Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Art. 182 of the Limitation Act.
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Art. 182 of the Limitation Act.

    Veda Goundar And Others v. Arunachalam Chettiar.

    This application under S. 115, C.P.C to revise the judgment of the learned Subordinate Judge of Cuddalore in A.S No. 208 of 1954 on his file, arises oat of proceedings in execution of the decree in S.C No. 844 of 1933 taken subsequent to the disposal of S.A No. 1432 of 1948 on 10th December 1951. The respondent before me, Arunachala Chettiar, was the plaintiff in S.C No. 844 of 1933, and he obtained a decree against Katayya Goundan. The petitioners in these proceedings are the legal representatives of Katayya. In execution of the decree in S.C No. 844 of 1933, the decree-holder Arunachala brought to sale the properties of the judgment-debtor Katayya and purchased them himself at the sale held on 9th November 1942. Katayya died on 14th November 1942, before the sale could be confirmed under O. 21, R. 92 C.P.C The sale was confirmed on 12th December 1942, but without notice to the legal representatives of Katayya. In S.A No. 1432 of 1948, to which the petitioners and the respondent were parties, this Court set aside the confirmation of sale. The judgment has been reported in Arunachala Chettiar v. Vadla Koundan (1). The respondent as the decree-holder-purchaser followed up the litigation that ended with S.A No. 1432 of 1948 by an application to the executing Court. In effect what he wanted in that application was (1) to bring on record the legal representatives of the judgment-debtor Katayya and (2) to confirm, the sale which had been held on 9th November 1942. The petitioners pleaded that the claim of the decree-holder auction purchaser was barred by limitation. The learned District Munsif allowed the claim ex parte the petitioners, who were the legal representatives of the judgment-debtor, without however specifically deciding the question of limitation. On appeal, the learned Subordirate Judge negatived the plea of limitation. That was the only issue pressed in the arguments before me in this application to revise the order of the learned Subordinate Judge.

    The decree-holder's application was no doubt registered as E.P No. 638 of 1952, The learned Counsel however did not contest the position, that it was not an “application for execution” within the meaning of Art. 182 of the Limitation Act. His contention was that Art. 181 applied, and that the three year period had to be computed from 14th November 1942, the date on which Katayya died, which death gave the decree-holder a right to bring on record the legal representatives of the deceased judgment debtor, Katayya.

    Confirmation of sale under O. 21, R. 92, C.P.C does not require an application by the auction purchaser. Confirmation is a statutory obligation imposed on the Court, if the requirements of O. 21, R. 92, C.P.C, are satisfied. Even if the decree-holder as auction purchaser formally applies for confirmation of the sale, it would not be an application to which Art. 181 would apply, and no question of limitation could arise. I did not understand the learned Counsel for the petitioners to challenge this position. What the learned Counsel for the petitioners urged was that the other relief the respondent (decree-holder-auction purchaser) asked for, to bring on record the legal representatives of the judgment-debtor, Katayya, made it an application to which Art. 181 would apply When the confirmation of sale originally ordered by Court was set aside in S.A No. 1432 of 1948, the proceedings in E.P No. 583 of 1942, which was the application for execution of the decree in S.C.S No. 844 of 1933, must be regarded as still pending. Confirmation of the sale held on 9th November 1942 had yet to be ordered under O. 21, R. 92. As I said no question of limitation could arise to decide the question, whether the sale had to be confirmed. In this case the sale could be confirmed only after notice to the legal representatives of the deceased judgment-debtor. The names of the legal representatives had to be substituted for that of the judgment-debtor. An application by the decree-holder or auction purchaser to bring on record the legal representatives of a deceased judgment debtor, in the course of proceedings in an application for execution validly made, is not itself an application for execution within the scope of Art. 182—See Upadrasta Venkatalakshmamma v. Garikipati Seshagiri Rao . It is not an application either within the scope of Art. 181. Even if it could be viewed as an application which the decree-holder or auction purchaser was under a legal obligation to present and Art. 181 is attracted to such an application, the position would be that pointed out in Chalvadi Kotayya v. Poloori Alimelamma (2). The learned Judges observed:

    “Possibly we are on safer ground if we hold with Wilson J. in Kedarnath Dutt v. Harra Chand Dutt (3), that so long as proceedings initiated by the decree-holder are pending, his right to apply for their continuance accrues from day to day, i.e, on every day on which the Court does not suo motu continue them. The right to apply will then not be barred till three years have elapsed after the proceedings have ceased to be pending.”

    The conclusion of the learned Sub-ordinate Judge was therefore right. This petition fails and is dismissed with costs.

    V.C.S

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Veda Goundar And Others v. Arunachalam Chettiar.
    (Jul 10, 1957)