Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • proper.5. Section 415, Indian Penal Code,
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • proper.5. Section 415, Indian Penal Code,
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The complainant, husband of accused No. 3, prosecuted six accused persons for offences punishable under section 417 read with section 34 of the Indian Penal Code (IPC), alleging that the accused concealed the fact of pregnancy of accused No. 3 at the time of her marriage to him. The marriage was settled on May 25, 1970, and performed on June 1, 1970, with the accused No. 3 living with the complainant thereafter and delivering a child on November 19, 1970. The complainant argued that the concealment of pregnancy amounted to cheating. The learned Magistrate, Kaij, District Bhir, was not satisfied with the merits of the case and acquitted all six accused. The complainant appealed against this acquittal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the order of acquittal passed by the learned Magistrate in respect of the charges under section 417 read with section 34, IPC, was legal and proper.
  2. Whether concealment of pregnancy by the accused and her parents constitutes "cheating" under section 415/417, IPC, given the requirement of deception related to property.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Queen Empress v. Bakma Kom Sadhu, 1886 I.L.R 11 Bom. 59 Held that a prostitute suffering from syphilis communicating the disease is not liable under s. 269 IPC; obiter observation that cheating under s. 417/420 IPC requires evidence of inducement by misrepresentation. The Court found the obiter observations unhelpful to the complainant's case as they did not establish the offence under s. 417 IPC in the present facts.
In re K. Rama Rao Considered the applicability of s. 420 IPC in a case of personation and appointment; held that posting to a service can be considered property but conviction under s. 420 was not proper in that case. The Court distinguished the case and held it did not assist the complainant, affirming that the ingredients of s. 417 IPC were not established here.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analyzed section 415 IPC, which defines "cheating" and requires deception that induces a person to deliver or consent to retention of property or to do or omit an act causing damage or harm. The Court emphasized that "dishonesty" and deception must relate to wrongful gain or loss of property as defined under sections 23 and 24 IPC. Although the complainant suffered harm to reputation due to the concealment of pregnancy, the Court held that this did not amount to deception with respect to property. The dominant motive behind the concealment was to facilitate marriage, not to cause wrongful gain or loss of property. The Court found that the prosecution failed to establish the essential ingredient of dishonest concealment of fact involving property. The cited precedents were examined but found not to support the complainant's case. Consequently, the Court concluded that the learned Magistrate correctly acquitted the accused as the offence under section 417 IPC was not made out.

Holding and Implications

DISMISSED

The Court confirmed the acquittal of all accused persons by the trial Court and dismissed the complainant's appeal. The direct effect is that the accused remain acquitted of the charges under section 417 read with section 34 IPC. No broader precedent was set by this decision.

    Ramkrishna Baburao Maske v. Kishan Shivraj Shelke

    Bhole, J.:— This is an appeal by the complainant, who has failed in getting the accused, whom he prosecuted, convicted. He prosecuted them for offences punishable under s. 417 read with s. 34, Indian Penal Code, but the learned Magistrate, Kaij, District Bhir, was not satisfied with the merits of the case and, therefore, acquitted all the six accused.

    2. The complainant is the unfortunate husband of accused No. 3 who is said to have been offered by her parents, accused Nos. 1 and 2 and some mediators, who were discharged. It is said that the marriage of the complainant with accused No. 3 was settled on May 25, 1970 and was performed on June 1, 1970. Accused No. 3 came to stay with the complainant on that day. They lived as husband and wife and she delivered a child on November 19, 1970 after about five months from the date of the marriage.

    3. She was taken to Ambejogai hospital and the doctor's report was that the child was delivered with seven months' pregnancy. The complainant's case is that he had married her at the time when she had already conceived much before the time of the marriage. It is, therefore, his case that her parents as well as she concealed from him the fact of her pregnancy at the time of the settlement of marriage and also at the time of marriage and thereby they have cheated him. The parents denied having any knowledge about the conception of their daughter and accused No. 3 also denied having cheated the complainant.

    4. The learned Magistrate after considering s. 415, Indian Penal Code found that ‘dishonesty’ is one of the ingredients of that section and that it is connected with property. He was, therefore, satisfied that the case of the complainant did not fit within the purview of s. 415, Indian Penal Code. He, therefore, acquitted all the accused. The point, therefore, that arises here for consideration is whether the order of acquittal passed by the learned Magistrate is legal and proper.

    5. Section 415, Indian Penal Code, is as follows:

    “415. Whoever, by deceiving any person fraudulently or dishonestly induces the person so deceived to deliver any property to any person, or to consent that any person shall retain any property, or intentionally induces the person so deceived to do or omit to do anything which he would not do or omit if he were not so deceived, and which act or omission causes or is likely to cause damage or harm to that person in body, mind, reputation or property is said to ‘cheat’.

    Explanation.—A dishonest concealment of facts is a deception within the meaning of this section.’

    6. Therefore, this section requires deception of any person not only in the case of one who fraudulently or dishonestly induces that person to deliver any property or to consent that any person shall retain any property but also in the case of one who intentionally induces that person to do or omit to do anything which he would not do or omit if he was not so deceived. Therefore, deception of any person is a common factor. This ingredient has necessarily, therefore, to be established. In the explanation of the section, ‘dishonest concealment of fact’ is a deception within the meaning of this section. Therefore, the prosecution has to establish dishonest concealment of facts. What is ‘dishonesty’ is also defined in s. 24, Indian Penal Code. Whoever does any thing with intent of causing wrongful gain to one person or wrongful loss to another person is said to do that thing dishonestly. Wrongful gain and wrongful loss are also defined in s. 23, Indian Penal Code. Wrongful gain is gain by unlawful means of property to which the person gaining is not legally entitled. Wrongful loss is loss by unlawful means of property to which the person losing is legally entitled. Therefore, in the matter of deception there should be intention of wrongful gain to one person or wrongful loss to another person. This means that there should, be a gain by wrongful means of property. In so far as the facts and circumstances of our case are concerned, the question of property does not arise at all.

    7. Now it is true that accused No. 1 has offered his daughter accused No. 3 to the complainant by not disclosing the fact of pregnancy. There was also naturally harm to the reputation of the complainant on account of concealment of the facts. The delivery of the child as a result of conception much before the marriage has also harmed his reputation. All this is because of the concealment of pregnancy by the bride, accused No. 3 herself, and also perhaps by her parents. They have also induced the complainant to marry accused No. 3 by concealing this fact. The dominant motive was to perform the marriage of accused No. 3 with the complainant. All this, however, does not at all show that there was a kind of deception within the meaning of s. 415, Indian Penal Code, because there cannot be a dishonest concealment of fact, which in turn is with respect of property.

    8. An offence under s. 415, Indian Penal Code, would be complete only when somebody by deceiving any person intentionally induces the person so deceived to do or omit to do anything which he would not do or omit if he was not so deceived and which act or omission causes or is likely to cause damage or harm to that person in body, mind, reputation or property. Under the explanation to s. 415, Indian Penal Code deception of any person would be as a result of dishonest concealment of fact. It is necessary for the prosecution also to establish that there was deception of any person and in consequence of the deception intentional inducement to do or omit to do must be there. In my view when there is dishonest concealment of fact that should be with intention of causing wrongful gain to one person or wrongful loss to another person. For the purpose of causing wrongful loss or wrongful gain the prosecution has to establish that gain or loss was by unlawful means and that was of property to which the person gaining or losing was not legally entitled. In other words, the result of concealment of fact should be for the purpose of wrongful gain by unlawful means of property. In the instant alleged cheating such a dishonest concealment of fact is absent. The facts of our case, therefore, show that there was no wrongful gain to the accused nor there was any wrongful loss to the complainant. If that is so, then one of the ingredients viz. dishonest concealment of fact cannot be said to have been established in this case.

    9. Mr. Dabir invites my attention to Queen Empress v. Bakma Kom Sadhu . 1886 I.L.R 11 Bom. 59. where the Division Bench of this Court was considering the case of a prostitute under s. 269, Indian Penal Code. This section is with reference to a negligent act likely to spread infection of a disease dangerous to life. It was held that the prostitute who while suffering from syphillis communicates the disease to a person who has sexual intercourse with her is not liable to punishment under s. 269, Indian Penal Code for a negligent act of spreading infectious disease dangerous to life. There was an obiter observation by West, J. in his separate judgment that if there was any offence, it was one of cheating punishable under s. 417 or 420, Indian Penal Code and to establish it there should be evidence believed by the Magistrate that intercourse was induced by misrepresentation on the part of the diseased person. Such obiter observations, in my view, will not be of any help to Mr. Dabir but then he relies on another case: In re K. Rama Rao2. This was a case of an accused who had applied for the post of a Supervisor (Civil Engineering) to the Public Service Commission and who after considering his application selected him as one of the candidates for appointment. After his appointment in the temporary post he was arrested and charged under s. 416, Indian Penal Code, for personation. Two sets of circumstances against the accused were found by two lower Courts. The first was that the accused represented himself to be K.V Ramrao holding the qualification of a licentiate in Civil Engineering from an Engineering College, Guindy, Madras to secure the post of an Overseer and was appointed as such. The second was with respect to obtaining a professional certificate on which the accused relied to entitle him to B.E degree. He was convicted for the offence under ss. 419 and 420, Indian Penal Code. It was urged on conviction of the accused under s. 420, Indian Penal Code in the revision application that was not a case in which on account of any deception any person has been induced to deliver any property. The ground that had been taken was that it was the Government who had appointed the accused and mere selection by Public Service Commission for appointment by Government would not constitute delivery of any property to the accused by the Public Service Commission, but it was conceded in that case that the posting of a person to any service was property and, therefore, the Division Bench did not find it necessary to go into the nicety of the question inasmuch as the restrictive scope s. 420, Indian Penal Code, created difficulties in the matter of application of that section to the facts of that case. The conviction under s. 420, Indian Penal Code was therefore held to be not proper and the accused was acquitted of the offence under that section but the conviction under s. 419, Indian Penal Code was upheld. I do not, therefore, think that this case can also in any way help Mr. Dabir. I am of the view that all the ingredients of the offence under s. 417, Indian Penal Code, with which the accused was charged have not been established in this case. The learned Magistrate, therefore, was right in acquitting the accused.

    10. I, therefore, confirm the order of acquittal of the accused passed by the trial Court and dismiss the appeal filed by the complainant.

    11. Appeal dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Ramkrishna Baburao Maske v. Kishan Shivraj Shelke
    (Feb 5, 1974)