean that the property, which the assessee holds, must be his own. As per the abovereferred definition, any kind of property held by an assessee would come within the definition of “capital asset”. It is not possible to read the definition of “capital asset” in a restrictive manner to mean that the property which the assessee owned by himself alone would come within the meaning of “capital asset”. In A.R Krishnamurthy and A.R Rajagopal v. CIT, [1982] 133 ITR 922 (Mad) referred to above, a point arose before this court at the instance of the assessee as to whether the transfer by way of a lease would amount to transfer of a “capital asset”. In that case, the assessee was a body of individuals, who had purchased various extents of properties in the year 1966 for a stated consideration. Thereafter, the assessee, by an instrument dated September 10, 1970, styled as lease-cum-licence, granted a mining lease in favour of a company. A question arose whether such a transaction would amount to transferring a capital asset thereby attracting capital gains. The point argued by the assessee before the court was that the transfer by way of lease must stand excluded from the transfer as defined under clause (47) of section 2 of the Income-tax Act. A Division Bench of this court negatived the point raised by the assessee. This court held that the right conferred on a lessee under a lease deed is a capital asset in the hands of the lessor. In A. Gasper v. Commissioner Of Income Tax, Calcutta, [1979] 117 ITR 581 (Cal) referred to above, the assessee was a tenant, whose rights were protected under the West Bengal Tenancy Act, 1956. However, due to a tripartite agreement entered into by him, the lessor and the proposed sub-lessee, he had extinguished his rights, as a result of which, the proposed party became the lessee of the property. The Calcutta High Court held that surrender of rights of the assessee referred to above would amount to extinguishment of his rights in the land/capital asset and therefore it attracts capital gains. This judgment was affirmed by the Supreme Court in A. Gasper v. Commissioner Of Income Tax, Calcutta, [1991] 192 ITR 382. In R.K Palshikar (Huf) v. Commissioner Of Income Tax, M.P, Nagpur, [1988] 172 ITR 311 (SC), a Hindu undivided family was the assessee; they had agricultural lands belonging to an ancestor; later on, the property was developed into a residential zone; various extents of properties were leased for a period of 99 years and the lease document provided for termination of lease on stated failures by the lessee. For the assessment years mentioned therein, a large sum of money was received as salami. A question arose as to whether the transaction effected by the assessee would amount to transferring a capital asset warranting capital gains tax. The Supreme Court held that the transfer by way of lease would amount to transfer of a capital asset and therefore tax is leviable as capital gains. From a reading of the abovereferred judgment, it is clear that the transfer by way of lease is treated as transfer of a capital asset on the principle that the lease creates an interest in the land and therefore to that extent, it extinguishes the right of the transferor. If the facts of the present case are analysed in the context of the law laid down by the Supreme Court and the various sections of the Income-tax Act, we have no difficulty at all in holding that when the assessee transfers his leasehold rights in the land in his occupation by way of a sub-lease to another person, it amounts to extinguishing his rights in the property and since his leasehold rights had created an interest in the land, i.e, enjoyment and possession and therefore it would definitely come within the definition of “capital asset” as defined under section 2(14) of the Income-tax Act. Whether the owner himself transfers by way of a lease or a lessee transfers by way of sub-lease, the principle remains the same, namely, in either action, there is extinguishment of rights.

    8. In the light of our discussion referred to above, we are not inclined to agree with the judgment of the Income-tax Appellate Tribunal as well as the Commissioner of Income-tax and accordingly restore the order of the Assessing Officer. The point of law raised by the Revenue in this appeal is answered in favour of the Revenue and against the assessee.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Commissioner Of Income-Tax v. Sujatha Jewellers
    (Mar 6, 2006)