Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Judgment Summary — B.K. Sharma, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

This opinion arises from two criminal appeals heard together against a common judgment dated 1-8-1985 by the Special Judge/Addl. Sessions Judge, Shahjahanpur in S.T. No. 323 of 1984 (connected with S.T. Nos. 368/1984 and 370/1984). The trial Court convicted three accused-appellants for offences under Section 396 IPC (dacoity with murder) and additionally convicted two of them under Section 25 Arms Act for possession of fire-arms. Sentences imposed included life imprisonment for the Section 396 convictions and sentences varying for the Arms Act offences.

The prosecution case was that on 12-2-1984 at about 7:30 P.M. six dacoits attacked in village Kumbhia Maphi (P.S. Khutar, Shahjahanpur). Two licensed guns (No. 89963 belonging to Sunder's brother and No. 2283 belonging to Badshah's father) were looted; Badshah was shot dead and Sunder was injured and later died; another witness (Rampal) sustained lathi injuries. The event occurred on a moonlit night; assailants were identified by witnesses in moonlight and torchlight.

During investigation, Vijai Bahadur (accused-appellant) was arrested on 25-4-84 and later identified at an identification parade (23-5-84). Khan Singh alias Ujagar Khan and Chhotey were arrested on 17-5-84; recoveries were made—licensed gun No. 89963 from Khan Singh and an unlicensed weapon from Chhotey. Identification parades for Khan Singh and Chhotey were held on 30-5-84.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the identification evidence against each accused-appellant (Vijai Bahadur, Khan Singh alias Ujagar Khan, and Chhotey) was reliable and sufficient for conviction under Section 396 IPC, given the circumstances of identification and the presence or absence of link evidence.
  2. Whether recoveries of fire-arms from Khan Singh and Chhotey established offences under the Arms Act (Section 25) and whether the recoveries could support convictions for offences under Section 411 or Section 412 IPC (i.e. receipt/retention of property known or believed to be stolen) or corroborate the Section 396 charge.
  3. What is the effect of the statutory presumption under Section 114 of the Indian Evidence Act (as invoked by recovery evidence) on proof of culpability for offences under Section 396/411/412 IPC, particularly where there is a time gap between occurrence and recovery and absence of link evidence.

Arguments of the Parties

Prosecution's Case / Arguments

  • The prosecution relied on eyewitness identifications (at identification parade and at trial) that the accused-appellants participated in the dacoity and that murder was committed by the dacoits as alleged.
  • Investigating Officer (I.O. K.P. Pandey, PW 11) produced evidence of arrest, identification procedures and recoveries of weapons: licensed gun No. 89963 recovered from Khan Singh and an unlicensed gun from Chhotey; relevant G.D. entry (Ex. ka 26) relating to lodging on 17-5-84 was produced.
  • Prosecution argued that recoveries (particularly of the licensed gun 89963 from Khan Singh) supported conviction for possession/offences under the Arms Act and could raise inferences about the accused's involvement.

Defence's Case / Arguments

  • The defence suggested alternative explanations: that Badshah (son of Deena) and Sunder (brother of Dayaram) had taken the gun to commit the dacoity and that in an encounter they were killed; further alleged collusion with licence-holders and incorrect charge-sheets against accused persons.
  • Defence pointed to procedural deficiencies: delay and exceptional accuracy in identification (six out of six identification), absence of link evidence (no memos of arrest, no clear testimony that accused were kept Baparda and not shown to witnesses between arrest and lodging, no production of constables who transported accused), and gaps in proving custody history.
  • Implicit defence argument: recoveries, where not linked temporally and evidentially to the occurrence, cannot be used to sustain the grave charge of dacoity with murder.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Sheonath v. State Of Uttar Pradesh (1990 Allahabad Criminal Rulings 553; 1990 Cri LJ 2423) Held that an identification performance of "six out of six" can be "too good to be believed" and is suspicious. The Court relied on this principle to treat the uniformly positive identification of Vijai Bahadur (six out of six) as suspect, contributing to rejection of the Section 396 conviction against him.
Mahendra Singh v. State (1991 Cri LJ 1381) Emphasized necessity of link evidence to show the accused were not shown to witnesses between arrest and identification; absence of such link evidence calls for benefit of doubt. The Court applied this authority to find that absence of link evidence for the accused (no proven custody chain, no constables produced, missing G.D. entries) fatally weakened the prosecution case and required giving benefit of doubt on Section 396 charges.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court first accepted the basic facts that a dacoity occurred on 12-2-1984 and that a murder and injuries were caused, and that two licensed weapons had been looted in the incident. The judgment then proceeded to evaluate separately the evidence against each accused-appellant and the legal sufficiency of that evidence for the offences charged.

On identification and link evidence

  • Vijai Bahadur: The only incriminating material against him was identification evidence. He was arrested on 25-4-84 and identified on 23-5-84. The Court held (relying on Sheonath) that the perfect identification performance (six out of six) was "too good to be believed" and suspicious, particularly since the FIR did not disclose any distinguishing features (hulia) of the dacoits. More importantly, link evidence was absent: the Investigating Officer did not adequately prove where, when and by whom the accused was arrested, lodging records, memos, G.D. entries, or who produced him as Baparda to the jail. A recorded statement by the accused before the Magistrate (“POLICE NE MUJHE PAHICHAN KARTAON KO DIKHAYA HAI”) and Ex. ka 33 (memo of identification showing lodging on 26-4-84) indicated gaps in custody history. In view of the lack of link evidence, the Court concluded trial identification could not sustain conviction under Section 396 IPC.
  • Khan Singh and Chhotey: Both arrested 17-5-84 and identified 30-5-84; while the timing of identification was not unduly delayed, the Court found similar fatal lacunae in link evidence. The Investigating Officer's testimony showed accused were made Baparda at the spot and were lodged at the police station (G.D. entry Ex. ka 26), and that they were sent to jail Baparda on 18-5-84; however, the Officer did not account for custody in the interim (no G.D. entries covering the whole period, no production of constables who escorted them, and no clear testimony that no one was allowed to see their faces). Statements by the accused to the identifying Magistrate ("THANE MEN PHOTO KHEECHA GAYA" and Chhotey's claim that witnesses knew him earlier) further complicated reliance on identification without link proof. Consequently, identification evidence alone was insufficient to convict for Section 396 IPC in the absence of link evidence.

On recoveries and presumptions

  • Chhotey: Recovery of an unlicensed (illicit) weapon from Chhotey established an offence under Section 25 Arms Act; however, there was no evidence that this weapon was one of the two licensed guns looted in the instant dacoity. Therefore the recovery did not corroborate a Section 396 charge against him. The Court sustained the Arms Act conviction but set aside the Section 396 conviction due to lack of linking evidence.
  • Khan Singh: Recovery of licensed gun No. 89963 (one of the guns looted in the incident) from Khan Singh was accepted by the Court based on the Investigating Officer's evidence; defence suggestions that others had the gun or collusion lacked supporting circumstances. Nevertheless, because the recovery occurred on 17-5-84 while the occurrence was on 12-2-84 (a substantial time gap) and because link evidence proving continuous custody/chain from arrest to identification was missing, the Court held it would not be proper to draw an inference that the recovery corroborated guilt for the Section 396 offence. The Court analysed the scope of the statutory presumption (Section 114 IEA) available from the recovery: while it would be unsafe to hold him guilty of dacoity with murder on that basis, a presumption could reasonably support a lesser conclusion that he was a receiver of stolen property. Because there was no material to prove that Khan Singh knew or had reason to believe that the gun was transferred by dacoity, the Court would not hold him guilty of the more serious Section 412 offence but found him guilty of Section 411 (possession/receipt of stolen property) — a lesser offence.

On sentences and corrective adjustment

  • The trial Court had not made a separate conviction under Section 412 IPC against Khan Singh because it had accepted the major Section 396 charge; the appellate Court, having set aside Section 396, re-examined the appropriate conviction and sentence and held that Khan Singh should be convicted under Section 411 and sentenced to three years RI.
  • For Chhotey, the Arms Act conviction under Section 25 was maintained; but the appellate Court noted that the period already served and bail admissions meant he had effectively undergone the sentence for that offence and therefore need not surrender.

Holding and Implications

Core Rulings:

  • Criminal Appeal No. 2244 of 1985 (Vijai Bahadur alias Vijai) — Allowed. Conviction under Section 396 IPC set aside; accused acquitted of that offence. Bail bonds cancelled and sureties discharged; accused need not surrender.
  • Criminal Appeal No. 676 of 1988 (Chhotey) — Partly allowed. Conviction under Section 396 IPC set aside and accused acquitted of that charge. Conviction under Section 25 Arms Act maintained. Because of prior custody and bail history, he has effectively served the relevant sentence and need not surrender; bail bonds cancelled and sureties discharged.
  • Criminal Appeal No. 676 of 1988 (Khan Singh alias Ujagar Khan) — Partly allowed. Conviction under Section 396 IPC set aside and accused acquitted of that charge. Convicted under Section 411 IPC and sentenced to undergo three years RI. Conviction under Section 25 Arms Act maintained; given time already spent in custody (specified as seven years and four months), he need not surrender. Bail bonds cancelled and sureties discharged.

Implications: The immediate consequences are the acquittal on the principal charge of dacoity with murder (Section 396 IPC) for all three accused-appellants and maintenance of arms-related convictions where recoveries supported such charges (Chhotey under Section 25 Arms Act; Khan Singh under Section 25 Arms Act as well as conviction for Section 411 based on being a receiver). The Court emphasized that absence of formal link evidence and unexplained custody gaps required giving benefit of doubt on the gravest charge; the Court limited the effect of presumptions arising from recoveries (Section 114 IEA) because of the time gap between occurrence and recovery and lack of connecting evidence. The opinion does not announce any new binding principle beyond applying existing authorities (Sheonath; Mahendra Singh) to the facts; its practical effect is the reallocation of guilt from the Section 396 offences to lesser offences where recoveries and evidence legitimately supported such findings.

Disposition / Directions

The Court directed that a copy of the judgment be sent to the learned Sessions Judge, Shahjahanpur within a week for information and compliance, and that a compliance report be submitted to the High Court within a month.

Note: This summary is drawn exclusively from the text of the provided opinion. Where the opinion did not supply discrete party submissions beyond the prosecution evidence and defence suggestions, the summary reflects only those matters expressly recorded in the judgment.

    Khan Singh Ujagar Khan And Chhotey v. State .

    B.K Sharma, J.:— Both these appeals have been heard together as they arise out of a common judgment dated 1-8-85 passed by Sri P.N Lal, the then Special Judge/Addl. Sessions Judge, Shahjahanpur in S.T No. 323 of 1984, connected with S.T No. 368 of 1984 and S.T No. 370 of 1984, whereby he convicted all the three accused-appellants of the offence under S. 396 IPC and sentenced them to undergo imprisonment for life and further convicted Chhotey accused-appellant and Khan Singh alias Ujagar Khan accused-appellant of the offence under section 25 Arms Act and sentenced Chhotey accused-appellant to undergo six months R.I for the offence under section 25 Arms Act and sentenced Khan Singh alias Ujagar Khan accused-appellant to undergo R.I for one year for the offence under section 25 Arms Act.

    2. The prosecution story was to the effect that a dacoity took place on 12-2-84 at about 7.30 P.M in village Kumbhia Maphi, P.S Khutar, district Shahjahanpur, in which six dacoits participated and they looted licensed gun No. 89963 from Sunder of his brother and looted licensed gun No. 2283 from Badshah, which was of his father, that when the looting was resisted and an alarm was raised and village people were seen coming the dacoits shot Badshah dead and also injured Sunder by firing two shots; that thereafter the dacoits fled away with the looted guns and cartridges; that Rampal witness also received Lathi injuries in the occurrence, that it was moonlit night and that Sunder died later.

    3. The assailants were identified in the moon light and in the light of torches. In another incident of dacoity at the house of Chhotey Lal, in village Kisariapur, police station Sehra Mau North, Chhote Lal snatched above licensed gun No. 2283 from the dacoits and deposited the same at police station Sehra Mau North.

    4. None of the witnesses in the present dacoity knew the dacoits from before. The usual FIR was lodged and the investigation started. During the course of investigation Vijai Bahadur accused-appellant was arrested on 25-4-84 and made Baparda and sent to jail. On 17-5-84 accused appellant Khan Singh alias Ujagar Singh and accused appellant Chhotey both were arrested by the police party led by I.O.K.P Pandey. From the possession of Khan Singh alias Ujagar accused-appellant aforesaid looted licensed gun No. 89963 was recovered and from the possession of Chhotey accused-appellant an unlicensed gun was recovered and from the possession of Ramesh accused (not an accused here) a country-made pistol was recovered. They could not produce any licence for the weapons recovered from their respective possession. The identification proceedings in respect of Vijai Bahadur accused-appellant took place on 23-5-1984 at the district Jail. Therein Vijai Bahadur accused-appellant was correctly identified by all the six witnesses, namely Ram Autar, Madan Lal, Munnu Lal, Puttu Lal, Ahibaran and Rampal, who went for identification. Out of them Ram Autar (PW 1), Madan Lal (PW 2), Munna Lal (PW 4) were produced at the trial and all of them correctly identified Vijai Bahadur accused-appellant at the trial without making any mistake, Chhotey and Khan Singh alias Ujagar Khan accused-appellant were put for test identification on 30-5-1984. Seven persons went to identify them. Out of them five witnesses, namely Ram Autar, Ahibaran, Madan Lal, Munnu Lal and Ram Pal correctly identified these accused-appellant at the identification parade without making any mistake. Out of these witnesses only Ram Autar (PW 1) Madan Lal (P.W 2) find Munna Lal (PW 4) were produced at the trial, where they made positive identification of both the accused-appellants without making any mistake.

    5. The learned Sessions Judge held that a dacoity took place in which a murder took place on the date, time and place as alleged by the prosecution, in which Badshah was shot dead at the spot and Sunder was injured, who died later on due to his fire arm injuries. He also placed on record corroborative fact that one looted licensed gun No. 89963 was recovered from the possession of Khan Singh accused appellant and the other looted gun was snatched in another incident in the circle of another police station subsequently by Chhotey Lal from a gang of dacoits who looted his house. He also believed the identification evidence given by the witnesses at the rial. He also believed the evidence of recovery made by the Investigating Officer from Khan Singh and Chhotey accused-appellants on 17-5-84. Consequently he made the convictions and awarded the sentences noted above.

    6. There is no doubt that two licensed weapons were looted on the date, time and place alleged by the prosecution and in the course of the dacoity murder was also committed by dacoits as claimed by the prosecution.

    7. Coming now to the offence under Section 396 IPC in so far as Vijai Bahadur accused-appellant is concerned, there is only identification evidence against him. As alleged by the prosecution he was arrested on 25-4-84 and was put up for identification on 23-5-84. The identification proceeding may not be said to be unduly delayed but there is substance in the argument that the result of the identification in respect of this accused-appellant was too good to be believed (because all the six witnesses who went to identify him at the district jail correctly identified him without making any mistake) particularly when no Hulia or special feature or features of the dacoits were disclosed in the FIR by the informant. In the case of Sheonath v. State Of Uttar Pradesh. (1990 Allahabad Criminal Rulings 553 : (1990 Cri LJ 2423) it was held that a performance of six out of six must be called too good to be believed and suspicious.

    8. Another circumstance fatal for the prosecution is that no link evidence whatsoever has been adduced by the prosecution. Link evidence means evidence to show that accused was not shown to any witness from the time of his arrest till the time of his lodging at the jail. There is only the evidence of I.O.K.P Pandey (PW 11) that he made this accused-appellant Baparda at the spot and it was only to the effect that the accused Was arrested along with a gun and his statement was ‘, recorded and he was made Baparda and was sent to jail Baparda and that a report was made for identification proceedings. The Investigating; Officer did not say in so many words that it was he who made the arrest. He did not disclose as to on what date, time and place this accused was arrested. He has not proved any memo about this arrest. He also did not place on record any G.D entry of his lodgement in the police station after the arrest made by him. He also did not say that he got the accused made Baparda. He also did not, say as to who took this acccused-appellant Baparda and lodged him at the district jail. At the time of identification proceeding this acccused-appellant has stated before the Magistrate “POLICE NE MUJHE PAHICHAN KARTAON KO DIKHAYA HAI” This statement is of great significance when the prosecution does not say as to on what date, time and place he was arrested, and at what place he was taken from time to time: and where he was kept in the night. The memo of identification proceeding is Ex.ka 33 which shows that he was lodged at the district jail on 26-4-84, which means that in the night of 25-4-84 he was kept somewhere, may be at the police station, may be somewhere else. The constable who took the accused and lodged him at the jail was not produced by the prosecution, he was not even named before the court to enable the court to summon him as a court witness. In the total absence of link evidence, the identification evidence given by the witnesses at the trial cannot be made the basis of conviction. I may place on, record a division Bench authority of our High Court, Mahendra Singh v. State, 1991 Cri LJ 1381 where it was said (at Page 1385):

    “……. The prosecution has, however, not given any link evidence to prove that Mahendra Singh alias Birendra Singh was brought Baparda from jail on that date and was kept Baparda till he was again lodged in jail the same day and he was not shown to any prosecution witnesses on that day. The case of Mahendra Singh has been that he had been shown to the witnesses. In view of this lapse on the part of the prosecution, we have no option but to give the benefit of doubt to him.”

    9. In the single Judge authority, Sheonath Bhar cited by me aforesaid, the same view was taken, In that case the prosecution had examined the investigating Officer and the Investigating Officer alone provided the link evidence and the explanation offered by the prosecution for the absence of link evidence in respect of not producing the case diaries was that the relevant case diary was weeded out due to lapse of time. In those circumstances it was held that the explanation offered by the prosecution cannot discharge the burden of prosecution to adduce a formal link evidence about the same in respect of taking the accused Baparda.

    10. I may mention here that so far as this accused-appellant Vijai Bahadur is concerned, there is no recovery from him of any of the weapons looted in the present dacoity. I.O.K.P Pandey has claimed that there was recovery of a fire arm from the possession of this accused-appellant but it is immaterial because the alleged recovered weapon was not said to be looted in the present occurrence. In fact, there is no evidence whatsoever that any fire-arm of any kind was recovered from the possession of this accused-appellant at the time of his arrest.

    11. Consequently, the charge against this accused-appellant Vijai Bahadur alias Vijai for the offence under Section 396 IPC cannot be sustained.

    12. Now we come to the other two accused-appellants Khan Singh alias Ujagar Khan and Chhotey. They, were arrested on 17-5-1984 and were put up for identification on 30-5-1984 and so there was no abnormal delay in getting the test identification done. The identification evidence led at the trial, however, suffers from the same fatal flaw of absence of necessary link evidence. There is only the statement of I.O.K.P Pandey (PW 11) that both these accused-appellants were arrested on 17-5-1984 and they were made Baparda at the spot and they were given direction to keep their faces concealed and not to allow any one to see their faces because they were to be put up for identification test. Beyond this there is also his evidence that from the spot of arrest they were brought to the police station and lodged there baparda. Copy of the G.D entry No. 16 dated 17-5-84 of 13.30 hours in this respect is proved by him as Ex ka 26. If we take the statement of the Investigating Officer at its face value, it at the most shows that the accused remained Baparda from the time of their arrest till 13.30 hours on 17-5-84, the time of their lodging at the police station. Beyond this there is evidence of Investigating Officer that the departure (Rawangi) of these accused from the police station for district jail was made Baparda on 18-5-84 and further that Constable Kamlesh and Constable Sukhbari Lal took the accused-appellants to jail Baparda. The time of departure from police station and the time of lodging at jail were not disclosed by the Investigating Officer. He did not say that he himself remained at the police station from the time of their lodging at the police station on 17-5-84 at 13.30 hours till the time of their departure from the police station on 18-5-84, so as to be able to say that they were kept Baparda so long as they remained at the police station. No. G.D entries of the period from the time of lodging of the accused-appellants at the police station till the date and time of their departure from there have been produced and proved. None of the constables who were on duty during all this period were produced by the prosecution to show that during the said period they (the accused appellants aforesaid) were kept Baparda in the Hawalat of the police station. In fact, the Investigating Officer did not even say that during the period these accused appellants were in the lock-up at the police station, they, remained Baparda and that no body was allowed to see their faces.

    13. Constables Kamlesh and Subhkai were also not produced by the prosecution to give their evidence that they started from the police station with these accused Baparda and that they kept them Baparda all along till the time of their lodging at the district jail and further that they did not allow any one to see their faces in the intervening period. We may only add that the Invest igating Officer did not claim that he had accompanied the constables when they took these accused-appellants from the police station to the district jail. This absence of link evidence assumes more significance when we notice that Khan Singh accused appellant stated before the Identifying Magistrate, “THANE MEN PHOTO KHEECHA GAYA”. The accused-appellant Chhotey no doubt stated before the Magistrate that the witnesses knew him from before. Nonetheless, the prosecution was bound to prove its case against this accused also by producing link evidence because its case was that the witnesses did not know the accused appellant Chhotey from before. The statement of this accused that the witnesses knew from before if taken to be correct, then the fact that he was not named in the F.I.R even then, becomes fatal for the prosecution.

    14. Now we have to consider the recovery of fire arms from these two accused-appellants. So far as the recovery from Chhotey accused-appellant is concerned, it is of an illicit weapon and it establishes the offence under section 25 Arms Act against him. But it shall have no bearing on the charge for the offence under Section 396 IPC. There is no recovery from his possession of any of the two weapons looted in the present dacoity. So no adverse inference can be drawn against this aceused-appeliant Chhotey in regard to the charge under section 396 IPC. Consequently, in the absence of link evidence, the accused-appellant Chhotey has to be given the benefit of doubt for the offence under section 396 IPC and his conviction for this offence cannot be sustained but his conviction and sentence for the offence under section 25 Arms Act ought to stand.

    15. Now we come to the recovery of the weapon from Khan Singh accused-appellant. This recovery is of the licensed gun No. 89963 looted in the present occurrence. In respect of this recovery, there is the evidence of the Investigating Officer. The defence suggestion to the Investigating Officer in regard to the same is that Badhshah. son of Deena and Sunder, the brother of Dayaram had taken the gun for committing the dacoity and in the dacoity an encounter took place and they were killed in that encounter and further that in collusion with the licence-holders of the guns incorrect charge-sheets have been submitted against the accused persons. However, there are no circumstances and no evidence to lend support’ to the said plea. The evidence of the Investigating Officer in respect of the said recovery has, therefore, to be accepted and this establishes the charge under section 25 Arms Act against this accused appellant. The learned Sessions Judge had framed the charge under section 396 IPC and also framed the charge under Section 412 IPC against the accused-appellant for retaining the said licensed gun No. 89963 along with eight live cartridges knowing and having reasons to believe that the possession of the said licensed gun has been transferred by commission of dacoity. The learned Sessions Judge being of the opinion that the evidence establishes the offence of dacoity with murder against this accused-appellant did not make a separate conviction for the offence under Section 412 IPC.

    16. Now the crucial question is as to what extent the presumption under section 114 of the Indian Evidence Act from the said recovery could help prove the charge under section 396 IPC or 412 IPC. Here it has to be kept in mind that the occurrence took place on 12-2-1984 but the said recovery was made on 17-5-1984. Therefore, considering this time gap we are afraid it would not be proper to draw inference in respect of corroborating the charge of dacoity with murder particularly when the material link evidence is missing, and the same entitles this accused-appellant to the benefit of doubt in regard to that charge. However, the matter does not end here. Even though the charge under section 396 IPC will have to fail against this accused appellant also in view of the absence of the link evidence, a presumption can certainly be raised on the basis of the said recovery that he was a ‘receiver’. Now the question arises as to whether the presumption should be whether he was a ‘receiver’ with the knowledge that the said fire-arm had been acquired by commission of dacoity. To support this presumption in favour of Offence under section 412 IPC, it has to be proved that this accused-appellant knew or had reason to believe that the possession of the weapon had been transferred by the commission of dacoity or that he received it from a person whom he knew or had reason to believe that he belonged to gang of dacoits. Since there is no such material on record, it will only be safe to draw a lesser presumption that he knew the fire-arm to be a stolen property. A factory made weapon is not something readily available in the market, which can be acquired just by (throwing money. So, the charge under section 411 IPC only is brought home to this accused-appellant Khan Singh, which is a minor offence with reference to the offence under section 396 IPC. Moreover, this accused-appellant had been tried by the learned Sessions Judge for the offence under section 412 IPC but he did not make a separate conviction for the offence under section 411 or 412 IPC because the major offence under section 396 IPC was established on his assessment of evidence.

    17. Now we come to the question of sentence for the offence under section 411 IPC to Khan Singh accused-appellant. In my view, three years RI should be sufficient to serve the ends of justice.

    18. Criminal Appeal No. 2244 of 1985 of Vijai Bahadur alias Vijai accused-appellant is allowed. His conviction for the offence under section 396 IPC is set aside, and he is acquitted of the same. He is on bail from this court. He need not surrender. His bail bonds are cancelled and sureties are discharged.

    19. Criminal Appeal No. 676 of 1988 is partly allowed in so far as Chhote accused-appellant is concerned his conviction under section 396 IPC is set aside and he is acquitted of the same. But his conviction for the offence under Secction 25 Arms Act is maintained. However, since he was arrested on 17-5-84 and was admitted to bail by this court on 18-9-92, he has already served out the period of sentence awarded by the Sessions Judge for the offence under section 25 Arms Act. At present he is on bail. He need not surrender. His bail bonds are cancelled and the sureties are discharged.

    20. Criminal Appeal No. 676 of 88 in respect of Khan Singh alias Ujagar Khan accused-appellant is also partly allowed. His conviction for the offence under section 396 IPC is set aside and he is acquitted of the same. However, he is convicted for the offence under Section 411 IPC and is sentenced to undergo R.I for three years for the said offence. His conviction for the offence under section 25 Arms Act is maintained however, he was arrested on 17-5-1984 and had been admitted to bail by this court on 18-9-92. It means that he has already suffered imprisonment for seven years and four months as under trial or against the sentence awarded by the Sessions Judge for this offence. Consequently, he need not surrender. His bail bonds are cancelled and the sureties are discharged.

    21. Let a copy of this judgment be sent to the learned Sessions Judge, Shahjahanpur in a week from today for information and compliance. The compliance report by the Sessions Judge, Shahjahanpur shall be submitted to this Court within a month from today.

    22. Order accordingly.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Khan Singh Ujagar Khan And Chhotey v. State .
    (May 17, 1996)