Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of section 127 of the Maharashtra Regional and Town Planning Act, 1966 (for short, referred to as MRTP Act).
  • provisions of section 49(7) of the MRTP Act
  • section 49(7) of the MRTP Act,
  • LAND ACQUISITION ACT 1894
  • LAND ACQUISITION ACT
  • 6.2. Rule. Rule
  • plan.17. Rule
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of section 127 of the Maharashtra Regional and Town Planning Act, 1966 (for short, referred to as MRTP Act).
  • provisions of section 49(7) of the MRTP Act
  • section 49(7) of the MRTP Act,
  • LAND ACQUISITION ACT 1894
  • LAND ACQUISITION ACT
  • 6.2. Rule. Rule
  • plan.17. Rule
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion — R.M. Borde, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner is the owner of land S. No. 253 situate at Kinwat. A final development plan (sanctioned in 1976) had earmarked portions of that land for various public purposes (water supply scheme, cultural centre and library, vegetable market and shopping complex). An area of 85 ares was taken into possession by the Municipal Council on 12-6-1998 without Land Acquisition Act proceedings. The petitioner served a notice under section 127 of the Maharashtra Regional and Town Planning Act, 1966 (MRTP Act) on 24-3-1999 claiming that reservation/allotment/designation had lapsed because acquisition was not initiated within the statutory period. The planning authority forwarded a land acquisition proposal (submission to the Collector is recorded as 2-3-2000), but that proposal was transmitted after the six-month period stipulated by section 127 following the petitioner's notice.

The petitioner also served notices under section 49(7) of the MRTP Act (on 30-7-2002 and again on 21-3-2005), and the State Government confirmed the section 49(7) notice on 22-1-2003. The Land Acquisition Officer later fixed a tentative valuation and asked the planning authority (Municipal Council) on 28-9-2004 to deposit two-thirds of the compensation (Rs. 1,45,00,000/-, tentative). The Municipal Council said it was unable to deposit the amount due to financial constraints and requested assistance from the State Government, which did not materialize. The petitioner approached the Court seeking a declaration that the reservation/allotment/designation of the land (Reservation Sites Nos. 36, 38, 39 and 40) had lapsed and that the land should be released for development by the owner.

Procedural note: Rule was made returnable forthwith and heard finally by consent of the parties. The petition succeeds and the rule is made absolute; no costs were awarded.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the reservation, allotment or designation of the petitioner's land under the relevant development plan is deemed to have lapsed under section 127 of the MRTP Act because acquisition proceedings were not initiated within the statutory period after service of notice?
  2. Whether a subsequent revision of the development plan (final revision sanctioned on 27-5-2002 and coming into force on 28-7-2002) revives any reservation that had already lapsed under section 127?
  3. What is the legal significance of the proceedings and communications under section 49(7) of the MRTP Act (purchase notice) and the subsequent action by the Land Acquisition Officer and the planning authority's inability to deposit the tentative valuation?

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The petitioner is the owner of S. No. 253 and reserve/designation in respect of parts of that land have not been acted upon for many years despite the development plan being sanctioned in 1976.
  • Notice under section 127 was served on 24-3-1999; acquisition proceedings were not initiated within six months thereafter; hence the reservation/allotment/designation is deemed to have lapsed under section 127 and the land is available for development like adjacent land.
  • Although notices under section 49(7) were also issued (30-7-2002 and 21-3-2005), and one was confirmed, no award or completion of acquisition occurred and the reservation should be treated as lapsed.

State Government / Planning Authority (Municipal Council) Arguments

  • The development plan underwent revision and the revised plan was sanctioned on 27-5-2002 and came into force on 28-7-2002; therefore, the earlier notice under section 127 (1999) is of no consequence because the revised plan operates.
  • After confirmation of the section 49 purchase notice, a proposal for acquisition was forwarded within the one-year period, so there is no question of lapsing of reservation in respect of that process.
  • The Municipal Council stated it could not deposit the tentative two-thirds amount (Rs. 1,45,00,000/-) determined by the Land Acquisition Officer due to financial inability and had requested the State Government for financial help; thus acquisition could not be completed because of lack of funds.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Kishor Gopalrao Bapat v. State of Maharashtra, 2005 (4) Mh. L.J 466 Holds that rights accrued to an owner under section 127 (lapsing of reservation) are not taken away by revision of the development plan under section 38; a revised plan does not revive a reservation that has already lapsed. The Court relied on this decision to reject the planning authority's contention that the 2002 revised plan revived reservation; it supported the conclusion that a lapsed reservation remains lapsed despite subsequent revision of the plan.
Bhavnagar University v. Palitana Sugar Mills (P) Ltd., 2003 (1) SCC 111 Authority cited for the legal position that a statutory obligation to revise a development plan under section 38 cannot be read to take away substantial rights conferred under section 127. The opinion refers to the law laid down in this Apex Court decision (via Kishor Bapat) to explain that revision under section 38 does not revive lapsed reservations under section 127.
Shri Baburao Dhondiba Solakhe (cited in the opinion) Referenced as presenting a similar factual and legal situation relating to lapsing of reservation under MRTP Act provisions. The decision was used as a factual/legal precedent in the discussion (via the Kishor Bapat analysis) to support the proposition that revision of the plan does not revive lapsed reservations.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court's analysis proceeded step-by-step and was closely tied to the statutory text of section 127 of the MRTP Act (quoted in full in the opinion) and the factual chronology of notices and government action:

  1. Chronology and statutory trigger: The petitioner served a notice under section 127 on 24-3-1999, and receipt by the planning authority is undisputed. Section 127 requires that, if acquisition is not effected within ten years from the date a final plan comes into force or if acquisition proceedings are not commenced within such period, an owner may serve notice and if within six months from service of that notice acquisition is not effected or proceedings are not commenced, the reservation shall be deemed to have lapsed.
  2. Timing of acquisition proposal: Although a request for acquisition was transmitted by the planning authority to the Collector on 2-3-2000, the Court found that this submission occurred after the six-month period stipulated by section 127 following the petitioner's 24-3-1999 notice. Because the planning authority failed to initiate acquisition proceedings within the six-month period, the statutory precondition for lapsing was satisfied.
  3. Effect of revised development plan: The planning authority argued the 2002 revised plan (sanctioned 27-5-2002, in force 28-7-2002) changed purposes for reservation and that the earlier section 127 notice was therefore of no consequence. The Court rejected this argument, noting that the property remained the same despite change of earmarked purposes, and relied on authority (Kishor Bapat and Bhavnagar University) to hold that revision under section 38 does not deprive the owner of rights accrued under section 127 nor revive a reservation which had already lapsed.
  4. Role of section 49(7) purchase notice and subsequent events: The Court recorded that the petitioner had also served purchase notices under section 49(7), one being confirmed and a proposal forwarded which resulted in the Land Acquisition Officer fixing a tentative valuation and directing deposit of two-thirds of compensation (Rs. 1,45,00,000/-) on 28-9-2004. However, the Municipal Council expressly stated it was unable to deposit the amount due to financial constraints and had sought State assistance which did not materialize. The Court observed that while the petitioner could not rely solely on section 49(7) to establish that the reservation lapsed, the events under section 49(7) (including the planning authority's inability to deposit funds) were relevant factual matters in its assessment.
  5. Conclusion from statutory compliance failure and surrounding facts: Considering the undisputed failure to commence acquisition proceedings within the statutory six-month period after the section 127 notice, together with the Municipal Council's admitted financial inability and absence of State assistance to complete acquisition, the Court concluded the mandatory requirement of section 127 had not been complied with and therefore the reservation/allotment/designation must be deemed to have lapsed.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The petition succeeds. It is declared that the reservation, allotment or designation prescribed in respect of the subject property (land S. No. 253, Kinwat; Reservation Sites Nos. 36, 38, 39 and 40) shall be deemed to have been lapsed, and the said property shall stand released from such reservation, allotment or designation and shall become available to the owner for the purposes of development as otherwise permissible in the case of adjacent land under the relevant plan.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: The landowner obtains a declaration that the reservation has lapsed and the land is available for development under the relevant plan like adjacent landowners.
  • No new broad precedent announced: The Court applied and relied upon existing authority (including Kishor Gopalrao Bapat and Bhavnagar University) to determine that revision of a development plan does not revive a reservation that has lapsed under section 127. The opinion does not purport to create a new legal principle beyond that application.
Rule is made absolute. Petition allowed. No costs.

    Jairam v. Municipal Council, Kinwat

    R.M Borde, J.:— Heard Mr. S.G Mundhe, learned Counsel holding for Mr. N.R Katneshwarkar, advocate for the petitioner, Mr. B.A Darak, learned Counsel for respondent No. 1 and Mr. S.P Daund, learned A.G.P for respondents No. 2 to 6.

    2. Rule. Rule made returnable forthwith and heard finally by consent of the parties.

    3. The petitioner, in this petition, claims that the reservation, allotment or designation made by the planning authority in respect of land S. No. 253 situate at Kinwat, belonging to the petitioner, is deemed to have been lapsed by operation of provisions of section 127 of the Maharashtra Regional and Town Planning Act, 1966 (for short, referred to as ‘MRTP Act’). The petitioner also contends that in spite of issuing notice under section 49(7) of the MRTP Act, land of the petitioner has not yet been acquired and as such the said land becomes available to the petitioner for the purpose of development in accordance with the rules and regulations as in the case of adjacent land.

    4. The petitioner claims that he is owner of S. No. 253 situate at Kinwat. It is contended that an area to the extent of 85 ares has already been taken in possession by the Municipal Council on 12-6-1998 itself without initiating proceedings as required under the Land Acquisition Act. So far as other part of said land survey number is concerned, an area to the extent of 1 hectare 42 ares is earmarked for water supply scheme, being Reservation Site No. 38, whereas an area to the extent of 1 hectare 35 ares has been earmarked for Cultural Centre and Library, being Reservation Site No. 39 and an area to the extent of 1 hectare has been earmarked for vegetable market and shopping complex, being Reservation Site No. 40. It is contended that though the development plan was sanctioned in the year 1976 itself, no steps for acquisition of the land were taken. The petitioner, as such, issued notice as contemplated under section 127 of the mrtp act on 24-3-1999. In spite of issuing notice, steps for acquisition were not taken by the planning authority. The petitioner, therefore, again transmitted a notice on 30-7-2002, as contemplated under section 49(7) of the Act to the Chief Secretary, Urban Development Department, Mantralaya, Mumbai, requesting the concerned authority to purchase the land of the petitioner, otherwise release the same from reservation prescribed under the relevant plan. The notice was received by the Chief Secretary and after considering the same, notice was confirmed on 22-1-2003 in respect of Reservation Site Nos. 36, 38, 39 and 40.

    5. It is the case of the petitioner that the planning authority thereafter forwarded a proposal for acquisition of the land. It appears that the Land Acquisition Officer determined the tentative valuation of the property and issued communication to the planning authority on 28-9-2004 to deposit an amount to the tune of Rs. 1,45,00,000/-, being ⅔rd amount of compensation in respect of acquired land. The Municipal Council has expressed its inability to deposit the amount with the Land Acquisition Officer and as such the land could not be acquired. The petitioner again waited for a year and was expecting that steps would be taken by the acquiring body for completing the land acquisition proceedings. The petitioner again issued a notice on 21-3-2005 as contemplated under section 49(7) of the MRTP Act and requested the planning authority and State Government to pay compensation or to release the property. It is contended in the notice that the petitioner on earlier occasion issued notice as contemplated under section 127 of the mrtp act on 24-3-1999, however, no steps were taken for acquiring the property within the stipulated period of six months and as such, the subject lands are deemed to have been deleted from the acquisition. In spite of lapsing of such reservation, the petitioner issued another notice under section 49 of the mrtp act requesting the planning authority as well as the State Government to purchase the property. However, in spite of confirmation of said notice, no concrete steps in respect of acquisition of subject property were taken and no award has yet been passed. The petitioner, therefore, by issuing notice on 21-3-2005, communicated the State Government as well as the planning authority that the reservation, designation, allotment, indication or restriction on development of the land shall be deemed to have been lapsed and the land shall be deemed to have been released from reservation, designation, etc. and same shall be deemed to have become available to the petitioner for the purpose of development. In spite of issuing notice as aforesaid, no further steps are taken. As such, the petitioner has approached this Court with a request to declare that the reservation of petitioner's land, being Reservation Sites No. 36, 38, 39 and 40 shall be deemed to have been lapsed.

    6. The State Government has filed an affidavit, which is sworn by Assistant Director of Town Planning, Nanded, controverting the claim of the petitioner. It is contended that in view of final development plan, which was sanctioned on 6-5-1976, the land was earmarked for different purposes, whereas the development plan has undergone revision and the same is sanctioned finally on 27-5-2002. There is some change in respect of the purpose for which the land is earmarked in the revised plan. It is, therefore, contended that as the revised plan has come into force from 28-7-2002, the notice issued under section 127 of the mrtp act, by the petitioner, is of no consequence. So far as purchase notice under section 49 of the mrtp act is concerned, it is contended that after the said notice was confirmed by the appropriate authority, a proposal for acquisition of the subject land has been forwarded within stipulated period of one year and as such there is no question of lapsing of reservation.

    7. The Municipal Council has also filed an affidavit-in-reply and has raised similar defence as adopted by the State. It is further stated by the planning authority that considering the financial crunch, the planning authority is not in a position to raise funds to the tune of Rs. 1,45,00,000/-, which is a tentative valuation determined by the Land Acquisition Officer towards ⅔rd amount of compensation. It is contended by the planning authority that a request has been made to the State Government for extending financial help and the property would be acquired after the State Government extends financial assistance.

    8. An additional affidavit has been placed on record by the planning authority as well as by the petitioner and it is stated that in spite of revision in the development plan in the year 2002, the property, which is sought to be reserved and which was earmarked for development purpose in the earlier plan, remains one and the same. It is further stated that only the purpose in respect of reservation of site has undergone change as per the revised development plan, however, property remains the same.

    9. It is borne out from the record that notice, as contemplated under section 127 of the Act, was issued by the petitioner on 24-3-1999. There is no dispute in respect of receipt of said notice by the planning authority. Admittedly, request for acquisition of the property has been made by the planning authority on submission of land acquisition proposal with the Collector on 2nd March, 2000. Considering the dates on which proposal for acquisition has been transmitted, it is more than clear that the said proposal has been submitted after the period stipulated under section 127 of the mrtp act. Therefore, the contention that the reservation, designation or allotment in respect of subject property in the relevant development plan shall be deemed to have been lapsed by operation of law, has to be accepted, as admittedly the proceedings were not initiated within statutory period. It is appropriate to refer to the provisions of section 127 of the mrtp act, which reads as under:

    127. Lapsing of Reservations. — If any land reserved, allotted or designated for any purpose specified in any plan under this Act is not acquired by agreement within ten years from the date on which a final Regional Plan, or final Development Plan comes into force or if proceedings for the acquisition of such land under this Act or under the Land Acquisition Act, 1894, are not commenced within such period, the owner or any person interested in the land may serve notice on the Planning Authority, Development Authority or as the case may be, Appropriate Authority to that effect; and if within six months from the date of the service of such notice, the land is not acquired or no steps as aforesaid are commenced for its acquisition, the reservation, allotment or designation shall be deemed to have lapsed, and thereupon, the land shall be deemed to be released from such reservation, allotment or designation and shall become available to the owner for the purpose of development as otherwise, permissible in the case of adjacent land under the relevant plan.

    10. It is tried to be contended on behalf of the planning authority that in the earlier development plan, the purpose for which the land was earmarked was different and as per the revised development plan, the property has been earmarked for a distinct purpose. It is tried to be canvassed that as the revised development plan has been operationalised in the year 2002, the act of issuance of notice under section 127 of the mrtp act, by the petitioner, on the planning authority is of no consequence.

    11. The said argument cannot be accepted for the reason that the property which was earmarked in the earlier development plan, which was finalised in the year 1976 and which has undergone revision in the year 2002, remains one and the same. It would be apt to refer to the decision in the case of Kishor Gopalrao Bapat v. State of Maharashtra, reported in 2005 (4) Mh. L.J 466, wherein, in para 11, it has been observed that:

    “11. The question, which falls for our consideration in the present petition is whether the Planning Authority exercising power under section 38 of the mrtp act, which deals with revision of development plan, can take away the rights accrued to the owner of the land on account of lapsing of reservation in view of contingencies mentioned in section 127 of the mrtp act. Similar factual and legal situation arose in the case of Shri Baburao Dhondiba Solakhe (cited supra) and this Court after taking into consideration the law laid down by the Apex Court in Bhavnagar University v. Palitana Sugar Mills (P) Ltd., 2003 (1) SCC 111, in paragraph (17) observed thus:

    “The legal position as regards MRTP Act on the basis of aforesaid observations made by the Apex Court in Bhavnagar University emerges that by imposition of a statutory obligation under section 38 on the part of the State or the appropriate authority to revise the development plan the rights of the owners accrued in terms of section 127 are not taken away. section 38 of the mrtp act, in our opinion, does not and cannot be read to mean that substantial right conferred upon the owner of the land or the person interested under section 127 is taken away. In other words, section 38 does not envisage that despite the fact that in terms of section 127, the reservation lapsed, only because of a draft revised development plan or final revised development plan is made would not automatically result in revival of reservation that had lapsed. If the reservation of the petitioner's land for the purposes of garden had lapsed and as we found in fact has lapsed on 28-2-1992, because of draft revised plan made in the year 1992 and thereafter final revised development plan sanctioned in the year 1999 would not revive the lapsed reservation.”

    12. In this view of the matter, it will have to be held that as the planning authority has failed to initiate proceedings in respect of acquisition within the stipulated period of six months from the date of receipt of notice under section 127 of the mrtp act, served by the petitioner on the planning authority, the reservation, allotment or designation shall be deemed to have been lapsed and the land shall be deemed to have been released from such reservation, allotment or designation and shall become available to the land owner for the purposes of development as otherwise permissible in the case of adjacent land under the relevant plan.

    13. The another aspect, which is also worth consideration, is that the petitioner has issued purchase notice under section 49 of the mrtp act on the State Government as well as on the planning authority on 30-7-2002. The said notice was confirmed by the State Government and the proposal for acquisition of the property was forwarded to the Land Acquisition Officer within the stipulated period of one year. The Land Acquisition Officer has arrived at tentative valuation of the property, which is to the tune of Rs. 1,45,00,000/- and directed the planning authority to deposit the aforesaid amount with the Land Acquisition Officer. A communication to that effect was sent by the Land Acquisition Officer on 28-9-2004. However, in spite of issuance of such communication directing the planning authority to deposit the tentative value of the land, the planning authority has specifically expressed its inability to deposit the said amount because of its poor financial condition. The planning authority could not collect the required amount for making deposit of the same with the Land Acquisition Officer either on its own or could not persuade the State Government to release financial assistance, although the proposal was transmitted to the Land Acquisition Officer on 2nd March, 2000. Petitioner has, therefore, again issued notice under section 49(7) of the MRTP Act, intimating the planning authority that as the land has not been acquired within the stipulated period, the reservation shall be deemed to have been lapsed. Although the petitioner cannot place reliance on the provisions of section 49(7) of the MRTP Act for the purpose of deriving an inference that the reservation shall be deemed to have been lapsed on account of failure of finalisation of land acquisition proceedings for number of years, however, it is a relevant fact to be taken into consideration for rendering decision in the matter.

    14. During the course of argument, the learned Counsel for the planning authority has in clear terms stated that the planning authority is not in a position to collect requisite funds and cannot purchase the property on its own because of financial crunch. It is also made clear that neither the State Government is responding positively nor there is any other scheme for arranging financial resources. In this view of the matter, it is clear that the planning authority is not in a position to purchase the property so also the State Government is also not coming forward with any proposal for helping the planning authority in the matter of purchase of the subject land.

    15. Taking into consideration the totality of the circumstances, we are of the view that the planning authority has failed to purchase the property within the stipulated period prescribed under section 127 of the Act after receipt of notice sent by the petitioner which was served on the planning authority. On account of failure to comply with the mandatory requirement of section 127 i.e initiating land acquisition proceedings within six months after issuance of notice as contemplated under section 127 of the mrtp act, the reservation, allotment or designation in respect of the subject property shall be deemed to have been lapsed and the subject property is available to the land owner for the purposes of development under the relevant plan, as in the case of adjacent land owner.

    16. In the result, Petition succeeds. It is hereby declared that the reservation, allotment or designation prescribed in respect of the subject property i.e land S. No. 253, situated at Kinwat, shall be deemed to have been lapsed and the said property shall stand released from such reservation, allotment or designation and shall become available to the owner for the purposes of development as otherwise permissible in the case of adjacent land under the relevant plan.

    17. Rule is made absolute accordingly. No costs.

    Petition allowed.
    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Jairam v. Municipal Council, Kinwat
    (Nov 1, 2007)