Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Mohd. Masood Ahmad v. State Of U.P And Others

Supreme Court Of India
Sep 18, 2007
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant was serving as Executive Officer, Nagar Palika Parishad, Muzaffarnagar. By order dated 21-6-2005 the State Government transferred him to the post of Executive Officer, Nagar Palika Parishad, Mawana, District Meerut. He challenged this transfer in Writ Petition No. 1110 (S/B) of 2005 before the Allahabad High Court, which dismissed the petition on 8-7-2005. The present civil appeal before the Supreme Court contests that dismissal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the transfer of the appellant, a public servant holding a transferable post, warranted judicial interference under Article 226 of the Constitution.
  2. Whether the alleged influence of an MLA, or complaints against the appellant, rendered the transfer order arbitrary, mala fide, or otherwise invalid.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The transfer was made at the instance of a Member of the Legislative Assembly, implying extraneous influence and mala fides.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The appellant was transferred because of complaints received against him.
  • As the post is transferable, the Government acted within its administrative discretion.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
B. Varadha Rao v. State of Karnataka (1986) 4 SCC 131 Transfer is an exigency of service; courts should rarely interfere. Cited to affirm that routine transfers fall within administrative discretion.
Shilpi Bose v. State of Bihar 1991 Supp (2) SCC 659 Similar principle that transfer orders should not ordinarily be judicially reviewed. Reinforced the limited scope of interference.
Union of India v. N.P. Thomas 1993 Supp (1) SCC 704 Judicial restraint in matters of transfer. Used to buttress dismissal of the writ petition.
Union of India v. S.L. Abbas (1993) 4 SCC 357 Transfer is an incident of service; interference only in rare cases. Applied to show that no exceptional circumstances existed here.
State of Punjab v. Joginder Singh Dhatt AIR 1993 SC 2486 Court has “no jurisdiction” to quash a routine transfer absent injustice. Quoted at length to illustrate why the High Court had acted correctly.
Abani Kanta Ray v. State of Orissa 1995 Supp (4) SCC 169 Transfer may be set aside only if arbitrary, mala fide, or contrary to rules. Relied upon to conclude that none of those vitiating factors were present.
N.K. Singh v. Union of India (1994) 6 SCC 98 Elaborated the “arbitrary or mala fide” exception to non-interference. Referenced within Abani Kanta Ray; supports the same test.
Rajendra Roy v. Union of India (1993) 1 SCC 148 Supreme Court settled the scope of judicial review on transfers. Cited as one of the leading authorities defining limited review.
NHPC Ltd. v. Shri Bhagwan (2001) 8 SCC 574 Reaffirmed settled principles on transfer jurisprudence. Invoked collectively with other cases to guide the analysis.
State Bank of India v. Anjan Sanyal (2001) 5 SCC 508 Continued application of limited-interference doctrine. Part of the line of authority relied upon.
Vijay Pal Singh v. State of U.P. (1997) 3 ESC 1668 (All HC) High Court followed Supreme Court directives on transfer matters. Cited to show consistency at the High Court level.
Onkar Nath Tiwari v. Chief Engineer, Minor Irrigation Deptt. (1997) 3 ESC 1866 (All HC) Same principle—transfer orders ordinarily not interfered with. Referenced to confirm the established view.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court noted that the appellant’s post is transferable and that transfer is “an exigency of service,” relying on the long line of authorities listed above. Judicial review is permissible only when a transfer order is:

  • Demonstrably arbitrary,
  • Vitiated by mala fides, or
  • Contrary to statutory rules or lack of competence.

The appellant’s sole allegation was that an MLA had recommended the transfer. The Court held that such political recommendation, by itself, does not invalidate the order; legislators are entitled to convey public grievances, and the executive may act on them if justified. The respondents asserted that complaints against the appellant motivated the transfer, which the Court found to be a valid administrative rationale. No evidence of mala fides, arbitrariness, or rule-violation was produced. Consequently, the High Court’s dismissal of the writ petition was deemed correct.

Holding and Implications

APPEAL DISMISSED. No order as to costs.

Immediate Effect: The appellant remains transferred to Nagar Palika Parishad, Mawana, District Meerut, and the High Court’s judgment stands affirmed.

Broader Implications: The decision reiterates, without creating new precedent, that courts will not interfere with routine transfer orders unless clear proof of mala fides, arbitrariness, or statutory violation is shown.

Show all summary ...

Markandey Katju, J.— Leave granted.

2. This appeal has been directed against the impugned judgment and order dated 8-7-2005 passed by the High Court of Judicature at Allahabad in Writ Petition No. 1110 (S/B) of 2005.

3. Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the record.

4. The petitioner-appellant, who was an Executive Officer, Nagar Palika Parishad, Muzaffarnagar, had in his writ petition challenged his transfer by the State Government by order dated 21-6-2005 as Executive Officer, Nagar Palika Parishad, Mawana, District Meerut. Since the petitioner was on a transferable post, in our opinion, the High Court has rightly dismissed the writ petition since transfer is an exigency of service and is an administrative decision. Interference by the courts with transfer orders should only be in very rare cases. As repeatedly held in several decisions, transfer is an exigency of service vide B. Varadha Rao v. State of Karnataka (1986) 4 SCC 131, (1986) 1 ATC 558, AIR 1986 SC 1955, Shilpi Bose v. State of Bihar 1991 Supp (2) SCC 659, (1991) 17 ATC 935, AIR 1991 SC 532, Union of India v. N.P Thomas 1993 Supp (1) SCC 704, (1993) 23 ATC 775, AIR 1993 SC 1605, Union of India v. S.L Abbas (1993) 4 SCC 357, (1993) 25 ATC 844, AIR 1993 SC 2444.

5. In State of Punjab v. Joginder Singh Dhatt AIR 1993 SC 2486 this Court observed (vide p. 2486, para 3 of the said AIR):

“3. We have heard learned counsel for the parties. This Court has time and again expressed its disapproval of the courts below interfering with the order of transfer of public servant from one place to another. It is entirely for the employer to decide when, where and at what point of time a public servant is transferred from his present posting. Ordinarily the courts have no jurisdiction to interfere with the order of transfer. The High Court grossly erred in quashing the order of transfer of the respondent from Hoshiarpur to Sangrur. The High Court was not justified in extending its jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution of India in a matter where, on the face of it, no injustice was caused.”

6. In Abani Kanta Ray v. State of Orissa 1995 Supp (4) SCC 169, (1996) 32 ATC 107, 1996 Lab IC 982 this Court observed (vide:

“10. It is settled law that a transfer which is an incident of service is not to be interfered with by the courts unless it is shown to be clearly arbitrary or vitiated by mala fides or infraction of any professed norm or principle governing the transfer. (See N.K Singh v. Union of India (1994) 6 SCC 98, (1994) 28 ATC 246.)”

7. The scope of judicial review of transfer under Article 226 of the Constitution of India has been settled by the Supreme Court in Rajendra Roy v. Union of India (1993) 1 SCC 148, (1993) 23 ATC 426, AIR 1993 SC 1236, National Hydroelectric Power Corpn. Ltd. v. Shri Bhagwan (2001) 8 SCC 574, AIR 2001 SC 3309, State Bank of India v. Anjan Sanyal (2001) 5 SCC 508, AIR 2001 SC 1748. Following the aforesaid principles laid down by the Supreme Court, the Allahabad High Court in Vijay Pal Singh v. State of U.P (1997) 3 ESC 1668, 1998 All LJ 70 and Onkar Nath Tiwari v. Chief Engineer, Minor Irrigation Deptt. (1997) 3 ESC 1866, 1998 All LJ 245 has held that the principle of law laid down in the aforesaid decisions is that an order of transfer is a part of the service conditions of an employee which should not be interfered with ordinarily by a court of law in exercise of its discretionary jurisdiction under Article 226 unless the court finds that either the order is mala fide or that the service rules prohibit such transfer, or that the authorities who issued the orders, were not competent to pass the orders.

8. Learned counsel for the appellant submitted that the impugned transfer order of the appellant from Muzaffarnagar to Mawana, District Meerut was made at the instance of an MLA. On the other hand, it has been stated in the counter-affidavit filed on behalf of Respondents 1 and 2 that the appellant has been transferred due to complaints against him. In our opinion, even if the allegation of the appellant is correct that he was transferred on the recommendation of an MLA, that by itself would not vitiate the transfer order. After all, it is the duty of the representatives of the people in the legislature to express the grievances of the people and if there is any complaint against an official the State Government is certainly within its jurisdiction to transfer such an employee. There can be no hard-and-fast rule that every transfer at the instance of an MP or MLA would be vitiated. It all depends on the facts and circumstances of an individual case. In the present case, we see no infirmity in the impugned transfer order.

9. The appeal is dismissed. There is no order as to costs.