Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • S. 23 of the Indian Trusts Act and sub-sec. 4 of S. 40 of the Employees State Insurance Act. Sec. 23 clause (d) of the Trusts Act
  • clause 4 of Sec. 40 of the Employees State Insurance Act
  • EMPLOYEES STATE INSURANCE ACT
  • S. 75 of the Employees State Insurance Act.
  • S. 23 of the Indian Trusts Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • S. 23 of the Indian Trusts Act and sub-sec. 4 of S. 40 of the Employees State Insurance Act. Sec. 23 clause (d) of the Trusts Act
  • clause 4 of Sec. 40 of the Employees State Insurance Act
  • EMPLOYEES STATE INSURANCE ACT
  • S. 75 of the Employees State Insurance Act.
  • S. 23 of the Indian Trusts Act
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This appeal arises from an order of the Employees Insurance Court, Madras, which decreed in favour of the Employees State Insurance Corporation a sum of Rs. 559.62 as interest at 6 percent per annum on arrears of employees' contributions amounting to Rs. 4,277.80 due from Messrs. Reid Co-operative Timber Works Ltd. for the period from 1st July 1959 to 30th April 1963. The factory (appellant) has challenged this order.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether interest is payable on arrears of employees' contributions under the Employees State Insurance Act or the Regulations framed thereunder.
  2. Whether the Employees Insurance Court has jurisdiction and power to award interest under the Interest Act, 1839.
  3. Whether interest should be calculated from the date of demand or from the dates on which the employees' contributions fell due.
  4. Whether the appellant can be deemed a trustee liable for interest under Section 23 of the Indian Trusts Act and Section 40(4) of the Employees State Insurance Act.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • No interest is payable on arrears of employees' contributions under the Employees State Insurance Act or the Regulations.
  • The first clause of Section 1 of the Interest Act applies only if the sum is payable by virtue of a written instrument, which is absent in this case.
  • The Employees Insurance Court lacks jurisdiction to award interest under the Interest Act as it is not a civil court and its jurisdiction is limited to disputes under Section 75 of the Employees State Insurance Act.

Respondent's Arguments

  • Under Section 1 of the Interest Act, the court has power to award interest from the date of written demand, which was made on 10th February 1965 with notice of interest at six percent per annum.
  • The Employees Insurance Court has jurisdiction to award interest as it is deemed a civil court under Section 78 of the Employees State Insurance Act and has powers under Section 75.
  • The Corporation is entitled to interest from the dates on which the employees' contributions fell due, relying on Section 23 of the Indian Trusts Act and Section 40(4) of the Employees State Insurance Act.
  • The appellant is presumed to be a trustee who received employees' contributions deducted from wages and is liable for interest due to breach of trust.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Interest Act, 1839, Section 1 Empowers courts to award interest on debts or sums certain payable at a certain time or otherwise from the time of written demand. The court applied the second part of Section 1 to hold appellant liable to pay interest from 10th February 1965, the date of written demand with notice.
Employees State Insurance Act, Section 75(1)(e) Confers jurisdiction on Employees Insurance Court to decide disputes relating to rights to benefits and their amount and duration. The court held that the right to interest is a question within the jurisdiction of the Employees Insurance Court.
Employees State Insurance Act, Section 78 Employees Insurance Court has all powers of a civil court for specified purposes and is deemed a civil court under certain provisions of the Criminal Procedure Code. Supported the court's jurisdiction to award interest under the Interest Act.
Indian Trusts Act, Section 23(d) Liability of trustees to pay interest in cases of breach of trust, including unreasonable delay in paying trust money. The court examined whether the appellant was liable as a trustee for interest but found no evidence of deduction of employees' contributions from wages.
Employees State Insurance Act, Section 40(4) Presumption that sums deducted by principal employer from wages are entrusted to him for payment of contributions. The court held that the presumption applies only if there is evidence of deduction, which was absent here, negating breach of trust liability for interest before demand.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court analyzed the applicability of the Interest Act, 1839, particularly Section 1, which allows courts to award interest either where sums are payable under a written instrument or from the date of written demand when no such instrument exists. The appellant did not dispute the absence of a written instrument but contested the applicability of the second clause. The court found that the Employees State Insurance Corporation issued a written demand on 10th February 1965 explicitly stating interest would be charged, thereby triggering liability for interest from that date.

The court rejected the appellant’s contention that the Employees Insurance Court lacked jurisdiction to award interest, interpreting Section 75(1)(e) and Section 78 of the Employees State Insurance Act as affirming the court’s civil court powers and jurisdiction over such disputes.

Regarding the respondent’s argument that interest should run from the dates contributions fell due based on trustee liability under the Indian Trusts Act and the Employees State Insurance Act, the court found no evidence that the appellant had deducted contributions from employees’ wages. Without such deduction, the statutory presumption of trust did not arise, and no breach of trust or liability for interest prior to the demand date could be established.

Consequently, the court concluded that interest was payable only from the date of the written demand and not earlier, and that the amount of interest should be adjusted accordingly.

Holding and Implications

The court modified the decree of the Employees Insurance Court by reducing the interest amount from Rs. 559.62 to Rs. 89.08, representing interest at 6% per annum on Rs. 4,277.80 from 10th February 1965 to 15th June 1965.

The decision clarifies that interest on arrears of employees' contributions under the Employees State Insurance Act is payable only from the date of a written demand specifying interest, and not from the dates contributions fell due, unless there is evidence that the employer deducted contributions from wages, triggering trustee liability. The ruling confirms the jurisdiction of the Employees Insurance Court to award interest under the Interest Act and limits the scope of interest liability to circumstances supported by evidentiary facts. No broader precedent beyond the parties is established. Both parties bear their own costs in this court and the lower court.

    The Reid Co-Operative Timber Works Ltd. Madras v. Employees State Insurance Corporation Through The Insurance Inspector.

    This is an appeal against the order of the Employees Insurance Court, Madras decreeing in favour of the Employees State Insurance Corporation a sum of Rs. 559.62, representing interest at 6 percent per annum upon the arrears of the employees' contribution (Rs. 4277.80) due by Messrs. Reid Co-operative Timber works Ltd. Madras for the period from 1st July 1959 to 30th April 1963. The factory has preferred this appeal.

    The contention of the appellant is that no interest is payable on arrears of employees' contribution, either under the provisions of the Employees State Insurance Act or under the Regulations framed by the Government in exercise of the powers conferred by S. 97 of the Act. Learned counsel for the Employees State Insurance Corporation would, however point out that under the Interest Act, 1839, the court is empowered to award interest. S. 1 of the Interest Act prescribes that upon all debts or sums certain payable at a certain time or otherwise, the court before which such debts or sums may be recovered may, if it shall think fit, allow interest to the creditor at a rate not exceeding the current rate of interest from the time when such debts or sums certain were payable, if such debts or sums be payable by virtue of some written instrument at a certain time or if payable otherwise, then from the time when demand of payment shall have been made in writing, so as such demand shall give notice to the debtor that interest will be claimed from the date of such demand until the term of payment. The contention of the appellant is that the first clause of this section would be applicable only if the sum is payable by virtue of some written instrument and in as much as there is no written instrument which obliges the appellant to pay the arrears of employees contribution, the first part of S. 1 can have no application. I accept this contention. But it is clear that under the second part of S. 1, the appellant would be liable to pay interest from the time when demand for payment was made in writing, giving notice to the debtor that interest would be claimed from the date of such demand. Ex. A.5 is a demand made by the Employees State Insurance Corporation on 10th February 1965. Be it noted that in this demand, the Corporation has expressly stated that interest at six percent per annum will be charged on the arrears of contributes. As all the ingredients necessary for the application of the second part of S. 1 of the Interest Act are present, I have little doubt that the appellant will be liable to pay interest upon the sum of Rs. 4277-80 from 10th February 1965, the date of demand.

    Learned counsel for the appellant would however contend that the Employees Insurance court has no power to allow interest under the Interest Act, because, according to her, it is not a civil court and its jurisdiction under the Act is confined to adjudication upon the questions and disputes which are catalogued in S. 75 of the Employees State Insurance Act. I find it difficult to accept this contention. In the first place, the Interest Act itself makes no distinction between different categories of courts in relation to their power to allow interest. All that it says is that the court before which such debts or sums may be recovered may allow interest to the creditor at the prescribed rate. The Employees State Insurance Court is undeniably such a court. In the second place, S. 75, which delimits the jurisdiction of the Employees Insurance Court, says in clause (1) sub-clause (e) that if any question or dispute arises as to the right of any person to any benefit and as to the amount and duration thereof, such question of dispute shall be decided by the Employees Insurance Court in accordance with the provisions of that Act. The right of the Corporation to the benefit of interest under the Interest Act is a matter which the court below is entitled to decide. Further, Sec. 78 of the Act says that the Employees Insurance Court shall have all the powers of the civil court for the purposes mentioned there, and such court shall be deemed to be a civil court within the meaning of Sec. 195 and Co. 35 Crl. P. Code. I would therefore repel the contention that the Employees Insurance Court has no jurisdiction to adjudicate upon the liability of the appellant to pay interest to the respondent, or that it is not a court which is empowered to allow interest under the Interest Act, 1859.

    Learned counsel for the respondent next contends that the Corporation would he entitled to interest not from the date of the demand but from the different dates on which the employees' contributions fell due. In support of this contention, he presses into service the cumulative effect of S. 23 of the Indian Trusts Act and sub-sec. 4 of S. 40 of the Employees State Insurance Act. Sec. 23 clause (d) of the Trusts Act is to the effect that where the trustee commits breach of trust, he it liable to make good the loss which the trust property or the beneficiary has thereby sustained, and that a trustee committing breach of trust is liable to pay interest in the following cases: (a) where he has actually received interest (b) where the breach consists in unreasonable delay in paying the trust money to the beneficiary; (c) where the trustee ought to have received interest but has not done so (d) where he may be fairly presumed to have received interest he is liable, in case (a) to account for the interest actually received, and in cases (b) (c) and (d), to account for simple interest at the rate of 6 per cent per annum, unless the court otherwise directs. I am asked to presume that the appellant factory has actually collected the employees' contribution by deducting the same from out of their wages and on this presumption I am asked to act upon clause 4 of S. 40 of the Act, which says that any sum deducted by the Principal employer from the wages under that Act shall be deemed to have been entrusted to him by the employee for the purpose of paying the contribution in respect of which it was deducted. There is nothing in the evidence on record to show that the appellant has deducted from the employees' wages the employees' contribution. On the other hand, the correspondence indicates that most of the employees had left the employ of the appellant when the appellant was called upon to pay the employees' contribution. The statutory presumption incorporated in clause 4 of Sec. 40 of the Employees State Insurance Act can be drawn only if there is evidence to show that the appellant had deducted from the wages of the employees the employees' contribution. If no such deduction has been made, the appellant cannot be deemed to have been entrusted with the employees, contribution. If the appellant cannot be deemed to have been so entrusted, no breach of trust can arise within the meaning of S. 23 of the Indian Trusts Act and no liability to pay interest for the period anterior to the date of demand can arise.

    I therefore hold that the proper decree to pass is one directing the appellant to pay interest at 6 per cent per annum upon the sum of Rs. 4277-80 from 10th February 1965 upto 15th June 1965 the date of deposit of the entire arrears. Both the learned advocates agree that this amount comes to Rs. 89-08. The Employees, Insurance Court has, on a wrong interpretation of the legal position, fixed this amount at Rs. 559-62. I direct that the decree of the lower court be modified and the sum of Rs. 89-08 be substituted in that decree for Rs. 559-62. In the circumstances of this case, the parties will bear their own costs in this court and the lower court.

    V.C.S/K.J

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    The Reid Co-Operativ... v. Employees State Insu...
    (Nov 3, 1969)