Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Classes) Act, 1994 (hereinafter referred to as the Act).
  • provisions of the Constitution and the Act
  • ARTICLE 14 CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
  • provisions contained in sub-section (4)
  • sub-section (1) of Section 3
  • sub-section (1).(7)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Classes) Act, 1994 (hereinafter referred to as the Act).
  • provisions of the Constitution and the Act
  • ARTICLE 14 CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
  • provisions contained in sub-section (4)
  • sub-section (1) of Section 3
  • sub-section (1).(7)
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion (R.R.K. Trivedi, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

This writ petition was heard on final disposal after counter and rejoinder affidavits were exchanged and the parties agreed that the petition could be decided at this stage.

Two impleadment applications (No. 71415 of 1997 by Ram Swarup Ahirwar and No. 23563 of 1998 by Dr. Satish Kumar and others) were filed; a counter-affidavit was filed with the second application. The principal question was whether the respondents could lawfully initiate a special recruitment drive to fill the entire backlog of reserved-quota posts in the cadre of Medical Officers (Ayurvedic/Unani) in Uttar Pradesh.

The factual matrix in the petition (as presented before the Court) includes the following specific facts from the impugned advertisements and the petitioners' status:

  • U.P. Public Service Commission issued Advertisement No. 3/95-96 inviting applications for 47 Medical Officer (Ayurvedic) posts (42 reserved for Scheduled Castes and 5 for Scheduled Tribes).
  • Advertisement No. 1 of 1996–97 invited applications for 433 Medical Officer (Ayurvedic) posts (389 reserved for Scheduled Castes and 44 for Scheduled Tribes).
  • All posts were in the pay scale of Rs. 2,200–4,000.
  • The petitioners claimed to have passed the B.A.M.S. degree (most in 1993; one petitioner in 1992), to be registered with the Indian Medical Council, and to belong to the general category. They challenged the advertisements as providing 100% reservation for SC/ST and excluding general category candidates.
  • The State's counter-affidavit stated that, of a total cadre of 2470 posts, 2272 posts had been filled and 198 remained vacant; there were about 241 supernumerary posts; 1826 Medical Officers were serving on an ad hoc basis; only 87 of the 2272 filled posts belonged to Scheduled Castes, a proportion the State characterized as very low. By letter dated 24.1.1996 the Government requested the Commission to take steps to complete the reserved-category quota, referring to the Uttar Pradesh Public Services (Reservation for Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes and Other Backward Classes) Act, 1994 (the Act).
  • It was not disputed before the Court that no recruitment advertisement had been published after 1988 until the impugned advertisements in 1995–96 and 1996–97.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the respondents could lawfully initiate a special recruitment drive to fill up the entire backlog of reserved-quota posts in respect of the entire cadre of Medical Officers (Ayurvedic/Unani) by issuing advertisements that provided effectively 100% reservation for Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes.
  2. Whether the manner in which the special recruitment drive was undertaken (by issuing advertisements excluding general category candidates) was in accordance with the provisions of the Uttar Pradesh Public Services (Reservation...) Act, 1994 and consistent with Articles 14, 15 and 16 of the Constitution of India (including the principles in Indra Sawhney and subsequent Supreme Court decisions).

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments (as advanced by Shri S.C. Budhwar)

  • The special recruitment drive advertised (providing 100% reservation for SC/ST) could not be legally undertaken by the respondents and is not in accordance with the Act or the Constitution.
  • The action was arbitrary and violative of Article 14 of the Constitution.
  • Direct recruitment intended to give effect to reservation must be in relation to vacancies arising in the year of recruitment and cannot be initiated by treating the entire cadre as the unit to be filled through a special drive.
  • Reliance was placed on Indra Sawhney v. Union of India and the Post Graduate Institute of Medical Education & Research, Chandigarh v. Faculty Association decisions to support these contentions.

Respondents' / Applicants' Arguments (as advanced by Shri B.D. Mandhyan and State counsel)

  • The special recruitment drive did not violate constitutional provisions; it was aimed at remedying a very low representation of SC/ST candidates (87 out of 2272 filled posts, about 5%).
  • The Uttar Pradesh Act, 1994 contains provisions authorizing special recruitment to remove backlog and the State's requisition to the Commission was in accordance with that Act.
  • Subsequent Supreme Court decisions, including R.K. Sabbarwal and others, interpret Indra Sawhney and support the legality of steps taken to remove backlog; reliance was placed on several Supreme Court decisions (R.K. Sabbarwal; State of U.P. v. Dina Nath Shukla; Ashok Kumar Gupta v. State of U.P.; Jagdish Negi v. State of U.P.).
  • The State maintained that its request to the Commission to initiate a special recruitment drive was lawful and consonant with constitutional and statutory provisions.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court in This Opinion
Indra Sawhney v. Union of India, 1992 Supp (3) SCC 217 : AIR 1993 SC 477 Establishes the principles on reservation limits (not exceeding 50%) and holds that, for application of the 50% rule, a year should be taken as the unit (to preserve equality of opportunity under Article 16). The Court relied on Indra Sawhney to interpret the Act and to conclude that special recruitment must follow a direct recruitment open to all categories; it used Indra Sawhney's year-as-unit principle to reject a scheme that effectively sought to fill backlog by excluding general-category candidates across the cadre.
Post Graduate Institute of Medical Education & Research, Chandigarh v. Faculty Association, JT 1998 (3) SC 223 Constitution Bench considerations on reservation, including the impropriety of making a single post 100% reserved to the exclusion of others; requirement to balance Articles 14, 15 and 16. The Court cited the PGI judgment (paras 30–33) to show that exclusive or cent per cent reservation for particular posts (or cadres) is impermissible; it relied on the PGI decision's emphasis on balance between reservation and equality to conclude the impugned 100% reservation could not be sustained.
R.K. Sabharwal v. State of Punjab, (1995) 2 SCC 745 : AIR 1995 SC 1371 One of the post-Indra Sawhney authorities interpreting reservation jurisprudence (relied upon by respondents). The Court noted that the respondents placed strong reliance on R.K. Sabharwal (and similar authorities); however, the Constitution Bench decision in PGI had considered and addressed such subsequent judgments in the context of reservation limits.
State of U.P. v. Dina Nath Shukla, JT 1997 (2) SC 467 A post-Indra Sawhney decision relied upon by respondents on reservation issues. The Court recorded that respondents relied on this case; the Court observed that the PGI Constitution Bench had considered judgments such as this one when addressing the broader issue of permissible reservation practice.
Ashok Kumar Gupta v. State of U.P., JT 1997 (4) SC 251 Another Supreme Court decision interpreting reservation principles (cited by respondents). The Court noted reliance on this authority by the respondents; the Court nonetheless applied the statutory text and the controlling principles from Indra Sawhney and PGI to reach its conclusion.
Jagdish Negi v. State of U.P., (1997) 7 SCC 203 : AIR 1997 SC 3505 Authority cited by respondents on reservation-related questions. The Court recorded respondent reliance and treated PGI/Indra Sawhney principles as determinative in testing the legality of the impugned advertisements.
Balaji (Balqji) — AIR 1963 SC 649; Devadasan — AIR 1964 SC 179; Thomas — (1976) 2 SCC 310 : AIR 1976 SC 490 Earlier Supreme Court decisions referenced in Indra Sawhney and PGI regarding the unit for applying reservation and balancing equality and protective measures. The Court referenced these historical decisions as discussed in Indra Sawhney/PGI to support the proposition that reservation must be balanced against equality and that treating an entire cadre as a unit to fill backlog may violate equality guarantees.
State of Andhra Pradesh v. U.S.V. Balram, (1972) 1 SCC 660 : AIR 1972 SC 1375 Referenced by PGI as precedent on application of Articles 14/15/16 and reservation principles. The Court cited PGI's references to Balram to underline the constitutional balancing approach; the Court relied on PGI's synthesis rather than treating Balram as independently dispositive here.
C.A. Rajendran v. Union of India & Others, AIR 1968 SC 507 Referenced in PGI and Indra Sawhney in the context of reservation jurisprudence and constitutional balance. The decision was referred to by PGI (and cited within this opinion) to illustrate the principle that reservation must be objectively and reasonably applied; the present Court invoked that jurisprudential context in reaching its conclusion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded by reference to the statutory text of the Uttar Pradesh Public Services (Reservation for Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes and Other Backward Classes) Act, 1994, reproducing Section 3 in full and then analysing subsections (1) through (4) in particular.

Key points in the Court's step-by-step reasoning (as stated in the opinion):

  1. Statutory textual analysis: The Court noted that Section 3(1) prescribes reservation percentages at the stage of direct recruitment and contemplates a roster. Section 3(2) specifically provides that if, in respect of any year of recruitment, vacancies reserved for any category remain unfilled, special recruitment may be made for such number of times (not exceeding three) as may be necessary to fill such vacancies from amongst persons of that category.
  2. Condition precedent to special recruitment: From subsections (2), (3) and (4), the Court concluded that special recruitment is contingent upon a prior process of direct recruitment in respect of the vacancies of a year in which reserved vacancies remained unfilled. The Court emphasized that the scheme in subsection (1) does not contemplate special recruitment as an independent or first-step process.
  3. Interpretive implication: The Court interpreted the phrase "if, even in respect of any year of recruitment" in subsection (2) to mean that special recruitment is a remedial mechanism following an open direct recruitment; therefore, special recruitment providing 100% reservation could only follow a prior recruitment open to all categories.
  4. Application to facts: The Court observed it was not disputed that no recruitment advertisement had been published after 1988 until the impugned advertisements in 1995–96 and 1996–97. Therefore, there had been no intervening direct recruitment open to all categories that could trigger a lawful special recruitment as contemplated by the Act.
  5. Consistency with constitutional jurisprudence: The Court examined the Supreme Court's decisions (particularly Indra Sawhney and the Constitution Bench decision in PGI) and concluded that those authorities preserve the limit that total reservation should not exceed 50% at a given point and require balancing equality (Articles 14/16) with remedial reservation. The Court cited Indra Sawhney's holding that a year should be the unit for applying the 50% rule and PGI's statements that cent per cent reservation for single posts or exclusive reservation that deprives others of opportunity is impermissible.
  6. Conclusion from statutory and constitutional analysis: Given the statutory requirement that special recruitment follow a direct recruitment open for all categories, and given the constitutional requirement to balance reservation and equality (and the rule against exclusive 100% closure of opportunities), the impugned advertisements that effectively provided 100% reservation without an antecedent open recruitment were held to be illegal and arbitrary and in contravention of both the Act and Articles 14, 15 and 16.

Holding and Implications

Core Holding: The writ petition is allowed and the impugned advertisements (Advertisement No. 3 of 1995–96 and Advertisement No. 1 of 1996–97, referred to as Annexures 3 and 4 to the writ petition) are quashed.

Implications and direct consequences (as stated in the opinion):

  • The respondents are permitted to readvertise the posts, but only in accordance with the provisions of the Uttar Pradesh Act, 1994 and in light of the Court's observations in the opinion (i.e., special recruitment must follow a direct recruitment open for all categories and must conform to constitutional limits on reservation).
  • There will be no order as to costs.
  • The opinion does not purport to lay down a new departure from existing Supreme Court precedents; rather, it applies the statutory scheme and the controlling principles from Indra Sawhney and the Constitution Bench decision in PGI to the facts before the Court. (The opinion specifically grounds its decision on the text of the Act and the cited Supreme Court authorities.)

This summary is prepared strictly on the basis of the material contained in the provided opinion. No facts, arguments or holdings have been added beyond those expressly stated in the opinion.

    Dr. Shashi Kant Rai And Others v. State Of U.P And Others

    R.R.K Trivedi, J.:— In this petition counter and rejoinder-affidavits have been exchanged between the parties and learned counsel for the parties have agreed that this petition may be decided finally at this stage.

    2. Two applications for lmpleadment have also been filed. First application is numbered as 71415 of 1997, which has been moved by Ram Swarup Ahirwar and the second application is numbered as 23563 of 1998 which has been moved by Dr. Satish Kumar and three others. Along with the second application, counter-affidavit has also been filed. The important question for determination in this writ petition is as to whether the respondents could legally initiate special recruitment drive to fill up the entire backlog of the posts of reserved quota in respect of the entire cadre of the posts of Medical Officers (Ayurvedic/Unani) in the State of Uttar Pradesh. Respondent No. 2, namely, U.P Public Service Commission, Allahabad, by advertisement No. 3/95-96 invited applications for the 47 posts of Medical Officers (Ayurvedic) out of which 42 posts were reserved for Scheduled Castes and 5 posts for Scheduled Tribes. Another advertisement No. 1 of 1996–97 was issued inviting applications for appointment on 433 posts of Medical Officers (Ayurvedic). Out of the aforesaid 433 posts 389 posts were reserved for Scheduled Castes and 44 posts for Scheduled Tribes. All the posts mentioned in the aforesaid two advertisements are in the pay scale of Rs. 2,200-4,000. Petitioners claimed that they were selected for Bachelor degree of Ayurvedic Medicines and Surgery, in short B.A.M.S, to combined pre-medical test held by the State Government in the year 1987–88 and passed their B.A.M.S degree course in the year 1993 except petitioner No. 4 who had passed the degree course in the year 1992. It has been claimed that all the petitioners passed their B.A.M.S degree from the State Government Ayurvedic Colleges and they have been duly registered with the Indian Medical Council. All the petitioners belonged to general category. As under the impugned advertisements No. 3 of 1995–96 and No. 1 of 1996–97 the candidates of general category have been excluded and 100 per cent reservation in favour of Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes category has been provided, they have approached this Court for quashing the aforesaid advertisements which are Annexures-3 and 4 to the writ petition. It has also been prayed that respondents may be directed to advertise the vacancies in accordance with law and to hold selection from the open market giving equal opportunity to the candidates of the general category also.

    3. Petitioners have stated that after the year 1988, no advertisement was published. The impugned advertisement Nos. 3 of 1995–96 and 1 of 1996–97 have been published for the first time illegally enforcing 100 per cent reservation in favour of Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes category. It has been alleged that the aforesaid action in the name of special recruitment drive is wholly illegal and contrary to the Judgments of Hon'ble Supreme Court.

    4. A counter-affidavit has been filed on behalf of the State Government, in paragraph 6 whereof it has been stated that there are total 2470 vacant posts for Medical Officers (Ayurvedic/Unani) out of which 2272 posts have been filled. 198 posts are still vacant. Besides the aforesaid, about 241 supernumerary posts have also been created for accommodating part-time Medical Officers serving in hill areas. 1826 Medical Officers are serving in the department on ad hoc basis. Out of 2272 posts already filled, there are only 87 Medical Officers belonging to Scheduled Castes category. Their percentage is very low, hence in order to fill up the backlog in the quota of reserved category, the Government by letter dated 24.1.1996 requested the Commission to take steps to complete the quota of the aforesaid reserved category. The request made by the Government to initiate special recruitment drive for the aforesaid purpose is in accordance with the provisions contained in the Uttar Pradesh Public Services (Reservation for Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes and Other Backward Classes) Act, 1994 (hereinafter referred to as the Act). The request made by the Government does not suffer from any error of law and is in consonance with the provisions of the Constitution. In paragraphs 12, 17 and 18 of the counter-affidavit, it has been averred that the special recruitment drive requisition has been sent to the Commission in accordance with the provisions of the Constitution and the Act to fill the backlog of reserved category of Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes. It has not been disputed that after 1988 no other advertisement was published.

    5. We have heard Shri S.C Budhwar, learned senior advocate, assisted by Shrl Arun Tandon for the petitioners, learned standing counsel and Shri V.M Sahai for respondents and Shri B.D Mandhyan and Shrl S.K Gupta for the applicants for implead ment.

    6. Shri S.C Budhwar, learned counsel appearing for the petitioners, has submitted that the special recruitment drive through the impugned advertisements providing 100 per cent reservation could not be legally undertaken by the respondents and the action is neither in accordance with the provisions of the Act nor in consonance with the provisions contained in the Constitution. Learned counsel has submitted that the action of the respondents is wholly arbitrary and violative of Article 14 of the Constitution of India. It has been further submitted that direct recruitment for giving effect to the policy of reservation could only be against the vacancies with regard to the year of recruitment and it could not be legally initiated taking into account the entire posts belonging to the cadre. Reliance has been placed by the learned counsel for petitioners in case of Indra Sawhney v. Union of India, 1992 Supp (3) SCC 217 : AIR 1993 SC 477 and Post Graduate Institute of Medical Education and Research, Chandigarh v. Faculty Association, JT 1998 (3) SC 223.

    7. Shri B.D Mandhyan, on the other hand, submitted that the special recruitment drive initiated by the State Government does not violate any constitutional provision. The representation for Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes in the service is only 5 per cent as there are only 87 doctors of this category out of 2272. The U.P Act No. 4 of 1994 contains provision for such special recruitment drive to remove the backlog. It has also been submitted that Indra Sawhney's case has been considered and interpreted in subsequent judgments of Hon'ble Supreme Court and the action on the part of the respondents is fully Justified. Reliance has been placed in case of R.K Sabbarwal v. State of Punjab, (1995) 2 SCC 745 : AIR 1995 SC 1371; State of U.P v. Dr. Dtna Nath Shukla, JT 1997 (2) SC 467; Ashok Kumar Gupta v. State of U.P, JT 1997 (4) SC 251 and Jagdish Negi v. State of U.P, (1997) 7 SCC 203 : AIR 1997 SC 3505. The submissions of the learned counsel for the respondents were more or less on the same line as stated above.

    8. We have thoroughly considered the submissions made by the learned counsel for the parties. In our opinion, it has to be seen first as to whether special recruitment drive directed by respondent No. 1 and initiated by respondent No. 2 is in consonance with the provisions of the Act. Section 3 of the Act is very relevant for the purpose which is being reproduced below:

    “3. Reservation in favour of Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes and Other Backward Classes.— (1) In public services and posts, there shall be reserved at the stage of direct recruitment, the following percentage of vacancies to which recruitments are to be made in accordance with the roster referred to in sub-section (5) in favour of the persons belonging to Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes and Other Backward Classes of citizens—

    (a) in the case of Scheduled Castestwenty-one per cent;

    (b) in the case of Scheduled Tribestwo per cent:

    (c) in the case of other backwardtwenty-seven per cent: classes of citizens

    Provided that the reservation under clause (c) shall not apply to the category of other backward classes of citizens specified in Schedule II.

    (2) If, even in respect of any year of recruitment, any vacancy reserved for any category of persons under sub-section (1) remains unfilled, special recruitment shall be made for such number of times, not exceeding three, as may be considered necessary to fill such vacancy from amongst the persons belonging to that category.

    (3) If, in the third such recruitment referred to in sub-section (2), suitable candidates belonging to the Scheduled Tribes are not available to fill the vacancy reserved for them, such vacancy shall be filled by persons belonging to the Scheduled Castes.

    (4) Where, due to non-availability of suitable candidates any of the vacancies reserved under sub-section (1) remains unfilled even after special recruitment referred to in sub-section (2), it may be carried over to the next year commencing from first of July, in which recruitment is to be made, subject to the condition that in that year total reservation of vacancies for all categories of persons mentioned in sub-section (1) shall not exceed fifty per cent of the total vacancies.

    (5) The State Government shall, for applying the reservation under subsection (1), by a notified order, issue a roster which shall be continuously applied till it is exhausted.

    (6) If a person belonging to any of the categories mentioned in subsection (1), gets selected on the basis of merit in an open competition with general candidates, he shall not be adjusted against the vacancies reserved for such category under sub-section (1).

    (7) If, on the date of commencement of this Act, reservation was in force under Government Orders for appointment to posts to be filled by promotion, such Government Orders shall continue to be applicable till they are modified or revoked.”

    9. From perusal of sub-sections (2), (3) and (4) of Section 3 of the Act, it is apparent that the special recruitment can be made for such number of times not exceeding three, as may be considered necessary to fill such vacancies from amongst the persons belonging to that category, provided that in the direct recruitment contemplated under sub-section (1) of Section 3 for vacancies reserved for any category of persons remain unfilled. Thus, for initiating a special recruitment drive, it is necessary that there should have been a process of direct recruitment in respect of the different services and posts as contemplated under sub-section (1) of Section 3. The scheme provided under sub-section (1) does not contemplate a special recruitment independently. For such a move, the condition precedent appears to be an effort of direct recruitment under sub-section (1) in which the vacancy reserved for any category of persons mentioned therein remained unfilled. The words, ‘if, even in respect of any year of recruitment’ used in sub-section (2) suggest that the procedure of special recruitment can be adopted both in case of direct recruitment in respect of the vacancies of any year of recruitment or otherwise. Thus, special recruitment providing 100 per cent reservation in favour of a reserved category could only follow a recruitment already undertaken open for all the categories.

    10. In the present case, it is not disputed that after 1988 there was no advertisement for recruitment of medical officers (Ayurvedic/Unanl). After 8 years, the impugned advertisements have been published providing 100 per cent reservation in favour of a particular category which, in our opinion, is not in accordance with the provisions of the Act. The legislative intent appears to be that the special recruitment providing 100 per cent reservation should only be initiated after the candidates of all the categories including general category had already availed the opportunity to seek appointment in their categories. The aforesaid legislative intent may be further ascertained from the provisions contained in sub-section (4) which provides that where due to non-availabillty of suitable candidates in all the vacancies reserved under sub-section (1) remained unfilled, even after special recruitment referred to in sub-section (2), it may be carried over to the next year commencing from first of July in which recruitment is to be made, however, it has been made subject to the condition that in that year total reservation of vacancies for all categories of persons mentioned in sub-section (1) shall not exceed 50 per cent of the total vacancies. In our opinion, the impugned advertisements providing 100 per cent reservation in favour of a particular category in absence of a direct recruitment as contemplated under sub-section (1) of Section 3, of the Act, is wholly illegal, arbitrary and in contravention of the provisions of the Act. The controversy may also be tested on the basis of the judgments of Hon'ble Supreme Court. In Indra Sawhney v. Union of India, (supra) while considering question No. 6 which was relating to the extent of reservation which can be made, Hon'ble B.P Jeevan Reddy, J., who delivered the majority judgment, held in para 96 as under:

    “96. The next aspect of this question is whether a year should be taken as the unit or the total strength of the cadre, for the purpose of applying the 50% rule. Balqji, AIR 1963 SC 649, does not deal with this aspect but Devadasan, AIR 1964 SC 179, (majority opinion) does. Mudholkar, J., speaking for the majority says:

    “We would like to emphasise that the guarantee contained in Article 16(1) is for ensuring equality of opportunity for all citizens relating to employment, and to appointments to any office under the State. This means that on every occasion for recruitment the State should see that all citizens are treated equally. The guarantee is to each individual citizen and, therefore, every citizen who is seeking employment or appointment to an office under the State is entitled to be afforded an opportunity for seeking such employment or appointment whenever it is intended to be filled. In order to effectuate the guarantee each year of recruitment will have to be considered by itself and the reservation for backward communities should not be so excessive as to create a monopoly or to disturb unduly the legitimate claims of other communities.”

    “On the other hand is the approach adopted by Ray, C.J, in Thomas, (1976) 2 SCC 310 : AIR 1976 SC 490. While not disputing the correctness of the 50% rule he seems to apply it to the entire service as such. In our opinion, the approach adopted by Ray, C.J would not be consistent with Article 16. True it is that the backward classes, who are victims of historical social injustice, which has not ceased fully as yet, are not properly represented in the services under the State but it may not be possible to redress this imbalance in one go, Le., in a year or two. The position can be better explained by taking an illustration. Take a unit/service/cadre comprising 1000 posts. The reservation in favour of Scheduled Tribes, Scheduled Castes and Other Backward Classes is 50% which means that out of the 1000 posts 500 must be held by the members of these classes, Le., 270 by other backward classes, 150 by Scheduled Castes and 80 by Scheduled Tribes. At a given point of time, let us say the number of members of O.B Cs. in the unit/service/category is only 50, a short fall of 220. Similarly the number of members of Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes is only 20 and 5 respectively, shortfall of 130 and 75. If the entire service/cadre is taken as a unit and the backlog is sought to be made up, then the open competition channel has to be choked altogether for a number of years until the number of members of all backward classes reaches 500, Le., till the quota meant for each of them is filled up. This may take quite a number of years because the number of vacancies arising each year are not many. Meanwhile, the members of open competition category would become age-barred and ineligible. Equality of opportunity in their case would become a mere mirage. It must be remembered that the equality of opportunity guaranteed by clause (1) is to each individual citizen of the country while clause (4) contemplates special provision being made in favour of socially disadvantaged classes. Both must be balanced against each other. Neither should be allowed to eclipse the other. For the above reason, we hold that for the purpose of applying the rule of 50% a year should be taken as the unit and not the entire strength of the cadre, service or the unit, as the case may be,”

    After the Judgment in Indra Sawhney's case, (supra), the State Legislature enacted U.P Act No. 4 of 1994. Section 3(2) of the Act provides for special recruitment but in order to preserve the equality clause and to provide equal opportunity to all segments of the society, the condition has been imposed that special recruitment should follow a direct recruitment open for all categories. In other words, it may be said that the ratio in the judgment of Indra Sawhney's case that at a given time, there should not be reservation for more than 50% has been preserved. If the special recruitment follows direct recruitment open for all categories and the vacancy reserved for any category of persons remains unfilled, then the special recruitment could be taken and in that case persons belonging to other categories could not have any complaint as to the extent of their quota in that particular recruitment they have already availed opportunity. Learned counsel for the respondent placed strong reliance in judgment of Hon'ble Supreme Court in case of State of U.P v. Dina Nath Shukla, (supra) and other cases. However, recently a Constitution Bench in case of P.G Institute of Medical Education and Research, Chandigarh, (supra) has taken into consideration the judgments relied on by the learned counsel for the respondents. The controversy before Hon'ble Supreme Court was with regard to enforcing reservation where there is a single post. Hon'ble Supreme Court in para 30 of the judgment has observed as under:

    “30. There is no difficulty in appreciating that there is need for reservation for the members of the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes and Other Backward Classes and such reservation is not confined to the initial appointment in a cadre but also to the appointment in promotional post. It cannot however, be lost sight of that in the anxiety for such reservation for the backward classes, a situation should not be brought by which the chance of appointment is completely taken away so far as the members of other segments of the society are concerned by making such single post cent per cent reserved for the reserved categories to the exclusion of other members of the community even when such member is senior in service and is otherwise more meritorious.”

    In para 31 it has been further observed as under:

    “31. Articles 14, 15 and 16 including Articles 16(4) and 16(4A) must be applied in such a manner so that the balance is struck in the matter of appointments by creating reasonable opportunities for the reserved classes and also for the other members of the community who do not belong to reserved classes. Such view has been indicated in the Constitution Bench decisions of this Court in Balaji's case, Devadasan's case and Sabharwal's case. Even in Indra Sawhney's case, the same view has been held by indicating that only a limited reservation not exceeding 50% is permissible. It is to be appreciated that Article 15(4) is an enabling provision like Article 16(4) and the reservation under either provision should not exceed-legitimate limits. In making reservations for the backward classes, the State cannot ignore the fundamental rights of the rest of citizens. The special provision under Article 15(4) must therefore, strike a balance between several relevant considerations and proceed objectively. In this connection reference may be made to the decisions of this Court in State of Andhra Pradesh v. U.S.V Balram, (1972) 1 SCC 660 : AIR 1972 SC 1375 and C.A Rajendran v. Union Of India & Others, AIR 1968 SC 507. It has been indicated in Indra Sawhney's case, (supra) that clause (4) of Article 16 is not in the nature of an exception to clauses (1) and (2) of Article 16 but an instance of classification permitted by clause (1). It has also been indicated in the said decision that clause (4) of Article 16 does not cover the entire field covered by clauses (1) and (2) of Article 16. In Indra Sawhney's case this Court has also indicated that in the interests of the backward classes of citizens, the State cannot reserve all the appointment under the State or even a majority of them. The doctrine of equality such a manner that the latter while surveying the case of backward classes shall not unreasonably encroach upon the field of equality.”

    In para 33, it has been provided as under:

    “33. In a single post cadre, reservation at any point of time on account of rotation of roster is bound to bring about a situation where such single post in the cadre will be kept reserved exclusively for the members of the backward classes and in total exclusion of the general members of the public and cent per cent reservation for the backward classes is not permissible within the constitutional frame work. The decisions of this Court to this effect over the decades have been consistent.”

    11. In our opinion, in view of the judgment of Hon'ble Supreme Court mentioned above, 100% reservation provided for backward and Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes categories by the impugned advertisements is not only in contravention of the provisions of the Act but it also offends the equality clause contained in Articles 14, 15 and 16 of the Constitution and thus cannot be sustained.

    12. For the reasons stated above, this writ petition is allowed. The impugned advertisement Nos. 3 of 1995–96 and 1 of 1996–97. Annexures 3 and 4 to the writ petition, are quashed. However, it shall be open to the respondents to readvertlse the posts in accordance with the provisions of the Act and in the light of the observations made above. There will be no order as to Costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Dr. Shashi Kant Rai And Others v. State Of U.P And Others
    (May 20, 1998)