AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947, Uttar Pradesh Dookan aur Vanijya Adhishthan Adhiniyam, 1962, Workmen's Compensation Act, 1923,
  • INDUSTRIAL DISPUTES ACT 1947
  • S. 6N of the Uttar Pradesh Act read with S. 25F of the Industrial Disputes Act (hereinafter referred to as the Central Act).
  • Sub-sec. (2) of S. 122 of the Uttar Pradesh Co-operative Societies Act, 1965 (Uttar Pradesh Act No. 11 of 1966).
  • S. 2(s) of the Uttar Pradesh Industrial Disputes Act (hereinafter referred to as the Uttar Pradesh Act).
  • S. 135 of the Uttar Pradesh Co-operative Societies Act, 1965,
  • Regulations the provisions of the Industrial Disputes Act
  • provisions of the Central Act and Uttar Pradesh Act
  • Uttar Pradesh Act No. 49 of 1984, regulation 5{ii)
  • Uttar Pradesh Industrial Disputes Act in S. 2(s)
  • Section 122 of the Co-operative Societies Act
  • provisions of the Co-operative Societies Act
  • Co-operative Societies Act, 1965, in S. 1(3)
  • Cl. (bb) of S. 2(oo) of the Central Act,
  • Central Act and Uttar Pradesh Act
  • S. 2(g) of the Uttar Pradesh Act,
  • S. 6N of the Uttar Pradesh Act,
  • S. 2(g) of Uttar Pradesh Act
  • S. 2(s) of Uttar Pradesh Act
  • Uttar Pradesh Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947, Uttar Pradesh Dookan aur Vanijya Adhishthan Adhiniyam, 1962, Workmen's Compensation Act, 1923,
  • INDUSTRIAL DISPUTES ACT 1947
  • S. 6N of the Uttar Pradesh Act read with S. 25F of the Industrial Disputes Act (hereinafter referred to as the Central Act).
  • Sub-sec. (2) of S. 122 of the Uttar Pradesh Co-operative Societies Act, 1965 (Uttar Pradesh Act No. 11 of 1966).
  • S. 2(s) of the Uttar Pradesh Industrial Disputes Act (hereinafter referred to as the Uttar Pradesh Act).
  • S. 135 of the Uttar Pradesh Co-operative Societies Act, 1965,
  • Regulations the provisions of the Industrial Disputes Act
  • provisions of the Central Act and Uttar Pradesh Act
  • Uttar Pradesh Act No. 49 of 1984, regulation 5{ii)
  • Uttar Pradesh Industrial Disputes Act in S. 2(s)
  • Section 122 of the Co-operative Societies Act
  • provisions of the Co-operative Societies Act
  • Co-operative Societies Act, 1965, in S. 1(3)
  • Cl. (bb) of S. 2(oo) of the Central Act,
  • Central Act and Uttar Pradesh Act
  • S. 2(g) of the Uttar Pradesh Act,
  • S. 6N of the Uttar Pradesh Act,
  • S. 2(g) of Uttar Pradesh Act
  • S. 2(s) of Uttar Pradesh Act
  • Uttar Pradesh Act
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner was repeatedly appointed on an ad hoc/temporary basis by respondent 2. His service ceased with effect from July 19, 1985; no written termination order was issued, and the termination was not for misconduct. The petitioner contended that this termination amounted to retrenchment under S.2(s) of the Uttar Pradesh Industrial Disputes Act and, because he was in continuous employment under S.2(g) of that Act, he was entitled to retrenchment compensation and one month's notice pay in lieu thereof. He raised a dispute which resulted in Adjudication Case No. 28 of 1987 before the Industrial Tribunal (2) Uttar Pradesh, Lucknow. The Tribunal (by award dated October 18, 1988) found the petitioner to be in continuous service and that the termination amounted to retrenchment, but refused to direct reinstatement with back-wages; instead it directed payment of compensation for years of service together with notice pay due on July 19, 1985 and interest at 12% per annum until payment. The petitioner impugned that portion of the award refusing reinstatement with back-wages by filing the present writ petition.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the petitioner's cessation of service on July 19, 1985 amounted to "retrenchment" under S.2(s) of the Uttar Pradesh Industrial Disputes Act and whether he was entitled to retrenchment compensation and notice pay under S.6N of that Act read with S.25F of the Industrial Disputes Act (Central Act).
  2. Whether the ad hoc/stop-gap appointments given under Regulation 5 (especially clause (iii)) of the Uttar Pradesh Co-operative Societies Employees Service Regulations, 1975 and the non-application clause (Regulation 103) operate to exclude application of the Central Act and the Uttar Pradesh Act (to the extent of inconsistency) so as to render the cessation not a "retrenchment".
  3. Whether, given the above regulatory scheme, the Labour Court/Tribunal could validly direct reinstatement with back-wages when the employee was not recruited in accordance with Regulation 5.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments (as presented by Ms Suman Sirohi)

  • The termination amounted to retrenchment under S.2(s) of the Uttar Pradesh Act and thus attracted mandatory consequences under S.6N of that Act; non-compliance makes the termination void and necessitates setting it aside.
  • Where a retrenchment order is set aside, the normal consequence is reinstatement with back-wages; the Labour Court/Tribunal should have ordered reinstatement with back-wages after finding continuous service (more than 240 days in a year) and unfair labour practice by respondent 2.
  • The Tribunal's finding in Para. 5 (that respondent 2 followed regulations in form but not in spirit and engaged in unfair labour practice) supported an award of reinstatement with back-wages.

Respondent 2's Arguments (as presented by Sri Rakesh Tiwari)

  • The petitioner was appointed repeatedly on ad hoc contracts of limited duration, each requiring fresh application; each such appointment automatically terminated on expiry as per the terms of appointment.
  • Such cessations fall within the exception in Cl. (bb) of the definition of "retrenchment" in S.2(oo) of the Central Act (non-renewal/expiry of contract) and therefore are not "retrenchment".
  • Appointments were made under Regulation 5 of the Regulations (stop-gap/short-term appointments pending recruitment by the Board), and Regulation 103 makes the Regulations prevail over the Industrial Disputes Act and other labour laws to the extent of inconsistency; therefore the Labour Court could not direct reinstatement with back-wages which is not available under those Regulations.
  • The Labour Court's power is to act within the ambit of the law and regulations governing the employee; it cannot grant relief (like reinstatement with back-wages) which is not provided by those Regulations.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Uttar Pradesh State Electricity Board v. Hari Shankar Jain [1978 (2) L.L.N 514] Principle that general law yields to special legislation. Relied upon to support the proposition that the general Industrial Disputes Act yields to special regulations governing co-operative societies.
Mary Seward v. The owner of the Vera Cruz [(1884) 10 A.C 59] Observation that provisions in general law are subject to special law; in case of contradiction, special law prevails. Used to reinforce the rule that special regulations should prevail over general statutes where inconsistency exists.
J.K. Cotton Spinning and Weaving Mills Co. v. State of Uttar Pradesh [A.I.R. 1961 S.C. 1170] Rule that general provisions yield to specific provisions and the intention that specific directions prevail for the matters they cover. Applied to justify that the special Regulations for co-operative societies should govern where they specifically address matters covered generally by the Industrial Disputes Act.
State of Bombay v. Hospital Mazdoor Sabha [A.I.R. 1960 S.C. 610] Authority cited by petitioner but held not helpful because subsequent statutory changes (Cl. (bb), Regulation 5(ii) and Regulation 103) did not exist when decision was rendered. The Court held this decision could not assist the petitioner in view of the later-introduced statutory/regulatory regime.
Hindustan Tin Works (P) Ltd. v. Employees of Hindustan Tin Works (P) Ltd. [1979 (1) L.L.N 6] Concerned the criterion for grant of compensation when retrenchment is held invalid. The Court stated this decision did not apply to present facts because the present case involves statutory/regulatory exceptions to retrenchment rather than the same compensation criterion issue.
Postal Seals Industrial Co-operative Societies, Ltd., Aligarh v. Labour Court II, Lucknow [1971 (22) F.L.R 38] Cited by petitioner but held not attracted to present facts. The Court found the precedent inapplicable on the facts of this case.
Mohan Lal v. Management of M/s Bharat Electronics Ltd. [1981 (2) L.L.N 23] Held that terminations not covered by any exception in S.2(oo) amount to retrenchment and non-compliance with S.25F renders retrenchment void ab initio. Referred to by respondent to support the view that terminations excepted under S.2(oo) are not retrenchment; consistent with the result based on Regulations 5(iii) and 103.
State Bank of India v. N. Sundaramony [1976 (2) L.L.N 5] Proposition that every kind of termination is retrenchment under S.2(oo) (as stated in that case). The Court observed the proposition exists but noted S.2(oo) itself makes exceptions; given regulation 5(iii) and 103, that earlier decision does not aid the petitioner on these facts.
H.D. Singh v. Reserve Bank of India [1985 (2) L.L.N 1037] Authority cited by petitioner but held not helpful given the regulatory exception in this case. The Court found the precedent did not assist the petitioner because regulation 5(iii) read with regulation 103 renders the regulatory exception decisive.
Uttar Pradesh Rajya Sahkari Krishi Evam Graminya Vikas Bank, Ltd. v. Labour Court, Allahabad [1994 (2) L.L.N 296] Held that mere fact that a workman worked more than 240 days as daily-rate employee does not entitle him to regularisation when engaged for fixed periods whose expiry ended employment; such cessations do not fall within S.6N. Applied as supporting authority that successive fixed-term engagements, even if exceeding 240 days in a year, do not necessarily confer retrenchment protections.
Uttar Pradesh State Co-operative Land Development Bank, Ltd. v. Labour Court, Allahabad (ref. Taj Mulik Ansari; SLP No. 7592 of 1993) Held that mere fact of more than 240 days as daily-rate employee does not entitle one to regularisation. Used to support respondent's contention that continuous ad hoc employment under the Regulations does not automatically confer retrenchment rights or regularisation.
ER Jesuratnam v. Union of India [1981 (2) L.L.N 483] Referred to in support of similar propositions regarding fixed-term/daily-rate engagements and non-regularisation. Invoked as an earlier decision consistent with the view that fixed-period engagements do not necessarily attract retrenchment consequences.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded by first identifying the regulatory framework governing the petitioner's employment: the Uttar Pradesh Co-operative Societies Employees Service Regulations, 1975 (notably Regulation 5 and Regulation 103). Regulation 5(iii) authorizes stop-gap appointments by the appointing authority pending selection by the Board for periods not exceeding 180 days (with a possible extension); the third proviso states that such appointments shall cease to have effect on expiry of the original or extended period. The Tribunal had found (Para. 5 of its award) that the petitioner repeatedly obtained fresh ad hoc appointments (typically for 90 days or less) and that the appointments were made in accordance with the letters of Regulation 5; the petitioner did not challenge that factual finding.

The Court noted that under S.2(oo) of the Central Act the definition of "retrenchment" contains an exception (Cl. (bb)) which excludes termination resulting from non-renewal or expiry of the contract of employment. Respondent's counsel relied on this clause to argue that the cessations were not retrenchment. The Court observed that although the Uttar Pradesh Act's definition of "retrenchment" in S.2(s) does not contain that exception, Regulation 103 of the Regulations provides that the Regulations shall prevail to the extent of any inconsistency with the Industrial Disputes Act and other labour laws applicable to co-operative societies—the latter being "general law" while these Regulations are "special law."

The Court analyzed the interplay between the Acts and the Regulations: the Regulations were promulgated under S.121 and S.122 of the Co-operative Societies Act and are a valid exercise of power to govern terms and conditions of service of employees of co-operative societies. The Court applied the established principle (supported by authorities cited in the opinion) that general law yields to special legislation insofar as the special law covers and conflicts with the general law. The existence of S.135 in the Co-operative Societies Act (which contemplates exclusion of the Industrial Disputes Act and the Uttar Pradesh Industrial Disputes Act for co-operative societies) was noted as indicative of legislative intention, even though S.135 had not been brought into force by notification. Thus, Regulation 103, by making the Regulations prevail when inconsistent with the Industrial Disputes Act and other labour laws, rendered the provisions of the Central Act and the Uttar Pradesh Act inoperative to the extent of inconsistency.

Given the undisputed factual finding that the petitioner's appointments were ad hoc/stop-gap appointments under Regulation 5(iii) and ceased upon expiry as envisaged by the Regulations, the Court concluded that the cessations fell within the exception contemplated by Cl. (bb) of S.2(oo) of the Central Act (and, importantly, were regulated by the special Regulations). Consequently, the Court held that the Labour Court/Tribunal was not competent to order reinstatement with back-wages because such a remedy was not available under the Regulations governing the employee; the Tribunal's award limiting relief to payment of compensation and notice pay (with interest) was consistent with the regulatory scheme and the Tribunal's findings. The Court therefore declined to interfere with the award except to direct compliance.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The writ petition is dismissed. The impugned award is not interfered with; respondent 2 is directed to make payment as directed in the award (compensation and notice pay) with interest calculated as ordered until the date of payment.

Implications: The direct effect of the decision is that the petitioner will not be reinstated with back-wages; instead he is entitled only to the monetary relief awarded by the Tribunal (compensation and notice pay with interest). The Court's reasoning rests on the primacy of the special regulatory scheme (Regulation 5 and Regulation 103 of the Uttar Pradesh Co-operative Societies Employees Service Regulations, 1975) over the general provisions of the Industrial Disputes Act and the Uttar Pradesh Industrial Disputes Act to the extent of inconsistency. The opinion does not expressly declare that it establishes a novel legal precedent beyond applying established principles (i.e., special law prevailing over general law); therefore, the decision's immediate consequence is confined to resolving the parties' dispute and directing payment in accordance with the Tribunal's award.

    Vikramaditya Pandey v. Industrial Tribunal (2), Lucknow, And Another

    1. The petitioner's case, inter alia, was mat the petitioner was appointed on ad hoc/temporary basis from time to time respondent 2. His service was terminated with effect from July 19, 1985. No written termination order was felt necessary since his services was ad hoc/temporary. The termination was not the result of any punishment on account of misconduct. Therefore, the termination being termination simpliciter, amounts to retrenchment within meaning of S. 2(s) of the Uttar Pradesh Industrial Disputes Act (hereinafter referred to as the Uttar Pradesh Act). Inasmuch as the petitioner was in continuous employment within meaning of S. 2(g) of the Uttar Pradesh Act, and, as such, is entitled to retrenchment compensation and one month's notice pay in lieu thereof. Neither any notice nor any notice-pay in lieu thereof nor any retrenchment compensation was paid to the petitioner. Therefore, the termination was violative of S. 6N of the Uttar Pradesh Act read with S. 25F of the Industrial Disputes Act (hereinafter referred to as the Central Act). Out of the said termination, a dispute was raised by the petitioner. Upon reference being made, Adjudication Case No. 28 of 1987 was registered before the Industrial Tribunal (2) Uttar Pradesh, Lucknow. The order petitioner filed his claim by means of a written statement submitted in the said case, which is Annexure 2 to the writ petition. Respondent 2 had also filed its written statement, which is Annexure 3 to the writ petition. Rejoinder statement of the petitioner is filed as Annexure 4 to the writ petition. In the course of proceeding witnesses were examined. By an award, dated October 18, 1988, the said Adjudication Case No. 28 of 1987 was disposed of. The said award is Annexure 7 to the writ petition. In the said award though the Tribunal had found that the petitioner was in continuous service within the meaning of S. 2(g) of Uttar Pradesh Act and that the termination amounts to retrenchment, but the Tribunal refused to pass an order for reinstatement with back-wages. On the other hand it had directed payment of compensation assessed for years of service alongwith the notice pay as due on July 19, 1985 together with interest payable, thereon calculated at the rate of 12 per cent per annum till the date of payment. It is this award, dated October 18, 1988, passed in Adjudication Case No. 28 of 1987, has been impugned by the petitioner, by means of present writ petition.

    2. Respondent 2 on the other hand has made out a case in the counter-affidavit that the petitioner was appointed on ad hoc basis from time to time on the basis of his applications for limited period specified in each contract of employment. On the expiry of each such appointment, the petitioner has to make fresh application for fresh appointment and each time fresh ad hoc appointment of limited duration was given. Since the period of appointment was limited, therefore, such appointment stood automatically terminated in terms of stipulation contained in the order of appointment on the expiry of stipulated period. Therefore, there was no termination of employment of the petitioner, which would come within purview of “retrenchment”. It was further contended that such ad hoc appointment was made while awaiting recruitment through the Board, according to the regulation of recruitment and that process of recruitment was continuing during the period when the petitioner was given appointment. Therefore, even assuming but not admitting it was a case of retrenchment, then again mere cannot be any question of reinstatement with “back-wages in view of regulation 5 of Uttar Pradesh Co-operative Societies Employees Service Regulations, 1975 (hereinafter referred to as the said Regulations.) Therefore, the present writ petition should be dismissed.

    3. Ms Suman Sirohi led Sri K.P Agarwal, learned counsel for the petitioner, contends that the order of termination amounts to retrenchment within the meaning of S. 2(s) of Uttar Pradesh Act attracting the consequences of S. 6N of the Uttar Pradesh Act which is mandatory. The non-compliance of those provisions makes the order of termination liable to be set aside. When such an order is set aside the natural consequences is of reinstatement with back-wages and the Labour Court has no alternative but to pass such an order of reinstatement with back-wages. The Labour Court had found that the petitioner had worked for more than 240 days in a year and was in continuous service within the meaning of S. 2(g) of Uttar Pradesh Act. Since the Tribunal had found in favour of the petitioner it ought to have granted the relief, as claimed Therefore, by means of present writ petition only mat part of the order of the Tribunal by which reinstatement with back-wages have been refused, has been challenged. Ms Suman Sirohi, learned counsel for the petitioner, supports the findings of the learned Tribunal she leads me to Para. 5 of the award wherein the learned Tribunal had found mat respondent 2 had been following unfair labour practice, though purporting to follow regulations for recruitment in letters without the spirit. Therefore, it was incumbent upon the Tribunal to order for reinstatement with back-wages.

    4. Sri Rakesh Tiwari, learned counsel for respondent 2, contends that in view of regulation 5 of the said Regulations, no one other than the Board could make recruitment and that too in the manner provided in the said regulation. Admittedly, the petitioner's appointment was made in terms of regulation 5. According to him the appointment was made within the exception provided in such regulation, wherein it was specified that ad hoc appointment of the limited period can be made by the person other man the Board with the approval of the Board. Since such appointment, each of which are fresh, independent, separate and distinct ad hoc appointment of limited period, are exempted within the exception as provided in the definition of “retrenchment” in S. 2(oo); of the Central Act. Therefore, according to him, the cessation of the employment not being termination and having been exception within meaning of retrenchment, as defined in S. 2(oo) of the Act the contention of Ms Sirohi and the finding of the learned Tribunal mat the petitioner is entitled to retrenchment compensation is wholly misconceived. Therefore, there cannot be a question of reinstatement with back-wages. That a part regulation 5 stares on the face, which bars recruitment in the manner other than provided in regulation 5 which would not be justified for the Tribunal to direct reinstatement with back-wages. Therefore, according to him the writ petition should be dismissed. He further contends that in view of regulation 103 of the said Regulations the provisions of the Industrial Disputes Act would yield to the special statute, governing the field.

    5. In order to appreciate the rival contentions, it is necessary to quote regulation 5 which runs as under:

    “5. Recruitment.— (i) Recruitment for all appointments in a co-operative society shall be made through the Board whether the recruitment is—

    (a) direct; or

    (b) by promotion from employees already in the service of the society; or

    (c) by taking on deputation or otherwise a person already in the service of another society, registered or deemed to have been registered under the Act, or a person in employment under a Corporation or an undertaking owned or controlled by the Central or the State Government body Corporate administering a local fund.

    (ii) Notwithstanding anything in Cl. (i) no reference to the Board shall be necessary in the following cases:

    (a) when it is proposed to fill with the concurrence of the Registrar any post by means of deputation of a Government servant; or

    (b) when the managing committee or any other authority competent to make the appointed proposes to fill up, as a stop-gap measure for a period not exceeding six months, a post by promotion from amongst the employees in the just below cadre on the principle of seniority, subject to the rejection of the unfit:

    Provided that any appointment thus made without consultation with the Board, shall, in every case cease, to have effect from the date on which the period of six months expires and the employee promoted to the higher post shall, unless he has already been reverted to his original post within the said period of six months, be deemed to have reverted from that date, to the post held by him immediately before such promotion:

    Provided further that the employee appointed to the higher post under this sub-clause shall, in no circumstances, be promoted under this sub-clause to any still higher post within the said period of six months nor shall be appointed under the sub-clause to the same post again after his reversion under the first provision.

    (iii) The Board may, pending selection for post to be filled in by direct recruitment, permit stop-gap arrangement to be made of the appointing authority for a period not exceeding 180 days:

    Provided that the intimation of such appointment is given to the Board forthwith and it is ensured that proper requisition for the post, as also additional information required by the Board, if any, has been furnished to it:

    Provided further that the Board may in special circumstances and at the request of the appointing authority, extend the period of 180 days by a period not exceeding 120 days:

    Provided also that the appointment made under this clause shall cease to have effect from the date on which the original period or the extended period of appointment under this clause expires”.

    6. Before the Tribunal in the written statement respondent 2 had made out a case that the Service Board had also advertised the vacancies, in which the concerned workman could have participated, claiming relaxation in age on account of his ad hoc work. The petitioner being daily wage ad hoc employee he cannot claim employment through back door unless he participated in the open market competition for direct selection through the Services Board. Admittedly the petitioner was not appointed through the procedure as laid down in regulation 5 and his appointment was made by way of stop-gap arrangement, pending selection for period not exceeding 180 days in terms Cl. (iii) of regulation 5, as quoted above.

    7. It has been found by the learned Tribunal in Para. 5 of the award that the petitioner gave number of applications from time to time for extension of his employment and every time he was given fresh ad hoc appointment for 90 days or less. It has also been found by the learned Tribunal that the said appointment was made following the letters of the said regulation. The third proviso to CI. (iii) of regulation 5, which prescribes that such appointment shall cease to have effect from the date on which the original “period or the extended period of appointment under this clause expires”. The said finding has not been challenged by Ms Sirohi. She has only challenged the other part of the award by which reinstatement with back-wages was not given. Therefore, admittedly the appointment is an appointment within meaning of Cl. (iii) of regulation 5.

    8. In S. 2(oo) of the Central Act, the expression “retrenchment” has been defined. Relying on the said definition Sri Rakesh Tiwari, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the respondent, sought to bring the present termination within the ambit of exceptions made in Cl. (bb) thereof. Admittedly, Cl. (bb) of the said definition excepts termination of service of a workman as a result of non-renewal of the contract of employment or on the expiry of period stipulated in the contract being terminated Therefore, the said appointment, which had ceased to have the effect on the expiry of the period stipulated in terms of the third proviso to regulation 5(iii) of the said Regulations comes within the exception as provided in Cl. (bb) of S. 2(oo) of the Central Act, and, as such, cannot be termed to be “retrenchment”.

    9. But Sri Rakesh Tiwari, had overlooked the fact that the retrenchment has also been defined in the Uttar Pradesh Industrial Disputes Act in S. 2(s) which does not make such an exception. The definition of “retrenchment” in S. 2 (s) comprehends all kinds of termination of service excepting (i) voluntary retirement and retirement on superannuation after attaining the age as stipulated in the contract. Therefore, Sri Rakesh Tiwari, cannot succeed on the said ground.

    10. Now the said regulation governs the service conditions of the employees of a co-operative society and has been made under S. 121 and published under Sub-sec. (2) of S. 122 of the Uttar Pradesh Co-operative Societies Act, 1965 (Uttar Pradesh Act No. 11 of 1966). These regulations govern the special class of the workmen employed in the co-operative societies, while the Industrial Disputes Act govern general class of workmen in the industrial establishment. Therefore, the Industrial Disputes Act is the general law, while the said regulations are special law. The general law yields to special law, is an established principle of law. In the case of Uttar Pradesh State Electricity Board v. Hari Shankar Jain, [1978 (2) L.L.N 514], it was held that the general law shall yield to special legislation. The case of Mary Seward v. The owner of the Vera Crus, [(1884) 10 A.C 59], it was observed that the provisions in the general law would be subject to special law and in case of contradiction special law shall prevail. In the case of J.K Cotton Spinning and Weaving Mills Company v. State of Uttar Pradesh [A.I.R 1961 S.C 1170], it has been held that, “the rule that general provisions should yield to specific provisions is not an arbitrary principle made by lawyers and Judges but springs from the common understanding of men and women that when the same person gives two directions one covering a large number of matters in general and another to only some of them his intention is that these latter directions should prevail as regards these while as regards all the rest the earlier direction should nave effect”. In the present case general law namely the Central Act and Uttar Pradesh Act govern the general workmen in all establishments in general while these regulations govern only the employees of co-operative societies for whom special legislation has been made.

    11. By S. 135 of the Uttar Pradesh Co-operative Societies Act, 1965, it provides that provisions contained in the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 (Act No. 14 of 1947) and the Uttar Pradesh Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 (Utter Pradesh Act No. 18 of 1947) shall not apply to the co-operative societies. The said Co-operative Societies Act, 1965, in S. 1(3) provides that the said Act shall come into force from such date as the State Government may, by notification in the Gazette appoint in this behalf. All the provisions of the Co-operative Societies Act was given effect to by the State Government with effect from January 25, 1968, by notification, dated December 30, 1967, except S. 135. Nothing has been brought to my notice of the effect that S. 135 has been given effect to. But the presence of S. 135 shows the intention of the Legislature that it had intended to exclude the application of the said Industrial Disputes Act and the Uttar Pradesh Industrial Disputes Act Therefore regulation 103 (with which we shall deal at a latter stage) cannot be said to be inconsistent with the scheme of the said Act, as conceive by the Legislature though the Government has not given effect to the same.

    12. Section 121 empowers the Registrar to determine the terms of employment of society, by framing regulation to regulate the amongst other things, conditions of service. Section 122 of the Co-operative Societies Act empowers the State Government to constitute an authority or authorities for the recruitment, training an disciplinary control of the employees and/or to frame regulations regarding recruitment, emoluments, terms and conditions of service including disciplinary control of such employees subject to the provisions contained in S. 70, settlement of disputes between an employee of a society.

    13. Therefore, the special provision regulating the conditions of service can be made so far as the co-operative societies are concerned. Therefore, the regulations framed are valid piece of legislation.

    14. Now under regulation 103 of the said Regulations, specific provision has been made in the following expression:

    “103. The provisions of these regulations to the extent of their inconsistency with any of the provisions of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947, Uttar Pradesh Dookan aur Vanijya Adhishthan Adhiniyam, 1962, Workmen's Compensation Act, 1923, and any other labour laws for the time being in force, if applicable to any co-operative society or class of co-operative societies, shall be deemed to be inoperative”.

    Therefore, the regulation 103, as quoted above, makes it clear mat if there is any inconsistency between the regulation and the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947, and any other labour law for me time being in force, the present regulation shall be applicable and the other laws shall be deemed to be inoperative. Undoubtedly, Uttar Pradesh Act comes within the meaning of other labour laws for the time being in force. On the other hand Industrial Disputes Act has been specifically mentioned Therefore, by virtue of regulation 103 the provisions of the Central Act and Uttar Pradesh Act shall be deemed to be inoperative as soon any inconsistency appears in the application of-the said regulation. Therefore, the contention of Ms Sirohi does not conform to the above situation and, as such, is unacceptable.

    15. In the above situation the decision in the case of State of Bombay v. Hospital Mazdoor Sabha, [A.I.R 1960 S.C 610], cited by Ms Sirohi cannot by of any help. Over and above Cl. (bb) as inserted by Uttar Pradesh Act No. 49 of 1984, regulation 5{ii) and regulation 103 were not in existence when the said decision was rendered. The decision in the case of Hindustan Tin Works (Private), Ltd. v. Employees of Hindustan-Tin Works (Private), Ltd., [1979 (1) L.L.N 6], cited by Ms Sirohi also does not apply, in the facts and circumstances of the case. Inasmuch as in the said case the criterion for the grant of compensation, when the retrenchment is held to be invalid, was under consideration, whereas in the present case there is no retrenchment. Even if there was retrenchment in view of regulation 5 of the said Regulations, the Labour Court was not competent to direct reinstatement of the petitioner, who was not recruited in terms of regulation 5. Inasmuch as the Labour Court has to act within the ambit of law and to have regard to the regulations by which the workmen is governed No relief, which is not available to the workmen in terms of the regulations, by which he is governed cannot be granted by the Labour Court. Similarly, the decision in the case of Postal Seals Industrial Co-operative Societies, Ltd., Aligarh v. Labour Court II, Lucknow, [1971 (22) F.L.R 38], cited by Ms Sirohi is also not attracted in the facts and circumstances of the present case.

    16. The decision in the case of Mohan Lal v. Management Of M/S Bharat Electronics Ltd., Ltd., [1981 (2) L.L.N 23], on the other hand lays down mat the termination of services which are not covered by any exception in S. 2(oo) amounts to retrenchment and non-compliance of S. 25F makes such retrenchment void ab initio. Therefore, the termination which are excepted under S. 2(oo) of the Act are not retrenchment. This decision cited by Sri Rakesh Tiwari supports the view taken above because of regulation 5(iii) and regulation 103. On the facts of the said judgment, in the facts and circumstances of the present case the ratio decided in the case of State Bank of India v. N. Sundaramony, [1976 (2) L.L.N 5], does not come to any assistance of Ms Sirohi. In as much as in the said case the proposition has been laid down that every kind of termination is retrenchment within meaning of S. 2(oo) of the Act. There is no dispute about such proposition. But S. 2(oo) itself makes exception of such termination which are not retrenchment and the present case being one such exception in view of regulations S(iii) and 103, the said decision cannot extend any help to Ms Sirohi with regard to her submissions. Similarly, the ratio decided in the case of H.D Singh v. Reserve Bank of India, [1985 (2) L.L.N 1037], does not held Ms Sirohi, in the facts and circumstances of the present case. Inasmuch as despite findings of the Labour Court that the petitioner had worked for more man 240 days, the termination, being an exception, in view regulation 5(iii) read with regulation 103, does not confer consequential benefit of retrenchment because of his continuous service which becomes irrelevant as soon the termination comes within the exception of Cl. (bb) of S. 2(oo) of the Act. In similar situation the workman who had been engaged for a fixed period and whose service came to an end after expiry of the contract period, though he had worked for more than 240 days due to successive such appointment of the fixed period within a period of 12 months, the cessation of employment does not come within the ambit of S. 6N of the Uttar Pradesh Act, was so held in the case of Uttar Pradesh Rajya Sahkari Krishi Evam Graminya Vikas Bank, Ltd. v. Labour Court, Allahabad, [1994 (2) L.L.N 296] (vide supra). In the case of Uttar Pradesh State Co-operative Land Development Bank, Ltd. v. Labour Court, Allahabad the case of Uttar Pradesh State Co-operative State Land Development Bank v. Taj Mulik Ansari, being Special Leave Petition (Civil) No. 7592 of 1993, as has been referred to in the case of Uttar Pradesh Rajya Sahkari Krishi Evam Graminya Vikas Bank, Ltd. (vide supra), it was held that the mere fact that the workman had put in more than 240 days as dairy-rate employee, does not entitled him for regularisation in his employment. The contention of Sri Rakesh Tiwari also finds support from the decision in the case of ER Jesuratnam v. Union of India, [1981 (2) L.L.N 483], as referred to in the case of Uttar Pradesh Rajya Sahkari Krishi Evam Graminya Vikas Bank, Ltd. (vide supra).

    17. For all these reasons I am not inclined to interfere with the impugned award. The writ petition, therefore, fails and is dismissed. Respondent 2, however, shall make payment of the amount as directed in the impugned award, calculated according to the directions given therein, calculating the interest payable till the date of payment

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Vikramaditya Pandey v. Industrial Tribunal (2), Lucknow, And Another
    (May 9, 1996)