AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of the Bombay Rent-Free Estates Act, 1852 and the exemption from Land Revenue (No. 1) Act 1863.
  • section 88-B of the Bombay Tenancy and Agricultural Lands Act, 1948
  • Bombay Public Trusts Act, 1950 (for short the BPT Act).
  • section 88-B of the BPT Act,
  • Act. Section 88-B
  • section 88-B,
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of the Bombay Rent-Free Estates Act, 1852 and the exemption from Land Revenue (No. 1) Act 1863.
  • section 88-B of the Bombay Tenancy and Agricultural Lands Act, 1948
  • Bombay Public Trusts Act, 1950 (for short the BPT Act).
  • section 88-B of the BPT Act,
  • Act. Section 88-B
  • section 88-B,
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioners, long-standing tenants of lands owned by the Shri Maruti Deo Trust Pimpli Limtek (the trust), challenged a certificate of exemption granted under section 88-B of the Bombay Tenancy and Agricultural Lands Act, 1948 (BT and AL Act). The trust, registered as a public trust under the Bombay Public Trusts Act, 1950 (BPT Act) only in 1984, owns lands bearing Gat No. 264 and 265 of Village Pimpli, Taluka Baramati, District Pune. The petitioners were in possession of these lands on 1st April 1957, the "tillers day" under the BT and AL Act. Respondent trustees applied to the Collector for a certificate of exemption under section 88-B on 9th July 1986, which was granted despite the trust’s registration occurring after the tillers day. The petitioners contested the validity of this exemption certificate, leading to the present petition.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a public trust can claim exemption under section 88-B of the BT and AL Act if it was not registered under the BPT Act on or before the tillers day, 1st April 1957.
  2. Whether the issuance of a certificate of exemption under section 88-B to a trust registered after the tillers day is valid when tenants were in possession on the tillers day and deemed owners under sections 32 to 32-R of the BT and AL Act.
  3. Whether the decisions in Laxminarayan Temple v. Laxman M. Chandore and Chhatrapati Charitable Devasthan Trust v. Parisa Appa Bhoske require reconsideration in light of the Bombay Rent-Free Estates Act, 1852 and the exemption from Land Revenue (No. 1) Act 1863.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The petitioners were tenants in occupation on the tillers day, 1st April 1957, and thereby became owners under sections 32 to 32-R of the BT and AL Act.
  • The trust was not registered under the BPT Act on the tillers day, only registering in 1984, so it could not claim exemption under section 88-B of the BT and AL Act.
  • The application for exemption made by the trustees in 1986 was invalid as the land ownership had already vested in the petitioners.
  • Reliance was placed on the decisions of this Court in Laxminarayan Temple v. Laxman M. Chandore (AIR 1970 Bom. 23) and Chhatrapati Charitable Devasthan Trust v. Parisa Appa Bhoske, which held that trusts must be registered before the tillers day to claim exemption.

Respondent Trustees' Arguments

  • Contended that the precedents require reconsideration due to the Bombay Rent-Free Estates Act, 1852 and the exemption from Land Revenue (No. 1) Act 1863, which impose restrictions on lands held by a Devasthan.
  • Argued that lands held by a Devasthan should be treated as absolutely exempt under section 88-B of the BT and AL Act regardless of registration timing.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Laxminarayan Temple v. Laxman M. Chandore (AIR 1970 Bom. 23) Trust must be registered under the BPT Act before the tillers day (1st April 1957) to claim exemption under section 88-B of the BT and AL Act. The Court followed this ruling to conclude that the trust’s registration in 1984 was too late to claim exemption, as ownership vested in tenants on the tillers day.
Chhatrapati Charitable Devasthan Trust v. Parisa Appa Bhoske Even if application for registration was made before the tillers day but registration not effected by then, exemption under section 88-B cannot be granted. The Court applied this principle to reject the trust’s claim for exemption, emphasizing that registration must precede the tillers day.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analyzed the relevant provisions of the BT and AL Act, particularly the amendments introduced by Bombay Act No. XIII of 1956, which vested ownership of lands in tenants who were in possession on the tillers day. Section 88-B, added by the same amendment, provides exemption from the Act’s provisions to lands owned by registered public trusts, subject to two conditions: the trust must be registered under the BPT Act and the income must be used for trust purposes.

The Court found that the trust was not registered on or before 1st April 1957, but only in 1984, which was after the tenants had already become deemed owners. The Court relied heavily on binding precedents that held registration must precede the tillers day for exemption to apply. The Court rejected the respondent trustees’ argument for reconsideration based on other Acts, finding no impact on the settled legal position.

Consequently, the issuance of the exemption certificate under section 88-B after the land had vested in the tenants was held to be impermissible.

Holding and Implications

The petition is allowed and the certificate of exemption under section 88-B of the BT and AL Act issued on 13th January 1987 is quashed.

The Court directed the authorities to proceed under section 32-G of the BT and AL Act to fix the purchase price for the lands. The decision directly affects the parties by invalidating the exemption certificate granted to the trust and confirming the petitioners’ ownership rights. No new precedent beyond the application of existing case law was established.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Eknath Bhiku Yadav And Another v. Ganpatrao Shankarrao Dhawan And Others

    D.G Karnik, J.:— By this petition, the petitioners challenge the certificate of exemption granted under section 88-B of the Bombay Tenancy and Agricultural Lands Act, 1948 (for short “the B.T and A.L Act”)

    2. Respondent Nos. 1 to 7 are the trustees of Shri Maruti Deo Trust Pimpli Limtek (for short “the trust”) which is registered as a public trust under the Bombay Public Trusts Act, 1950 (for short “the BPT Act”). The trust is the owner of the lands bearing Gat No. 264 and 265 of Village Pimpli, Taluka Baramati, District Pune (for short “the said lands”). The petitioners are the tenants of the trust since long and it is not disputed that they were in possession of the said lands on 1st April, 1957 i.e the “tillers day” prescribed under BT and AL Act. The respondent Nos. 4 to 7 made an application to the Collector, the respondent No. 10 herein for issuance of a certificate of eligibility for exemption under section 88-B of the BT and AL Act on 9th July, 1986. A notice of enquiry was issued to the petitioners and they were given even an opportunity of cross-examining the applicant trustees. In the cross-examination, the trustees of the trust admitted that the petitioners were the tenants in occupation of the said lands on 1st April, 1957. They further admitted that the trust was not registered on 1st April, 1957 i.e on the “tillers day” but was registered as a public trust under the BPT Act for the first time in the year 1984. Despite this admission, the respondent No. 10 issued a certificate of exemption under section 88-B of the BT and AL Act. That certificate is impugned in this petition.

    3. Learned counsel for the petitioners submits that the petitioners were tenants in occupation of the said lands on 1st April, 1957. The petitioner being in possession as tenants on the tillers day, they became owners of the said lands under the provisions of section 32 to 32-R of the BT and AL Act. An application for exemption and issuance of a certificate under section 88-B of the BPT Act was made by the trustees on 9th July, 1986 when they were not the owners of the land as the land was deemed to have been purchased by the petitioners on 1st April, 1957 under the provisions of the BT and AL Act. Therefore, there was no question of grant of a certificate of exemption under section 88-B of the BT and AL Act. Learned counsel for the petitioners referred to and relied upon two decisions of this Court in Laxminarayan Temple v. Laxman M. Chandore reported in 7969 Mh.L.J 476 : AIR 1970 Bom. 23 and Chhatrapati Charitable Devasthan Trust v. Parisa Appa Bhoske reported in 7979 Mh.L.J 163 in support of his submissions.

    4. The BT and AL Act when enacted in 1948 granted protection against eviction to the tenants of agricultural lands. It did not provide for any automatic purchase of the lands in occupation by the tenants. provisions of section 32 to 32-R along with few other sections were inserted into the BT and AL Act by means of an amendment effect by bombay act no. xiii of 1956. Under the amended BT and AL Act, subject to certain exceptions with which we are not concerned, the tenants became owners of the lands in their possession from the tillers day i.e from 1st April, 1957. By the same amending Act, section 88-B was also added to the parent Act. section 88-B provides for exemption from provisions of the BT and AL Act save certain sections thereof. It inter alia grants exemption from the provisions of the Act to the lands which are the property of a trust for an educational purpose, hospital, panjarapole, a gaushala or an institution for public religious worship. The exemption granted to the public trust is subject to two conditions viz. (i) the trust should be registered or deemed to be registered under the BPT Act, 1950 and (ii) the entire income of such lands should be apportioned for the purpose of the trust. Therefore, in order to get an exemption under section 88-B, a trust must be registered or deemed to be registered under the provisions of the BPT Act.

    5. It is not the case of the respondent trustees that the trust was registered under any of the old Acts relating to the public trusts and therefore deemed to be registered under the BPT Act. It was their case as set out in the application for exemption as also as stated in the cross-examination of the trustees that the trust was registered for the first time on 8th August, 1984. It is also an admitted position that the petitioners were the tenants in possession of the said lands on the tillers day i.e 1st April 1987. In Laxminarayan Temple v. L.M Chandore (supra), a Division Bench of this Court has specifically held that in order for the trust to claim an exemption under section 88-B of the BPT Act, the trust must be registered before 1st April, 1957. This is so because if the trust was not registered on 1st April, 1957, a tenant would become a deemed purchaser of that date and once the tenant became a deemed purchaser and the ownership of the land which vested in him on 1st April, 1957 could not be divested by subsequent registration of the trust. The said decision has been followed and applied by another Division Bench in Chhatrapati Charitable Devasthan Trust v. Parisa Appa Bhoske (supra). In that case, the Division Bench went further and said that even where an application for registration of a trust was made before 1st April, 1957 but the registration was not actually effected before 1st April, 1957, the tenant would become the deemed owner of the land and thereafter, a certificate under section 88-B of the B.T and A.L Act could not be granted. The Division Bench rejected the argument advanced that the registration would relate back to the date of the application.

    6. Learned counsel for the respondent Nos. 1 to 7 submitted that the aforementioned decisions require reconsideration as the provisions of the Bombay Rent-Free Estates Act, 1852 and the exemption from Land Revenue (No. 1) Act 1863. Learned counsel submitted that these Acts impose restrictions on the lands held by a Devasthan and therefore, the lands held by a Devasthan should be treated as absolutely exempt under section 88-B of the B.T and A.L Act. The two decisions of the Division Bench of this Court referred to above are of long standing. The first decision was referred more than 35 years ago and has stood the test of time. We are not satisfied that they require reconsideration as in one opinion nothing contained in the two Acts cited above would make any difference to the ultimate decision and ratio of the two cases. We therefore reject the request of the learned counsel of the petitioner for referring the matter to a larger Bench.

    7. For these reasons, we are of the view that it was not open to the respondent No. 10 to grant a certificate of exemption to the trust after the said lands vested in the petitioner on 1st April, 1957.

    8. Accordingly, the petition is allowed. The impugned certificate of exemption under section 88-B of the B.T and A.L Act issued by the respondent No. 10 on 13th January, 1987 is hereby quashed. The concerned authorities are directed to hold proceedings under section 32-G of the BT and AL. Act to fix the purchase price at an early date.

    Petition allowed.
    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Eknath Bhiku Yadav And Another v. Ganpatrao Shankarrao Dhawan And Others
    (Feb 6, 2006)