Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of S. 2(oo) of the Industrial Disputes Act (Central)
  • INDUSTRIAL DISPUTES ACT
  • Art. 23 of the Contract Act.3.
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of S. 2(oo) of the Industrial Disputes Act (Central)
  • INDUSTRIAL DISPUTES ACT
  • Art. 23 of the Contract Act.3.
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Provided Legal Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The services of the workman (respondent) were terminated by his employer, Scooters India Ltd., under Standing Order 9.3.12, which provided that a workman absent from duty without leave for more than ten consecutive days would be deemed to have left the services and his name struck off the rolls. The workman raised an industrial dispute. The Presiding Officer of the Labour Court at Lucknow awarded that the termination amounted to retrenchment and directed that the workman be deemed continued in service with entitlement to full back wages.

The employer filed a writ petition challenging the Labour Court's award. The opinion reviews prior litigation involving similar standing orders (including High Court and Supreme Court decisions) and considers statutory provisions (S.2(oo) of the Industrial Disputes Act and the later insertion of clause (bb)) bearing on whether such termination amounts to "retrenchment."

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether termination of services under Standing Order 9.3.12, by treating absence exceeding ten consecutive days as automatic termination, amounted to "retrenchment" within the meaning of S.2(oo) of the Industrial Disputes Act.
  2. Whether a clause in Certified Standing Orders that effects automatic termination without providing an opportunity of hearing is valid, or whether it is contrary to principles of natural justice (audi alteram partem) and must be treated as invalid or read down to include an opportunity to be heard.
  3. Whether the exceptions introduced by insertion of clause (bb) in S.2(oo) (termination for continued ill-health or non-renewal of a fixed-term contract) apply to the present facts where the employee was a permanent employee and not under a fixed-term contract.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Vijai E.V. Eldred v. Scooters India Ltd. [1992 S.C.D. (1) 484] Observed that clause 9.3.12 conferred arbitrary, unbridled power on management to treat services as terminated after ten days' absence; held such power violated natural justice and was opposed to public policy (Art. 23 of the Contract Act). The opinion cites this decision to show an earlier view that Standing Order 9.3.12 was objectionable for denying an opportunity to show cause. The decision is discussed as part of the historical treatment of the clause.
Scooters India Ltd. v. Vijai E.V. Eldred (Civil Appeal No. 3486 of 1992; S.L.P. (C.) No. 14812 of 1992) — Supreme Court Held that the High Court should not have entertained the writ petition on an industrial dispute involving disputed questions of fact and that delay/laches (over six years) warranted dismissal; the Supreme Court set aside the High Court's order (including the High Court's declaration on clause 9.3.12) on these procedural grounds. The opinion recounts this outcome to explain that the earlier High Court's invalidation of the standing order was set aside by the Supreme Court on procedural grounds rather than on the merits of the automatic-termination question.
Uptron India Ltd. v. Shammi Bhan [1998 (2) L.L.N. 959] Clarified that the earlier Scooters India judgment did not decide the legal validity of clauses for automatic termination; held that any clause in Certified Standing Orders providing for automatic termination of a permanent employee's service (not directly related to production) would be bad if it did not provide an opportunity of hearing. Also considered S.2(oo) and the exceptions in clause (bb) to the definition of "retrenchment." The opinion relies on Uptron as the authoritative statement that automatic termination clauses in Standing Orders must afford a hearing; it applies Uptron's analysis to conclude the Standing Order here must be read to include an opportunity to show cause and that the Labour Court correctly treated the termination as retrenchment.
Escorts Ltd. v. Presiding Officer [1997 (3) L.L.N. 65] Used to support the interpretation of clause (bb) of S.2(oo): that the contract of employment referred to must be a fixed-term contract containing a stipulation for termination before expiry, and that clause (bb) applies only in such fixed-term contract contexts. The opinion cites Escorts as supportive authority for the construction of clause (bb), and uses that construction to conclude that clause (bb)'s exceptions do not apply where the employee is a permanent employee without a fixed-term contract.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court's analysis proceeds in the following steps, applying statutory language and relevant precedents to the present facts:

  1. Identification of the operative Standing Order: The termination arose under Standing Order 9.3.12, which provided for deeming a workman to have left service if absent without leave for more than ten consecutive days.
  2. Labour Court finding upheld: The Labour Court held that the automatic termination effected under the Standing Order amounted to "retrenchment" and therefore required application of the rules governing retrenchment (including observance of natural justice); it directed reinstatement with back wages.
  3. Review of prior decisions: The Court reviewed prior authorities. It noted that an earlier High Court decision had declared the clause invalid but that the Supreme Court subsequently set aside that High Court judgment on procedural grounds (that the High Court wrongly entertained the writ petition and because of delay). The Court further considered the later Supreme Court decision in Uptron which expressly addressed the validity of automatic-termination clauses.
  4. Legal principle from Uptron: The Court relied on Uptron's clear statement that a Certified Standing Order clause providing for automatic termination of a permanent employee's service (not related to production) is invalid if it does not provide an opportunity of hearing. The Court emphasized that the Scooters India Supreme Court outcome did not adjudicate the validity point and thus did not overrule the reasoning that automatic termination without hearing is objectionable.
  5. Statutory framework — S.2(oo) and clause (bb): The Court examined the definition of "retrenchment" in S.2(oo) and the exceptions introduced by clause (bb) (post-1984 amendment) which exclude termination for continued ill-health or non-renewal/termination in pursuance of a stipulation in a fixed-term contract. The Court analysed clause (bb) (echoing the interpretation in Escorts) and concluded that clause (bb) applies only where there is a fixed-term contract or the termination is in pursuance of a stipulation in such a contract.
  6. Application to present facts: The petitioner was a permanent employee (not under a fixed-term contract). Therefore the exceptions in clause (bb) did not apply. The Standing Order did not provide any mechanism to give the workman a hearing or opportunity to show cause. That lack violated the principles of natural justice (audi alteram partem) and Article 14 was invoked as embodying those principles in administrative action.
  7. Reading-in remedy rather than striking-down: Instead of declaring Standing Order 9.3.12 wholly ultra vires, the Court read into the Standing Order an obligation to afford a reasonable opportunity to the workman to show cause against termination. On that basis the Court agreed with the Labour Court that the automatic termination, effected without a hearing, amounted to retrenchment, and that the Labour Court's remedy (reinstatement with back wages) was correct.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The writ petition filed by Scooters India Ltd. is dismissed. The Labour Court's award—that the automatic termination under Standing Order 9.3.12 amounted to retrenchment and that the workman should be reinstated with full back wages—is upheld. The interim order is vacated.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: The workman is to be treated as having been retrenched unlawfully when terminated under the Standing Order without being given an opportunity to show cause; the Labour Court's direction for reinstatement with back wages is sustained by this Court.
  • Treatment of Standing Orders: The Court did not declare Standing Order 9.3.12 wholly void; rather, it held that the Standing Order must be read to include a requirement that a permanent workman be given a reasonable opportunity of hearing before his services can be treated as terminated. In other words, automatic termination without a show-cause opportunity cannot stand as applied to permanent employees (unless other statutory exceptions clearly apply).
  • Interaction with statute and precedent: The decision applies and follows the Supreme Court's reasoning in Uptron regarding the necessity of an opportunity to be heard, and it applies the statutory definition of "retrenchment" and the limited reach of the clause (bb) exceptions to conclude those exceptions do not shelter the employer in the present facts.
  • Precedential note: The opinion applies established authorities (as discussed in the body of the judgment) and does not state that it is establishing a novel or broader precedent beyond the application of the principles derived from the cited Supreme Court decisions and statutory interpretation to the present facts.

    Scooters India, Ltd. v. Labour Court And Another

    1. The services of the workman respondent 2 were terminated in view of the Standing Order 9.3.12 The Standing Orders are being reproduced as hereunder:

    “9.3.12 Any workman who remains absent from duty without leave, in excess of the period of leave originally sanctioned or subsequently extended for more than 10 consecutive days, he shall be deemed to have left the services of the company of his own accord, without notice, thereby terminating his contract of service with the company and his name will, accordingly, be struck off the rolls.”

    Thereafter an industrial dispute was raised by the workman. The Presiding Officer of the Labour Court at Lucknow in its award held that the termination of the petitioner's services amounted to retrenchment in the eye of law and he must be deemed to be continued in service and he is entitled for full back-wages.

    2. Being aggrieved against the award of the Labour Court, the employer Scooters India, Ltd., has filed the present writ petition. The Standing Order was considered by this Court in the case of Vijai E.V Eldred v. Scooters India, Ltd. [1992 S.C.D (1) 484], wherein it was observed that Cl. 9.3.12 gave arbitrary power in the hands of the management to treat the services of the workman terminated, if the workman failed to attend to his duties for ten consecutive days. The powers vested in the management is unbriddled and uncanalised. It is also obnoxious for the reasons that it violates the principles of natural justice inasmuch as the workman was denied an opportunity to show cause as to what reasons had compelled him in not attending his duties. The Court was of the view that Cl. 9.3.12 of the Standing Orders is opposed to public policy and is hit by Art. 23 of the Contract Act.

    3. The Civil Appeal bearing No. 3486 of 1992 with S.L.P (C.) (No. 14812 of 1992 was filed by the Scooters India, Ltd., before the Hon'ble Supreme Court. The appeal was allowed and the judgment and order of the High Court was set aside resulting into the dismissal of the writ petition filed by the respondent workman in the High Court. It is relevant to reproduce the relevant observation of Hon'ble Supreme Court which indicated the reasons for allowing the appeal and dismissal of the writ petition.

    “The above facts are alone sufficient to indicate that there was no occasion for the High Court to entertain the writ petition directly for adjudication of an industrial dispute involving the termination of disputed question of fact for which remedy under the industrial laws was available to the workman. That apart, the writ petition was filed more than six years after the date on which the cause of action is said to have arisen and there being no cogent explanation for the delay, the writ petition should have been dismissed on the ground of laches alone, it is also extraordinary for the High Court to have held Cl. 9.3.12 of the Standing Orders as invalid. Learned counsel for the respondent rightly made no attempt to support this part of the High Court's order. In view of the fact that we are setting aside the High Court's judgment, we need not deal with this aspect in detail.”

    4. Two years after the said judgment on validity of similar Standing Orders was assailed before the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Uptron India, Ltd. v. Shammi Bhan [1998 (2) L.L.N 959]. The relevant Certified Standing Orders is quoted below:

    “The services of a workman are liable to automatic termination if he overstays on leave without permission for more than seven days. In case of sickness, the medical certificate must be submitted within a week.”

    Paragraph 22 of the judgment in the case of Uptron India Ltd. v. Shammi Bhan [1998 (2) L.L.N 959] (vide supra), Hon'ble Supreme Court had the occasion to reconsider the judgment passed in Civil Appeal No. 3486 of 1992, Scooters India Ltd., v. Vijay E.V Eldred, decided on 10th March 1996. It was urged before the Hon'ble Supreme Court that any stipulation for automatic termination of service made in the Standing Orders could not have been declared to be invalid and in that regard the certain sentences which have been reproduced above were brought to the notice of the Hon'ble Supreme Court.

    5. In Para. 23, at page 963 of the judgment in the case of Uptron India, Ltd. v. Shammi Bhan [1998 (2) L.L.N 959] (vide supra), the Hon'ble Supreme Court has observed:

    “In view of this observation, the question whether the stipulation for automatic termination of services of overstaying the leave would be legally bad or not, was not decided by this Court in the judgment relied upon by Sri Manjoj Swarup. In that judgment the grounds on which the interference was made were different. The judgment of the High Court was set aside on the ground that it could not decide the disputed question of fact in a writ petition and the matter should have been better left be decided by the Industrial Tribunal. Further, the High Court was approached after more than six years of the date on which the cause of action had arisen without there being any cogent explanation for the delay. Sri Manoj Swarup contended that it was conceded by the counsel appearing on behalf of the employee that the provision in the Standing Orders regarding automatic termination of services is not bad. This was endorsed by this Court by observing that

    ‘Learned counsel for the respondent rightly made no attempt to support this part of the High Court's order.”

    This again cannot be treated to be a finding that provision for automatic termination of services can be validly made in the Certified Standing Orders. Even otherwise a wrong concession on a question of law, made by a counsel, is not binding on his client. Such concession cannot constitute a just ground for a binding precedent. The reliance placed by Sri Majoj Swarup, on this judgment, therefore, is wholly out of place.

    It was further observed, in Para. 25, at page 964 of the judgment:

    “In view of the above, we are of the positive opinion that any clause in the Certified Standing Orders providing for automatic termination of service of a permanent employee, not directly related to ‘production’ in a factory or industrial establishment, would be bad if it does not purport to provide an opportunity of hearing to the employee whose services are treated to have come to an end automatically.”

    After holding that by means of the Certified Standing Orders the services cannot be deemed to be terminated automatically, Hon'ble Supreme Court delved into the provisions of S. 2(oo) of the Industrial Disputes Act (Central) which defines retrenchment.

    6. By the amending Act XLIX of 1984, two further exceptions were introduced in the definition by inserting Cl. (bb) with effect from 18 August 1984; one was the termination of service on the ground of continued ill-health of the workman and the other was termination of service on account of non-renewal of the contract of employment on the expiry of the term of that contract. If such contract of employment contained stipulation for termination of service and the services of the workman are terminated in accordance with that stipulation, such termination, according to Cl. (bb) would also not amount to “retrenchment.”

    7. It was further observed in Uptron India, Ltd. [1998 (2) L.L.N 959] (vide supra), in Para. 31, at page 965 of the judgment:

    “From the facts set out above, it would be seen that the respondent was a permanent employee of the petitioner. There was no fixed-term contract of service between them. There was, therefore, no question of services being terminated on the expiry of that contract. In the absence of a fixed-term contract between the parties, the question relating to the second contingency, namely, that the termination was in pursuance of a stipulation to that effect in the contract of employment, does notarise.”

    8. It was further observed, in Para. 32, at page 965 of the said judgment:

    “The contract of employment referred to in the earlier part of Cl. (bb) has to be the same as is referred to in the latter part. This is clear by the use of words ‘such contract’ in the earlier part of this clause. What the clause, therefore, means is that there should have been a contract of employment for a fixed-term between the employer and the workmen containing a stipulation that the services could be terminated even before the expiry of the period of contract. If such contract, on the expiry of its original period, is not renewed and the services are terminated as a consequence of that period, it would not amount to “retrenchment.’ Similarly, if the services are terminated even before the expiry of the period of contract but in pursuance of a stipulation contained in that contract that the services could be so terminated, then in that case, also, the termination would not amount to ‘retrenchment.’ This view finds support from a decision of this Court in Escorts, Ltd. v. Presiding Officer [1997 (3) L.L.N 65].”

    But as in the case of the workman in Uptron India, Ltd. v. Shammi Bhan (vide supra), this case does not fall in either of the two situations contemplated by Cl. (bb) The “rule of exception,” therefore, is not applicable in the instant case and consequently the finding recorded by the Tribunal on “retrenchment” cannot be disturbed.

    9. In the present case, there is no dispute that at the time, when the services of the petitioner were retrenched, he was a permanent employee working under Scooters India, Ltd. As he overstayed and did not join the duties even after the lapse of 10 days, his services were terminated without giving him any opportunity to show cause. The Standing Order does not provide for giving an opportunity to a workman to show-cause against the absence. Thus, it is evident that Standing Order is against the principles of audi alteram partem which are embodied in Art. 14 of the Constitution of India. If this Court do not read the principles of natural justice in it, then the Standing Order 9.3.12 would be ultra vires. Hence, instead of declaring it as ultra vires, the principles of natural justice can be read, meaning thereby that the services of a permanent workman can only be terminated in accordance with the said Standing Order, if the workman is given a reasonable opportunity to show cause against the termination of his services. That was actually done by the Labour Court which observed that the automatic termination of the services of the petitioner amounted to “retrenchment” as contemplated under S. 2(oo) of the Industrial Disputes Act, and as such principle of natural justice was violated by not giving an opportunity to the petitioner to show cause against his absence The Labour Court rightly directed the reinstatement of the workman into service with back wages. The judgment of the Labour Court has illustrated correctly the law which was before it and its judgment cannot be faulted. The writ petition is accordingly dismissed. The interim order stands vacated.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Scooters India, Ltd. v. Labour Court And Another
    (May 13, 1998)