Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of the Madras Sales Tax Act,
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of the Madras Sales Tax Act,
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitions (by different assessees) were heard together as they raised a common point. In the lead petition Asea Electric (India) Private Limited paid Rs. 42,915-58 as tax at 6% on turnover Rs. 6,60,239-66 for machinery imported from Sweden and sold to Bharat Heavy Electricals Limited under an import permit dated 12 November 1964. Invoices were presented on 4 February 1966 and 24 March 1966; assessment combined values under both invoices. The seller returned the turnover as chargeable and did not claim exemption. On 18 January 1966 the Supreme Court decided Khosla & Co. (P.) Ltd. v. Deputy Commissioner of Commercial Taxes. If petitioners' facts are correct, those decisions would mean the sales should be exempt from tax. The purchaser (a wholly Government-owned company) instructed its units to seek refunds from sellers, correspondence with the Department failed, and the sellers and purchaser joined in filing petitions to quash that part of the sellers' assessments relating to these transactions. The other petitions involve similar facts with different figures.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the transactions in question are import sales covered by Khosla & Co. (P.) Ltd. v. Deputy Commissioner of Commercial Taxes and therefore exempt from sales tax.
  2. Whether a person who paid tax to an assessee (the purchaser) can maintain a petition for certiorari to challenge the assessment of the assessee (locus to sue / whether a non-party can be "aggrieved").
  3. Whether a party that has paid tax under a mistake of law is entitled to refund by means of a petition under Article 226, and the applicable limitation period for such refund claims.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The transactions were import sales; in view of Khosla & Co. (P.) Ltd. v. Deputy Commissioner of Commercial Taxes the sales do not attract tax.
  • The purchaser (having paid tax to the sellers under contract terms) sought refunds and, joined with sellers, challenged the assessments as charging tax on transactions that should be exempt.

Revenue's Objection

  • The Revenue objected that the purchaser cannot maintain the petition for certiorari because the purchaser was not a party to the assessment proceedings (questioning the purchaser's locus to sue).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Khosla & Co. (P.) Ltd. v. Deputy Commissioner of Commercial Taxes (1966) 2 M.L.J. (S.C.) 81 : 1966) 2 An. W.R. (S.C.) 81 : 1966) 2 S.C.J. .703 : 19661 17 S.T.C. 473 Establishes that import sales of goods are exempt from sales tax under the circumstances considered in that decision. The court applied Khosla to hold that, if the transactions bore the character claimed by petitioners, those import sales would be exempt and the relevant part of assessments should be quashed or reconsidered in light of Khosla.
Sales Tax Officer v. Kanhaiya Lal Makund Lal Saraf 1959) S.C.J. 53 (1959) S.C.R. 1350 : (1959) 1 M.L.J. (S.C.) 35 : (1959) 1 An. W.R. (S.C.) 35 : (1958) 9 S.T.C. 747 Establishes that where a tax is levied by mistake of law the State ordinarily must refund it; if refund is not made, remedy through Court is open, subject to restrictions and a three-year limitation from when the mistake became known. The court relied on this authority to hold that an assessee who paid tax by mistake of law may seek refund by petition under Article 226 and that the right to apply for refund arose on 18 January 1966 (date of Khosla), with petitions filed within three years.
State Of Kerala v. Aluminium Industries Ltd., Kundara, Quilon (1965) 16 S.T.C. 689 Supports the proposition concerning refund for mistake of law and exemplifies calling for a report from the authority concerned or remitting the question for investigation. The court noted this case as precedent for calling for a report or remitting the question to the assessing authority to investigate and decide the character of the transactions.
11 Halsbury (Supplement), Paragraph 265 Authority cited for the proposition that a party aggrieved need not necessarily have been a party to the original proceedings; certiorari is discretionary and may extend to any person aggrieved. The court referenced Halsbury in discussing whether a purchaser (not a party to assessment proceedings) could be regarded as an aggrieved person entitled to maintain certiorari; applied the principle cautiously, noting dependence on facts.
Thames Magistrates' Court, ex parte Greenbaum (1957) 107 L.J. 184 (C.A.) An example where certiorari was permitted to a person aggrieved though a stranger to the original proceedings (street-trader licence dispute). The court used this case to illustrate that certiorari is not confined to parties to the lower proceedings and to show factual dependency in deciding who is "aggrieved".

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded as follows:

  1. It examined the factual matrix of the lead petition (Asea Electric) and noted the timing of invoices, payment of sales-tax and the import permit, and that the seller had filed returns treating turnover as chargeable.
  2. It observed that the Supreme Court decision in Khosla & Co. (P.) Ltd. (18 January 1966) would, if petitioners' facts are correct, render the import sales exempt from tax.
  3. Relying on Sales Tax Officer v. Kanhaiya Lal Makund Lal Saraf and State of Kerala v. Aluminium Industries Ltd., the court held that where tax is levied by mistake of law the State is ordinarily obliged to refund and that a remedy under Article 226 is available, subject to limitation (three years from knowledge of the mistake). The right to apply for refund arose on 18 January 1966 and the petitions were within time.
  4. On the purchaser's locus to sue, the court acknowledged authorities (Halsbury; ex parte Greenbaum) that certiorari is not confined to original parties but emphasized that whether a person is "aggrieved" depends on the facts. The court expressed doubt whether the purchaser alone could be regarded as an aggrieved person able to maintain certiorari but observed that the assessee (seller) was itself a petitioner, making a final determination on that locus issue unnecessary for present disposal.
  5. Accordingly, the court allowed the petitions in part: it quashed that portion of each assessment charging tax on import sales covered by Khosla, and directed the assessing authority to investigate the character of the transactions (using original or certified records filed by assessees) and to finally determine tax liability/exemption in light of Khosla. If the authority finds the transactions covered by Khosla it must refund the relative tax. The court declined to award costs.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The petitions are allowed; the court quashed that part of the assessments which charged tax on import sales covered by Khosla & Co. (P.) Ltd. v. Deputy Commissioner of Commercial Taxes and directed re-investigation and determination by the assessing authority in the light of that decision.

Implications: The direct effect is that the assessing authority must investigate the transactions claimed to be import sales, determine exemption or liability applying Khosla, and refund any tax found to have been wrongly charged. The court did not state any broader new precedent; it applied existing authorities and made no costs order.

    Asea Electric (India) Pte., Ltd., And Another v. The Joint Commercial Tax Officer, Madras 1 And Others.

    1. These petitions for certiorari by different assessees raise a common point and have, hence, been heard together. It will suffice to notice the facts in the first of these petitions, to determine the main questions. The Asea Electric (India) Private Limited, paid a sum of Rs. 42,915-58 as tax at six per cent on the turnover of Rs. 6,60,239-66, being the value of machinery imported from Sweden and sold to Bharat Heavy Electricals Limited, under a permit therefor issued to the latter by the Assistant Controller of Imports, under the Import Trade Control Regulations. The permit was dated 12th November, 1964. According to the terms of the contract between the parties, the seller was paid 90 per cent of the invoice value and the sales-tax in full when presenting the invoices to the purchaser. That was on 4th February, 1966. A* second invoice also was presented on 24th March, 1966. The assessment was on the combined values under both the invoices. The seller, in its return for the year 1965-66, showed the turnover as chargeable to tax and did not claim any exemption, on the ground that it related to import sales of the goods. On 18th January, 1966 the Supreme Court decided Khosla & Co. (P.) Ltd. v. Deputy Commissioner of Commercial Taxes (1966) 2 M.L.J. (S.C.) 81 : (1966) 2 An. W.R. (S.C.) 81 : (1966) 2 S.C.J. .703 : (19661 17 S.T.C. 473. If the facts, as stated in the affidavit in support of the writ petitions, are correct, there can be no doubt that, in view of this decision, the sales would not attract tax.

    2. The purchaser is a wholly Government-owned company, with its registered office at Delhi, and having some of its units in the State of Madras. After Khosla 3? Co. (P.) Ltd. v. Deputy Commissioner of Commercial Taxes (1966) 2 M.L.J. (S.C.) 81 : (1966) 2 An. W.R. (S.C.) 81 : (1966) 2 S.C.J. .703 : (19661 17 S.T.C. 473, came to its notice, it instructed its units to claim refund of the relative taxes, not exigible under the law, from the respective sellers. The sellers corresponded with the Department at different stages, but in vain. Eventually, the sellers and the purchaser have joined in filing the petition for quashing that part of the assessment of the sellers, which related to the said transactions. The facts in the other petitions are similar, except for the fact that they are by different assessees and the figures of the turnover and actual tax levied, are also different.

    3. As we said, if the transactions bear the character which the petitioners claim they did, Khosla & Co. (P.)Ltd. v. Deputy Commissioner of Commercial Taxes (1966) 2 M.L.J. (S.C.) 81 : (1966) 2 An. W.R. (S.C.) 81 : (1966) 2 S.C.J. .703 : (19661 17 S.T.C. 473, would clearly apply to them, with the result the import sales will be exempt from tax. It is well-established that if an assessee has paid tax, though voluntarily, but by mistake of law, he is entitled to ask for refund of such tax means of a petition under Article 226 of the Constitution. The leading authority, followed subsequently in several cases, is Sales Tax Officer v. Kanhaiya Lal Makund Lal Saraf 1959) S.C.J. 53 (1959) S.C.R. 1350 : (1959) 1 M.L.J. (S.C.) 35: (1959) 1 An. W.R. (S.C.) 35 : (1958) 9 S.T.C. 747, State Of Kerala v. Aluminium Industries Ltd., Kundara, Quilon. (1965) 16 S.T.C. 689, establishes two propositions: (1) where a tax is levied by mistake of law, it is ordinarily the duty of the State, subject to any provision in the law relating to sales tax, to refund the tax: no question of estoppel will arise when the mistake of law is common to both the parties; and (2) if refund is not made, remedy through Court is open subject to the same restrictions and also to. the period of limitation, namely, three years from the date when the mistake becomes known to the person who has made the payment by mistake. The right to apply for refund in the instant cases arose on 18th January, 1966, when the Supreme Court decided Khosla &Co. (P.) Ltd. v. Deputy Commissioner of Commercial Taxes (1966) 2 M.L.J. (S.C.) 81 : (1966) 2 An.W.R. (S.C.) 81 : (1966) 2 S.C.J. 703 : (1966) 17 S.T.C. 473, and the writ petitions have been filed well within the period of three years. A prayer for refund con-not be refused by Courts merely on the ground that although the character of the transactions prima facie appears, it had not been fully investigated. In such a case, either a report will have to be called for from the authority concerned, containing its finding on the question, as was done in State of Kerala v. Aluminium Industries Ltd (1965) 16 S.T.C. 689. or the question remitted to such authority with a direction to investigate and decide it, in the light of the authority.

    4. The second petitioner being but a purchaser, who paid the tax not to the State but to the assessee, under the terms of the contract between them, the Revenue has taken the objection that the purchaser cannot maintain the petition for certiorari. That raises the larger question as to whether a person who has not been a party to* particular proceedings, can claim to be aggrieved by the orders therein and maintain a petition to quash the same. As a general proposition, it may be recognised that a party aggrieved need not necessarily have been a party to the original proceedings: 11 Halsbury (Supplement), Paragraph 265:2?. v. Thames Magistrates' Court, ex parte Greenbaum (1957) 107 L.J. 184 (C.A.). That case has been digested in 26 English and Empire Digest 482 (1692). That covers a case of a person aggrieved by the refusal of borough council to register him as a registered street trader or to grant or renew an annual licence or by the cancellation by a borough council of his registration as a registered street trader or by the revocation or variation by a borough council of an annual licence. Two street traders, both wishing to occupy a certain pitch in a street, applied to the borough council for a licence for it. The council decided in favour of one of them and the other appealed to the Metropolitan Magistrate against the refusal of the licence to him. The person in whose favour the decision had been given was not a party to the appeal. The Magistrate reversed the order and then the other applied for an order of certiorari to quash the Magistrate's decision. It was held that the petition lay, and this was on the view that certiorari was a discretionary remedy and was not confined to the parties before the lower Court, but extended to any person aggrieved, including a stranger. But the question whether a person is aggrieved is closely bound up with the particular facts, and naturally, therefore, no general proposition can be laid down as a touchstone. Under the provisions of the Madras Sales Tax Act, the seller is no doubt enabled to pass on the tax liability on him to the purchaser. But it should be remembered that it is by way of reimbursing himself and there is, on that account, no liability whatever to tax on the part of the purchaser. If the purchaser paid in such circumstances, it is as part of the contract between himself and the seller, in relation to the sale of goods. Whether, in such a context, the purchaser can be regarded as an aggrieved person, in our opinion, cannot merely rest on the fact that he is in a sense indirectly affected by the assessment of the seller to tax. This is not a case of a dependent order, in the sense the grant to one necessarily involves denial to the other. To such a case, as we are inclined to think, the principle of the citation from Halsbury and! the English and Empire Digest, will have application. We doubt, however, whether the purchase can be regarded for the present purpose, an aggrieved person who by himself can maintain the petition for certiorari. Fortunately, however, the assessee itself figures as a petitioner here and it, therefore, dispenses with the necessity of ourselves deciding the question finally.

    5. In the result, we allow the petitions, quash that part of the order of assessment in each of these cases, which charges to tax the import sales, such as are covered by Khosla &Co. (P.) Ltd. v. Deputy Commissioner of Commercial Taxes (1966) 2 M.L.J. (S.C.) 81: (1966) 2 An.W.R .(S.C.)81:(1966)2 S.C.J. 703: (1966) 17 S.T.C. 473, and direct the assessing authority to investigate the character of the transactions claimed to be import sales, in the light of the original or certified copies of the record relevant to this question, to be filed by the relative assessees, and finally determine the tax liability for exemption of the transactions, in the light of Khosla & Co. (P.) Ltd., v. Deputy Commissioner of Commercial Taxes (1966) 2 M.L.J. (S.C.) 81: (1966) 2 An.W.R.(S.C.)81:(1966)2 S.C.J. 703 : (1966) 17 S.T.C. 473. In the event of the abusing authority coming to the conclusion that the transactions are covered by Khosla & Co. (P.) Ltd. v. Deputy Commissioner of Commercial Taxesm (1966) 2 M.L.J. (S.C.) 81: (1966) 2 An.W.R.(S.C.)81:(1966)2 S.C.J. 703 : (1966) 17 S.T.C. 473, that authority will, of course, have to refund the relative tax to the assessee Concerned. No costs in any of these petitions.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Asea Electric (India... v. The Joint Commercial...
    (Oct 14, 1968)