AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Court's Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The writ petition (filed under Article 226) sought a mandamus restraining the respondents from levying or collecting any cess under the Research and Development Cess Act, 1986 (the "Cess Act") in respect of payments made and to be made by Petitioner No. 1, Wig Brothers (Builders and Engineers) Private Ltd., to Heit‑Kamp and/or Balcke‑Durr (German companies) under a collaboration agreement between the petitioner and the German collaborators. The petition also challenged the validity of the levy and collection of cess under the Act and Rules, sought quashing of a Demand Notice dated 22.7.1991 issued under Rule 6 of the Rules, and challenged Section 2(h) of the Act as ultra vires Articles 14 and 19(1)(g) of the Constitution and Rule 3 of the Rules as ultra vires the Act.

Procedurally, the Court heard counsel for the parties, considered pleadings (including counter‑affidavit and rejoinder), examined contract documents and annexures (tenders, letter of intent, contract dated 11.1.1990, collaboration agreement in the record as Annexure‑4, RBI correspondence and approvals), and dismissed the writ petition. The Court noted that an interim order had been granted on 5.11.1992 staying the demand arising from the demand notice dated 20.7.1991, and that the interim stay had operated for approximately twelve years.

The opinion refers to the collaboration agreement in multiple places and with different dates as they appear in the record (the petition initially refers to a collaboration agreement dated 28.11.1989; other parts of the record and the pleadings refer to dates including 28.11.1988 and 22.11.1988). These varying dates are reproduced as they appear in the opinion.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the petitioner is an "industrial concern" within the meaning of Section 2(e) of the Cess Act (read with Section 2(c) of the I.D.B.I. Act) and therefore liable to pay cess under Section 3 on payments made towards the import of technology.
  2. Whether the payments by the petitioner to Heit‑Kamp and/or Balcke‑Durr amounted to import of "technology" within the meaning of Section 2(h) of the Cess Act.
  3. Whether the Demand Notice dated 22.7.1991 issued under Rule 6 of the Rules should be quashed.
  4. Whether Section 2(h) of the Act is ultra vires Articles 14 and 19(1)(g) of the Constitution and whether Rule 3 of the Rules is ultra vires the Act.
  5. Whether interest or other monetary accretions should be directed on the delayed payment of the cess, given the interim stay of recovery issued earlier by the Court.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The petitioner company is not an "industrial concern" within the meaning of Section 2(e) of the Cess Act read with the I.D.B.I. Act.
  • There was no import of technology within the meaning of the Cess Act; the contract was essentially a civil contract for tailor‑made cooling towers and did not involve transfer of ongoing technical know‑how enabling the petitioner to design and engineer cooling towers independently.
  • The German firms (Heit‑Kamp and Balcke‑Durr) were merely sub‑consultants providing services to N.T.P.C., and any technical interactions were effectively between the collaborators and N.T.P.C.; therefore, the petitioner argued that N.T.P.C., not the petitioner, was the entity importing/using the technology.
  • The contract was a deemed export contract and accordingly did not fall within the purview of the Cess Act.
  • The petitioner emphasized that the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) and other authorities were repeatedly told that no foreign collaboration approval from the Central Government was required because there was no transfer of technology to the petitioner.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The respondents maintained that the petitioner is an "industrial concern" as defined by Section 2(e) because a foreign collaboration agreement involving import of technology was approved in its favour by the Central Government.
  • It was alleged that the petitioner entered into a collaboration agreement (record refers to an agreement dated in November 1988/1989) with Heit‑Kamp for the import of technology from Germany and that this agreement was approved by the Central Government; accordingly, the petitioner imported technology and is liable to pay the cess.
  • The respondents denied that the works were merely civil works and asserted that cooling towers are essentially plant and equipment rather than pure civil works.
  • The respondents denied that the bid was submitted jointly with the foreign collaborators; they asserted that the contract and subsequent agreement dated 11.1.1990 were executed by the petitioner alone and that the contract was awarded to the petitioner alone, who alone was responsible for its execution.
  • The respondents asserted that the collaborators did not transfer technology directly to N.T.P.C.; the technology was imported by the petitioner from the collaborators in terms of the collaboration agreement and was required by the petitioner to perform the contract awarded to it by N.T.P.C.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Assistant Collector of Central Excise v. Dunlop India Ltd., (1985) 1 SCC 260 High Courts should normally not grant a stay of recovery of tax; stays of recovery of tax should be exceptional because interim orders can cause heavy loss to the Government/department. The Court relied on this authority to criticize the long interim stay in this case (which lasted about 12 years) and to explain why stays of recovery should be granted sparingly. The decision informed the Court's comments about the effect of the interim stay on public funds.
Indian Carbon Ltd. v. State of Assam, 1998 (1) UPTC 1 Interest on delayed payment of tax can be charged only if the statute makes a substantive provision for charging such interest. The Court treated this Supreme Court decision as binding under Article 141 and held that because the Cess Act contains no provision for payment of interest on delayed payment of cess, the Court could not direct realization of interest. The Court therefore declined to order interest despite its observations on the fairness of charging interest.
Article 141 of the Constitution (binding precedent principle) Decisions of the Supreme Court are binding on all courts in India. The Court expressly stated that the Indian Carbon Ltd. decision is binding under Article 141 and followed it in refusing to order interest in the absence of a statutory provision.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court's analysis proceeded in the following steps (as stated in the opinion):

  1. The Court framed the threshold requirement for imposition of the cess: it must be demonstrated that the petitioner is an "industrial concern" which has "imported technology" as those terms are defined in the Cess Act (Section 2(e) and Section 2(h)) and that the cess is chargeable under Section 3(1) and payable under Section 3(2).
  2. The Court examined the pleadings and documentary record, including the counter‑affidavit which expressly stated that a foreign collaboration agreement involving import of technology had been approved by the Central Government in favour of the petitioner.
  3. On the question whether the petitioner was an "industrial concern," the Court found (on the basis of the counter‑affidavit and the record) that a foreign collaboration agreement involving import of technology had been approved in favour of the petitioner; accordingly, the petitioner satisfied Section 2(e)'s definition and was an "industrial concern."
  4. Turning to whether the petitioner had "imported technology," the Court scrutinized the contract dated 11.1.1990 (Annexure‑3) and the collaboration agreement (Annexure‑4). It observed that the contract and related documents showed the contract was awarded to the petitioner alone and executed by the petitioner alone (not jointly with Heit‑Kamp/Balcke‑Durr), and that the collaboration agreement showed the petitioner required and imported the technology from the German collaborators because the technology was not available in India.
  5. The Court rejected the petitioner's contention that N.T.P.C. was the entity importing the technology or that the collaborators were providing services directly to N.T.P.C. The Court concluded there was no transfer of technology by the collaborators directly to N.T.P.C. and that the technology in question had been imported by the petitioner for the purpose of executing the contract awarded to it.
  6. Based on these factual and documentary findings, the Court held that the cess under Section 3(2) was payable by the petitioner. Consequently, the writ petition seeking relief from the levy was without merit and was dismissed.
  7. Regarding consequences of interim judicial relief, the Court observed that an interim stay of recovery had been in effect since 5.11.1992, staying a demand dated 20.7.1991, and that this stay had permitted the petitioner to retain the money for approximately twelve years. The Court used this factual backdrop to explain its view that interest ordinarily should be payable on delayed payments of taxes to prevent unjust enrichment from successful interim stays.
  8. However, the Court applied the binding Supreme Court decision in Indian Carbon Ltd. (interpreted under Article 141) and found that the Cess Act contains no provision for charging interest on delayed payment. Therefore, notwithstanding its observations about interest and fairness, the Court declined to direct payment of interest. The Court did, however, note Section 9(2) of the Cess Act (which permits imposition of penalty up to ten times the arrears) and directed the respondent bank to consider imposition of penalty not exceeding ten times the amount in arrears, if it deemed fit.
  9. Finally, the Court made recommendations to the executive (Central and State Governments) to consider amending taxing statutes to provide for interest on delayed payment of taxes, and directed that copies of the judgment be sent to specified government officials and that copies be made available to parties on payment of usual charges by 14.7.2003.

Holding and Implications

Holding: WRIT PETITION DISMISSED.

Direct consequences and implications (as expressly indicated in the opinion):

  • The Court held that the petitioner is an "industrial concern" within Section 2(e) and that the petitioner imported technology within the meaning of Section 2(h); accordingly, the cess under Section 3(2) of the Cess Act is payable by the petitioner.
  • The Demand Notice issued under Rule 6 (dated 22.7.1991) is not sustained by the writ petition and the petition is dismissed; the petitioner remains liable for the cess.
  • The Court declined to order interest on delayed payment because the Cess Act contains no substantive provision for interest and the binding Supreme Court decision (Indian Carbon Ltd.) disallows charging interest absent such a provision; accordingly, the Court could not direct interest despite its comments about the fairness of charging interest.
  • Under Section 9(2) of the Act (which permits imposition of penalty not exceeding ten times the arrears), the Court directed the respondent bank to consider imposing a penalty up to the statutory maximum, if it so deemed fit.
  • The Court recommended that the Central and State Governments consider amending taxing statutes to provide expressly for payment of interest on delayed tax payments to avoid the inequity where successful interim relief results in financial benefit to the petitioner during the pendency of proceedings.

The opinion contains no assertion that it establishes a new legal precedent beyond applying and following existing Supreme Court authority (notably Indian Carbon Ltd. and the principle in Dunlop regarding stays). Where the opinion discusses broader policy recommendations (statutory amendment to provide for interest on delayed taxes), those are recommendations to the executive and not a judicial rule change.

Source: Opinion excerpt supplied for summarization. The summary above is based exclusively on the content of that opinion and does not add or infer facts beyond what the opinion contains.

    Wig Brothers (Builders And Engineers) And Another v. Union Of India And Others

    M. Katju, J.:— This writ petition has been filed for a mandamus restraining the respondents from levying or collecting any cess under the Research and Development Cess Act, 1986 (hereinafter referred as the ‘Cess Act’) in respect of payments made and to be made by the petitioner No. 1, Wig Brothers (Builders and Engineers) Private Ltd. to Heit-Kamp and/or Balcke Durr (German Companies) under the collaboration agreement dated 28.11.1989 between Heit-Kamp and the petitioner No. 1. Petitioners also prayed for declaring the levy and collection of cess under the Cess Act on payments made by the petitioner No. 1 to Heit-Kamp and/or Balcke-Durr as ultra vires the Cess Act and the Rules made thereunder. Petitioners have also prayed for quashing the Demand Notice dated 22.7.1991 under Rule 6 of the Rules to the petitioner by respondent No. 3. They have also prayed for declaring Section 2(h) of the Act as ultra vires Articles 14 and 19(1)(g) of the Constitution and Rule 3 of the Rules as ultra vires the Act.

    2. We have heard learned counsel for the parties. The petitioner No. 1 is a company incorporated under the provisions of the Companies Act having its Registered Office at Mathura Road, New Delhi. It is executing the works in respect of which cess under the Act is sought to be levied and collected from the petitioner No. 1 at Vidyut Nagar, Dadri in the State of Uttar Pradesh. It is alleged in para 2 of the petition that 70 percent of the contract work has already been executed at Dadri in respect of which the cess is being levied. The Cess Act was brought into force with effect from 1.12.1987 Section 2(d) of the Act defines ‘import’ as follows:

    (d) “Import” in relation to any technology, means the bringing into India of such technology from a place outside India.”

    3. Section 2(e) defines Industrial concern as follows:

    (e) “Industrial concern” has the meaning assigned to it in clause (c) of Section 2 of the Industrial Development Bank of India Act, 1964 and includes any other person in whose favour a foreign collaboration involving the import of technology is approved by the Central Government.

    4. Section 2(h) defines technology as follows:

    (h) “Technology” means any special or technical knowledge or any special service required for any purpose whatsoever by an industrial concern under any foreign collaboration, and includes designs, drawings, publications and technical personnel.

    Section 3 of the Act states:

    (1) There shall be levied and collected for the purposes of this Act, a cess at such rate not exceeding five percent on all payments made towards the import of technology, as the Central Government may, from time to time, specify, by notification, in the official Gazette.

    (2) The cess shall be payable to the Central Government by an Industrial concern which imports technology on or before making any payments towards such import and shall be paid by the Industrial concern to any specified agency.

    5. Under Section 9(2) of the Act, penalty can be imposed for non-payment cess, not exceeding ten times the amount in arrears.

    6. It is alleged in para 6 of the petition that the petitioner company is not an industrial concern within the meaning of Section 2(e) of the Act read with Section 2(c) of the Industrial Development Bank of India Act (I.D.B.I Act).

    7. It is alleged in para 8 of the petition that the National Thermal Power Corporation of India floated a global tender dated 21.3.1988, inviting bids on turnkey basis for design and engineering supply of equipment, construction and commissioning of 4 Natural Draught Cooling towers of 25,000 cub. metre for the National Thermal Power Corporation project at Dadri, District Ghaziabad. Annexure-1 to the petition is a copy of the Tender Invitation (minus the technical specifications and Drawings). The Tender Invitation mentioned that the Government of India had received a credit from the International Bank of Reconstruction and Development (IBRD) towards the cost of the project and that the N.T.P.C intended to apply a portion of the proceeds of the credit to finance portion of the design and engineering charges, equipment cost, supervision of erection and commissioning charges of foreign collaborators, etc., for the project. The qualifying requirements as stipulated in the said Tender Invitation, inter alia included the requirements that the “Bidder furnishes along with a bid an undertaking jointly executed by the bidder and his collaborator for successful performance of the Cooling Towers as per proforma attached.”

    8. In para 9 of the petition, it is alleged that the petitioner company together with E. Heit-Kamp of Germany and Balcke-Durr, Germany in response to the said Tender Invitation submitted a bid dated 16.6.1988 to the N.T.P.C for the said project. In para 10, it is stated that N.T.P.C after evaluation accepted the petitioner's bid and awarded the contract for the said project namely supply of equipment, construction and commissioning of 4 Cooling Towers on turnkey basis for the Thermal Power Project at Dadri to the petitioner with Heit-Kamp and Balcke-Dull as collaborators for the said purpose, and the N.T.P.C issued a letter of intent dated 8.11.1988 to the petitioner company Annexure-2. Pursuant to the same, the N.T.P.C entered into an agreement dated 11.1.1990 with the petitioner vide Annexure-3. In para 11 of the petition it is alleged that Cooling Towers are essentially civil works as they are tailor made, designed and engineered according to the needs of the specific power plant, and the same design or technology cannot be used for another Cooling Tower. The petitioner entered into an agreement with Heit-Kamp dated 28.11.1988 for providing the required design and engineering, documentation, expertise and supervision services as required by N.T.P.C The Collaboration Agreement is only for the said project and does not stipulate transfer of any on going Technical Know how to the petitioner Company which would enable it to acquire the ability to design and engineer cooling towers. Under the collaboration agreement there was no provision of the related services which are usually the subject-matter of technical know-how agreements. True copy of the Collaboration Agreement is Annexure-4.

    9. The N.T.P.C vide its letter dated 19.11.1988 sent to the petitioner a Proforma of a Joint Undertaking required by it to be executed jointly by the petitioner company alongwith Heit-Kamp and Balcke-Durr, Germany Collaborators, for the said project. Accordingly, the petitioner submitted the said joint undertaking dated 29.11.1988 vide Annexure-5. It is alleged in para 17 that the N.T.P.C has been directly in contact with Heit-Kamp on the technical aspects of the project and has been seeking clarification from Heit-Kamp from time to time. A true copy of the letter dated 5.3.1991, written by N.T.P.C to Heit-Kamp to illustrate this fact is Annexure-6 to the petition. It is alleged in para 18 of the petition that Heit-Kamp and Balcke-Durr were providing services really to N.T.P.C as is evident from the minutes of the meeting held on 3.11.1988, between the N.T.P.C and the representatives of the petitioner company. It is alleged that this clearly shows that for the deputation of Heit-Kamp and Balcke-Durr Engineers to Dadri during the construction period for supervising the construction of the Cooling Towers, the extent of deployment shall be in line, inter alia with N.T.P.C Technical Specifications, and the Petitioner's bid, and the decision taken by N.T.P.C in this regard after discussions would be binding on the petitioner and Heit-Kamp including Balcke-Durr without any commercial implications to N.T.P.C A true copy of the said minutes is Annexure-7.

    10. It is alleged in para 19 of the petition that there was no import of Technology within the meaning of the Cess Act. The contract was essentially a civil contract. It is alleged in para 20 that the petitioner company executed the project as Leader with Heit-Kamp and Balcke-Durr as its associates. Hence it made an application to the Reserve Bank of India, by a letter dated 27.2.1989, for grant of permission for opening a letter of credit in favour of Heit-Kamp towards payment of design and consultancy charges for the project vide Annexure-8. In response to this letter, the Reserve Bank of India allowed the petitioner to open a letter a credit vide Annexure-9. The N.T.P.C also certified to the Reserve Bank of India about the amount against I.B.R.D loan paid to the petitioner vide Annexure-10.

    11. Subsequently, the petitioner by letter dated 18.4.1989, requested the Reserve Bank of India for grant of permission to open letter of credit for D.M 11,56,000 less the amount for which sanction had already been granted by the R.B.I A true copy of the said letter is Annexure-11. In response to the said letter, the R.B.I by letter dated 21.6.1989, informed the petitioner that it should first take approval from the Union of India, Ministry of Industries, for the collaboration agreement with Heit-Kamp. A true copy of the said letter is Annexure-12. It is alleged in para 24 of the petition that pursuant to the earlier approval, the petitioner company had made payment to Heit-Kamp on or about May-June, 1989, and the respondent No. 2 never required or asked the petitioner company to obtain the approval of respondent No. 1 to the collaboration agreement. Copy of the letter in this connection is Annexure-12A.

    12. It is alleged in para 25 of the petition that the petitioner was all along stressing before the Reserve Bank of India that they were not required to take foreign collaboration approved from the Central Government as there is no transfer of technology from Heit-Kamp or Balcke-Durr to the petitioner. The Germany collaborations are only sub-consultants for the project for the supply of design and drawings to the petitioner and they are also responsible for the construction and testing the Cooling Towers. However, respondent No. 2 insisted that the petitioner should obtain approval from respondent No. 1. In view of this, the petitioner was forced to apply for grant of foreign collaboration Approval before the respondent No. 1. Only thereafter the Reserve Bank of India gave its approval dated 30.3.1990 to the Collaboration Agreement with Heit-Kamp on the condition of levy of cess under the Research and Development of Cess Act, 1986. A true copy of the approval dated 30.3.1990 is Annexure-14.

    13. It is alleged in para 27 that no cess is payable under the Cess Act because the contract is a deemed export contract and does not fall within the purview of the Cess Act. However, the petitioner received notice dated 22.7.1991 under Rule 6 of the Rules for payment of cess vide Annexure-16. Hence this petition.

    14. Counter-affidavit has been filed and we have perused the same. In para 6, it is stated that the petitioner company is an ‘industrial concern’ within the meaning of Section 2(e) of the Cess Act read with Section 2(c) of the I.D.B.I Act. It is alleged that the petitioner company entered into a collaboration agreement dated 22.11.1988 with Heit-Kamp, a foreign company of Germany for import of technology from outside India, and the said agreement has been approved by the Central Government. It is alleged that the petitioner company has imported technology under the said collaboration agreement, and hence is liable to pay the cess.

    15. In para 7 of the counter-affidavit, the respondents have denied that the petitioner is doing essentially civil work. It is alleged that cooling towers are essentially plant and equipments and not civil work.

    16. In para 8 of the counter-affidavit, it is denied that the bid was submitted by the petitioners jointly with Heit-Kamp and Balcke-Durr. It is alleged that the bid was submitted by the petitioner company alone and not as a Joint bidder with Heit-Kamp and Balcke-Durr. It is alleged that at the time of invitation of tenders, it was understood that the technology for setting up of the Natural Draught Cooling Towers was not available in India, and hence the bidders were required to the up with foreign collaborators for the import of technology. As per terms of the Tender, the successful bidder was required to furnish a joint performance guarantee. From the contract documents, it is evident that the contract was given to the petitioner company alone and not jointly with Heit-Kamp and/or Balcke-Durr, the Germany collaborators. An agreement dated 11.1.1990, Annexure-3 to the writ petition was executed by the petitioner alone as contractor. This agreement clearly provides that the contract was awarded to the petitioner company alone, and the petitioner company alone was responsible for execution of the contract.

    17. In para 11 of the counter affidavit, it is stated that the petitioner company alone imported the technology. The recital in the collaboration agreement dated 22.11.1988 makes it clear that the petitioner company desired to make use of the special know-how and the technical services and assistance of Heit-Kamp.

    18. In para 13 of the counter-affidavit, it is alleged that the Collaborators came into contact with N.T.P.C at the instance of the petitioners in discharge of their obligations towards the petitioner company under the collaboration agreement dated 22.11.1988 There was no transfer of technology by the collaborator directly to the N.T.P.C The technology in question was imported by the petitioner from the collaborator as per terms of the collaboration agreement, and not by the N.T.P.C It was the petitioner company, and not the N.T.P.C, which required the necessary technology for executing the contract awarded to it by N.T.P.C The contract was awarded by N.T.P.C to the petitioner company and not to Heit-Kamp or Balcke-Durr.

    19. In para 22, it is alleged that the petitioner is an ‘industrial concern’ and having imported technology is liable to pay the cess.

    20. We have also perused the rejoinder-affidavit in this case.

    21. We have carefully considered the submissions of learned counsel for the parties. For imposition of the cess, it has to be demonstrated that the petitioner is an industrial concern which imported technology.

    22. The petitioner has alleged that it is not an industrial concern vide para 7 of the writ petition. This allegation has been denied in para 6 of fee counter affidavit, where it is stated that the petitioner is an industrial concern, which has entered into a foreign collaboration by agreement dated 22.1.1988 with Heit-Kamp, a Germany company, for import of technology from outside India, and the said agreement has been approved by the Central Government. In para 7 of the counter-affidavit, it is stated that Cooling Towers are essentially plant and equipments and not civil work.

    23. We are of the clear opinion that petitioner is an industrial concern as defined in Section 2(e) of the Act since a foreign collaboration agreement involving import of technology has been approved in its favour by the Central Government, as is evident from para 6 of the counter-affidavit. We are further of the opinion that the petitioner has imported technology.

    24. No doubt the stand of the petitioner is that it was the N.T.P.C which imported the technology, but we cannot accept this submission. A perusal of the contract dated 11.1.1990, Annexure-3 to the petition shows that it was executed by the petitioner alone, and not jointly with Heit-Kamp. A perusal of the said agreement shows that the contract was awarded by N.T.P.C in favour of the petitioner and not jointly in favour of the petitioner along with its Germany collaborators. We, therefore, fully agree with what is stated in paras 8 and 11 of the counter-affidavit. The collaboration agreement dated 22.11.1988, Annexure-4 to the petition shows that the petitioner has imported technology from the Germany collaborators. It was the petitioner Company and not the N.T.P.C which required the necessary technology for executing the contract. The technology was not available in India and hence was imported from Germany by the petitioner.

    25. We do not agree with the submission made by the petitioner that Heit-Kamp and Balcke-Durr were really providing services to N.T.P.C We are of the opinion that there was no transfer of technology by the collaborators directly to the N.T.P.C The technology was imported by the petitioner from the collaborators as per terms of the collaboration agreement and not by the N.T.P.C The technology was required by the petitioner and not by N.T.P.C Hence, in our opinion, the cess certainly payable by the petitioner under Section 3(2) of the Act. Thus, there is no force in the writ petition and it is dismissed.

    26. It appears that in this case, this Court had passed an interim order on 5.11.1992 staying the demand against the petitioner in pursuance of the demand notice dated 20.7.1991 Thus, due to the interim order of this Court the demand remained stayed for a period of 12 years.

    27. It may be mentioned that money doubles in six years (because of interest). In this case, the petitioner has avoided payment of cess for about 12 years, counting from the date of the demand notice dated 20.7.1991 Thus, even though we are dismissing this petition, the petitioner has really won the case, because he did not have to pay interest from 20.7.1991 till today.

    28. It may be mentioned that there is misconception about interest. Interest is not a penalty or punishment at all but is the normal accretion on capital. Had the petitioner paid the amount in question in July, 1991, when it was due, the respondents would have invested the same somewhere and earned interest thereon. Instead, the petitioner has kept the money with himself for about 12 years and has earned interest thereon. Hence for every Rs. 100 which the petitioner had to pay in July, 1991, he has in fact, earned an additional Rs. 300. This is because Rs. 100 becomes Rs. 200 after six years, and in another six years this Rs. 200 doubles and becomes Rs. 400. Thus, even though we have dismissed this writ petition today, the petitioner has really not only won the case (because of the interim order of this Court) he has really earned Rs. 300 for every Rs. 100 he had to pay. Thus, even though we are dismissing this petition the petitioner has got three time more amount than what he has to pay now. All this happened because of the interim order of this Court staying the demand.

    29. In Assistant Collector of Central Excise v. Dunlop India Ltd., (1985) 1 SCC 260, the Supreme Court strongly criticized the tendency of various High Courts to grant stay of recovery to tax. The Supreme Court held that normally the High Courts should not under Article 226 grant stay of recovery of tax save under very exceptional circumstances. By interim orders, such as the one passed in the case, the Govt. or concerned authority/Department often suffers heavy loss.

    30. The whole misconception about interest is that often it is regarded as a penalty or punishment. That is not so. Interest is the normal accretion on capital, as already stated above, and does not amount to a penalty. Hence, in our opinion, interest should ordinarily be ordered to be paid whenever there is delay in payment of the tax or other money liability, otherwise the petitioner who succeeds in getting an interim order from his Court really wins the case even while technically losing it (and often wins it several times over, as has happened in this case).

    31. However, the Supreme Court in Indian Carbon Ltd. v. State of Assam, 1998 (1) UPTC 1, has held that interest can be charged on delayed payment of tax only if the statute has made a substantive provision in that regard. This Supreme Court decision is binding on us under Article 141 of the Constitution and hence as long as it stands, we have to follow it. There is no provision in the Cess Act for payment of interest on delayed payment of the cess, and hence in view of the aforesaid decision of the Supreme Court, we cannot direct realization of interest. However, in view of Section 9(2) of the Act, we direct the respondent bank to consider imposition of penalty not exceeding 10 times of the arrears, if it so deems fit.

    32. In view of the above observations regarding interest made in this judgment we recommend to the Central Government and State Government to consider amending all taxing statutes (by a suitable Ordinance or Amending Act) to provide for payment of interest whenever there is delay in payment of taxes (for whatever reason). Let the Registrar General of this Court send copies of this judgment to the Union Law and Finance Secretaries, New Delhi, as well as the Chief Secretary, Law and Finance Secretaries, U.P, forthwith. Copy of this judgment shall be given to the parties on payment of usual charges by 14.7.2003

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Wig Brothers (Builders And Engineers) And Another v. Union Of India And Others
    (Jul 11, 2003)