AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • Income-tax Act of 1918, Sch. V, Para 17
  • Income-tax Act by S. 16(2) and S. 18(5)
  • INCOME TAX ACT 1918
  • section is S. 4(1)(b)(ii).
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • Income-tax Act of 1918, Sch. V, Para 17
  • Income-tax Act by S. 16(2) and S. 18(5)
  • INCOME TAX ACT 1918
  • section is S. 4(1)(b)(ii).
Smart Summary

Concise Analytical Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The assessee, Sir Joseph Kay, a resident of India, was assessed to income-tax for the assessment year 1952–1953. In his total income the assessing authorities included income arising or accruing to him outside the taxable territories, specifically an annuity entitlement of £500 from three United Kingdom insurance companies under annuity policies. In fact the insurance companies paid Sir Joseph Kay £225 in cash, retaining £275 which they treated as tax payable in the United Kingdom. The narrow question referred to the Court was whether the correct amount to be included in Sir Joseph Kay's total income for the year ending 31 March 1952 was £500 (the annuity entitlement) or £225 (the amount actually received in cash).

The charging provision invoked was S. 4(1)(b)(ii) (total income includes income accruing or arising to a resident outside taxable territories). The matter was argued in light of the English statutory rule (R.19) in the General Rules to the Schedules of the English Income-tax Act 1918 and related provisions, and it was referred to this Court for decision.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, for the purpose of assessment under S. 4(1)(b)(ii), the income from the annuity payable to Sir Joseph Kay for the year in question was the full £500 (the annuity entitlement) or only £225 (the amount actually paid to him after deduction/retention by the UK payer for tax).
  2. Whether the English statutory scheme (R.19 and related provisions), under which the payer is assessed and entitled to deduct and retain tax at source and is discharged on paying the residue to the annuitant, operates to make the retained amount part of the payer's income rather than the annuitant's income for Indian tax purposes.

Arguments of the Parties

Assessee's Arguments (as presented by Mr. Palkhivala)

  • The amount liable to Indian tax should be the amount actually received by the assessee in cash, i.e., £225, not the full annuity of £500 which the insurers were liable to pay.
  • Under the English law (R.19 to the English Income-tax Act 1918) when an annuity is payable out of profits the payer is assessed on the annuity and is entitled to deduct and retain tax; the payer's obligation to pay tax is a substantive liability of the payer and the deduction retained by the payer is not a payment on behalf of the annuitant but a statutory retention by the payer.
  • The scheme of deduction under the Indian Act (S. 18 and S. 18(4)) is different: S. 18 casts an obligation on the payer to deduct tax but preserves the assessee's liability if tax is not deducted; S. 18(4) deems sums deducted at source to be income of the assessee for computing his total income. By contrast, the English rule does not create that deeming fiction in favour of the annuitant.
  • Relying on the legal distinction between a debt accruing and an income accruing (see Lalbhai v. Commissioner), the contention was that although a debt of £500 accrued, only the part discharged to the annuitant in fact (£225) became income of the annuitant for the accounting year, because £275 was extinguished or retained by statute as tax.

Department / Revenue's Arguments

  • The annuity of £500 was the income of Sir Joseph Kay and that full amount should be included in his total income for assessment purposes.
  • The retention of £275 by the insurance companies under English law is a method of collecting tax but does not alter the substantive fact that the £500 annuity is the income of the annuitant; the legal fiction that treats the payer as assessed cannot change the underlying fact of who owns the income.
  • Analogies drawn to S. 18(4) and company dividend grossing-up were not applicable to the annuity situation; the levy on the payer in England is procedural and for collection convenience, and the annuitant remains the owner of the income and can seek refund where appropriate.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Lalbhai v. Commissioner of Income-tax, Bombay North, Kutch and Saurashtra Baroda, 1952 Bom 457 Distinction between a debt accruing or arising and an income accruing or arising — the debt does not become income until it is discharged. The Court acknowledged the principle but held Mr. Palkhivala's reliance on it to be a misreading in the present facts: there was no extinguishment of part of the debt by statute; rather the statutory retention by the payer operated to discharge the whole debt of £500, and thus £500 remained the annuitant's income.
Commissioner of Income-tax v. Blundell Spence and Co. Ltd., 1952 Bom 282 Dealt with grossing up dividends and whether tax paid by a company could be taken into account when taxing a shareholder; contrasted company tax (on profits) and shareholder's dividend (income to shareholder). The Court treated that decision as not being in pari materia with the present case: dividend taxation and company tax operate differently. The Court held the annuity situation stands on different footing and the Blundell Spence principle did not assist the assessee here.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded by analysing the English statutory provisions (R.19 in the General Rules to the Schedules of the English Income-tax Act 1918) and the practical effect of those provisions. R.19 provides that where an annuity is payable out of profits brought into charge, assessment shall be made upon the person liable to the annuity (the payer) and that the payer, on making payment, may deduct and retain a sum representing the amount of tax thereon; further, the person to whom such payment is made shall allow such deduction and the person making the deduction shall be acquitted and discharged as if that sum had been actually paid.

The Court accepted the factual operation described: the insurers paid £225 to Sir Joseph Kay and retained £275 to satisfy the tax on the £500 annuity. The Court then analysed whether that statutory machinery changed the substantive ownership of the income.

Key steps in the Court's analytical path:

  1. Recognition that R.19 operates by a legal fiction that treats the annuity as assessable on the payer and permits the payer to retain tax; but a legal fiction for assessment and collection cannot negate the underlying fact of who owns the income.
  2. Application of the debt-versus-income distinction: while a debt may not become income until discharged, the statutory machinery here effects a discharge of the entire debt of £500 (the £225 paid plus the £275 retained for tax), rather than extinguishing part of the debt; therefore £500 is the annuitant's income.
  3. Rejection of the argument that the retained £275 became the payer's income by reason of the English deeming fiction. The Court emphasised that the fiction was introduced solely to facilitate collection and assessment and does not alter the patent fact that the annuity belonged to the annuitant.
  4. Analogy to a hypothetical where insurers paid the full £500 and the annuitant paid £275 to the revenue: nothing in substance would be different; the statutory retention by the payer merely changes the collection route.
  5. Reference to refund provisions: if the annuitant were not liable to the tax which the payer paid, he could obtain a refund. That possibility reinforces that the tax was in truth on the annuitant's income.
  6. Distinction from shareholder/dividend situations (as in Blundell Spence): company tax is on company profits and not a payment on behalf of the shareholder in the same way; therefore the legal machinery for dividends and grossing up under Indian S.16(2) and S.18(5) is not analogous to the annuity situation.

On these bases the Court concluded that the English statutory arrangement does not convert the annuitant's income into the payer's income for Indian assessment; rather the full annuity of £500 remained the income of Sir Joseph Kay and properly fell to be included in his total income for the relevant year.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Court held that the sum of £500 was properly includible in the assessee's total income for the year ending 31 March 1952 for the purpose of assessment for the year 1952–1953.

Direct consequences and implications (as stated in the opinion):

  • The Court upheld the income-tax authorities' inclusion of £500 in Sir Joseph Kay's total income and thereby sustained the assessment on that basis.
  • The assessee was ordered to pay the costs.

Observations in the opinion about broader legal implications:

  • The decision emphasises that a statutory or assessment-related legal fiction (treating the payer as assessed) cannot change the substantive fact of ownership of income; for tax assessment purposes the underlying factual characterisation of who owns the income controls.
  • The Court distinguished the annuity situation from dividend/company tax mechanics and from the deeming provisions in the Indian Act (e.g., S.18(4)), concluding those provisions do not create an income where none existed, and that the present case does not rely on such a deeming fiction to reach its result.

Note: The summary above strictly reflects the content and reasoning contained in the provided opinion. No information has been added beyond what appears in the text.

    Joseph Kay v. Commissioner Of Income-Tax, Bombay City, Bombay

    Chagla, C.J:— Although the question arising out of this reference has been elaborately and ingeniously argued, it is really a very simple one. The assessee Sir Joseph Kay is a resident of this country and he was assessed to tax in the assessment year 1952-1953 and in his total income the income arising or accruing to him outside the taxable territories was also included and in this income was included a sum of £500/- which the assessee was entitled to receive in the United Kingdom from three insurance companies under annuity policies which he had taken out with those insurance companies, and the only dispute which is the subject-matter of this reference is whether the sum of £500/- has been correctly included in the total income of the assessee or the correct amount that should have been included is £225/-.

    2. In fact, the assessee actually received from these three insurance companies £225/- and the contention of Mr. Palkhivala is that what is liable to tax is the amount actually received by the assessee, viz., £225/-, and not £500/- which was the amount of annuity which the insurance companies were liable to pay to the assessee. The charging section is S. 4(1)(b)(ii). The total income includes the income accruing or arising to the assessee without the taxable territories during the relevant year, and the very short question that we have to decide is—what was the income of the assessee in the accounting year in respect of these annuity policies? Was his income £500/- as contended by the Department or his income was £225/-?

    3. The reason why these insurance companies in the United Kingdom paid only £225/- to the assessee and not £500/- is this. By reason of the provisions of the law, to which we shall presently refer, when an annuity is payable out of profits, the English law requires that the payer should pay to the annuitant the amount due to him in respect of the annuity less the income-tax payable on the annuity, and the law also provides that the amount of the annuity payable by the payer shall be considered to be the income of the payer and the payer will pay tax on that annuity.

    4. In other words, the substance of the matter is that instead of the annuitant paying tax on £500/-, which tax admittedly amounts to £275/- by reason of the method of taxation adopted by British Parliament the payer of the annuity is required to pay the sum of £275/-, and ??? law also provides that when the payer pays to ??? annuitant £225/- instead of £500/-, the annuitant ??? must give a full discharge to the payer of the annuity.

    5. It is on these provisions of the English law that the contention is put forward by Mr. Palkhivala that Sir Joseph Kay's income which accrued to him within the meaning of S. 4(1)(b)(ii) was only £225/- and not £600/-.

    6. The relevant provision with regard to tax on annuity payable out of profits is to be found in the General Rules applicable to Schs. A, B, C, D and E which are annexed to the English Income-tax Act 1918, and R. 19 is the material rule.

    7. That rule provides that where any annuity is payable wholly out of profits or gains brought into charge to tax, no assessment shall be made upon the person entitled to such annuity, but the whole of the profits or gains shall be assessed and charged with tax on the person liable to the annuity, without distinguishing the same, and the person liable to make such payment, whether out of the profits or gains charged with tax or out of any annual payment liable to deduction, or from which a deduction has been made, shall be entitled, on making such payment, to deduct and retain thereout a sum representing the amount of the tax thereon at the rate or rates of tax in force during the period through which the said payment was accruing due.

    8. Therefore the rule clearly provides that there shall be no assessment with regard to this annuity upon the person receiving the annuity. It equally clearly provides that the annuity shall be deemed to be the income of the payer of the annuity and that the payer shall pay tax on that annuity and he is entitled to deduct from the annuity the amount of the tax which he is liable to pay. Then the second paragraph of R. 19(1) is important:

    “The person to whom such payment is made shall allow such deduction upon the receipt of the residue of the same, and the person making such deduction shall be acquitted and discharged of so much money as is represented by the deduction, as if that sum had been actually paid”.

    9. Therefore the payer receives a complete discharge as far as his debt to the annuitant is concerned when he pays not the full amount of the annuity but the amount of the annuity less the tax payable on that amount.

    10. What is urged by Mr. Palkhivala is that under this rule there is no liability upon Sir Joseph Kay to pay the tax. It is not his liability to pay the tax that is being discharged by the insurance companies. He says that the law imposes a liability upon the payer himself and it is that liability, a substantive liability, which is being discharged when the payer pays tax to the revenue in England.

    11. The contention therefore is put forward that what Sir Joseph Kay is entitled to in view of this provision of the law is not £500/- but only £225/-. Attention is drawn to the provisions of s. 18 of our act and it is pointed out that the scheme of deduction under the two Acts is fundamentally different.

    12. It is said that under S. 18, although an obligation is cast upon the payer of salaries etc., to deduct the tax at the source, the person who is entitled to the salary still remains liable to pay the tax if the tax has not been deducted, and it is made clear by S. 18 that the person deducting the tax at the source is deducting it on behalf of the person entitled to the salary. It is also pointed out that under S. 18(4) it is expressly provided:

    “All sums deducted in accordance with the provisions of the section shall, for the purpose of computing the income of an assessee, be deemed to be income ???”.

    13. It is ??? that in the absence of these provisions under the English law the only part of the annuity which became the income of Sir Joseph Kay is £225/- and not £500/-, that when the insurance companies deducted £275/- they were not deducting the sum on behalf of Sir Joseph Kay in order that they should pay the tax on behalf of Sir Joseph Kay, but they were deducting it because the English statute cast an obligation upon the insurance companies to retain this sum, and it was by reason of this statutory obligation that this sum was being paid.

    14. What we must really look at is the substance of the legal provisions to which reference has been made and on which reliance has been placed, and we must look at the substance of the matter from only one simple point of view. Whose income was this £275/- which was retained by the insurance companies under the provisions of R. 19?

    15. It is clear that the tax was payable on the annuity due to Sir Joseph Kay and it was by a legal fiction that the income of Sir Joseph Kay was deemed to be the income of the insurance companies. That legal fiction was imported by the English law in order to collect the tax from the payer of the annuity rather than from the annuitant himself. But the legal fiction cannot possibly change the patent fact that the annuity is that of Sir Joseph Kay and the whole of £500/- is the income of Sir Joseph Kay and no part of it is the income of the insurance companies.

    16. It is then urged that even though £500/- may be due as a debt by the insurance companies to Sir Joseph Kay, the fact that a debt had accrued to Sir Joseph Kay did not result in law in an income accruing to Sir Joseph Kay. That proposition of law is perfectly sound.

    17. A distinction has been drawn (see ‘Lalbhai v. Commissioner of Income-tax, Bombay North, Kutch and Saurashtra Baroda’, 1952 Bom 457 (AIR V 39) (A) between a debt accruing or arising and an income accruing or arising, and the debt does not become income till it comes in, or put in a different language, the debt does not become income till it has been discharged. What Mr. Palkhivala argues is that although the debt might have been £500/-, £275/- were extinguished by statute and only £225/- was discharged by the insurance companies, and therefore the only amount which became the income of Sir Joseph Kay was £225/- and not £500/-. That is completely misreading both the position in law and the actual facts that emerge in this reference.

    18. There is no extinguishment of the debt or part of it by statute. What the statute provides is that on the insurance companies paying £225/- to Sir Joseph Kay the full debt is discharged because the insurance companies have retained £275/- which are to be paid as tax on £500/-. Therefore, this is not a case of extinguishment of part of the debt, viz. £275/-, but a discharge of the debt in the manner provided by law.

    19. Nor is Mr. Palkhivala right when he contends that the debt is only partly paid and not fully paid. He says that even if there is no extinguishment, only part of the debt in fact has been paid to Sir Joseph Kay and that part is £225/- and not the whole of £500/-. In substance the whole debt of £500/- has been paid to Sir Joseph Kay. The mode of payment is this £225/- have been actually paid in cash to Sir Joseph Kay, and the balance of £275/- is retained by the insurance companies in order to pay the tax which is payable on the sum of £500/-.

    20. It is difficult to understand how the position is different from what it would have been if the insurance companies had paid the full sum of £500/- to Sir Joseph Kay and Sir Joseph Kay would have paid £275/- to the Income Tax Authorities which he was liable to pay. Surely Mr. Palkhivala then could not have contended that the full sum of £500/- has not been paid to him or that the debt has not been discharged.

    21. Instead of permitting the insurance companies to pay the full sum of £500/- to Sir Joseph Kay and then collecting £275/- from him, the taxing machinery set up in England provides that the Taxing Authorities will recover £275/- from the insurance companies themselves and permit the insurance companies only to pay £225/- to Sir Joseph Kay. It may be that strictly according to the language of the law the insurance companies are not paying £275/- on behalf of Sir Joseph Kay, but you cannot get away from the salient fact that they are paying £275/- on the income of Sir Joseph Kay and not on their own income.

    22. It is pointed out that in the absence of provision like S. 18(4) you cannot consider £275/- as the income of Sir Joseph Kay. Section 18(4) does not make something, which is not the income of the person to whom the salary is due, his income.

    23. The legal fiction introduced by S. 18(4) is that the person, part of whose salary has been deducted at the source, shall be deemed to have received that part of the income for the purpose of tax. But what he is deemed to have received was his income and to repeat, there is no fiction introduced in S. 18(4) which makes something the income of the person which was not in fact his income.

    24. But the fiction that has been introduced in the English law is that the income of Sir Joseph Kay is to be considered the income of the payer of the annuity. But what we are concerned with is not the fiction but the fact and the fact remains and no argument can undermine that fact that £500/- was the income of Sir Joseph Kay and no part of it was the income of the payer or of any one else.

    25. Any doubt that there might be with regard to the true position is completely set at rest by the provisions to which our attention has been drawn with regard to the refund of income tax. If Sir J. Kay was not liable to pay tax on this sum of £500/- which tax has been paid by the insurance companies by reason of his total income, he would be entitled to get either a refund of the full amount or a proportionate refund.

    26. It is impossible to contend that Sir Joseph Kay should obtain a refund with regard to payment of tax in respect of something which is not his income. The answer given by Mr. Palkhivala is that the Income-tax Act of 1918, Sch. V, Para 17 statutorily makes the deduction which has been made by the payer of the annuity part of the total income of the annuitant, and it is because of this that the annuitant becomes entitled to claim the refund.

    27. But the very reason why the annuitant is allowed to include in his total income the deduction made by the payer is that the payer is paying tax out of the income of the annuitant and when the annuitant prepares a statement of his total income he is entitled to include in it what has been deducted out of his income for the purpose of payment of tax.

    28. Therefore, looking to the whole scheme both of deduction and of provisions with regard to refund, it is clear that the English law does not overlook or ignore the fact that the annuity payable is the income of the annuitant; indeed it would be extraordinary if the British Parliament overlooked the obvious fact, and that the annuity being the income of the annuitant the easier and the more convenient way of recovering tax would be to recover it from the payer of the annuity rather than from the annuitant himself.

    29. But having made that provision it proceeds to make it clear that the annuitant has received the full amount of the annuity, that the payer receives a proper discharge, and that in proper cases the annuitant is entitled to refund of tax if he was not liable to pay tax which the payer of the annuity has paid.

    30. Mr. Palkhivala has relied on a judgment of this Court in ‘Commissioner of Income-tax v. Blundell Spence and Co. Ltd.’, 1952 Bom 282 (AIR V 39) (B). What we held there was that the assessee, a non-resident company registered in the United Kingdom with its head office in London, received dividend in respect of some shares held by it in a company which was assessed to income-tax both in the United Kingdom and in India.

    31. We held that in grossing up the dividends received by the assessee the income-tax authorities were not entitled to take into consideration the tax paid by the company in the United Kingdom. In our opinion the two cases are not in pari materia. The only income of a share-holder is the dividend that he receives on the shares which he holds. The tax which the company pays on its profits is a tax not paid on behalf of the shareholder. The company pays tax on its own income which is the profit made during the working of the company, and the share-holder pays tax on his income which is the dividend.

    32. But in order that relief should be given to the shareholder and in order that the same income should not be taxed twice, a machinery is introduced into the Income-tax Act by S. 16(2) and S. 18(5) by which the share-holder is allowed to gross up the dividend received by him and then to deduct the tax paid by the company which by legal fiction is deemed to have been paid on his behalf. But in the case which we are dealing with there is no legal fiction with regard to the income of the annuitant.

    33. The annuity that he receives stands on the same footing as the dividend received by a shareholder, and we are not permitting the income-tax authorities to tax Sir Joseph Kay with the help of some legal fiction introduced into our income-tax Act for the purpose of dealing with shareholders who have received dividends from companies here. We are upholding the action of the income-tax authorities in taxing Sir Joseph Kay on the simple finding that in substance and in fact the income of Sir Joseph Kay is £500/-, that it accrued to him outside the taxable territories and that as he is a resident he is liable to pay tax on that amount.

    34. The question therefore referred to us must be answered as follows: “The sum of £500/- fell to be included in the assessee's total income for the year ending 31st March 1952 for the purpose of assessment for the year 1952-1953.

    35. The assessee to pay the costs.

    K.S.B
    Answer accordingly.
    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Joseph Kay v. Commissioner Of Income-Tax, Bombay City, Bombay
    (Sep 23, 1955)